From the customer service to the pastries everything is a 5/5 at this place. A cute little hidden gem that I see myself enjoying for a long time. The cold brew is great, the ham and cheese croissants are delish, the iced tea was wonderful, and the Nutella babka is the best you can ever get. Strongly recommend to drop in and pick up some Pastries. read more

Yardsale Cafe - Cold brew with oat milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Small cafe in Brooklyn with really friendly staffs! It's a small cafe with minimal seating inside. My coworker recommended this place and brought in a whole babka for the team to tried. This place became my go to whenever I crave babkas. My husband and I absolutely their babkas. We've gone back 3x just for their babka! I have tried babkas from other places and it cannot compare. read more

Excellent pastry shop. Picked up a spinach and cheese bureka, too much chocolate cookie, and Nutella babka. Bureka was flakey with a crispy cheese base. Liberally covered in sesame seeds. Cookie was soft with big chunks of chocolate. Nice balance of sweetness and saltiness. Babka was my favorite. Super soft and incredibly rich. On par with any of the Jewish bakeries in NYC. They were well stocked even though we came by around 4 pm. Service was friendly and quick. read more

OMG the cheesecake, I'll be dreaming of it daily. The kids were entertained for hours going through vintage comics and post cards and the pastries are divine. Highly recommend read more

See all

I came here on a Sunday evening around 5:30pm. I got 2 everything croissants, a chocolate croissant, and a cinnamon roll. The cinnamon roll was my favorite. Delicious. I'm looking forward to trying their burnt cheesecake on my next trip there. read more

See all

I'm typically not a pastry girl, but ever since I discovered this place from the office catering at my company, I haven't looked back. My all-time favorite is the ham and cheese croissant. Even though I eat these every week in my office, I never get sick of it and look forward to the days that we get catering from here. I also highly recommend the basque burnt cheesecake. It's so creamy and you can taste the slight tinge of bitterness of the cake which helps to balance out the sweetness on the inside. This place is a hidden gem in NYC and I know it's only a matter of time before this place blows up. read more

Fabulous! Always fresh pastries and coffee! Love the atmosphere.Would recommend highly. Also enjoy the items chosen for sale around the shop. read more

My words will never do justice for the burnt cheesecake. Wow. The best cheesecake I have ever had! I didn't have much expectation since it's the only gluten free item they had, but boy am I going to keep coming back! So creamy and flavorful. I haven't finished my slice and I already crave it, Completely disagree with other reviewers: this place is definitely better than Roots. The service was fast and pleasant. Plus they have amazing trinkets for sale. 10 stars if I could! read more

Yardsale Cafe - Burnt Cheesecake - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The flavors are complex and often astonishing in a good way. The babka is decadent, both juicy and crisp. The savory offerings are unique and very good as well. I would describe them as delicate and subtle with delightful flavor surprises. One was especially memorable, filled with a thin cheese, with notes of rosemary bringing delight to my taste buds. Definitely worth investigating. read more

The coffee was AMAZING! I got a plain almond milk latte. Didn't even need any flavoring - I just put two stevia in it. Probably the best coffee I've had in NYC so far. read more

Such a cute little coffee shop! Has a vintage vibe, their tea selection is great and you can browse old playbills/kitchen ware while you're in there! The barista's are super nice! The cinnamon rolls are also very rich and great, but the vegan cookies are my fave read more

The best! Their babka is incredible, as are their coffee drinks. You really can't go wrong here, everything is made with love. They're also the friendliest baristas/servers in the neighborhood which I very much appreciate! The space is also so cute. I wish they'd bring back their lunch salads and sandwiches though :) read more

This cafe is my happy place in the morning. I love the cozy and easygoing vibe. They have the best croissants in the neighborhood hands down and the coffee is always excellent. I'm also basically addicted to the burekas as I love savory pastries, something you don't often see at other cafes around here. The owner and baristas are always friendly -- one of them suggested I try simple syrup in my hot coffee and this was a game changer for me! My kids love to check out the vintage playing cards so I can drink my coffee in peace, and I may or may not have been eyeing the NKOTB trading cards for the better part of a year. :) read more

A very welcome addition to the neighborhood! Good coffee, great food, and a very friendly staff! Many, if not all, of the desserts are freshly made, in addition to an excellent menu of salads and bites. As you can see, I recently ordered the fattoush salad and it was excellent! Served as a sizable portion of well-cut veggies (heirloom tomatoes, radishes, baby cukes) and herbs with a light dressing and seasoned croutons. Also a big fan of the "Too Much Chocolate" cookie, although I think there's never too much chocolate in a cookie! Support this local biz and don't forget to browse the shelves for cool, retro gifts. Everything is for sale at the Yardsale Cafe! read more

See all

Best pastries in the neighborhood. The babka, cinnamon rolls, cookies, and cheese cake are 10 out of 10. They also make a fantastic cup of coffee. read more

What's better than delicious babkas, croissants, bourekas, and coffees? An incredible owner who knows customers by name and actually takes the time to make sure each and every person feels welcome and taken care of. Yardsale is more than a cafe, it's a super special locale where every detail has tremendous thought put behind it. Gorgeous antiques, a lovely backyard, and friendly smiles to brighten your day. Love you Yardsale! read more

Yardsale Cafe - Enjoying a lavender oat matcha latte 3 - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I stopped into Yardsale on my way home the other day and they did not disappoint! The nutella babkas are amazing. The iced tea is so refreshing. The other reviews are right about this place! I also love the idea of a thrift store/coffee shop. So unique! read more

Oh, my, wow... ... is all I can say about the MATCHA LEMON COOKIE!! It's dense, it's salty, it's sweet, it's lemon-y fragrant, and the matcha has a creamy texture in this cookie. The universe gave me a sign today (it was outside of their store) so I stopped in. The staff was cheerful and the whole vibe of this place reminds me of happiest moments of my childhood. read more

I've been in this coffee shop before about a year ago because I lived in Florida, This year I went back to my old neighborhood to drink great coffee and great pastries!!!!! Service was great food was fantastic and I got some souvenirs for my friend, After all it was a perfect place to lay low for a little while here is some pictures. read more

See all

Cute little shop with coffee, sandwiches, and other small plates. Walls and shelves are lined with just about the kitschiest stuff you've ever seen. read more

I don't typically have a difficult time making a choice between sweet treats but at Yardsdale everything is so good that I often end up eating a few different things. The Basque-style cheesecake it absolutely to die for, super creamy but with a deliciously firm, caramelized outside. The Babkas are equally delicious, either in cinnamon or Nutella (my mom prefers the Nutella for dessert and cinnamon with her morning coffee) The salads and other savory goodies are also delicious and the team that works here leaves you wanting to come back for more and more. Would HIGHLY recommend you check this place out! read more

Don't love giving out 5s because nothing is perfect but damn the almond milk cortado is top level. This beverage tasted like a marshmallow meeting a pillow meeting a bold espresso and then them all dancing together to make a smooth sweet caramelized yummy drink. I've been here a few times and it's always good. The vintage decor and old school stuff for sale is solid for nostalgia. If your in the South Slope... it's worth a stop. read more

Yardsale Cafe - Almond Milk Cortado - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

just bought a cinnamon roll from this place. lovely whipped cream cheese frosting but the cinnamon roll itself was stale and must had been made days before, and then they put the frosting on the day of. very disappointed won't be coming back here. read more

Great local coffee and early lunch spot. Still need to try the Burnt Cheesecake! Great coffee and the pastries are delicious. Back patio seating and vintage items for sale inside. read more

Been frequenting Yardsale since its opening. You couldn't ask for better folks- but let's get to the Bakery- Things like "Burnt Cheesecake" and "Nutella Chocolate Babka" aren't just incredible, they are purely addictive. The cookies ( this word hardly describes these things...) are incredible- Chocolate Chip, or Green Tea Matcha Lemon, and so much more....And, don't forget- they feature a lovely garden out back, and - as the name implies, they are an active antiques shop! I've bought cool presents for friends, from intricate teapots to antique ephemera, Vinyl like mad too !......drop by and be seduced but Yardsale's comforting ambience, and go mad on the culinary creations. ss read more

See all

I can't say enough great things about this coffee shop. I come here all the time and they are consistently great with fantastic customer service. As some others have said, the cheesecake is amazing. It is the best cheesecake I have ever had. Their other pastries are fantastic. Another favorite is their chocolate cookies and their babka. All of their pastries are made on the premises by the owner who is there all of the time. The coffee is great; they make the best lattes. The ambiance is so fun. Going with the yard sale theme they have lots of great items, none food, for sale too. I love looking through everything. Overall, this is what the area needed. You will not be disappointed if you give it a shot. read more

Matcha lemon cookie is AMAZING! And the back patio is adorable, chill, and cozy. Love the staff, very friendly. read more

Yardsale Cafe - Matcha lemon cookie - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Stopped by for a chocolate chip cookie and it was one of the best I had in the city! The service was great as well and there were tons of cute and interesting things to look at / buy. read more

Let's have an open and honest conversation about how that burnt cheesecake changed my life. Combine that with the all too seasonal cinnamon rolls, and I'm sold forever. read more

Great coffee and friendly staff! Highly recommend the babka and other freshly baked pastries. Don't miss out on this neighborhood gem!

We were passing through the neighborhood when the smell of Yardsale's baked goods lured us in. The bakery's interior was really unique and charming, with all sorts of knick knacks and small porcelain figurines decorating the walls. When we reached the counter, we inquired about the Cinnamon Babka and they told us that they had just finished baking one which was still too warm to slice into. This was actually a huge plus for us though because we especially love fresh baked goods, and we didn't hesitate to buy the entire loaf. As soon as we got home, the entire babka was gone in a matter of minutes. Because it was fresh out of the oven, the interior was still super warm and moist and tasted just so incredibly delicious. Needless to say, this was one of the best babkas I've ever had in my life, beating out even Breads Bakery's babkas with how fresh it was. Highly, highly recommend. read more

A sweetly, unique cafe, we thoroughly enjoyed the interestingly eclectic environment along with the delicious bakery items on offer ..highly recommend! read more

This cafe has (had?) the best cinnamon roll I've ever tasted. That said, on my last visit the roll was quite stale. Ordered a cold brew and was charged .50 cents extra for light ice. I get it, there's more coffee that way but couldn't help feeling nickel and dimed. Hope they're doing well but I left with a bit of a bad taste in my mouth. read more

Cute new Cafe in neighborhood. Had an oatmilk latte, Israeli salad, and nice conversation with owner. Looking forward to more vegan pastry options. Has an outdoor backyard but I didn't check it out. Coffee was good as well. Will be seeing how they mature. read more

See all

Anytime I am in BK, I have to stop in to grab an iced latte and a babka! This place is the absolute cutest and while I am not able to go there every day, the owner took the time to learn my name a couple visits ago and now he remembers me! This shop is great for treating yourself to something sweet! Also, I always end up buying a piece of art off the display wall because why not?! If not for me, it's a great gift. I love this little café! read more

My wife, daughter and I used to live around the corner from Yardsale. It was our go to coffee and chocolate croissant spot. The selection of sports cards and other unique memorabilia is a bonus! Shawn and his team were always so welcoming to us! So much so that when we moved to Chicago, we continue to order their coffee beans and I've managed to increase my sports card selection. . Keep up the good work! See you guys soon read more

My favorite cafe in bk. I love the babka, croissants, bourekas, cinnie rolls, and cookies. I usually go for the lavender oat matcha, but the coffee's been so good when I've switched it up. Plus, they have all these cool items the owners find at flea markets and yardsales. I always leave with a little gift for a friend. Really great service- such nice people, and there's a really cool little patio out in the back! read more

Yardsale is delicious and fun! It's such a unique shop with its cute outdoor seating area and vintage products. I love stopping by as often as I can because there is something different to check out every day! The absolute best part about this place is the service. The owner is the most attentive, kind and generous business owner I've ever met. He remembers my name and always encourages me to try something new. I'm not sure if anyone could be even kinder - this is what makes yardsale my favorite shop - the people! read more

Best cafe and bakery in Park Slope hands down. Shawn makes amazing babka and croissants and serves up great coffee. Highly recommend stopping here! read more

Best burnt cheesecake ever! Coffee was delicious, and the server was very warm and friendly too. Will need to go back just to try the babka! They do not have indoor seating currently, but have a small patio space available for seating (weather-permitting). Very cute interior with antiques for sale. read more