I strongly recommend that home warranty customers document, and if possible, record their interactions with this "company." My experience was so concerning that I have filed a formal complaint with the home warranty company, which has now assigned a claims specialist to review the matter.
Fortunately, I was lucky to have video footage of the interaction via our home security system.
This company was dispatched to my home for a plumbing issue involving the water supply to my refrigerator. The refrigerator is approximately FIVE feet from my kitchen sink. There is an open and easily accessible route through the cabinet and behind the dishwasher directly to the plumbing under the sink, where there is an accessible cold water supply and shut off.
Rather than discuss the obviously straightforward connection to the cold water supply, the plumber began describing this as potentially being a major job. He mentioned the possibility of having to CUT INTO THE CONCRETE to run a water line!!! I had my mom, who is elderly, there meeting him and she called me and put me on the phone with him when he started going off on this tangent.
I work in construction and I understand enough to recognize when someone is being disingenuous. The suggestion that this could potentially require cutting into the concrete is completely ABSURD. Once I got him on the phone, he quickly backtracked, and then ended up leaving the house shortly after, providing no services. It is now 5 days post visit and this "company" has still not filed a report with my home warranty.
The entire interaction left me questioning whether the goal was to genuinely diagnose and resolve the plumbing issue or simply justify performing no work on a home warranty dispatch.
To be clear, I am describing my personal experience and my concerns based on what I personally observed. I do not know how this company is compensated by home warranty providers or whether compensation is received simply for responding to a dispatch. However, based on my experience, I believe home warranty companies should carefully review this contractor's diagnosis, representations, and service practices.
I cannot help but wonder what an elderly homeowner or someone with no construction experience would have believed after being told that a refrigerator water line located approximately five feet from an accessible cold water supply could potentially involve cutting into their concrete.
I would not allow this company back into my home, and I would strongly encourage others to document their service visit and independently verify any claims.
I will be filing claim with the state, the CSLB and BBB, as I noticed that their CSLB# is suspiciously absent from their website, which is in contrast to CA State Law.
I hope that, if this company is operating as a properly licensed contractor, it quickly addresses these issues and seriously reviews its service practices. read more