A lovely spot for a casual date night with someone special or friends and family. Comfy atmosphere, attentive staff and delicious signature potato pie, what's not to love! read more

See all

Something that nobody ever wants to hear but we found hair in our pizza... three or four times in a row we found hair embedded in our pizza, absolutely disgusting. We would order, find a hair in our pizza, not order from them for a few months, and then try again- STILL HAIR! Even grocer is that this last pizza we got we ate the whole thing and then noticed a hair... I have called and notified them before, but apparently didn't matter. I'm not ordering from them ever again unfortunately. read more

Willington Pizza Too - Hair in pizza... latest occurrence - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

We camp in eastford each summer and stop to eat at Wellington pizza too for late lunch/early dinner on Fridays. We usually have a,small potato pizza and a large antipasto (which we love). Changed it up today had a calzone with the antipasto, then had an apple pie pizza, took it to the camper for dessert tonight. OMG it was fabulous! The best ever, especially with vanilla ice cream. We will definitely be getting this again. Wellington Pizza Too is worth the stop. Oh and their service is really good also. T.Heideger read more

This is going to sound odd but all ive had so far were sides - meatballs & sauce and onion rings. The meatballs are delicious. The sauce is amazing. The onion rings are battered not breaded which i prefer and they were phenomenal. Will be back. Convenient ordering using the Toast app. read more

Yes, I have no learning curve went a third time take out. My pizza was good, but my alfredo dinner had about 1/3 the alfredo sauce needed so dry and tasteless ziti for 18 bucks - and of course my side was wrong when I got home. What kills me is it was slow mid afternoon. They kitchen staff just doesnt give a shit. Never ever again. read more

Great selection of items. Good atmosphere. Heard the pizza was good. Doesn't compare to some of the more popular New Haven pizza places but a great option when in the area. Beer and wine options were just ok. Service was great. Very attentive and food comes quick. read more

Willington Pizza Too - Chicken Bites - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

See all

Nice neighborhood pizzeria. Every time I go it's been excellent, and I've been a lot. Good food, good service, good prices and excellent beer selection. I'll continue to go and recommend. read more

Solid central Connecticut pizza in a NASCAR decorated building. They know what they're doing and the staff takes good care of the customers. read more

Horrible. They make Sicilian pizza dough "only on Fridays". Silly me. I thought that sounded special. The dough was gummy, not at all like a good Italian crust that has a light, airy texture. The sauce had no flavor. Greasy cheese. And a weird under taste that I could not figure out. My husband likes the grinders here. Avoid the pizza. I ate one slice and was not going to take the leftover pizza home, but he would have been embarrassed. In the garbage it goes when we get home. On the pro side, lovely server and a generous pore of wine. read more

A surprisingly solid pizza from a small hole in the wall shop. Ordered a small with red onions and they added green peppers as well by mistake. Server apologized and gave us the mistaken pizza au gratis, offering to get the correct pie to us while we picked at it. They have very good wings as well. Those got devoured before pictures could be taken. Good quality, good price, good pizza, and great staff If I had to ding them on anything it would be that they have off-tasting tap water. So if you dine in, might want to get some bottled waters as well. Beyond that, a great choice for pizza in the area. Good job Willington pizza too! read more

See all

Was the absolute worst pizza I've had in a long time. Could have oiled my car with the greasy mess. Thank god for paper towels. 34.00 dollars for a Jiffy Lube experience. Gone done hill every time I go there. Will have to be desperate for a Fonzy duck tail to order again. read more

All the food we ordered came out cold ...and I don't know why they think Burnt fries are what people want ...how about teaching your chefs how to cook read more

Waitress was friendly. Chef came out and made joked with us. Nice place, great pics and memorabilia on the walls.

I'm sorry but I've never had a good pizza from WP Too. If you want Willington Pizza I suggest going to the other location. Every pizza I've ordered here has either been soggy, or overcooked. I always do take out, and sadly never check the pizza prior to leaving. The last pizza I got the toppings were so burnt that I didn't really eat my pizza. At least with a soggy pizza you can pop it in your own oven, but even that is disappointing. I've never ordered anything here besides pizza, so I can't vouch for their other menu items. read more

Just the service alone is worth the drive! We had the BEST WAITRESS I've ever encountered! Marie is prob one of the sweetest, most attentive ppl I've ever met. I couldn't get over how genuinely nice she was We stumbled on this restaurant by accident. After driving 2 hrs we got hungry and decided to get off the exit and I'm so glad we did! The food was amazing! Absolutely delicious and so flavorful!!! We got a an order of Buffalo wings (12 pcs for $17.99: I thought it was a little pricey for wings but they were worth it). Cooked they way I like them, plenty of flavor We also ordered a Large Pizza $22, half Pepperoni and Sausage, half Hamburg and Garlic! Yum Yum Yum! For dessert, Marie suggested the Key Lime Pie and Boyyyyyy it did not disappoint!!!! Absolutely delicious I'd definitely take the drive back out to this little hidden gem Thank you Marie for the great experience! read more

Willington Pizza Too - Buffalo Wings were delicious - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

See all

Rip off! This is what $20 gets you. $5 for the fries. $13 for 12oz of chicken bits? Never again I feel like I was robbed. I asked about the portion size and the counter person said "I don't make the prices" read more

Willington Pizza Too - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

Good pizza with a lot of different options. The staff was friendly and the prices were super reasonable.

Last time ordering online, ordered a BLT grinder. As specific as I could get, I put NO Mayo. Not only did the grinder come with Mayo, they put cheese & peppers on it. BLT=bacon, lettuce & tomato. My son had to throw it away. So, this time I ordered, I ordered online but called in the BLT grinder, and specifically said: only bacon, lettuce and tomato; NO Mayonnaise! Once again, no mayonnaise must mean put mayo on a BLT. Once again, my son threw a $10 grinder away. Willington Pizza needs to realize some people have a severe egg allergy, and NO Mayo means no mayonnaise. read more

If you like bread order the BLT, worst I've ever had. Like 3 pieces of bacon on the sandwich.

Hi Foodies, I have to give this restaurant a negative review after spending $47 on a extra large house pizza and mild wings on a Saturday evening. The pizza was soggy with a wet crust. It was not well made or cooked properly? The leftovers we threw in the garbage as it's too risky to eat again and we don't ever waste food we pay for with hard earned money after a long work week! My mom had diarrhea after and I was dizzy. The wings were ok but pink inside not cooked properly, very greasy and so large couldn't fit in the small little cheap dipping cup they give you of blue cheese with two or three celery sticks. Big Y has better pizza. It's hard to believe they expect tips or a good review selling this type of half cooked soggy food? We won't be a returning customer read more

These guys price gouged the sh** out of me during Covid. $29 for an order of wings. I learned my lesson and will never go back.

The eggplant Parmesan also the sausage and spaghetti is so much to eat in one seating. Great taste. Personal is so very pleasant.

We love this place! Always fresh, amazing dishes and AMAZING service! The tuna melt is my favorite and my husband loves the pizza. Great specials too. read more

The worst part about this place is that everyone knows it's good! The cheeseburger pizza (with pickles and ketchup) is amazing along with their classic red red potato pizza (WITH bacon AND broccoli). We love the house salad and have bought it by the gallon. Tonight I ordered the Chicken Caesar wrap with homemade chips and it was exactly what I wanted. Will order it again. The kid likes the Hosmer Mountain sodas. My dad loves the meatball and sausage casserole and orders it every time. This is a great place to stop on the way home from soccer games or anywhere along 84. Love that they use the Toast app and have curbside pickup. read more

Willington Pizza Too - Cheeseburger pizza - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

See all

I stopped in here for lunch on a Sunday afternoon to get some takeout pizza. We ordered half red potato and half California. The sauce on the pizza is really good and there are definitely a lot of toppings. They make a heavy pizza, so definitely not a thin crust style. The crust is a little bland but overall its a good pizza. Its also a bit expensive so just keep that in mind. read more

Willington Pizza Too - half red potato half California - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

Willington pizza is our local restaurant and it is very nice. It had amazing pizza and grinders also!!!

Had possibly the most bland grinder ever. I asked for grilled chicken instead of fried and I mean, come on...would it kill you to put some salt and pepper on it? Even dousing it with hot sauce I couldn't eat it....I don't understand why people wouldn't just...make decent food? read more

Went to have lunch there around 2. We were 4 adults and a child. As we walked in, the waitress behind the counter just stared at us as if she were irritated by our presence. She shook her head, put it down, looked back up at us, continued to stare almost with disgust... and that was our greeting I was not the only one to see this, my other daughter who was with us saw the same.. We proceeded into the dining room and found our table because you seat yourselves. That same waitress with the same " I don't want to be here atttitude" came to our table ..no smile, threw menus down and said "drinks", again as if we were annoying her... I thought, "really like I want to order from you with your welcoming attitude". we all just looked and said NO.. We ended up leaving there before she could come back. .. There were only two other couples there in booths? I worked in customer service so I know about it. Never would I greet a person or family visiting the establisment I worked in like this. This was my second visit after a first horrible one, but I wanted to give it another chance.. Never going back. Go to the orginal willington pizza .. thats what we did and had great service and food! She lost a BIG tip... read more

Nice place in town to get pizza and wings. Came in around 8:30PM to place a to-go order. There is a front counter as soon as you walk in where you can place your order. The employee at the counter was friendly. Other than pizza, the menu consists of soups, appetizers, breads, salads, and some dinner entrees. My only complaint is that the pizza is pricey. If you want to create your own pizza, a small is $8.95 while a large is $14.95. Additional toppings are $1.50 per topping for a small pizza and $2.25 per topping for a large pizza. Premium toppings are $1.99 per topping for small pizzas and $2.99 for a large pizza. They offer different bases for the pizza, such as red (just a regular cheese pizza with red sauce), white, and pesto. The pesto base is more expensive than the red and white bases. For specialty pizzas a small pizza is $10.95-$13.50 while a large is typically $23+They do not offer medium sized pizzas. We ended up placing an order for 2 large pizzas, one large cheese ($14.95) and one large California pizza ($23.95). We also placed an order for a cup of New England clam chowder ($4.95), lemon pepper wings ($10.95), and sweet red chili wings ($10.95). It took about 15 minutes for the food to be ready. The pizzas were delicious. They square-cut the pizzas and the pizza crust is more on the thinner side (but not too thin). I really enjoyed the cheese pizza - it's the classic cheese pizza you'd hope for and had the right ratio of sauce and cheese. The California pizza had fresh garlic, mozzarella, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, and black olives as toppings. It was also tasty but I think I will go for another specialty pizza next time as I don't enjoy the tart flavor of sun-dried tomatoes. My parents, however, liked the pizza especially with the sun-dried tomatoes. I also really liked their wings. Crunchy and juicy in texture. They seasoned the chicken well so the lemon pepper and sweet red chili flavors came out well. The sweet red chili isn't spicy, it's more sweet. The New England clam chowder was a little lukewarm but nothing a microwave can't fix. It was a delicious clam chowder and they gave me plenty of oyster crackers to go with it. Overall great food. Pricey, but not a bad place to splurge on. read more

Saw the signs on the highway on a long trip, was tired of gas station food, decided to give it a try Its expensive AF, we had a half/half pizza (half cheese and half chicken) and a side salad, coffee and a small soda. Total came to $46 after tip Should've eaten at TA next exit over. Pizza itself wasn't too bad. Leaving this review as a bookmark for future trips - ohh hi read more

A very good restaurant with a good selection of basic food items and a few unexpected things as well. Love the fried zucchini and ranch and I feel like we've been ordering a lot more than usual. The only downside is that the crust of the pizza sometimes is soggy. All in all I really like Willington Pizza Too. read more

I didn't have a good experience last night. Typically we get and love their pizza but last night we order grinders. Not good....turkey grinder with extra Mayo, the bread was dry, the turkey was try and there was no extra Mayo. read more

Spuds in any form thrill me. Combine that with pizza, which should be its own food group, and you have a winner. Their red potato pizza is creamy goodness. Layered with sour cream base, cooked potatoes, cheese, and bacon there is just no way this can't be a good thing. They have an option of adding broccoli, I ask why spoil this with something healthy? I'm not a fan of their other pizzas since they have a heavy crust, so I always stick with the tried and true. Their antipasta salad is huge and is definitely enough for two. The inside of the restaurant is dark and dated and is in a rundown strip shopping center, we usually order to go. read more

Willington Pizza Too - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

Giving three stars bc I personally don't love the pizza but the wings are good and grinders are also good for the area.

I've been to 9056 pizza places in my life (kidding). I visited W2 a few weeks ago after meeting the chef at my Willimantic business. Up to now, it's the best pizza I've had ever. No BS. Rivals Pepe and Worcester st, but maybe a bit better. Sauce, dough toppings in perfect balanceI typically don't write reviews..there's enough opinions out there about everything and everybody thinks theirs is the best. But this place is good. No more words needed... try their pizza. Am going back soon to see if the Italian entree's are as good. Cheers! read more

Ordered these buffalo chicken bites a few days ago for $14. Abysmal proportions and It's not the first time either. Been going to Willy 2 for a long time but this was the last straw. The Pizza is also lacking and ridiculously expensive for pizza with a crust that can't support the toppings on it. read more

Willington Pizza Too - Buffalo Chicken Bites - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

Picked up veggie pie it was ready quick and workers were very friendly! Appreciate the good service

Got a cranberry walnut salad today, asked for a small. Looked back at the menu and it turns out they have just one size for it. Instead of saying this, they gave me a salad I could hold in one hand for the price of the full. $12 for this salad I could make at home easy. Be weary when you order take out, this was a rip off. Looks like I'll be going to Pepe's instead next time. read more

Willington Pizza Too - Pizza Near Me - Willington, Connecticut

I'm very confused by the hype around Willington pizza/too. I'm convinced with every restaurant I've had in the area that ppl here have been deprived of good food and therefore mediocre food is amazing to them. Mediocre is the perfect word to describe Willington pizza. I've tried many pizzas here now and nothing's really made me say wow. The best out of the mediocre bunch is the red potato pizza with bacon and cheese (No broccoli), cheese pizza is ehhh, add bacon still ehhh. But the worst was the taco pizza. We weren't a fan of the meat on the pizza and don't even think about trying to reheat it at home. Would be nice if they delivered and cutting the pizza into squares makes no sense to me ‍ read more

For decades en route between NYC and Boston we've been suffering through the truck stop food a few miles up the toad. Today we walked out of there, unable to face another lousy fast-food meal, and discovered Willington Pizza Too. Wow, what a difference! We had delicious, fresh, handmade sandwiches and some of the yummiest, crispiest, thick cut potato chips we'd ever tried. The sandwiches were generously sized and full of fresh ingredients. Good prices, great food, and perhaps most importantly, literally 60 seconds off route 84. Skip Mickey D's on your next trip and dig into some REAL food. read more