Great pizza and options. Being from NY/NJ it's hard to impress me when it comes to pizza and sandwiches and I enjoyed the 2 slices of pie here. I have to caveat that I did get individual slices there, which in my opinion is always the best since they put the slices into the oven to warm up which adds a little more crunch in the crust and your slice. I will try ordering a whole pie sometime, but service was nice and the feeling inside was warm and inviting. They had all the usual suspects of table adds that I always can tell if a place will have good pies or not. If the table doesn't have the oregano, garlic salt, parm and red pepper flakes on the table, they probably aren't going to be the best pies! Just my overall observation. If you're in the area, give it a try if you really know your pizza pies. read more

This place is cool! Should definitely give this place a try if you looking for a pizza spot. They have such different types of pizza. I like how they serve the pizza on a tray. The flavor is so good and I love the thin style pizza. Not too much dough so you can really taste the flavor of the pizza. The slices are a good size for the price as well. They put the pizza in the pizza toaster oven to heat it up. Give this place a try! read more

Wiseguy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Cozy little place in herndon. Service is fast and always busy there. The fresh made pies are great. Depending on how long the slices are out, it might not be as good though. read more

Wiseguy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Great service and pizza slices and ambiance and word count is limiting me and everything else was good read more

Wiseguy Pizza - Cookies - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

This is not NY style pizza! If Chef Boyardee made pizza, it would be better than this. The sauce is pathetic and the cheese was sparse. I believe it's safe to say that it might be the worst pizza in Nova. 2/10 rating and that's because the guy behind the counter was a nice guy. read more

I was excited to try this place after hearing about it from multiple people, but was really disappointed. We got the backyard and mushroom truffle pizzas. Both were lacking in flavor, thin, and very dry. For the price, I would have expected higher quality. Portions are large though! That is the one plus. read more

This place is kind of a mixed bag. On the one hand, the pizza, while nothing special is definitely a cut above the major chains like Dominos, etc. That said, I have found it middling when compared to some smaller local chains and a few mom and pop pizza places in NOVA. Pizza quality aside, their attention to detail is severely lacking. I ordered a "Family Meal" that contained a 18 inch cheese pizza and a large family size Caesar salad. The pizza arrived, but the restaurant omitted the salad. If this was a one off, I might be more understanding, but I read a different person's review on Yelp with the exact same experience. I guess the store hasn't learned to be more careful with making sure orders are fulfilled correctly. I am afraid between the middling pizza and the careless service, I won't be back. read more

This Pizza spot is amazing!!! Rob help me today and was amazing!! The pizza is very fresh and tasty. read more

First time coming after seeing high Google reviews. Friendly service. Anton offered free drink while waiting for my pizza. Pizza is a bit expensive, but very good. Would recommend! Next to Chipotle, small shop. 4.5 stars due to high price of the pies. read more

Amazing food and service. Rob greeted us upon arrival and was a pleasure. Would recommend this location! read more

Wiseguy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Great service while providing knowledge of their rewards program! Definitely worth it read more

Wiseguy Pizza - Good Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Came to wiseguys and had an amazing experience with Rob. Explained everything to me and helped me pick out the right pizza. Check them out!

Coming from an NJ native, this is the best pizza I've had away from home!! Amazing service every time! Rob is always so friendly and welcoming! read more

Wiseguy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

See all

Great pizza joint. Quick and friendly customer service right on Elden Street. Right across from Amphora Diner.

Ordered their margherita pizza and some cookies for take-out. The pizza was so flavorful, perfect pizza texture where you get the ooey-gooey cheese pull while having that nice crunch of the crust and base of the pizza. The cookies were cooked to perfection. Nice and gooey, with that slightest hint of crunch on the edges and in-between the center. Highly recommend and will be ordering takeout again! The inside is a bit small, so I'd recommend take-out read more

I have placed orders online from the Herndon location 3 times now. My order has never been ready according to the Order Pick up time. The pizza isn't anything to write home about so there's no justifiably reason for the wait. Update : I was told my pizza would be ready in 15 minutes when I arrived at my scheduled p/u time. I waited in my car, came back in after 15 minutes and was told the wait was 20-25 minutes!! This is beyond ridiculous. I will never be back here. It's unacceptable. read more

Yummy pizza! Give it a try and you won't be disappointed. Thin and delicious. The cheese is wonderful. read more

I love the Wiseguy Pizza chain. Ever since the pre-pandemic days when I used to work in DC, I would frequent both of the locations inside the city. And then when they opened a location slightly closer to me in Arlington, that became my go-to location. And so now that there is a location in my hometown of Herndon, this will be the one I frequent from now on. There's a lot of great NY style pizza places in DC and Northern VA. Wiseguy is in the discussion for being one of the best. I've been to the Herndon location once so far and while it's not as glitz and glammy as the DC locations in terms of its decor, it does what it needs to do to serve amazing pizza. The special topping combinations change regularly but every slice I've ever tried at any Wiseguy location has been phenomenal. If you live on the western side of Northern VA, I recommend you check out Wiseguy next time you want a delicious slice of NY pizza. read more

Best pizza we've had in a long time. I'm a pizza snob and usually make my own, but Wiseguys is the real deal.

Management better come in and do some supervising for this location. First off the place looks like a mess. Outside, inside..just not kept and the kicker is there are no customers so why aren't employees tidying up?? I've been to the DC location several years back and thought the pizza was very good. I wanted to try it again since it is closer by but we walked in...saw the old, crusty stale looking pizzas...and had to walk out. So, I can't comment on the taste of the pizza...but I can say the pies just didn't look appetizing at all. read more

$5 for a "giant" slice? What a scam! You get a sad, tasteless sliver of pizza that's an insult to the word "giant." This is one of the newer Wiseguys Pizza locations (Herndon), but don't expect the legendary vibes of the original Mass Ave spot in DC. That place hasn't been the same since 2022, and it shows. Wiseguys used to be a DMV pizza king--golden crust, perfect sauce, the works. But ever since Thompson Hospitality swooped in, it's been a straight-up tragedy. They've traded soul for profit, and the pizza's paying the price. I gave the Herndon location three chances, and every time? Bland, lifeless, and just plain nasty. You're better off grabbing a frozen pie from Giant down the street--seriously. Thank the pizza gods for Jet's Pizza nearby. $8 gets you two legit slices and a soda--properly priced and actually delicious. It's heartbreaking to see Wiseguys fall so far. Thompson Hospitality gutted a DMV gem. RIP the real Wiseguys Pizza. You deserved better. read more

Food is amazing and rob was great all the staff is always very friendly I got the il capo and buffalo pizza but all their slices are great only one left to try is the mushroom one read more

This pizza is awesome. Rob helped me with my order and was super friendly. Best pizza in Herndon

Rob had excellent customer service. He explained to me the ingredients in the pizza. I appreciate his attention to detail.

Best pizza in town and staff are so nice and friendly. Rob was definitely the most welcoming and helpful person working there.

Ordered pizza, salad and drinks for the family to be delivered. Only received the pizza and the Uber delivery driver stated that was all he was given. Called the store and they just said oh I'll just refund what you didn't get. WHAT??!!?! So my family just gets pizza and no salad or drinks. These are real wise guys. Don't waste your time or money on these fools!! read more

Ordered a pizza & wings. Got the pizza & no wings. Requested driver use Ring Doorbell and hand deliver. Food was placed on the cold ground. Driver indicated when caught leaving "That's all they gave me". Why would anyone want their food left on the cold concrete. Will never order from them again. The only redeeming factor was they refunded my order. read more

I've worked across the street from this restaurant for many years and even though it opened six months ago, I have not tried it until today. I'm really glad I did because I now have a good pizza option that is not far from work or home at all. If you've seen any reviews from me, you know I'm a native NYer and I basically gave up on pizza in VA years ago, until discovering Teddy's in Middleburg several years ago, but the drive can be a grind. I did not really think a chain pizza restaurant would be any good as Domino's, Papa John's, Marco's and Pizza Hut are all awful to me. However, Wiseguy was a great surprise! This is a true Brooklyn Style pizza cooked perfectly. The crust was crisp and not floppy, the cheese and sauce were balanced perfectly, no sloppy, gross pizza that is drowning in sauce with way too much cheese that just slides off, no, this one was perfect. The sauce has an excellent taste as well. I judge pizza this way: If you can walk down the street while eating a slice and it's not making a mess, the pizza chef has done something right and in this case, they do a great job. We met the GM of the restaurant, a native NYer himself, so he knows what good pizza is supposed to taste like and he has really shaped this restaurant up considering what some of the previous reviews have said. The restaurant was clean, well lit, and the music was playing. The GM is a great guy, we really enjoyed talking with him. Finally, if you are looking for a lunch spot, you can't miss this incredible deal: 18" Cheese pizza for $11.99 from 11am-2pm, seriously, that can't be beat. 4 people can eat for $3 each- you just don't see that, especially in this economy. Give Wiseguy a shot, I think you'll like it. read more

Ordered a large cheese pizza for takeout, tasted great, like a slice you'd grab in NYC.

Been meaning to try Wiseguy since they opened in Herndon. I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni and sausage through GrubHub. Pizza arrived on time with no issues, was a little cold but I put that down to the time it took to deliver to my house. Pizza itself tasted great though, was nice and thin with a crispy crust. I ordered with Marinara sauce and I think that made it taste even better with just a little bit of sweetness that I like. Being originally from NJ not far from NYC, I feel like I know good pizza and this one was good. I miss Rocco's Pizza in Leesburg, but this is even closer to my house and a good substitute. Will definitely be ordering from here again! read more

Very Very misleading. "BIG SLICES UNDER $5" They were nor BIG nor UNDER $5 Total of $10.58 for 2 MEDIUM not BIG slices. Never going there again, place will not survive! read more

Wiseguy Pizza - two slices of pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

See all

Felt it was a ripoff. Slice of a pizza and 2 garlic knots equal $17 after tax and tip. Didn't contest just won't return to this restaurant again! read more

Great customer service. As soon as we walked in we were greeted. Pizza came out fast and was delicious. We will definitely be back.

Bottom Line: This pizza, and Hasan, are two of the best things in the Reston/Herndon area. This past Friday night I was in the mood for pizza, but found my former NY Style pizza place has let quality control drop. I am not naming them because maybe I had loved them for years now and don't want to hurt their business more than it may already be suffering. I saw the sign weeks ago, saw where it was located and checked their reviews on Friday night and decided to take a chance. I called the location to see if they could adjust one particular item on my UberEats order (I wanted extra cheese) and Hasan answered and was great to talk to. Funny, enthusiastic, and he made sure I knew he had all the pizza experience in NYC - and I would not be disappointed with my first Wiseguy experience. The pizza was as close to perfect as it gets, and much much better than two area places that claim to make New York style pizza. If you want real NY style pizza, order from this place now. It's that simple. read more

Great Pizza, great spot, excellent service. Very reasonable prices. Love the buffalo chicken ranch pizza. Much better than Jett's.

Probably the best pizza I've had in the Herndon area since we moved here 20 years ago. Definitely the best pizza outside of pizza shops in NYC. read more

Won't ever order from here again. They Outsource delivery to DoorDash (& don't advertise it). Missing half the order & the stuff that made it here was cold. Called the shop to get it fixed and was told I could come pick it up but nothing else they could do - couldn't even adjust the order and refund. Chargeback inc. Pizza was meh. read more

All, this is my first visit and I can say that the service was great and their chocolate chip cookie tastes great. Music was also good. However, the pizza is unfortunately subpar. The crust was chewy and overall low in flavor and salt, which was reminiscsent of standard lower quality pizza pickup joints. The sauce had raw garlic which I recommend they saute first before adding to the sauce to avoid the overpowering bitterness of raw garlic. Chili peppers had no punch, might consider offering jalepenos instead. The price is also too high for the quality. If they improve the crust and sauce, they might have a chance on repeat customers. As for my opinion, I won't be returning unless they improve. read more

As good as the other locations!! Staff are super friendly and service is quick. This location is a bit small (5-6 tables) so definitely good for take-out. You can get by slice or whole pies. I love their specialty flavors since they're so unique. My favorites are Chicken Paneer and Chicken Parmesan! read more

Update: I decided to give Wiseguys another chance as my wife wanted to try it. The experience was absolutely horrible. We ordered pepperoni pizza online and went to pick it up. After arriving, they had lost the order but offered my wife a cheese pizza that had been sitting out. She declined and asked for the pizza we ordered. Instead of making it, they took the cheese pizza behind the counter and pretended to make a new pizza, but instead just put uncooked pepperoni on the old cheese pizza and gave it to her. She asked if they had just made it, and they said yes. When she got home, we confirmed the stale pizza was topped with raw pepperoni which immediately fell off when it was picked up. The pizza was ice cold after the 7 minute drive home. Original Review: I was excited to try this place after hearing lots of good things. I ordered online and added the thick pepperoni cups as an extra topping. When I got home I realized these were never added to the pizza. Since this topping was an extra $6.50, I called to ask for a refund or credit for that amount. The person answering the phone could not understand my request, so kept repeatedly hanging up on me. When I finally got through to the manager after 6 calls, he told me he knew this was an issue and the topping wasn't actually available at this location. None of this was ever communicated when I picked up the pie. He told me he couldn't "get into the system" to credit me, and just said "sorry, I've got customers here" and hung up. Tough to support a business who is knowingly charging customers for a product they don't have, and refusing to make it right. The pizza itself was fine, but nothing to write home about. read more

Wiseguy Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia