Basic pizza shop I've passed by this location a bunch of times, and always liked the design of the place but never enough to try it. Decided to make a lunch trek, and see if they were any good. Coming in, there's a single person manning the helm. We thumb through the menu then flag them down to order. We get a smattering of slices, the loaded fries and the steak and cheese egg rolls. We were not sure where the blackened pizza slice came from on the kitchen floor, but we ignored it and opted to eat to go. Food came out reasonably quick. Took our pics then swapped bites. The egg rolls were as described. Steak and cheese in a wonton fried. Very one note, crispy and greasy with only a weak cheese sauce flavor. Not bad, but basic. The fries were very much college dorm nachos style. They had a thin coat of cheese over matchstick fries with toppings that fell through to the bottom. The cheese solidified quickly which welded the fries together into a giant clump. Not great, but if it's late at night and you're drunk they do scratch that greasy horribleness itch one can get. The pizza had a good crust, but the sauce and cheese were lackluster. The dough was fresh and cooked through, but the sauce was weak and no tomato flavor and the cheese was non-existent. The toppings on the specialty pizza's were pretty good, they just had a horrible base to work off of. As one of the few options for pizza in that area, you would be remiss to find much better pizza around. It's not great, but it is functional. read more

See all

Got the parm pie with chicken- awesome. Loved how they made the crispy chicken. Sauce was definitely fresh. Also, the ranch is bangin'. Definitely check it out! read more

Wicked Slice - Parmesan pie with crispy chicken - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

UGH. thought we would give this place a chance - not for us. Pizza was gross...the basil looked like it was scraped off the bottom of the oven- salad awful...and with packets of ken's dressing - nope?!? Bathrooms - one out of order and one has no trash can - so uhm....where you all washing your hands and putting that paper towel???? the staff was kind - just a huge miss for us. read more

Great Experience! It was very much appreciated how good the food matched the description and the Steak and Cheese egg rolls were great, and the Thin Crust Style Pizza was awesome, this was a great delivery! Thank You! read more

Legit Boston-style pizza and sub spot. I grew up on the north shore and haven't had a chicken cut prepared thin, tender and crispy since moving away 25 years ago. Will definitely drive out of my way to come back here! read more

My pizza had No flavor. The chicken on my pizza a was dried out. Overpriced. Will not go back. read more

Pizza is a thin crust New York style pie. Cut the correct way - in triangles. Pizza is cooked to just the right crispness. Owners are very friendly. read more

The pizza is good, and available by the slice. Excellent! I also appreciate that they do not use soy in their pizza. (Or at least, they were not last time I checked.) Thank you for not taking the cheapest option when it comes to cooking oil! read more

This place was great. I ordered years ago, but didn't get pizza, and we didn't enjoy much. I read they had new owners so we ordered a chicken parm pizza and tendies. Both were fantastic. I could smell the tendies on the way home & couldn't wait to dig in. Crispy, generously seasoned and the sauces were delicious. We tried hot garlic, Thai chili and honey bbq. The chicken parm pizza had a marinara sauce, cutlet, provolone and fried peppers and onions. Crust was crisp, cheese was perfectly browned and just smothering the crispy cutlet. I'd triple the peppers, just my preference, because they were so good. We will definitely be using them as our go to pizza joint in the area. The guys were super friendly when I picked up and looks like they're going great things to patio! So glad I gave a second shot!! read more

We managed to get lost on our way to the David Hayes Sculpture Fields and were getting hungry on Labor Day. I spotted this pizzeria, pulled a u-turn and walked in hoping pizza by the slice was available. I happily discovered that there were several varieties offered including one of my margarita, one of my favorites. The pizza is thin, New Haven style without the brick oven, but still better than most. I did encounter a communication problem in that the pizza was not reheated before being boxed, but it still was very good. Unfortunately we live on the other side of the Connecticut River and do not frequent this area often so it is unlikely we will be back any time soon. read more

Wicked Slice - two locations - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

See all

First time here since before the fire. Has slices to eat in. Great thin crust and for or five varieties by those slice. Tomato sauce nicely balanced. Enough cheese but not to much. Sausage an pepper was superb read more

These guys are awesome !!!!!! Pizza is great . Vincenzo read more

Stopped in for an early dinner. Place was not busy and no masks were observed on the staff. Ordered the garlic bread with cheese, cheese steak sandwich and the genoa salami grinder. Decided to dine in. Food came pretty quickly and was served as a take home meal. Garlic bread had plenty of garlic and cheese and came with marinara sauce. The bread was a panini roll. Nice and hot, roll was very soft and the marinara sauce was good. Where everything falls down is with the sandwiches. The Genoa grinder (12 inch) had 6 slices of meat on it. It was served warm as requested but there was so little meat that I ended up eating just the meat and cheese. Bread was nice and warm but without any meat it didn't really matter. Bread should have had oil sprinkled on it but if it was it was about two drops. Totally dry once you removed the meat and cheese. Same could be said fir the cheese steak sandwich. Not much meat and not much flavor. This is our first time trying the Coventry location we normally order our pizzas from the Hebron location and they never disappoint. But we won't be coming back to the Coventry location anytime soon. A complete disappointment and waste of money In my book. Should also add the table was dirty with crumbs and the floor under it appeared to have particles of hamburger. Was hard to tell when the seating are had been cleaned last. read more

Best food in coventry staff is the best service is great and food is always cooked perfect.

Best pizza I have ever had!!!!! And very respectful workers you will not regret spending your money here

When you're looking for toppings that can cave in a crust and satisfy your cravings this is the place to be.

Friendly, clean, fast, and good pizza. Had I know I would be paying $21 for a small 4 topping pizza when the order was place, I'd had said no thank you. Pizza is just as good down the road for $16. Grossly over price. I will not come back. read more

We have tried a few pizza variations over the months as well as some non pizza items. Pizza: first time was a thin overcooked pie. 80% of the crust was burnt and inedible. We still gave them another chance at a different time, and the same result. One of the pizzas was fine, the 2nd, burnt. The quality control just doesn't seem to matter. They are also priced a little higher than most take out only pizza places. Next we tried a few oven toasted subs. They were all mediocre at best. Not all that fresh ingredients and hastily assembled. The eggplant was missing the eggplant and seems to be a triple fried and baked shell of batter. I'm was not impressed with the quality of any of the ingredients. It's not bad by any means, but just a regular non-Greek pizza place. read more

I'm not a fan, sorry : /...that being said they have delicious loaded spuds and sweet potatoes fries AWESOME, mediocre salads and \_(**)_/ okay pizza. One truly good thing? They're quick in a pinch usually. But if you arrive 30mins to closing don't expect the red carpet treatment ~ I completely understand...BUTT... read more

I've lived in this area for over 30 years and have to say this was the worst take out I've ever had. The pizza looked like a frozen pizza and the crust tasted like a chemical disinfectant. The grinder had barely any meat and some salad mix for the veggies. The Greek salad was horrible. Only lettuce with a minuscule amount of feta. Asked the employee at least 3x for dressing and he insisted it was in the container, it was not. We threw the pizza out as we were afraid of giving it to the kids with such a strong chemical taste. Overpriced and a wasted $50. It was the day before Thanksgiving and only one employee was there. He obviously just wanted to get out of there and put minimal effort into the food. We've always heard rave reviews about the place, but this was our first and last trip there! read more

I had a salami grinder here today. There was very little meat, two thin slices of provolone cheese, two very thin slices of tomato, lots of lettuce, and lots and lots of bread. Needless to say, I was very disappointed! I will not be coming back! My husband's grinder was also mediocre. Don"t waste your money. read more

I expected more from a place thats so pricey (compared to other pizza places). Ive ordered food from here multiple times. The grinders ive recieved had bread that was dry snd fried chicken nearly overcooked with an obvious taste of burntness. I have also ordered pizza here on sunday night and recieved the "last customer screw you" treatment, the pizzas crust was very hard and the cheese tasted burnt. Before i moved, i had a pizza place i really liked where dinner combos where $12. This time i decided to order one of their dinner combos, chicken and broccoli pasta. What i got was dry pasta and chicken with black chars from the grill all over, furthermore i expected broccoli florets but the product used was packaged frozen broccoli (I can tell because ive worked in kitchens for years). It doesn't seem to me the cooks really care about the food (or cook at all really). A pasta dinner priced at $15 should have been much better. The menu is pretty pretentious for a place that uses mostly frozen products, ive realized now after giving this place multiple chances that the food is just garbage, and im not ordering from here anymore. read more

Wicked Slice - Chicken and broccoli over pasta with black chars all over. Added olive oil at home to make more appetizing - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

Remember Ellio's frozen crap pizza? Go buy that instead of going to Wicked Slice. This pizza was awful. Rubbery crust that tastes just like the cheapest frozen pizza you can buy. This is NOT pizza. The sauce follows the same "flavor" profile. I went here based on reviews from Yelp and the menu looked really good. Not the first time I've been led down the wrong path by the low-brow palates posting on Yelp. read more

Wicked Slice - Generic frozen gross pizza - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

Good pizza no question nice and fresh good pizza overall, friendly staff Easy parking in and out.

Consistant with the quality of their food, don't forget they have more than pizza they have great wraps and salads with generous portions

All I gotta say is they were very prompted with our last min order of 2 mega pizzas! For the fact it was last min the pizzas were great , and on point! read more

I used to love this place but I feel like the staff could give 2 shits for their customers. I love the menu. In the past, when the staff cared, the food was great. If you get lucky and the owner is in there, the pizza is good. Usually though, it's cold, they forget to put it in the oven for you, the chicken isn't cook all the way in the grinders, and the salads will contain all the things you asked them to hold. Believe me, this is not a 1 try bad experience review. Things happen, busy nights can mean less optimal food even from the best places. That's not been my experience. It's always dead in there, and the kids always act like we are breaking up the party. I am local and have given them many many times constantly hoping whatever the problem is in the kitchen, that's it's corrected. It's sad that it hasn't been. Im writing this review hoping they read it bc you guys have something special here but your complete lack of acting like you serve is destroying it. You are NOT the only game in town. Honestly, it would take a tiny bit of customer service improvement and this place could be the top spot in Tolland and Windham counties. Get your shit together. read more

Amazing pizza!! Great staff! Love that Jack! I enjoy the different option for specialty pies and that they have a great sauce. Crust is always perfectly done! read more

Anybody who rates this place less than 5 stars was likely deprived of oxygen and lacks proper sensory perception! Great food, great atmosphere, and a great crew! read more

I have been in the store twice for pick up and saw the staff not wearing their masks properly. They pull them up when a customer comes in. This is extremely disappointing. read more

Ordered tuna grinder but got home to discover we picked up a mystery meat grinder...we called and told them we got the wrong order. They said it was philly cheese steak but that we could come back and pick up the correct order...At first we told them no big deal, we'd try it.... However it tastes horrible! Literally looks like ground beef! See the photo... No cheese! Really strange taste too....we're not picky eaters but this is THAT bad...called again and they've now offered to deliver the correct sandwich....said they already made that offer, not true, they originally offered for us to pick it up... done with wicked slice!!! Dimitris or Georginas any day!! read more

Wicked Slice - Bad sandwich - A close-up of a beef taco filled with seasoned ground beef and melted cheese, served on a decorative plate with a poinsettia and holly design, suggesting a holiday setting. - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

This was our first time ordering and I must say, it was very disappointing. Pizza was suppose to have meatballs, but three slices in and didn't find any. We ordered a calzone, which was nothing like what a calzone should be - the inside was a pile of mush and not sure ricotta cheese was involved. Spent a lot of money for a pizza and calzone to have such a mediocre meal. read more

Wicked Slice - Calzone with broccoli and sausage. - A close-up of a calzone with a golden-brown crust, filled with broccoli, sausage, and melted cheese. The calzone is partially sliced open, revealing the filling inside. It is placed on a piece of parchment paper on a wooden surface, with some crumbs and cheese visible around. - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

SUMMER 2018 UPDATE: Unfortunately Wicked Slice had a fire in July of 2018 and is no longer open. They will hopefully be back to Coventry soon! Regardless of them no longer being open, I did want to put a review out there to highlight the great things Wicked Slice brought to Coventry. One- I was hesitant and not excited when I learned that another pizza place was coming to Coventry. We already have two (average at best) pizza places. That immediately changed with my first bite into Wicked pizza. Their pizza was a step above the rest and was always hot, fresh, and delicious. They also had a lot of fun with experimenting with different pizza toppings (and things you wouldn't ever expect to see on pizza like literally chicken tenders) and it was fun to try their new menu items! Two- Wicked Slice was amazing to the Coventry community. In their short time open in Coventry they truly made an impact-- offering free pizza for school and library events, as well as being present at town functions selling their slices. I hope Wicked Slice reopens in Coventry soon as we all miss their pizza read more

Enjoying the most delicious house salad that was delivered to my house in Andover! Thank you! Awesome ! read more

Wicked Slice - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

Don't go by the posted prices...because apparently they don't mean anything. I went here tonight with my son and ordered two slices of cheese and two slices of pepperoni to go. While waiting for them to be heated up, I was looking at the chalkboards hung above the kitchen with some menu items and specials. One of the specials was a combo deal for any two slices and a can of soda for $5.75. So when my slices were ready I said I would take the special deal with the cans of soda. She told me the total, which was over $13 and I immediately knew something was off. I asked for a receipt and when I got it, I saw that the combo deal price was listed at $6.50, not $5.75 as on the board. The manager was standing right there so I brought it to his attention. He looked at my receipt and said "oh. Yeah. The prices went up." That's it. No apology. No refund. Nothing. I stood there waiting for him to offer me a refund or something considering he had an advertised price right in front of us and NOTHING showing the higher price I was charged. Yet apparently, he felt he could charge me whatever he wanted and I would just take it. Which I did. And now will never come back. read more

Best pizza EVER! Becky's margarita pizza is THE BEST. Chicken salad with cranberries is the best. Wings are also great. I highly recommend Wicked Pizza. The also deliver read more

Wicked Slice - BEAT PIZZA EVER!!! - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

In all seriousness, when was the last time you ordered a pizza and savored every bite? I stopped in for what I thought would be a quick slice and got stopped in my tracks. I had heard of Wicked Pizza but had never met anyone who had actually had one of their pies. First thoughts:. $7 for two slices and a drink 2 LARGE slices An AWESOME lunch bargin Random Thoughts: No seating inside Picnic tables with umbrellas outside The pies choices are eclectic, but WOW I didn't start enjoying brussel sprouts until I was an adult. Had I had this pizza when I was a kid I would have been in convert much sooner. The layers of flavors DEMAND that you savor each bite. It's like nothing I have experienced with Pizza. I am sitting here trying, with out success, to describe this creation that has elevated my view of the simple pizza to ... THIS (to be continued) read more

If you looking to order an allergy friendly items (vegan cheese, gluten free crust), be sure to check if they have it in stock before placing your order. They were out of the vegan cheese and didn't call until I had arrived. The person on the phone didn't tell me they had a back up plan, but offered a casual sorry. The manager didn't apologize, but told me they had a plan in place after I had left and connected with them on their social media page. Clearly, they don't care if they disappoint their customers. Just based on the customer service, I don't think I will be back anytime soon. read more

Decided to give this place a try again. What a mistake. Ordered a sandwich and the guy making it came back up to the counter to answer the phone and tap an order into the touchscreen they use. He did this wearing the gloves he had been wearing to make my sandwich. When he was done on the phone and touching the counter, phone and touchscreen panel he went back to making my sandwich WEARING THE SAME GLOVES. This is disgusting and I doubt is consistent with health department rules. I walked out. Does the owner of this place have any idea how unsafe their employees operate? read more

I stopped in one day to finally try out this new restaurant in Coventry. I ordered a order of chicken wings. I was very disappointed that they were flat pieces of chicken rather than the usual plump pieces I'm uses to. The flavor of the wings was nothing to shout about. Would recommend The Bidwell Tavern if you want delicious wings in Coventry. Just a note that unfortunately this business will be closed for a while because of a fire in the restaurant last week. I would call first to see if this have reopened. read more