Truly a hidden gem. The best chicken and waffles on Long Island, full stop. Was fortunate enough to stop in when they weren't too busy so the chicken was made fresh. The spicy 5 Brothers syrup is exquisite on the chicken, and the waffles were cooked perfectly and paired very nicely with the chicken. Make the journey, brave the tiny parking lot, and you'll end up thanking yourself. This place does not disappoint. read more

My husband got this delivered on Uber so I'm not sure if the quality of the chicken suffered during the delivery process but it was nothing to write home about. The macaroni and cheese was delicious, top tier. This place has really good reviews on cleanliness and friendly staff. The food had excellent reviews, and the mac & cheese was delicious. I will have to check out the location in person because I believe based on other people's reviews that the quality of food did in fact suffer due to the delivery. read more

Best fried chicken I've had in a long time. The waffle was a treat also and the mac & cheese was fabulous.

The food is amazing very flavorful. It's the best. I've tried no doubt about it. Catfish is my favorite. The mac & cheese will make you run around the block twice. I haven't tried everything on the menu, but from what I have tried you you don't know what you're missing. read more

See all

Wow...just wow...truly the best fried chicken I've had in a long while. Always pass this place but never tried it, reason why will be stated at the end of this review. The fried chicken was served hot with warm chicken juices dripping out with every bite. The chicken was well fried and well seasoned. Not overwhelming with spices that at most chicken places the mixture of spices doesn't end well. But these 5 guys got the seasoning just right, subtle and balanced flavor, not just on the outside skin but seasoned straight through to the bone. And the sauce it comes with only enhances the flavor experience. The waffles were excellent, they obviously use the best waffle mixture but most importantly it was not hard or overcooked. I also had the coleslaw which tasted amazingly like homemade. Again nice balanced seasoning with just the right amount of kick. Now here's the sad part...the parking! If these guys relocate to a strip mall with endless parking, they'll have lines out the door all day long. Won't get into the parking details, but if you're not from the area just be prepared to perhaps park a few feet away and walk over. But trust me it's worth it to experience this great fried chicken!. read more

The food is not the same as it used to be. I used to get a chicken Gyro that was delicious now it is completely different. The chicken is not the same and seasoned weird. I would also get their chicken over rice but the rice is completely different. Used to be my go to spot. They still have good waffles. That's it. read more

This review is regarding an UberEats order. I have never physically been to the location, so I can't comment on things like customer service or the interior. Taste: A Portion: A Price: B Food I was a little hesitant to order because the prices are a bit high (even more than Popeyes, which I already find overpriced), and I didn't want to risk spending a lot on chicken that could end up dry or overcooked like some reviews mentioned. Luckily, the chicken I got was on point. The skin was crispy perfection, and the inside was juicy and moist, but definitely not undercooked. They nailed it! The waffle, however, arrived a bit soggy, but that's to be expected with delivery. After five minutes in my air fryer, it crisped right back up. I imagine you could do the same in a toaster oven or under the broiler if needed. The mac and cheese was also delicious! Not quite on par with Grandma's homemade, but more like a solid "sissy mac" using Grandma's recipe--comforting and cheesy enough to hit the spot. The banana pudding was also REALLY good. It wasn't the best banana pudding I ever had, but it was certainly up there. Next time I'll be ordering a large for sure! Price The prices are on the higher side, but given the quality, I'd say it's worth it. I suspect they position themselves as a more upscale option. Ordering on UberEats adds a bit of a premium too, but overall, I'd say this was a pretty good value for what I got. read more

Don't ever order food over the phone. They answer the phone and speak to you like they don't want the customers. Last 3 times my order has been completely wrong and they reacted like it's your fault. read more

food is good ordered on Uber Eats with their buy one get one and I only got the one meal not enough for my family, I will eat here again just becareful when packing order and ordering for delivery you might not receive the correct order. read more

Was pricier than it needed to be, food was delicious, but wait was too long. The workers will just stair at you rudely and keep on talking amongst themselves. Cashier never smiled, but got the job done. read more

I love this place so much and the staff are amazing and the food is amazing and delicious I will definitely come back and there chicken is amazing their drinks it's really great I try some of them and I love them a lot I will definitely come back for the fried chicken it is so good your friend Dj Dee love read more

Chicken is seasoned well and crispy! Waffles are flavorful as well! Everything was delicious! We will definitely order again! read more

5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles - 1 Waffle with 4 Pieces of Chicken - Waffles Near Me - Patchogue, New York

Probably the best chicken and waffles I have had. Wish they had a sitting area. Their chicken and waffles are best eaten straight out of the fryer and the waffle maker. read more

They're very punctual, always have a smile, their chicken Gyros, chicken cheesesteak, and chicken over rice are delicious. Haven't been disappointed yet. read more

This was the worst takeout I've had in a long time, the falafel was chopped up and dry, the chicken on the chicken and waffles was terrible, they forgot part of my order and wanted me to drive back to get it and the overall vibe of the meal was cheap fast food . read more

opens late for a breakfast place. The wait was long. And the floors were dirty. The food was mid all around and cold.

Good place service is professional lots of choices. The chicken is delicious. The waffles are freshly made as you order. They come in a paper box with syrup. They also give you some kind of red sauce for the chicken I didn't explore. The chicken didn't need anything, in my opinion. Perfect as is. The downside is parking, only two spots, and on a busy road, it's hard to get in. Finding an alternative and walking a few feet for this chicken is my answer. The cost was under $10 for three pieces and a waffle. They have been the for many years and directly across from KFC, so they are definitely doing something right. It's worth a try. read more

5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles - Three piece meal Breast, thigh and leg - Waffles Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Five stars for being nice.One for jacking up the single specification my order.When I said I wanted two breasts two wings two legs,I seriously meant it.WE HATE THIGHS...so now I have two and the wing nor breast I was really looking forward to.I called the gentleman polite but the logic of when I come back to buy more they will replace the breast..what about the wing..the gas in my Hemi for that half an hour ride?Nice but even the offer of four pieces,come on just customer service wise replace the entire six pice that was incorrect...polite yes.Nobody forgot to charge me?Fair is fair.But,the rest of the order is correct.If I forgot my money at home would I still have gotten my food?Probably not,that would have been an accident too?lol Very clean and bright spot..pics to come minus my correct chicken lol kinda read more

Haven't had chicken & waffles in a long time but this was pure gas. The chicken had a nice crisp. The waffle with powdered sugar & syrup was so good. The mac hit the spot. I only seen 4 brothers though lol read more

See all

The young men behind the counter provided good service. The ambience is not great. The plastic fork broke on the chicken. The chicken was properly cooked and not too dry. The Mac and cheese was so cheesy that oil pooled on top. The waffle was decent, just like one you get at the breakfast in a mid-range hotel. It wasn't bad but I'll probably not return. Might be fine for take-out. read more

Food is great! Staff is very pleasant! Prices are reasonable. Clean in the kitchen area and where you enter. read more

Best chicken and waffles around, definitely get the Mac and cheese for the side it's great

How have i not been here before!? The waffles and fried chicken was so good. The corn nuggets were surprisingly yummy as well. I got my son tenders and they were giant pieces but not as tasty as the regular fried chicken. The waffle batter had a hint of sweetness to it which we love. Cant wait to go back read more

5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles - Waffles Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

***WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE EXPERIENCE*** DO NOT PLACE ONLINE ORDERS FOR THIS PLACE, PRICES ARE SIGNIFICANTLY HIGHER ONLINE THAN IN STORE. (This was a in store pick up). I spoke to the store owner about it so that he could help me in the process to have the price difference refunded with Grubhub customer service and he became immediately rude & aggressive because of the price discrepancy and started calling me names saying "I don't know what I was talking about, I am drunk ""The prices are the same""blah blah blah" he then further insulted me by saying "I wasn't his customer because I purchased the food online" WHAT!? in the photos you will see how I was over charged by over $20 and Grubhub sent me a refund for the difference within just a couple hours. read more

See all

This place is so good. It's not traditional fried chicken in the southern sense but it is tasty. The tenders are always cooked to order and hot. Highly recommend trying! read more

Outstanding! What a great little place. The atmosphere was fun, and even though it was busy, our food came hot and fast. I love the bow-ties! They seemed to recognize and greet quite a few regulars so it nice to know it's well-loved locally and has that awesome home-town feel. The food was delicious. We had fried chicken and waffles and it was seasoned and cooked perfectly. I'm so glad this is a local place and not somewhere we stumbled upon while traveling... I think we'll be visiting 5 Brothers often. read more

See all

I still dream about the waffle!!!! It was amazing ! Everything was !!!!! The chicken was so crispy and not greasy at all.

Food was really good hot and juicy chicken and waffles were nice and fluffy. Staff was friendly

You had a grand opening in setauket store with 2 pieces of chicken and a waffle for 3.50 .why don't you have the same thing for 5.99? Looks like you only have 4 pices od chicken. read more

I DO NOT pass out five stars lightly but, this place is pretty solid. Came to visit my family out on the Island and Brother said "the chicken is good" well the truth was told that day. Lol The whole crew is so nice in the store and the food was amazing. I really wanted a sweet treat but, I'll wait until next time. read more

We ordered 20 pieces, all white meat. We received 5 breast and 15 wings. Very little meat on the chicken. Sides are small. Expensive for this amount of food. read more

Fried Chicken & Buffalo Wings 5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles 530 Medford Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772 Fresh and crispy fried chicken. Get the 5 brothers sauce. It's delicious. Followed by Saucy, juicy Buffalo wings. Amazing The staff are all brothers, and super friendly. Every time I go their always smiling MashaAllah. Enjoy every bite and don't forget to say Bismillah and Alhamdulilah for everything Review: (5 out 5 Stars) read more

See all

Called ahead from beach. 15 minutes away for double order of chicken w waffles, mac n cheese side. It's right at the light so you might miss it. It's a small shop with no seating. Soda dispenser and refrigerated drinks on left wall and all of the cooking area, refrigerated sides and dessert as well as service counter on your right. Fresh batch of chicken as we came in. Our order was ready to go along with 2 added desserts with 5 minutes wait to be rung up. 20 minute drive home we smelled the fried chicken all the way. When we finally sat to eat the chicken stayed crisp, the waffle was still firm and with powdered sugar waiting for syrup, vanilla wafting from the box. the side we picked was mac n cheese (extra flavor of sour cream made it extra creamy) read more

5 Brothers Fried Chicken & Waffles - Front counter - Waffles Near Me - Patchogue, New York

See all

Happy 2025!! My daughter told me to try this place after I dropped her off at Islip airport on New Year's Day. I was hungry so I went by myself sorry hubby. One of the brothers greeted me was talking with be and asked where I came from. I told him and he said I have never seen you before then he said Thank You for coming in from so far as I walked in. The place was bright, and had a few tables so you could eat there and clean you barely smelled the food cooking in front of you. I placed my order of 5 wings and waffles with a side of Mack and cheese. This came up to around $22.00 with tip included and I rounded it up. The price was really good!! There were so many options and so many other items on the menu. The waffle was good freshly made and was hot when i got it as was the wings. The Mac and cheese it was good as well. I would come back again. I showed my husband the menu and he is ready to go!! Try 5 Brothers Fried Chicken and Waffles KaC read more

The food was delicious the waffle was great the curly fries were so tasty and crunchy you would think that this is going to be a. 5star review the way it started sorry to disappoint once I took a bit out of the Fried chicken I was so disappointed it was pinkish inside if remember chicken is not suppose to be a little pink I'm not eating medium well steak smh the service was great ambiance there no seating in the restaurant read more

See all

When you order only Chicken there needs to be a discount and not pay full price. I only wanted 8 pc chicken only and they charged me full price as if I orders the combo deal, which comes with waffles and two sides. The service is ok but more than half of these guys have no clue what is happening . Do not oder chicken only jeer the entire combo. Chicken that is great is Texas chicken better service . read more

Wanted to try this place out since I like eating waffles and chicken wings. Have to say this place did not disappoint! Was a little nervous when bringing in three other foodies to also try it out because I would never hear the end of it for making a bad selection when there was a KFC right across the street. In addition to making a good tasting waffles, the fried chicken was nicely seasoned and had a good crunchy skin. Not greasy and not dry. In fact, the prices were real good. For $7.99 you get four pieces of chicken and a side along with an 8 inch waffle. The 3-piece version was $6.99. One of my friends got the fried shrimp order (no waffles) and he said it was very tasty. I would recommend giving this place a try and you won't be sorry you stopped by. read more

SUCH AN UNDERRATED GEM. Many people probably overlook this place since it looks like a hole in the wall type of place and there's no seating arrangement. BUT, lemme tell you - that is a HUGE mistake. We were a little skeptical at first but we decided to get the 3 piece Chicken Tender with Waffle & fries which was around $9. It was worth every penny. The chicken was fried perfectly and was so juicy and moist. It had such good flavor and paired with the waffle was amazing. The waffle by itself was amazing and had actual flavor. We also got the fries which could have honestly been the star of the show by themselves. They were crunchy and flavored amazingly - especially when paired with the 5 brothers sauce. Unfortunately didn't get a picture of the fries but you're just gonna have to believe me on that one. All in all, amazing spot, would def come again. read more

See all

Ending 2023 with a BANG. The boys over at 5 brothers do NOT dissapoint. The chicken & waffles are always on point but the banana pudding is on another level. 8/10. read more

My husband has been dying to go here and we finally visited it! We got the fried chicken with waffles, cole slaw and sweet corn nuggets. The chicken was crispy in all the right places and perfectly cooked. The Coleslaw was subpar and I would probably pass on that next time. The sweet corn nuggets were great, you can't eat just one! We ordered the food as takeout, and they gave us plenty of syrup to top our waffles with. The waffles even had butter and powdered sugar on them. The prices were more then fair as well, this may be a frequent eats for us. read more

See all