I stopped in one day to finally try out this new restaurant in Coventry. I ordered a order of chicken wings. I was very disappointed that they were flat pieces of chicken rather than the usual plump pieces I'm uses to. The flavor of the wings was nothing to shout about. Would recommend The Bidwell Tavern if you want delicious wings in Coventry. Just a note that unfortunately this business will be closed for a while because of a fire in the restaurant last week. I would call first to see if this have reopened. read more

If you looking to order an allergy friendly items (vegan cheese, gluten free crust), be sure to check if they have it in stock before placing your order. They were out of the vegan cheese and didn't call until I had arrived. The person on the phone didn't tell me they had a back up plan, but offered a casual sorry. The manager didn't apologize, but told me they had a plan in place after I had left and connected with them on their social media page. Clearly, they don't care if they disappoint their customers. Just based on the customer service, I don't think I will be back anytime soon. read more

So sad. Expected much more. Crust was tasteless and too hard. The pizza had very little flavor. The cheese was not melted.

Duh! Wicked good food! The wings are decent size, good selection of flavors. The pizza is the thin crust style so you either love it or your drunk and love it even more. read more

Good pizza, but tonight we had the chicken parm dinner meal delivered and they forgot the rolls which is what it is, but the chicken breast was all breading, extremely thinly sliced to the point there was barely any meat at all. Between the missing rolls and terrible chicken they get a 2 out of 5 star. read more

Picked up the worst wrap ever chicken was completely burnt when they put it in the wrap like they didn't see it unfortunately even less places to eat in this town now! read more

Wicked Slice - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

Love the selection of slices they offer - we drive 30 minutes just to enjoy their pizza.

Very good thin pizza. Fresh toppings and a nice tasty red sauce I haven't tasted before. It is Wickedly delicious pizza. Try it out! read more

See all

This place is a great find. Just wanted a quick lunch. It only took about 5 minutes to be out the door. The pizza is top notch. One of the best I've had, and I can be a little snobby about my pizza. Two specialty slices and a soda only cost me about $5.50. The slices are good size too. There's no question in my mind I'll be back. read more

So happy wicked slice is back up and running! After a long much anticipated wait I have to say the food was better than it was the first time around. The store has a nice new look to it and the staff is always very kind and quick. They are one of the few places in the area that delivers pizza and that defiantly sets them aside from the other pizza places in town. ( there is way too many pizza choice for a town so small) My boyfriend says I live off pizza. Also they sell by the slice which is great for lunch or if ur not super hungry. The flavors are cool and unique. You will not find this pizza anywhere else. Aside from pizza they have "wicked" yummy wings and salads,apps, grinders, a little bit of everything to be honest. All around a great restaurant! read more

Eh, thought we'd see what people were talking about but sadly not for us. Loved the variety of 'fresh' toppings, yet the eggplant was soggy like frozen. Crust was bland and overall not worth the price tag. Too much sauce and not enough cheese. read more

Horrible!!! Wings were so full of fat, they were disgusting. Very dry,,,, Spinach salad.... So much smaller and had NO Gorgonzola cheese or bacon!!! Prices are outrageous and the quality is NOT good!!! Very disappointing!! read more

Last night I ordered a red pie with chicken cutlet, onion, and bacon. Unfortunately it came with grilled chicken instead. I called and they said they would make a new one and come drop it off. Keep in mind they don't deliver. They also said that I will have a free pizza under my phone number for another day just for the inconvenience. What great customer service! I really appreciated it! I tried to tip the guy that came to drop it off, he declined my gratitude but I insisted he take it. Keep up the good work guys! Coventry's #1 pizza place in my opinion!! read more

I finally get my Ham and Turkey Grinder made the way I like it. Sarah is a Master-Sandwich-Maker, and always applies her many skills towards creating your sandwich for you that is always delicious. read more

So stopped with my neighbor on a beautiful sunday afternoon. Looking for a new pizza place. All ill say is get here now!!! While this hidden gem is still a little obscure. The pizza AMAZINGLY flavorful, we got the eggplant parmigiana and the sauce alone was clearly homemade & outstanding, but the headliner, the showstopper was the mac-daddy pizza! Absolutely one on the most flavorful pizzas ive ever had, and im a fat guy who loves food!!! Please try this place, you wont be disappointed! Plus its BYOB. read more

Wicked Slice - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Connecticut

First time here pizza was really good you won't be disappointed I got the Margherita pizza in a good fellas pizza both so good. The staff was really friendly and the owner was very friendly highly recommended this place read more

The pizza is so good. The red sauce on the pizza is incredible. All the toppings are fresh. Best pizza place around. They made a mistake on our pizza and immediately offered us a gift certificate. I was so impressed with the immediate acceptance of the error, the apology and making it right. Mistakes happen but the fixing of the mistake is more important. Wicked gets it. I would recommend them to everyone. read more

Our pizza was 20 minutes later than they said it would be for takeout. The pizza itself was pretty bland, and to make matters worse, I found a hair buried in my slice. read more

Definitely don't get delivery. It's been an hour and a half and I'm still waiting. I get it you have a business and it gets busy but this Is ridiculous. The food is ok but not worth the wait. read more

Worst customer service. Every single visit is an issue (even before covid). Tonight we experienced them giving our order away to someone else, then realized it wasn't correct so took it back and did not repackage. Also had to go in to grab my order after being told it would be brought out. Finally realized it wasn't going to be brought out when I saw every worker leaving the building. I can honestly say I probably will not order here ever again, which is a shame because their food is typically good. read more

Mmmmmm mmm mmmm. Have only gotten take out twice but yum! The mac and cheese pizza is delicious and still remains crispy even with a hearty portion of macaroni and cheese on top. Also comes with bacon and jalepeno, a nice touch. The chicken Bacon ranch pizza is also very good. The wings are a good size and we tried the golden and the garlic flavors both very tasty. Nice job! read more

We've ordered pizza from here twice now and that's been enough, it's just not that impressive. I like the idea of a lot of their specialty/ premium pizzas (we've tried the Boba Fetta, chicken bacon ranch, Hawaii five-0, and one with meatballs eggplant & ricotta which was our favorite but still just ok) but they have been underwhelming. The toppings are fine but there is not enough sauce, the pizza is dry and for "thin crust" it's not really that thin, like honestly I think Domino's thin crust is better. They are generous with their sizes, a medium is more like a large you'd get anywhere else, but that's not enough to keep us going back. read more

My favorite pizza joint in America, bar none. I just created this yelp account because I could not believe the average review score was only 3.5. Delicious thin crust pizza with innovative specialty choices. If you aren't ordering a specialty here, you're not doing it right. I moved to California and my first stop when I get back around to CT is Wicked Slice! read more

We get pizza here probably once a week. Gluten free for me and non-GF for the husband. Even on busy nights, the pizza is always ready in a half hour or 20 minutes. Great toppings and really tasty flavor combos (apple and bacon? Mmmm.) i would skip their avocado pizza because the avocado is cooked and that's kind of gross, but I have liked every other pie I've tried. Rumor has it that they'll have ice cream this summer, so now they really will be my favorite restaurant. read more

I wanted to show support for a new local business so I ordered a few pizzas to bring to work. I was impressed with what they showed me! I was greeted by a friendly worker at the counter and the manager even took some time to come over and say "hello" while I was cashing out. I brought the pizza's to my office to surprise my co workers and they all thought the thin crust pizza was delicious. I thoroughly enjoyed the very tasty GLUTEN FREE white pizza. Tonight I will order some pizza for my family- they've listened to me rave about it all week, now it's their turn to enjoy some wicked good pizza! read more

I went in to pickup 1 slice to go. The owner went over to the case with his bare hands and a bandaid on his finger grabbed the slice and put it in the box. That was nasty. read more

This place is great for a quick bite. Their paninis Are delicious and they also have pizza by the slice which is also very good. There is no seating inside but they do have an outdoor seating area. read more

This place is the best pizza place in Coventry! The pizza and prices are 5 star! I really enjoyed the cheeseburger pizza!! Some other very creative choices as well. read more

The pizza is excellent as always but they cannot figure out how long orders will take. 4 times in a row our food has been 15+ minutes later than stated. I'd gladly wait the time if told accurately up front. Shame, we were really looking forward to the reopening. read more

Delicious pizza and always on time. I love a good thin crust pizza! The only reason they don't get 5 stars is because a couple of times the pizza has been a tad underdone, but still very good! Best pizza in town! read more

Great thin crust pizza with not-your-typical toppings and combinations. Wings are decent, too. From what I understand, you can BYOB, but there's only picnic tables outside. I've had pizza all over and of various types (thick, thin, italian, greek, etc) and this is my second favorite place in the entire country. Luckily it's right here in my own town! read more

Sometimes quite okay, sometimes underdone and doughy. Not as good as Blaze, but far from a real non-Northeast CT pizza.

Tried Wicked for the first time today, I was impressed with the pizza flavors, I tried a slice each of the spicy shrimp, the mushroom gouda , and the pepperoni. Great tastes, not too acidic sauce, the cheese was properly cooked and the crust was nice and thin and crunchy, but not burned and not doughy. Definitely better than the Italian place down the street, or even willington. Very happy and will be ordering from there often. read more

not usually a fan of thin crust pizza,but have to say this turned me around and will opt for their tin crust pizza every time. had the specialty combo loaded with items and very tasty. Large pie fresh toppings. Will definitely be back soon. read more

I tried this place a while back and the pizza was terrible. The owner was gracious enough to offer us a free pie and ask us to give them a second chance. When my wife went to pick up the "free" pie they made her pay for the pizza we ordered and gave her a small 3 cheese pizza (That had very little cheese) for free. The pizza was terrible and I will never return. Efen for free. Highland park market has a much better thin crust pizza, and it's cheaper. read more

We have been to get pizza twice and both times it was very busy. Consequently, our pizza was not cooked enough. The crust was not cooked enough, rather raw and not crispy. The pizza itself was very tasty and they have great combinations. We haven't been back but plan on trying it again soon. read more

Not a fan of the food. I have only had the pizza, but I don't really like it to be honest.

This place just opened up right next to the long-standing town pizza place.. pretty ballsy! Here's my take: presuming they'd be busy, I called in my order for pick-up. The man on the phone was clear and helpful and did not make me feel rushed. He told me it would be ready in about 40 minutes. Once I arrived I noticed a line that went all the way out the front door! It's a new restaurant in a small town.... it is to be expected. I was surprised to find that there is NO INDOOR SEATING. You may either take your food to go or enjoy their nice outdoor seating area. For what it was, the place was clean though cramped at the ordering area. The staff were excellent. I was impressed by how they kept their cool despite being severely overwhelmed with orders. I wanted to give the menu a good try so I ordered 6 Wings in Skippy golden sauce, a chicken pesto wrap, a cup of chili, an order or Italian fries, and a small bacon cheeseburger pizza. I'll admit.. the only item I thought was exceptional was the pizza. The others were "meh" but I am sure that as this business finds their footing and the orders get less crazy things will improve. If they have a public bathroom I didn't see it (but didn't look either). The prices are fair and the location is convenient. Their extensive and somewhat unusual menu is what really draws me in.. I mean.. bacon cheeseburger pizza? And it was fantastic! I'll visit again when things calm down a bit and update my review accordingly . read more

Very fresh food. One of the best eggplant grinders I've had. Also great vegetarian panini options. We will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Very similar pizza to Da' Vinci in Hebron (which the guy also owns I believe). It's the only thin crust in town which already starts them off in a good spot but they go above and beyond with an eclectic, yet good, offering of pizza toppings. Also nice to have an option for a slice of pizza besides Highland. Only thing they still need is to offer delivery! read more