Cancel

Open app

Search

Windsor Mill Tavern

4.3 (165 reviews)
Closed • 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

Order Windsor Mill Tavern Takeout or Delivery

Windsor Mill Tavern Photos

WINDSOR MILL TAVERN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Good for groups
Outdoor seating
Happy hour specials

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Windsor Mill Tavern

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Recipe shows time and what was ordered  Moody Blue Salad Full
Robert W.

We've been here a couple times before and food and service was always good. It was our one year anniversary since we met here we wanted to celebrate here. Our waitress Kaitlyn took our order @ 6:23 for a bottle of wine and a crab cake for starters. Then we ordered house soup and salad so we could get dinner quickly. The wine was good and the crab cake was good. I'm in the habit of watching people come in after me to see when they get their order. The people in front of us came in approximately 10 minutes after us, the couple beside us came in a little later and the older couple came in after them. Yes we ordered before the out three couples and they had a different waitress. Kaitlyn came by a couple times to let us know our order would be out soon. The first couple got their meal, then the couple beside us got their meal. At 7:30 the couple beside us finished their dinner and Kaitlyn came by and said again "our meal would be up soon". It's just a bowl of soup and a salad, what was so hard about our order. So we cancelled our dinner with Kaitlyn. So who is to blame for us not getting dinner? Did the kitchen staff drop the ball or Kaitlyn for not following up with them for a simple order. The ambiance was quieter than normal but service was terrible

Moody Blue Salad Full
John C.

Terrific! Wife and I both enjoyed dinner. Spedini de Mare (scallops, shrimp, and asparagus over risotto) was incredible. Definitely making the drive to visit again soon.

Entrance area from inside restaurant.
Kristine T.

We went to Windsor Mill Tavern Saturday Evening, 6th of December and we absolutely LOVE it! The staff seems to love their jobs, the service is amazing and the food is delicious and comforting. I had the delicious crab cake appetizer and Salmon in Beurre Blanc Sauce and my husband had the Fried Cheese Curds and Stuffed Pork chop. Both absolutely delicious. Best Mashed potatoes I have ever had. This was our second time at Windsor Mill Tavern and we love the warm Irish Pub Style atmosphere. Only thing missing is a fireplace! This is our new favorite hangout after having moved here to Severance, Co this past March. We love it. Oh! And the seats are comfortable as well. We will be back. Love having a place that is only a couple miles away from where we reside! Well done staff and management! This place is a gem!!!! And the prices? Quite reasonable!

Cream of chicken soup -- excellent!!!
Mark B.

When in the Greeley area, I was hungry for lunch and found Windsor Mill Tavern via Yelp. Fun little place! It's in the basement of a building -- so it took me a few minutes to fugue out how to enter the place. I sat at the bar, and my bartender was great. I started with a cream of chicken soup -- it was excellent, and I wish I had ordered a bowl instead of a cup. : ) For my main course, I ordered the steak bites with mashed potatoes. The steak was ok -- some pieces were pretty chewy -- but I ate most of it and enjoyed the mashed potatoes a lot. Total bill -- with tip -- was $40. Not bad considering how high inflation is!

Menu
Maddy B.

We've been to Windsor Mill Tavern a handful of times now and it's quickly become one of our go-to spots. I love the weekday deals, it gives us an excuse to pop in without feeling like we're splurging. The menu is huge (in a good way) and honestly has something for whatever you're in the mood for. We've tried a few different things and have never been disappointed. They also have a solid tap list, including our favorite: 805. The ambiance is perfect for a casual date night with a good vibe all around.

Chicken Cordon Blue w/Asparagus
Dave E.

Having been here many times in the past this visit was a bit of a disappointment. The good news is they still have Juicy Bits (NEHIPA) on tap. Curious news is they only have 1 white wine, in this case Pinot Grigio, on happy hour. . The bad news concerned dinner. I've always ordered the curried mussels appetizer with the soup of the day. Before it was prepped with yellow Urey and was delicious. This time it was either red curry but more likely sriracha and it was hot ... TOO DAMN HOT in my opinion. Wasn't an enjoyable meal at all yet it was still described on the menu as yellow curry. It even looked different than times past. Perhaps a one off as we'll try it again. Oh, I also had a cup of the soup of the day which was a steak and potato chowder. It was excellent!!!

Street view

Amazing drinks, food and service. The fish and chips (walleye) was delicious. I'm sorry I didn't take any photos

Chicken friend wagyu
Kelsie T.

This is our second time coming to Windsor Mill Tavern. We were hoping for the prime rib but they stopped making it. We still had a great experience. The margarita I had was perfection, I got the chicken fried waygu and my husband got the chicken risotto. We also enjoyed the cheese curds and Brussels for a starter. We ended with the espresso torte and bread pudding. Everything was wonderful!

Foyer and entrance of the restaurant. The bar is in the middle.
Todd G.

What a great place! Tucked into the property with several other restaurants in downtown Windsor. Built in the style of an Irish pub the ambiance is so cool. Plenty of space for guests and diners. I had the Bangers and Mash, a perfect Irish fare. My wife had the Cowboy burger and had to bring half home. Our friend had the Bison Philly and it filled the plate. Try the bourbon bread pudding too. Our server, Sophia was awesome and was very responsive, friendly, and timely. The entire staff was busy and the bar was packed as well.

Pineapple teriyaki burger with bison patty and side of soup, chef's special was a steak chowder.

See all

Reviews are largely positive. Diners highlight the varied and flavorful food, attentive and friendly staff, inviting pub atmosphere, and good drink selection.

Read the full review summary in the app

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Tim D.

Tim D.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of G P.
0
13
0

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 1

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Tim D.

Tim D.

Thank you Stacy!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Tim D.

Tim D.

Thank you Stephanie!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 5 of 5

Ask the Community - Windsor Mill Tavern

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bars 1,629 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

William Oliver's - Windsor

William Oliver's - Windsor

4.3(32 reviews)
0.2 mi

There is so much to say about this little bar in Windsor. First when I moved here with my partner…read moreand this was the first place we tried in town. We were greeted by two incredible bartenders Eliza and Zack and a general manager Cole that have now become close friends of ours. The vibe was great (no TVs, amazing), service was quick, the drinks were delicious, and the food-while bar food-was acceptable, and the staff were so friendly and fun. We established a weekly bar night routine to come in and see the regulars and these workers. I looked forward to it, and made great friends. But then the general manager wasn't there anymore and our bartenders left too, and all we had left were two amazing bartenders Ed and Sam. They have now been carrying the burden of the lack of staff and they are the only reason we have kept coming back at all. They try so hard to make everyone comfortable and happy, and are two truly wonderful people. But it all went downhill from there. We took a gamble the other night and went in on a day we never do, and they recently hired a new bartender Dani, who greeted us with low energy and a somber tone. That's fine, not everyone loves their job, but within 5 minutes of meeting us, she told my partner she didn't like the song playing in the bar because it mentioned a transgender person in a relationship (and no she did not say it like that, she said derogatory offensive outdated terms) out of the blue! We are a queer couple! We did not invite, initiate, or try to have any type of conversation like this and she just says that to them? Spreading hate to a stranger unprompted? I was shocked and disgusted. Ed and Sam are two wonderful, welcoming bartenders that have been nothing but kind to us, but this is not the William Oliver's I know. The only reason this is two stars and not one star is because of them

I love the vibe of this little bar. It is so cozy, warm, and welcoming. I was absolutely ecstatic…read moreto see they had multiple vegan items on the menu and felt very included. The staff was very attentive and friendly. I will say my tacos did come out cold which was a little bit of a bummer. I feel like I wish the jackfruit was seasoned more and cooked in the bbq sauce to offer a little bit more flavor. Otherwise great experiences.

Photos
William Oliver's - Windsor - William Oliver's Windsor, CO (also in Fort Collins, CO)

William Oliver's Windsor, CO (also in Fort Collins, CO)

William Oliver's - Windsor
William Oliver's - Windsor

See all

Hearth Restaurant and Pub - Scottish Salmon

Hearth Restaurant and Pub

3.8(257 reviews)
0.1 mi
•$$

Seated promptly BUT the table had NOT BEEN PROPERLY CLEANED. My spot was incredibly sticky. Got…read moreit on the menu, my phone, my hands. Disgusting! Tried to get staff attention without success so stepped into the men's room to grab wet and dry towels to clean up myself. Ugh. Samuel eventually appeared and we ordered drinks for ourselves while waiting for our son and daughter in law. Great beer choices for me - JuicyBits. Decent wine choices. Our daughter in law arrived, ordered a nice red, and she split a Reuben Sandwich with my wife. Both sandwich and fries were very good. I'd ordered the Penne Ala Vodka with shrimp. The Shrimp were very nicely done as they're frequently overcooked and tough. But the penne and sauce were only meh. Bit of a disappointment as I've definitely had (and personally made) better. Not too busy for a Friday nite and we were allowed to extend our conversation a bit ... unhurried. Pleasant evening.

Don't even bother. We made a reservation and got seated right away even though it was fairly…read morecrowded. Our waitress was new which was fine but she never came back to check on us or tell us there is a wait. After 45 minutes our waitress and another lady tells us there is a wait and a backup of to go orders. Then I noticed food was coming out they were serving it to all the people who came and ordered after us. We never even got our appetizers or any food,

Photos
Hearth Restaurant and Pub - Viewz!!

Viewz!!

Hearth Restaurant and Pub - Reuben Sandwich and Fries

Reuben Sandwich and Fries

Hearth Restaurant and Pub

See all

Tiho's Tequila Bar & Restaurant - Fresh, Fast Fun, Fajitas

Tiho's Tequila Bar & Restaurant

4.0(49 reviews)
0.0 mi

Today is my daughter's birthday. We decided to go celebrate her birthday at Tiho's Restaurant…read more Sunday special is all day happy hour. Our reservation is at 5pm and we were seated right away. The ambiance of the restaurant is really nice. Our waitress was Analise. She was very friendly, polite and professional. She was attentive also. Great customer service. Their dinner menu items were kind of limited, but they have the traditional Mexican food items such as Tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and fajitas. We were all very happy with our food choices. Their smothered burrito is huge!! This restaurant is kind of pricey compared to other Mexican Restaurants. But we were very happy with the service and the food. They were all delicious. The complimentary chips and salsa were very good. The tortilla chips are definitely homemade. We will definitely come back here again for lunch or dinner.

Super busy even for a Monday evening. The service was pretty quick, could have been better but a…read morepacked house and the servers were doing their best! The prickly pear margarita was SO good! The chicken nachos (not pictured) were great as well, a perfect thing to order for a large table to share. The smothered burrito was delicious, definitely big enough for two to share. The space itself was comfy and accommodating for a party of 5 (and a small baby). The only thing I didn't love was the metal bull hanging off the wall that made so much noise (every hour) in an already loud space, it was too much to be around by the end of dinner.

Photos
Tiho's Tequila Bar & Restaurant - One of the best selection of premium tequilas in Northern Colorado!

One of the best selection of premium tequilas in Northern Colorado!

Tiho's Tequila Bar & Restaurant - Combo Fajitas with Grilled Shrimp and Carne Asada.

Combo Fajitas with Grilled Shrimp and Carne Asada.

Tiho's Tequila Bar & Restaurant - Incredible Weeknight Specials!

See all

Incredible Weeknight Specials!

Windsor Mill Tavern - bars - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...