We came into this pie shop right after dinner nearby to grab some desserts to go for home. Heard great things about it and so glad we came in. Their key lime pie was absolutely mouth watering. It was full of flavors and still light and creamy. That's my favorite. We also got their strawberry and coconut cheesecake and the blueberry pie. My friends like what they got too. The two gentlemen behind the counter were so patient with our group. Thank you for waiting for us to make up our minds. read more

See all

The pies are great. I tried the strawberry rhubarb mini pie, a slice of key lime pie, and took home a chicken pot pie. The rhubarb was a bit tart for me though, so I probably won't get it again if I ever go back. Key Lime was average. Their chicken pot pie was good. Unfortunately, the service was a bit odd, which seems to be a recurring theme in other reviews. While checking out, I asked why there was an extra $2 charge on the chicken pot pie. The cashier told me it was because the strawberry rhubarb pie had been warmed in their oven and that baked pies incur an additional $2 charge. The explanation didn't make much sense, but it was my first visit, so I assumed there was some policy I didn't understand. When I got home and looked at the menu, I realized the $2 charge had actually been applied to the chicken pot pie. From what I can tell, they charge an extra fee if they bake one of the refrigerated pot pies for you. Mine was frozen, came with at-home baking instructions, and was never baked in-store. I sent an email to the address listed on the receipt to let them know they might be charging customers incorrectly, but never received a response. The food was good, but the whole situation was strange. read more

My mom and I stopped on for lunch when we were near the Junction. We ultimately got a Chicken Pot Pie and a Shepherd's Pie (plus one to go for my dad) which we really enjoyed. Nice filling and great crust. The place is small, and very little in the way of seating, but we were able to snag a couple of spots. Service was...meh. We'd come in mid-afternoon, and they'd been slammed earlier with a very heavy lunch rush. This meant most of the savory pies were gone. When all of the pies we'd enquired about were out, we'd decided to head out and try another place. As we were leaving I noticed a sign promoting a couple of other pies, namely the Chicken Pot and Shepherd's. They had a few of those cooking in the oven, as it turns out, to be ready in 10. Why were these not suggested, when the server knew what we were looking for, I dont really understand. So, we ordered 2 Chicken Pot pies, waited the 10 minutes for them to cook, only to find out when they were done, there was really only 1 Chicken Pot Pie. Why didn't they know this 10 mins before? Fortunately my mom was accommodating and was happy enough to have the Shepherd's instead. Happy enough with what we bought and ate. The pies are tasty. Not very happy with the service. read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Shepherd's Pie in a to-go container. - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Went here after our post dinner walk and decided to get pie. We were trying to decide between their Mexican Chocolate pie, White Chocolate Banana Crea pie, And their Seasonal Yuzu cheese cake. (almost got us) Opted for the banana because I've typically liked regular banana cream pies and haven't had one in awhile. Not the prettiest looking in the container. It had this light whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder on top of this white chocolate banana custard. In that custard was also these large chunks of bananas which was unexpected. I did enjoy the pie, but I don't think I would crave it. One thing I would change would be the pie crust. Something about it wasn't doing it for me. All in all, a solid experience. I've been here multiple times before and tried a good majority of their pies. Still need to tried a pie shake as well as their other offerings. If you like pie, this place has plenty of them. read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

Clean, welcoming pie shop where you can get whole pies without a notice. It was my roommates birthday & we got him his favorite key lime pie. When I tell you, he said it was one of his favorites. The pie was very succulent with the perfect amount of tartness. Pie shop located in a great area with mostly street parking, a couple of small lots and there is a paid parking garage behind. read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Key lime pie -$40 - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I can't say enough good things about this place! It's easily one of my favorite pie shops - every pie I've tried has been amazing. The white chocolate banana cream pie is my absolute favorite; I seriously dream about it, haha! The staff is always so kind and welcoming. Definitely go check them out! (: read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

We decided last night to splurge and get some slices of pies. We got the S'mores pie, I could not eat it after a couple bites. The crust had no taste of graham, but did taste of some kind of chemical. The top was meringue, not marshmallow, and the chocolate was hard, not creamy. The cookies and cream pie was fine, nothing special. The Marionberry Cheesecake was inedible. It had a very off putting sour taste. No cream cheese flavor, lots of sour cream taste. Spent over $40 for 3 pieces, of which one was edible! Very disappointed. Service was fine and the atmosphere was cute. read more

This Bakery is a hidden gem. I was looking for a very special dessert for my brothers birthday í decided to try Pie Ala Mode. I ordered the Crème Brule Chessecake. It was absolutely delicious! I was pleasantly surprised! I highly recommend this Bakery! You will not be disappointed! read more

Felt like I gained 5 pounds just sniffing the freshly baked pies when I came in the place & with all the yummies displayed, I wanted all of them The place is clean & felt like gramma's kitchen and the staff friendly & helpful read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - A slice of apple crisp pie with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Well well well did I see Savory Pies!! So we ordered a few savory pies the Cheeseburger 3/5 it was unfortunately salty, great flavor profile but it might just be an off day? Will let you know if I try again. The Spinach and Feta 5/5 so freakin' good definitely will be ordering more of these. Creme Brulee Cheesecake 2/5 I really really really wanted to like it but alas the cheesecake base is just too sweet let alone adding the brûlée, would be great to get more zest but I'm sure there are those who love it! For me I'll be going back for the Mexican chocolate pie mmmmm As always the service is always super sweet, friendly and helpful and the interior is lovely, high ceilings y'all!! Definitely worth a stop read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

10/10 pie and service was great! Definitely coming back here. They have a punchcard too. Buy 10 get one free read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Cookies and Cookies & Cream Slice & French Apple Slice are so good!! 10/10 food and service - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Talk about pie shop/bakery that was amazing. After tasty ramen for dinner with friends while visiting friends in Seattle. They suggested walk next door for slice of pie. I never been so was pumped for desserts. They always good to best food spots in Seattle. It not often find not only amazing bakery but one that specializes in pies. The minute walk in not only smells of all baked goods heavenly. U look at the display of all the pies, savory pies, and tough just pick one. One that stood out for me was Blue Hawaiian. See Hawaiian not pineapple associate with it. Blueberry and coconut. I had to get it. It was da bomb! One slice more like for two. They also sell whole pies and even do classes want learn make them. The filling was so so good. Mound of blueberries, crust nice light delicious, and coconut shaving on top perfect balance. They also sell merchandise, two refrigerators different drinks, and chill pies ready also order. The inside cool. Not really many spots sit down eat pie. The service five stars from minute walked in warm greeting and all smiles. Next time in Seattle be back try more pies!!!! read more

See all

Walking past this adorable pie shop, we could literally smell the pies baking from the street--it was impossible to resist. We made a point to come back the next day to see where all that goodness was coming from, and wow, we're glad we did! The staff greeted us with a warm welcome, and the menu had both sweet and savory options--which was exactly what we were hoping for. I had the shepherd's pie for lunch, and it was fantastic--the crust was buttery and flaky, the filling flavorful, and the mashed potatoes perfectly seasoned. We also tried the hamburger hand pie (so good!) and the chicken pot pie, which was just as delicious. Of course, we couldn't leave without taking home a few sweet pies. The peach pie was pure perfection, and the Hawaiian Blue--filled with toasted coconut, pineapple, and blueberry--was an unexpected but amazing flavor combo. If you're looking for a place with incredible pies, whether fruity or savory, A la Mode is a must-visit. You won't be sorry! read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I prefer pies to just about any other dessert. I was excited to try A La Mode, so I forked out what I consider way too much for a pie. I wanted the peach pie since it is in season only to be disappointed there weren't any in the store. Ok... it happens. I ordered a petite french apple. I feel compelled to say that it was among the worst pies I have ever had. The crust wasn't bad.... but the crust is about all I could taste. I was extremely disappointed. I ALWAYS finish my pie. This time I could not. Good thing too because an hour later I lost everything in the bathroom. It was definitely the pie because it was all I had. I do not recommend A La Mode.... because of the prices and because of the pie. Store bought pies are a lot better. I wish I lived close by to tell the owner myself. everything else about the store is great.... except what matters most. read more

Everything I wanted as an after meal snack. If I hadn't already eaten, I would've loved to get a couple pies here - their variety is amazing and you can definitely find something no matter what you're in the mood for. Sweet, savory, dessert, or meal. They'll definitely have something to do the trick read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Spicy eggplant hand pie - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Severely undercooked pies, to the point the bottom crust was completely raw, and we had to spit it out. I've never given a restaurant 1-star before, but it was inedible. read more

The Mexican Hot Chocolate is a perfect balance of rich chocolate with whipped cream that is not overly sweet and hint of heat from the chili. Decadence. The French Apple has a great balance of apples butter and cinnamon with a crisp crumble topping. The Blue Hawaiin is great also blueberry's and coconut. The crème brûlée cheesecake is to die for, almost as good as Juniors in Brooklyn. I typically door dash but I brought in my cards and proof of purchase and they gave me the punches, great service that shows they value their guests. read more

I was disappointed that despite there being pies in the display case, the slice we got were already pre sliced and packed to go. My husband thought his would be fresh cut because there was a whole new pie. I thought MY slice seemed really small, especially compared to the one my husband got. But they were different styles. I had a s'mores pie, which was ok. My husband's was banana cream, which was good! read more

This might have been the best slice of pie I've ever had. Apple filling was so flavorful and the perfect blend of tart and sweet. Very friendly service too. Only negative comment I have is that now I have no more pie to eat and that makes me sad. read more

The pies are okay, and people are very friendly here! This is another establishment that does not accept cash. Completely unacceptable in todays day and age for any business to have this policy. read more

We picked up a couple of pies from here for Thanksgiving. We had a top-notch berry pie. It was brimming with great berries, had a wonderfully flaky crust, and was delicious. That pie would earn this place five stars. But we also had a caramel chocolate pecan tart. The tart crust was far too thick and undercooked. The top of the tart was tasty, but the nuts seemed a little off (stale?). It was a two-star offering that might stretch to a two-and-a-half. The prices are high, though reasonable. Good pies are not inexpensive to make. The berry pie showed top-quality ingredients. The nuts in the tart have me double-guessing the quality and consistency of the ingredients across the full range of pies. We will have to return again, though we don't live close to here. This first experience tempers our enthusiasm somewhat, so it might be some time before we return for a second visit. read more

I had such a great experience picking up my pies during the weekend. The service was honestly fantastic, largely thanks to the cashier she had this really stylish short blonde hair (I told her she looks like a famous soccer player LOL) and had such a welcoming vibe. She made the whole hand off feel effortless and was so genuinely friendly that it really brightened my afternoon. It's one thing to get great dessert, but having someone provide that kind of top-tier service makes a huge difference. I'll definitely be back, not just for the pies, but because the staff makes the visit so pleasant. read more

I just had a slice of their Marionberry hazelnut pie. I am a pie lover and was looking forward to it... The filling was good, but the crust was inedible. The texture, which should be flaky, was stiff, dense and hard, like stale pita bread, Also, it had no taste of butter, as if it had been made with vegetable oil instead. Tasted like an old cracker. Pretty terrible, and disappointing for a shop specializing in pie. Please go to Snapdragon instead, where they take baking seriously and do it deliciously. I would not bother with posting a review, but this was beyond bad. I scraped off the filing and then put the crust in the compost bin. The help there was very jolly, however. Nice! read more

Found this place open and got there around 8pm. What a surprise to find amazing pies so late at night! Both wonderful and dangerous. Lol. I had to try the white chocolate banana cream pie and it was fantastic! Huge piece with many chunks of banana throughout. Not too sweet either so it didn't wreck your tastebuds, allowing you to finish the whole piece. Would highly recommend if you like pie. I do wish the crust was a little more flakey, mine was a little chewy, but overall very good. The place was nice and clean and very busy for 8pm. Glad to see a small business appearing to be thriving. They had berry pies, cream pies, and a shepherds pie, all on display and all looked great. Looked like they also sold pie dough for the DIY crowd, along with pints of ice cream. Great experience! read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - White Chocolate Banana Cream Slice - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

This place is great. Probably what would make it better would be seating. I get it, most probably don't hang around eating or drinking their pie and it's all togo. This recent trip I took a cottage pie (although they call it Sheppard's Pie) home, which was everything I had hoped and expected. I love beef pies and can't wait to go get another one. During this visit I also got to try their sour cherry pie in a shake (who doesn't love shakes, ha ha) and I thought it was excellent. I would love to try just the pie al-a-mode next time. Staff are always friendly and ready to serve you. If you are hoping for more selection, ensure you go earlier in the day. We manage to always get here in the evening and the number of pies to choose from is less, but that's ok, they are still delicious. read more

Excellent pies! We got Seattle's best apple pie and it did not disappoint! We also added $2 for a huge scoop or vanilla ice cream to make it an alamode! Friendly service and cute decor inside. The aroma of all the pies is amazing. Definitely will be back next time in seattle. It's also located near the farmers market on Sundays! read more

See all

Solid pie selection, the only one I miss is the butterscotch bourbon pie. Parking was kind of okay, but dicey when busy. read more

We were hesitant to try this place out because we always find pies are too sweet. Our cousin took us here and swore that this place is worth a try. We are glad we listened to them because their pies were not too sweet at all, which meant they were REALLY GOOD. We got the apple pie and cookies & scream (Halloween pun), they were perfect! The service was also very friendly and they had a little standing area where we can quickly enjoy the pies. read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - Pie selection - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

I was so excited to have their pie- I got their strawberry rhubarb slice for $8.00 - Bummer so bland and not even sweet savory - I was bummed that I paid that price for blandness - I won't be back - service was meh - read more

After the sticker shock and potentially long wait wears off, it really is the best pie out there. The crust is definitely butter based not shortening which makes all the difference. read more

I stopped in for a tart cherry pie for my partner's birthday. It was delicious! I will definitely be back to try their other offerings.

My review is primarily about the service. My family came in for dine-in pie ("for here") but the slices we ordered were taken from the "to-go" fridge. I saw this and repeated that we were taking our pie "for here" because it was a little loud for the staff to hear us, and maybe they didn't catch the initial request? Instead of slicing us a fresh cut from the pie at that point, they then scooped out our pies from the plastic "to-go" containers and put them on plates. I was off-put by that, but I always worry people will throw away food at that point and I'm not about that, so, I didn't make a fuss even though I thought it was not how you should present a slice of pie, when you state you will slice any pie. Later, I think it was an owner or manager... I saw THEM fresh-slice a different customer's slice of pie and put it on a plate. Maybe there's a disconnect in the staff training, or expectations? Why offer customers a pre-packaged slice then scoop it out of the container sacrificing presentation when they are dine-in? The pie itself was delicious as usual (thank you), but the service made me feel inequitable because it didn't make sense and someone else got a different level or kind of service. If you are trying to move product from a pie that had already been sliced and packaged, you could offer that at a discount. Especially if it's "Day Old". That's how old-school bakeries do it. read more

GO THERE!!! Never a disappointing decision no matter what you are in the mood for. I've had the Mexican chocolate and a couple of different fruit pies. Delicious!! I had the burnt cream brûlée cheese cake for the first time. It was superior to any cheese cake I've had from the Cheesecake Factory. Amazing!! read more

Bought 3 slices of lemon meringue pie. The was no crust to speak of, just a rim of crust. There was no meringue, it was overly sweet whip cream. It was like a bowl of pudding. All 3 of us concur. Expensive, awful. read more

In 2021, The Seattle Times deemed A La Mode Pie as the best place to get apple pie in the Seattle area (article below). With such esteemed recognition, how could I not try it?! They offer a variety of freshly baked pies, drinks and ice cream of course! You can order a full pie (most are $38), a slice ($8) or mini pie ($10). The mini pie is intended to serve two people, so it was the perfect size for me to taste what all the hype is about. Even less than one hour before closing, there was still a good amount of pies on the rack behind the counter. The kind employee boxed up my mini French Apple pie to-go, quickly processed my payment and then I was off! So... was this apple pie the best in the city? I'm disappointed to say that I wasn't blown away. It was not a bad pie, but given their award-winning recipe, I had pretty high expectations. Upon first glance, the crust and crumble were baked to a perfect golden brown, so that was a great sign. The crust itself was nice and buttery, but the streusel on top tasted somewhat bland. Normally, the filling is my favorite part, but this one fell flat for me. The apples were sliced thin and pretty mushy. They didn't have much flavor either and definitely needed more cinnamon and/or spice. However, I did enjoy the slight tartness of the apples and how the filling was essentially pure fruit rather than the goopy type that you find in a lot of pies. It also wasn't too sweet which was a plus. If you are in the area, I would suggest giving this spot a try and see what you think. Everyone has different tastes. Hopefully their other pies would be better, especially considering the pretty steep pricing. 3.25 stars. Article: https://www.seattletimes.com/life/food-drink/what-is-the-seattle-areas-favorite-pie-flavor-and-where-do-the-pros-buy-pie/ read more

A La Mode Pies West Seattle - French Apple pie - mini size ($10) - Desserts Near Me - Seattle, Washington

The pies at A la Mode Pies were delicious! The pies were so good I forgot to take photos! D: I ordered a slice of Peach Summer Pie and French Apple Pie, both $8 per slice. The Peach Summer pie was my favorite because of the fresh peaches that were stuffed in the pie. It was packed with peach sweetness and the crust was well baked. The French Apple pie was delicious but not as good as the peach one since it wasn's as sweet. My favorite part of the apple pie was the buttery crumble topping; the apple flavor wasn't very strong. Maybe overpowered by the cinnamon buttery crumble. The pies here are worth a try, but the price is what got me a bit. I wonder if $8 a slice is reasonable. The price of 2 slices equates to a meal now. read more

See all

Outstanding the best pies period. Just be ready to pay for what you get. The lemon meringue was my favorite.

Living close to such an amazing pie place is very dangerous for my Sour cherry, chocolate caramel pecan tart, & Mexican chocolate are so so so good. Sour cherry pies are my absolute favorite, so I tend to go back to that one, but I recently tried the blue Hawaiian (blueberry, pineapple, coconut) and all it really tasted like was sugary blueberry. Even the crumble topping tasted like straight sugar. Wouldn't repurchase. But it was still good read more

I tried a slice of Mexican Chocolate pie and it was tasty. The middle is mostly chocolate cream though which is ok but I prefer something closer to a pudding consistency. The crust was good, as was the white cream on top. Not too cloyingly sweet overall, I thought. There is some spice on top because this is Mexican chocolate. It's $8 for a slice which seems a little steep but the slice is fairly large and you could probably share with someone if you don't want a ton of pie. This establishment is pretty cute and I'd like to try more, especially the cookies and cream! read more

Crème brûlée cheesecake was so good. They gave us one on the house as well. Tried it with our friends strawberry rhubarb pie and it was amazing read more