As much as I like this place I wasn't treated like a valued customer the last time I visited he downtown location on 6/24/2016 around 4:15 p.m. The young boy whom I assume was the "manager" of some sort literally yelled across the restaurant in a snarky and rude tone asking if I was going to pay for my $3.77 gelato. When he was ringing me up I was having trouble with my credit card due to recent traveling (they temporarily cut it off to prevent possible fraud as it was outside of my normal spending habits). I asked him to hold off on it for a moment and got some cash (no one else in line as it was a very slow day). I went back to the register and paid a nice young lady $4 and told her to keep the change for the tip jar and then picked up my overpriced gelato. After finishing, I started to walk out with my colleague and was yelled at from across the restaurant questioning if I planned on paying for the gelato. I pointed to the young lady and she politely informed the extremely rude young boy making pizza that I had already paid. This was about as unprofessional as it comes. Even if I was dressed in ratty homeless clothing this would not be acceptable (I was in business casual slacks, a button down, and loafers. Not exactly thief attire). An experienced manager would have walked to me and politely asked his question. It was not busy at all so the boy who screamed across the restaurant wouldn't have missed much by politely approaching me like a decent human being. Sadly, I won't be back into this establishment because of the customer service I received. Your Pie should really start hiring more customer service experienced employees to interact with customers. read more

Closed at 9:02 Friday night. Wouldn't let us order despite still having a grand total of 6 people still eating. If it was any good, I think it would be busier. read more

Amazing food and great people. They are super friendly. I also liked that they were very attentive to my children making sure they had what they wanted on their pizza. My wife got the gluten free pizza and loved it as she has had them all over and one of her favorite. read more

My boyfriend and I love coming to this Your Pie. It's our favorite one we've been to (we've been to 3 total).The pizzas are never burnt and everyone overall is super sweet. One guy in particular named Chris is always super helpful and is even considerate of our vegan lifestyle. He makes sure our pizzas are separate from non-vegan pizzas and we can tell he works really hard. We were very surprised to find out he isn't manager or has any promotion cause he definitely deserves it. read more

Was a good pizza joint right on the main through way downtown. Fast and friendly service in a nice atmosphere. Prices are fair as you can build your own personal pizza with all the toppings you want no extra charge or get one of the house selections. All in all a good experience and a good eat. read more

My husband and I were here for a few days. We loved the pizza. Even ordered it twice while we were in town. Unfortunately the service wasn't all that great. It wasn't very busy and the staff seemed rude. Other than that I would suggest getting the pizza ! read more

First time eating at Your pie. The food was great and the staff are friendly. The atmosphere in and around the business has a very "small town" vibe. Definitely enjoyed it and would recommend it to anyone looking for good food. read more

Fantastic restaurant. The staff is extremely friendly and the place is pristine. The pizza's that they make taste great and the variety is limitless. If you have never eaten at Your Pie, please bring a whole battalion of you and your friends to eat here! You won't regret it! P.S. They are great towards the college crowd! read more

3.5 stars, maybe 3.75 for the overall experience. Good pizza, designed by you, cooked to order with lots of fresh ingredients to choose from. Great for Columbus. If you've ever had truly world-class, 5 star pizza, though, you'll agree that YP is simply 3.5 stars. YP also has a nice selection of craft brews on tap. For the best of the best look for Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana certification, or when in ATL try Antico for pizza that is as close to 5 stars as you'll find anywhere. Also try Taconelli's in PHL, Frank Pepe's in New Haven, or maybe Grimaldi's in Brooklyn. read more

I was looking for a lunch place in Columbus and stumbled across this gem. Pizza and salad were great and the staff were very friendly. I would definitely come back! read more

Returning from a trip to Chicago, I was craving pizza, but figured I wouldn't be satisfied after eating pizza there. My husband said a coworker (who's taste buds I trust) gave them great reviews. So we decided to give them a try. We enjoyed it so so much Our favorite is "The Grand Central". The garlic knots, oh my, delicious. Anytime we want pizza out, it's Lepoma's. If you haven't tried it, you are definitely missing out. The staff has been very nice. read more

This place was a great find! I had a Delicious made to order pizza. I loved the wheat crust! I so appreciate that Katlyn took her time and made my pizza perfectly! I definitely recommend this spot! read more

It's okay but I do not see what the hype is all about. One girl wrote that it is like "subway for pizza" but gave it 4 stars. For the price it does not deserve 4 stars. The crust is not very good and the toppings just did not seem that fresh or tasty. Honestly, even though its a chain, go to Mellow Mushroom and get a MUCH better pizza. read more

Pizza is good but portion to price is not really worth it. It was 8$ for just a small personal pizza not including drink or side item..

Its good lol tastes so natural i wouldve dropped a pic but its all gone its pretty small and im still fucking hungry but yeah lol

I made my own pepperoni meatball bacon broccoli pineapple spinach barbecue thai sauce pizza and it was amazing!! I would definitely recommend this place. It was clean the staff was very friendly and the price wasn't bad. read more

Good pizza but overpriced. Also there is always a lot of people in the restaurant because of events downtown so it's always a long line for the bathroom. The bathroom is always dirty. read more

Sunday night in Columbus doesn't have many options. We ate here on valentine's day weekend after a long day on the Riverwalk. Create your own pizza, what's not to love? We enjoyed the food, but I had an awesome time playing foosball in the back! read more

Really good pizza spot! My boyfriend and I went here. I think our pizza and cheese sticks came to a total of $13. Really good deal! I asked him, "Now, would you trade this for two hot and ready pizza's from little ceasers" he said "No." no hesitation. The cheesticks were sooooooo gooey. And everything was made to order and fresh! So many options. Will definitely return read more

Can you really go wrong with a "subway-esk" Build Your Own Pizza? No, the only things i'd suggest is that they have a list of ingrediants posted somewhere so we can actually decide before hand what we want on our pizza. Other than that - YUM! read more

Great portions for a personal pie, and the price is awesome. I love the BBQ chicken pie here. It's like 7 bucks, and the beer is cheap also. It's nice to have restaurants that aren't bars that serve craft beer for reasonable prices. Nobody wants to pay 6 bucks for a beer. Most beers here are like 4 bucks. Very affordable and open late! read more

Taste: B+ Service: B+ Quality: B+ Cleanliness: A- This place is like Subway for Pizza; you get it your way (more or less). After you place your order for one of their special "pies," you can tell the person behind the counter exactly what you want on your pizza. The only thing I didn't like was the fact that some toppings like sausage costed extra and they didn't tell me until I was at the cash register. You can choose the pizza dough as white or wheat. Both are made right in front of you. My only complaint is that it is made a little too thin, almost to the point where the pizza slices just droop and snap off when you pick them up. Prices are reasonable with most pizzas coming out to about $8-9. But these pizzas are small enough that one person should be able to finish one off solo. So in that respect some may consider them pricey. Taste is good, especially because you choose what you want on top. But with the short amount of time the pizza spends in a shallow oven, you can't really expect it to taste like genuine New York pizzas. After the workers ring you up and serves you your pizza, there is zero additional service. Not even a "thank you come again!" when you leave. read more

Just what you're hoping it will be: Perfect spot for an inexpensive pizza with fresh, tasty ingredients. The orders are made in front of you, and are ready quickly. Nice, friendly staff. Nice location for weekends, with outdoor seating on Broadway. read more

Very friendly staff. Good pizza...and awesome drink machine :) all you need in a restaurant

The pizza I got from here was probably the most average pizza I've ever had. It was good, but the thing about bad pizza is that it's still pretty good. It's definitely subway-like in that you can pick all the ingredients on your pizza, but it's also subway like quality. I'd eat here again, but would not seek it out. read more

So good! Pizza with any and all toppings for 7.99 and you can add a drink and a salad/chips/gelato for 3.49. Great deal, but the quality puts it on top. Overall an awesome place to eat! read more

Good pizza, good salad, assortment of beers. In a great area for strolling downtown before or after eating. Ambiance lacks just a tad for this downtown location. read more

The food was tasty, love the thin crispy crust baked in the hot stone oven. You can choose from the menu or create your own. We are here for lunch I appreciate that I was filled up without feeling over full. Prices are great even have smaller pizza for children. The kiddos in front of us were given scraps of dough to play with. Would definitely come back. read more

This is now Columbus's second location, and it seems business is baking. Their brick oven pizzas, allow you to get your taste buds moving to your perfect specifications. The staff, whether in a group setting or the dreaded lunch alone, are courteous, and prompt to get your pie out quickly. If you've saved room make sure you check out the array of pallet cleansing gelato, finishes off the meal quite well. read more

Excellent pizza and at a kick ass price. Thin, crips and tasty crust with no flop when picked up. Outstanding favors on the Southern Heat version. Will be back when in town. read more

Your Pie - Pizza Near Me - Columbus, Georgia

GREAT service! And quick delivery. Always good pizza and very nice employees. I love going here and afterwards being able to walk around downtown. It's in such good location. read more

sat outside when there were no customers and was kicked out in an unprofessional way by a manager. was told this was "not a little hang out spot" when we were waiting on friends for only a few minutes. i am an adult and was treated like a child by this manager. read more

Really fresh ingredients make a delicious pizza. Kinda pricey, but worth it.

Amazing pizza. The basil pesto sauce is great. Fresh ingredients the gelato has great flavor. Truly a treat.

This was a great stop for a custom thin crust pizza and I loved the Nat special. We also had 3 other custom combos that were awesome. The staff were friendly. It is in a great area and has outdoor seating too. It was a memorable stop before leaving this town! Thank you! read more

Loved this place! Great food and service. Salad was fresh and the pizza was amazing! Great selection of toppings. Will definitely eat here again next time I'm in Columbus. read more

Great place to visit if you're headed to or from Fort Benning. Fresh ingredients, GF options, and very nice employees. Worth a visit.

Genuinely enjoy the pizza here. Unique options, endless choices, and decent gelato to book! My favorites are the Thai Pie and and the Southern Heat. Good hours too! read more

My husband and I love eating here. Always tasty, just wish they would bring back the pickled jalapeños and green olives!

Ordered pizza over phone and showed up on time to find it wasn't made. We went up and asked and they hadn't started. Horrible Service