We just moved to the area and my husband is a pizza snob. We were looking for a new go to pizza spot and this was delicious!!! The Cacio E Peppe pizza was so good! The service was very quick for multiple pies. Will definitely be back! read more

Honey pepperoni is just amazing! So good I will eat it though I don't like pepperoni pizza even. Mushroom bacon ham chicken pizza is just wow. Even my "cheese pizza only" kid is hooked on it and gets it every time. This place is great for foodies who value fresh healthy ingredients and a clean friendly staff. My # 1 pizza place!!! read more

Really great pizza and service here! Also very clean restaurant! We enjoyed our experience here as a family!

This pizza is absolutely delicious! I got a meat lovers and a vegetarian! Both cooked perfectly! The garlic knots were very tasty as well!

This is a small and cozy place with good food and great service. We ordered takeout on Super Bowl Sunday and were pleased with the service and the quality of food. Being from out of town, we like to try small businesses and this is one we will come back to in the future. read more

I just turned 21, I went to this place because I know I've visited it before. The pizza tastes amazing as always, however when the staff asked how old I was and I mentioned to them that I turned 21 today because I was trying red wine, one of them came and asked if I wanted a dessert free of charge! It was the tiramisu, and it tasted amazing, better than the one I made in highschool a few years ago. The people here are friendly and the place itself is just a vibe. If I could rate more stars, I'd give it a 10/10 read more

We had a great experience and the pizza was better than some pizza we had when we lived in NY. So happy we found this spot! We tried the Re Umberto (Delicious) & Meat Amore Mio (Delicious) Wings were great too!!! read more

Amazing Amazing Amazing love this place, was greeted the moment we walked in which is always nice and welcoming, place was quiet and laid back perfect for a 1st date specially if you like Pizza lol. Love the Brick Oven taste, as well as the sauce and the cheese is a perfect 10. Can't wait to go back! read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

Amazing pizza! Henry is fantastic and very informative. Love the relaxed atmosphere. Will definitely be back. read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

The pizza was very good. They put lots of toppings on the pizza. I would suggest you give them a try. read more

Pizza is amazing. Had the Umberto and the chicken bacon. Pepperoni roles and burratta apps outstanding. Well worth the trip read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

The bruschetta with burrata cheese was delicious, the bread and tomatoes were very fresh and delicately seasoned highlighting the taste of the other ingredients. We had the Tartufata and the meat Amore pizzas. Both were fantastic and the Tartufata was our favorite. It has truffle cream base, mozzarella, funghi trifolati (porcini, shiitake, mushroom, portobello), sausage. The staff is very friendly and attentive We highly recommend Amore Mio Pizza!!! We highly recommend Amore Mio Pizza! read more

We got takeout today for the first time. Everything was absolutely delicious! We tried 4 different pizzas that were cooked to perfection...the mushroom truffle, cheese, pepperoni, and amore pizzas were the best pizzas we've had in Clayton and in the RDU area. Fresh ingredients, clean establishment, and friendly owner. 10/10 Can't wait to return! read more

Excellent. I had a big order so got to try a lot of different menu items. First the pizza was great, just right, and especially good crust. Salads were good as well. Owner Henry is super nice and obviously puts customers first and thinks a lot about what makes a customer happy. That is not him in the picture but showing the oven. I'll return to Amore Mio for sure. Prices were reasonable too. Good beer selection as well (Red Oak, Wicked Weed, Stella, etc). Worth the trip. read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Oven - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

Just left this place for the first time and will be back soon. I was looking for a Grandma pie and they don't make them. I ordered the Regina Margherita and it was FABULOUS. I have live here 12 years coming from Virginia and before that South Jersey, this is the best pizza I have had in NC. The freshest cheese and basil knocked this outta the park. It was cooked just right unlike the place down the road that overcooks their pies. Nice people ,very friendly. Pies are one size and small for what you pay for, BUT the quality, freshness and flavor are worth it. read more

Ordered pizza via doordash and received everything I paid for and more. Was blown away by the delicious variety but my personal favorite was loaded with mushrooms and sausage. Amazing! Every pizza we tried was great and at a couple bucks more than little Caesars- totally worth the price. Was pleasantly surprised to find a special dessert pizza and fun messages written inside of each box. For something different and fresh- try amore! read more

See all

Wonderful place and wonderful food! The decor is very beautiful. We will be coming back! Food was delicious and reasonably priced. We were sat down immediately and had great service. read more

See all

We made it back to Amore Mio on a Wednesday evening to give it a second try. In general, we had a more refined experience with better service and clearly more-experienced staff preparing our pizza. Once again, I thought the restaurant's tastefully decorated interior added to the experience. For this visit, we tried the Bruschetta Burrata for an appetizer and were thoroughly pleased. It was delicious as is, but thanks to a tip from our server it was even better with a bit of the strawberry balsamic from the dispenser on our table. I would absolutely order this again. We shared the Regina Margherita pizza for our meal. The crust was perfect and the pizza overall was very, very good. Both of us liked the shaved Parmesan on our pizza, but I think there was a little too much of it as it was on the edge of being too salty for my taste. In addition, like on our prior visit, I felt like the pizza was allowed to rest too long before being served as it was barely lukewarm. These minor quips aside, Amore Mio served us arguably the best pizza I've ever had in Garner. During our visit, we were the only dine-in Customers, although there were several pickup orders. Although Yelp doesn't support fractional ratings, Amore Mio really ranks somewhere between 4.5 and 4.75 stars. read more

Ordered the Hawaii Mati pizza and the buffalo wings and it was excellent! Delicious and fresh and the staff were friendly. I did pick up but will be dining in next time, the restaurant is beautiful, modern and cozy. Loved the pizza oven. Overall a great experience will add this to my regular places to visit! read more

The pizza was good and the wine was good. In general it's real pizza thin crust with plenty of toppings.

Really clean and nice ambiance. All the pizzas are freshly made. My favorite was the bruschetta. Will definitely be coming back the next time we are in town! read more

The BEST pizza I've had in NC since I moved here in 2009! I can't wait to try more flavor combinations.

Tried a couple of pizzas from Amore Mio last evening based on some positive feedback from friends. Keep in mind this is what good pizza is all about. Please do not compare them to fast food pizza which is mostly what we have in the Clayton market. My son ate a whole cheese pizza and I had the Chicken, Ham, mushroom and bacon pizza. All I can say is delicious!!! Excellent customer service and pizza was fresh and very tasty. Yes, pricier then the fast food national junk pizza but well worth it and I will definitely be back to try others! Well done Amore Mio! read more

Amore Mio Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

See all

The pizza here was great. The standard pepperoni was really good and the Re Umberto was fantastic. In my opinion, this is the only upscale pizza in the 40/42 area and it's great. This will be our go-to pizza place for the foreseeable future. read more

Amore Mio Pizza - The Re Umberto was fantastic. 10/10 will order again. - Pizza Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

When the wife and I are traveling we like to hit random pizza joints. This place did not disappoint. Absolutely delicious. Everything is house made and you can tell. Robust flavorful sauce, perfectly crisp yet chewy crust. Fresh creamy mozzarella. And the prices are very reasonable for an "artisnal" style place. Really you probably pay less here for much better food than the chain pizza places! If you live in or are passing by Garner on 40, stop by, you won't be disapointed. read more

What a gem. Lovely thin crust pizza with high quality ingredients. We will be back very soon to try more pizzas and appetizers.

I would give a 100 stars, if I could. Quality ingredients make for excellent pizza. Treat yourself with the Nutella Pizza. It is DIVINE. It is worth the drive to Garner for this delicious food. Chef's kiss read more

I got the vegetarian pizza and it was delicious! Good eats and Italian NY style pizza that's near me.

Our favorite (and our friends') place for fabulous pizzas and great salads. Small and casual.

Excellent pizza , we need better quality around Garner. If there is one comment , pepperoni gets to greasy . read more

Last night, I met a couple of friends at Amore Mio Pizza after seeing it had 4.9 stars and 80 reviews. The menu sounded interesting, and great reviews. There was only 3 empty tables when we arrived, and all 3 were dirty. No big deal. I grabbed a paper towel off the table and wiped it down. It was obvious they were busy, so it didn't seem like a big deal. Then we met IT! IT was one of the rudest people I have ever met. Chastising me for wiping down the 'dirty' table. It never gave its name, never asked if we would like a drink or appetizer. IT quickly demanded we leave if we wanted pasta or salads because they weren't gonna make them for us. Its words were sharp and curt, then it fluttered away. One of my friends tried to compliment the person's star pimple covers, but it ignored her. The rudest was off the charts, and it was obvious our patronage of their establishment was not desired at 7:30pm on a Friday night. So we took the hint and left. We walked down the sidewalk to the Indian Restaurant in the same plaza. Can't tell you if their food is good or not, but the service was horrific. read more

As a first time visitor to this restaurant I'm I have to admit, I'm impressed! They make a great V brick oven/ wood fired pizza. We arrived on their special $10 any pizza night. That right there makes it worth checking out! Warning!! If you wind up liking this place like I do it might make your wallet a little bit smaller The pizzas are pretty pricey. (For instance a pepperoni pizza is $15.00, a Hawaiian pizza is $17.00.. They only have one size pie..) It's worth the trip, it definitely isn't your average NC pizza. Only you can decide if you want to spend the money. read more

I waited until we visited multiple times to write a review. I have never ever had fresher or better pizza, not in Rome, not in NY, not in Chicago. Please support this small and amazing cafe. read more

At first look, this little restaurant in Garner, NC just looks like any other pizza joint, until you try the Pepperoni Rolls with homemade garlic butter as an appetizer (or even a meal)! They are the best I have ever had! I have been craving them since the last time I was in town. They did not disappoint on my second trip! And the pizzas on the menu range from a yummy pepperoni to multiple gourmet Italian masterpieces! And if you are like me and you have a difficult time choosing between all of Henry's wonderful creations, you can get half-and-half pizza! This trip I had half Re Umberto and half Tartufata! Delicious! And if you don't have enough room for their homemade Tiramisu, then at least get the Nutella rolls to go! This place is 5 star from the food to the unique dinnerware and clean, simple yet classy decor. And to top it all off, the service and staff are very friendly, welcoming, and happy to explain their selections and make recommendations. I highly recommend Amore Mio!! I will be back when I am in town again! read more

See all

Fantastic!! Best pizza and salad I've had in a decade or more. Maybe even my entire life (sneaking up on six decades). There are about ten tables in the restaurant. So, if you want to dine-in, go early. Their menu is focused on those items they can deliver with the highest standard. In other words, if you want a chili dog or hamburger, go to Char-Grill. I gave them five stars because their food is amazing! We shared a pizza, a salad and individual desserts. Bottom line, unless you're a teenager or an endurance athlete, those dishes were surely intended to be shared. Consider that when making your selections. You can always order more if I'm wrong. My wife and I will definitely go again! We chose: Caprisi Salad. Chicken, Ham, Mushrooms and Bacon pizza. Homemade Tiramisu. Cannolis (should've picked only one dessert as we were stuffed!). read more

Me and the wife ventured here a few weeks ago ..there was no yelp page at the time..so here are my thoughts: * Cash only ...I know there are some mom and pops that subscribe to this..but cmon ..no one carries cash anymore. * Pizza is only one size and it's small for the price .. * Pizza wasn't bad , decent taste for the area...pizza for some reason struggles to be good in the 40/42 area. read more

Favorite place to get pizza! We eat here several times a month. It's truly the best.

Loved the staff!! Food was to die for. Loved our date there! Me and my husband went on a date here and it was one of the best dates ever! The staff was amazing and the pizza was light and tasty! read more

Ordered pizza tonight great place pizza was awesome! I have tried this place many times it has never disappointed me! Food is always fresh!

Delightful people and delicious pizza! Even provided cheese and red pepper for toppers. We look forward to trying more offerings from here!