We got the chance to try some of their eats at their booth in the Great Inland Seafood Festival this year! We tried- LOBSTER & CRAB RAVIOLI: This was one large ravioli covered in Saffron Cognac cream sauce. It was packed full of shredded meat and was super soft and flavorful. SHRIMP & PENNE: This was also an absolute hit. The garlic and herb cream sauce really topped the pasta and shrimp, and was a beautiful nod to a tried and true classic. SHRIMP & CRABCAKE EMPANADA: This was also tasty as they did not short us on the filling and the outside was nice and crisp while still keeping a soft filling. It also came with a nice coleslaw on the side. We had a great time interacting with the staff here as well and found it sweet they collectively as a group thanked everyone who came by to eat. read more

See all

Celebrated our 33rd anniversary but won"t wait a year to come back. Food presentation was beautiful and tasted fabulous. Our server was friendly, extremely knowledgeable and professional. We are looking forward to going back. read more

First off, the character of the restaurant... true to Hyde Park, which is not necessarily as positive a compliment as some might think aka overpriced for what you get... Location. Location. Location. That's what you're paying for in Hyde Park, the location. Therefore, the character of the restaurant is set up to attract those individuals who don't mind paying more than something is worth based on hype and location. My character assessment is pretty critical but the food was actually pretty good. It was just overpriced for what you get. Let's delve into the explanation of my food critique. We tried the mussels which were great. The sauce that the mussels were cooked in did a great job of enhancing but not overpowering the mussels. The ravioli...decent but way overpriced. I specifically tried the lobster and crab ravioli where you only get 5 pieces of ravioli. If you look at past reviews from 2021, you notice that many of the menu items increased in price by about 20%. I know there's a pandemic, supply chain issues, and price increased but not 20% worth of increase. Lastly, I checked in at Alfio and, to my surprise, got free gelato. I went with the peanut butter cup gelato in all of its chocolate peanut butter glory. From reading my critique you may think I had a bad experience. My experience was ok. The service was great. We had a server named Leandra who was super accommodating, friendly, and personable. The food was pretty overpriced for what you get. Overall, I had my experience at Alfio's and I doubt I'll return but that doesn't mean others shouldn't try it out. It just wasn't my cup of tea. Happy Yelping, Kristin read more

See all

An amazing place for good food and a great time!! Home made pasta, wine pairings and comfort make this place not only a great place to eat, but a great place to want to be more than once a week! If you haven't been there, get there! read more

Wonderful place to eat! Is a Italian and Argentinian Fusion. With a great Raviolis so good and so big... I try the Zukini seafood pasta, something incredible good. The sauce was amazing. If I comeback to OH I definitely visit them back. read more

See all

Delicious food and service! Everything was amazing, and the waitress was extremely friendly. It was very clean inside.

Alfio's was fabulous! Our server Sulley took the time to explain the menu/specials for our Valentine's Day dinner. We appreciated his recommendations and ordered everything he mentioned. Thanks Sulley! The only negative was a party of 6 that came in had NO regard for how loud they were. (A group of 4 women next to us even moved tables) I wish staff told these "talkers" to keep it down so our romantic dinner didn't end on a sour note! read more

Back again and tried different dishes ..... my new favorite appetizer is the scallops in a delicious Butternut squash puree and my new favorite Entree is the braised short rib and gnocchi!!!!..... they've added and deleted a couple items off the menu like the seafood risotto and crème brûlée!!! :( check- in quality check annnnnnnd still 5 stars.... not to mention our excellent server Biljan we had the pleasure of having 2 visits in a row, 5 Star food with 5 star service.... can't beat that!!! read more

See all

We came here on Friday and it was packed, but they let us sit at the bar. Great service, loved the skirt steak with chimichurri and they did a great job cooking it "medium rare." The gnocchi bolognese was good but slightly salty for our taste. There's free gelato if you check in on yelp, and that was very good :). We look forward to coming back another time. read more

Alfio's Buon Cibo - Skirt Steak with Argentine Relish - Italian Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

This place is amazing. One of the best restaurants in Cincinnati. Food is excellent and always fresh. The value is great Service is always incredible and staff are friendly and fun. read more

One of the best meals I have had. The service is great as well as the meal. The ambiance is wonderful. read more

Absolutely divine meal!! We came here in recommendation of a friend and we're so happy they shared this place with us. We had a 6:30 reservation and I had 6pm in my head, so we showed up really early but they sat us right away with no question! Service was extremely friendly but not overbearing. We told her it was our first time and she made sure to highlight her favorite dishes and crowd favorites. I loved how accommodating they were to vegetarian options. She said most all of their pastas could be made vegetarian, which opened up so many more options for me! I got the butternut squash agnolotti and it was out of this world. My husband got the short rib and it just melted off the bone. We ordered the bruschetta appetizer and it was maybe too much arugula, but delish. The salads are also amazing! So many yummy options that I wish we could have sampled them all. Save room for dessert because they are also amazing. The break pudding and tiramisu are to die for. The ambiance is perfect for a fancy date night or celebration. It's tucked back and dark, but not too dark. Comfy seats make staying there for a while really easy. It's expensive, but completely worth the splurge for a nice night out! read more

The service was fantastic, our waiter, Wazowski, was knowledgeable of the menu, sharing favorite items and appropriate pairings, and just pleasant in his approach. The combination of Italian and Argentinian cuisine is impressive. We left full and satisfied! Will recommend to all friends and family. Loved this family gem!!! read more

See all

Service was friendly, and most of the food was good. However we ordered a salad and requested no onions, and it came out with onions. Also my wife and I both got mild food poisoning. Ordered a dessert to go, and when we got home, discovered we were given the wrong one. Updating from 2 to 1 star. Still sick 4 days later. So more than 'mild' food poisoning read more

Lobster tans shrimp ravioli was great. A bit creamy but if your like me and like that then do it. The empanadas for appetizer... AMAZING! Such a sweet spot and service is wonderful. Great for a date night! They also had a wonderful birthday surprise which was beautiful! read more

Alfio's Buon Cibo - Birthday special - Italian Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Really interesting and am a bit unsure how to rate this restaurant. It charges high end prices but does not have the commiserate service that should be included First, the food in general was great! Short Ribs, burrata, duck bacon fettuccine, grilled Caesar salad all phenomenal. Bad miss with the gnocchi. It was like someone plopped balls of dough in a pot with little care of taste or texture. Very heavy and plodding. The truffle sauce was oily and overbearing. Just disappointing. The service was very friendly and very inattentive at the same time. Plates piling up and no teamwork when other bussers or servers walked by, saw them, and I assume just thought it wasn't their table. Even the manager walked by twice until I asked them to help the third time he walked by. 10 minutes for a drink order, another 10 to receive menu's...if you are going to charge higher end prices, service should match the expectations. So very good food, and a Potemkin Village of actual service. read more

Karlyn was amazing ! Food was delicious Def a great time and will come back soon!!!!!!!!!!

Amazing food and fantastic service! My husband and I had a wonderful dinner here yesterday evening. We've missed fine dining in the several months that this pandemic has worn on and we were looking forward to our evening. Alfio's didn't disappoint! We started out with some cocktails. My husband had a Peroni and I had the Down the Rabbit Hole cocktail. It's a bourbon cocktail that is cherrywood smoked and it was fabulous! It came to the table with a coaster on top - holding all the cherrywood smoke in the glass. It was smoky and slightly sweet. We decided on the Mussels for an appetizer. They were delicious. The only thing missing was some crusty bread to soak up the broth. For our main course I ordered the Ravioli Duo. I chose the Lobster and Crab ravioli and the Wild Mushroom ravioli. My husband ordered the Italian Filet. It was served with gorgonzola mashed potatoes and Brussel's spouts. We both thought our meals were fantastic! Both of the raviolis had great flavor and it was impossible to pick a favorite. My husband said his steak was delicious and cooked perfectly. We finished the evening by sharing a Strawberry Gelato. It was creamy, sweet and a slightly decadent end to an amazing dinner. Stacy, our server, provided excellent, friendly service which added to a wonderful dining experience. I'm looking forward to our next visit to Alfio's. read more

See all

Excellent service and food was fantastic. Sarah our server was impeccable The bread pudding is a must, save room read more

Best restaurant in Cincinnati hands down. The glass of milk was delectable. Pairs perfectly with the cheesecake. Don't listen to your friends when they ridicule you for ordering the milk. They just don't know any better. Your enjoy that milk. read more

Alfio's Buon Cibo - Man I love milk - Italian Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Absolutely amazing service, always attentive to the level of water and i never had an empty glass. I got the pasta duo with the butternut anglotti and the lobster ravioli.... incredibly amazing . . . next time i think ill order a full of the butternut because of how amazing it was. server answered all our questions and was knowledgeable about ingredients and everything that goes into preparing read more

Came in for Valentine's Day date night and was not disappointed. We had a reservation for 7:30 and was not seated for a few minutes after. For waiting, staff handed out complementary glasses of Prosecco. Everything from our appetizers to the dessert was absolutely delicious. The braised short rib is a must, along with the butternut squash agnolotti. Very cozy spot for a date night, with knowledge staff! read more

Unbelievable food, service (Lenore was amazing), and ambiance...highly recommend...we will definitely be back soon!!!

Food amazing and was especially pleasantly impressed by the hostess Peyton. She had a bubbly attitude and is just so sweet. The ambiance is super laid back and you feel like you have your own little pod. It's definitely a must try if you haven't already! read more

If you're looking for a fancy place to go out to for a special occasion, I can't recommend anywhere other than Alfio's Buon Cibo. We ate here early in the evening on 11/11/2020. Our waitress was very knowledgeable about the menu and attentive. We got the fixed price menu which had amazing variety. Myself: Spicy Pork Belly and Shallot Empanada, Argentine Chili, Grilled Argentine Skirt Steak, Reese's Cup Cheesecake Fiance: Warm Gorgonzola Cheesecake, Butternut Squash Soup, Stuffed Flounder in a Lobster Cognac Sauce, Chocolate Caramel Tiramisu. We also got a free scoop of gelato for being Yelpers. We don't have a single complaint about anything we ate. We were so full we had to take a lot home. read more

See all

This is one of the most knowledgeable teams I have come across in Cincinnati. From the food to the wine to the cocktails, everyone is well informed and eager to be of service. Absolutely a desirable date night spot. The ambience is warm and inviting. I couldn't find a bad thing to say about this place. read more

AMAZING empanadas. Best empanadas that I've ever had. And the sauces were a huge plus! I'm definitely coming back here again when I'm in town. The mushroom ravioli (I forget if there's truffle in there) was also to die for. The service was amazing and finding parking was a breeze. read more

Alfio's Buon Cibo - Italian Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

You haven't been to Alfio's yet!!!? What are you waiting for? This is one of the BEST restaurant in Cincinnati! (My personal favorite!) My pescatarian self loved the wild mushroom ravioli and the pistachio crusted salmon. My husband adores the filet and churrasco. PRO TIP: Ask for the side of chimichurri. Thank me later! The food is great, the wine selection is amazing. They do an outstanding job putting an impressive selection together. Do not leave this place without trying the goat cheesecake. It's so good, that my husband has stopped there just for dessert. We are obsessed! Alfios never disappoints! For many many many years in business making my belly happy. read more

This remains one of our very favorite restaurants in the Cincinnati region. The food is of the highest quality and great flavor abound! Last time I ordered the Mussels and Norway Halibut and everything was delicious! read more

I need to go back without a doubt. The service and food was awesome( 5 STARS). The leftovers were fantastic in a way that they sent me to heaven while I was on my lunch break at work the day after:D. Recently I went here to celebrate my birthday. I knew my family was coming to visit from out of town and they wanted something more traditional Italian. Despite, the unique Argentinian flare (I can't wait to try those dishes) they offer a lot of your typical Italian dishes like meat ravioli with five cheese and tomato sauce. I was a bit nervous since no one in my immediate circle has heard of this place and for some reason it is not recognized on google maps (HEY GOOGLE! you should fix this). But as soon as I walked in I could just tell it was going to be a good experience. The ambiance is romantic and welcoming with not over-the-top decor. It was comfortable in a way that it welcomed those who were dressed in suites as well as those wore dressy casual attire. Though the place is not too large, I liked the layout of the tables--they give you just enough space to have your own privacy so you feel like you are not joining another party or able to "accidentally" listen to their conversations. Aside from the ambiance our waitress was pleasant and attentive. I also loved that she told us that it was half off ravioli day (I wonder if it's every Tuesday?) while she asked us for our drink order (Psst the Meritage Argentinian wine was perfect). Of course this swayed us so 3 out of four of us ordered ravioli dishes. I had the pleasure of trying everyone's dish and I liked all of them. The chicken marsala had a simple yet flavorful sauce with al dente noodles and tender large pieces of chicken breakfast; the five cheese angus ravioli were juicy and provided a punch due to the rich 5 cheeses mixed within the dish; the short rib ravioli were to die for... the sauce was a white cream sauce with a hint of wine and the meat was well seasoned and so tender. I also enjoyed the mushroom addition since the earthy flavor complimented the meat and cream sauce; and the wild mushroom ravioli were seasoned and cooked well--perfect for those who love their dish to have a prominent mushroom flavor. The portions for all 4 dishes were bigger than expected since I believe this place to be a bit upscale and typically restaurants of the same caliber will offer smaller portions (all of us had leftovers). The main courses were wonderful and my night ended with a scoop of rumchata gelato. It was smooth, tasted great, wasn't too sweet and just melted in my mouth with each bite (Thank you Yelp for offering this check-in gift right on my birthday :D). Do yourself a favor and book you reservations now. This place deserves you and you deserve to eat their amazing food. read more

See all

I was very impressed with my experience! Working at a Forbes Five Star rated resort (Sea Island), I am accustomed to certain dining standards, but I was blown away by the team's service tonight! Karlyn was an amazing server, and her menu knowledge and recommendations were on point. The mozzarella salad and lamb were wonderful! The sommelier Cole, was great with his wine knowledge and poise; a great complement to my experience. Karlyn was also very well versed in wine and whiskey acumen, and she made excellent recommendations. Sully was also present to help with thoughts and samples. Lots of staff touched the table to make a memorable evening, including Chef Alfio! I appreciate all of the staff creating a fantastic evening...especially for a miniscule single guest on a slow Tuesday evening! The decor was lovely and not overpowering, and the music and lighting were lively and comfortable. read more

Yum. Every single dish I've had here is excellent. I've eaten here for a fun double date with multiple courses, a romantic evening with my husband, and a casual night with my family, as we sat at the bar to have a quick dinner. Service is friendly, food is outstanding. Highly recommend. read more

Always good service, great wine selection, and top-notch food! One pf our favorite spots!

We were recommended by our friends to go to Alfio's in Hyde Park. Our evening started off with some fantastic drinks at the bar... And then it went south. Our waiter was not existent most of the evening as we had to fight him down continuously when we needed something. When he showed up, we asked for two drinks for our dinner partners and let him know that it was a birthday celebration for our husbands. He kept apologizing that it was busier than normal, but we had a reservation... so not sure why he was not attentive. The food was average at best with almost every dish being too salty and luke warm frites with my husband's $65 skirt steak everything meant to Cherri on our friends lamb. He never brought an espresso martini. I ordered and never recognize the birthdays at our table. We had heard nothing but rave reviews about this place, but we are not interested in returning. read more

Nice atmosphere. It's dark inside , great place to take a date. The door is very tasty , good size portions. Got the background - the owner is the chef. I love that the person cooking the food is invented in the success. The drinks are reasonable. And they have a great selection of bourbons. Good wine selection - prices vary but you can get a glass of Pinot noir for $ 10.00 Overall good experience. We went in for drinks and we're able to get a pub table Bar tender was great. Good vibe. You should go there- I / we will be back. read more

service, ambiance, great bread, drinks and food! love alfios. I have never been disappointed- from the top tier service to the unique and delicious menu it is 5/5. the empanadas are wonderful- korean bbq was my personal favorite. I have had both the short rib truffle ravioli and the mushroom and both are phenomenal. the tiramisu was delicious as well! highly recommend! read more

We tried Alfio's tonight after tasting their Korean BBQ empanada at the Taste of Cincinnati last year. Our experience exceeded expectations in both taste and service! Sarah was spectacular as our guide through the menu! She made amazing recommendations and was fun to talk to throughout the meal! Regardless of the food, go visit her! She will no doubt steer you in the right direction! In fact, everyone on staff that we encountered was friendly and helpful! Now on to the food - We have not had a meal that we have ooh'd and aah'd over in a long time. This meal will not be forgotten anytime soon! We started with the mussels and two empanadas (yes you can do that!). The broth for the mussels was good enough to eat with a spoon - so flavorful and yummy! We had the Korean bbq and spinach/cheese empanada...both delicious but the Korean is still my fave! We decided to try the raviolis and loved the short rib best! For the main course we split the salmon, which was delicious, but the butternut mash was the star of the dish for me! We were so full we ordered dessert to go. Looking forward to trying the chocolate cake when I have more room! But I have no doubt it will not disappoint! read more

See all

Oh my god!!! This is so far...one of my favorite places to eat in the city. Food is exquisite, service is excellent, incredible! I literally do not know why I haven't been here before!!! For sure a MOST if you come to Cincinnati. read more

Alfio's Buon Cibo - Steak with fries and chimichurri - Italian Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

First off, what has taken me so long to discover Alfio's Buon Cibo!?!?! My mother took me here last weekend, since she's been raving about it for months. Alfio's is known for their spin on Italian-Argentine dishes that do not disappoint. Can we say DELICIOUS! First we were greeted by the most friendly staff that welcomed us in and quickly seated us. The owner Scott stopped by to introduce himself to me, and already knew my mother. A few of the waitresses also remembered my mom from past visits. Our waitress was Allie and she was wonderful. She was on point throughout our whole meal, keeping our drinks full, providing great food recommendations, and casual chit chat that was nice. Now to the food! We started off by sharing the Grilled Romaine Salad. It was so yummy, the perfect amount of grilled flavor with a delicious tomato vinaigrette. It was a perfect portion for sharing. Since I was told they were known for their freshly made ravioli, that was my dinner selection. I had the Duo meal and chose the Short Rib Ravioli and Five Cheese Angus Ravioli. Both just melted in my mouth! The truffle sauce in the Short Rib was just perfectly paired. The cheese of the Five Cheese was the perfect amount of oozy cheesiness, without taking away from the ravioli itself. I had leftover of both to indulge in again for lunch. My mom had the Halibut with parmesan, spinach risotto which was also cooked perfectly. After all of that food we were too full for dessert, but I can't wait to try some of their selections at my next visit. I recommend you trying Alfio's Buon Cibo soon if you haven't already. They're nicely tucked in Hyde Park Square. The food is amazing, and for the price you can't beat it. I look forward to my next of many meals to come! read more

Alfio's Buon Cibo - Grilled Romaine Salad - Italian Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Nice ambiance & friendly waitress. Our drinks were superb however the chicken parm was a disappointment. My husband is very picky and decided to go with the chicken parm because he figured it's easy enough to make and not mess up. The chickens was dry and stringy and had very little taste. The scallop and shrimp fettuccine on the other hand was delicious. Very nice hint of white wine and other flavors mixed in. That saved the evening. Not sure if we will be going back. read more

Alfio's Buon Cibo - Summer sangria and Erica's old fashion. Both very good - Italian Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all