I made a special trip to Willimantic because Tony's Pizza was the No. 7 vote getter for the CT Visit, CT Pizza Trail. See. It's already working to stimulate tourism. LOL Tony's is a Greek Style, neighborhood pizza spot. I ordered a large red pizza with "Grinder Meatball", peppers and onions when I was about 15 minutes out. I arrived. I took some pics from the parking lot, and by the time I walked inside, they had just pulled my pizza out of the oven and boxed it. The transaction was easy since I had paid online. If you order this Grinder Meatball topping, which seems to be somewhat of a signature, DO NOT, freak out when you open the box and don't see meatballs. The onions and peppers are on top of the cheese. And they mix up the thin sliced meatballs with the sauce, and put them under the cheese. Given how they work the Grinder Meatball topping, my comments may not apply to all of Tony's Pizzas. First of all, I like this style of thin cut , almost wiry, white onion and green peppers. Good appearance. Good flavor. The crust was medium thick and pan-crisped. Fairly standard Greek Style crust. Also, I liked the cheese, but it could have been a bit more well done for my tastes. It was well melted. But there was minimal marbling on top, which I like. I liked the meatball topping and Tony's gave you a lot of meatball pieces. Here's the only thing I didn't love about this pizza. Because the meatball slices were mixed into the sauce and they were so generous with the meatballs, the flavor of the sauce got lost. I couldn't tell if the sauce was average, good or very good. It just wasn't noticeable in relation to the meatball flavor. I would recommend asking for a side of sauce and dip pizza into the sauce, or maybe add extra sauce to the pizza. I think the crust would hold up to that. This probably wouldn't be an issue if you got a cheese pizza or a pepperoni pizza. Tony's has a bunch of inside seating. I suspect families eat hear regularly. I was there early. So I'm not sure how busy it gets. If I lived in the area, I could see regularly ordering from Tony's. I bet they have good meatball grinders too. 4.25 Stars read more

See all

I recently got a sausage and mushroom pizza, the cook put so much cheese on it I literally threw it out, I don't plan on going back, they used to make an awesome pizza, idk what happened, it was pretty disgusting. read more

This is a tried and truly awesome restaurant. I started eating at Tony's when I was in college in 1992...the food was always reasonably priced and delicious. Move forward 35 years later and with a more mature palate, their food is still just as amazing as it was in the 90's and reasonably priced! I hope and pray that God continues to BLESS this restaurant for many many more years! Thank you, Tony's, for being our comfort food and to go place to eat!! read more

See all

My parents have been taking me to Tony's Pizza my entire life. It feels like home when you walk in the door. The memories from childhood come flooding back. Now going there with my kids is so meaningful. Don't be in a rush, take you time and enjoy the atmosphere of this family run business. They are filled with heart and appreciation for your support of their business. The food is always consistent, the staff is always pleasant and the leftovers will be enjoyed tomorrow. read more

See all

Wasn't to hungry tonight so I settled on a plain cheese pizza from Tony's. It was delicious and still hot by the time I got it home. I have not yet had a bad food from here. If you're in the area and looking for a delicious pizza this is the place to go. read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Willimantic, Connecticut

Pretty run of the mill pizza joint when you walk in. Friendly service, plenty of booth seating. Not a fan of the "I can get this at every pizza place" type pizza. Wasn't anything I'd go back for but it's not something I'd ever send back. The cheeseburger grinder that we tried was good. I'd go back and try other menu items. read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Willimantic, Connecticut

The food as always is great. Tastes fresh and in hearty helping. The counter staff is nice and prompt which is great. I don't often eat there but I have never had bad service there. It has plenty of booth seating and a counter with stools which is nice and not common anymore. It's clean. Done in Red, black and dark blond wood. read more

If you're ever in Willimantic Ct and are hungry for a pizza that takes you back to when you were a kid. This is the place. Family owned and run. Walking in you smell the fresh pizzas coming out of the oven and a place that time has forgotten, which is a good thing.service was excellent and price was just right. So what are you waiting for head out now and get you a delish pizza. read more

See all

It was the best pizza we've had in a long time. Lots of fresh mushrooms and vegetables.

Not so good. Specially the way they cut the pizza. What a mess. - pizza was not cooked all the way. It was a large all pep and half sausage. - location a bit messy and not clean. - to much going on behind the counter. To many chiefs not enough workers. It was late and we were hungry. Local hotel recommended this place. read more

First time here,excellent pizza by far the best in the area! I'll definitely be going back,wish I had tried them years ago.

The best. Greek pizza. Family owned and operated. The best pizza. The best. Best ever. Get the hint? read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Willimantic, Connecticut

My 3rd time eating here, and as always been happy with my food. Definitely bringing back old Willimantic Flavor. This what a SAMICH looks like . read more

Tony's Pizza - Italian Grinder - Pizza Near Me - Willimantic, Connecticut

Have been a fan of this place since I was a child Still holding strong - Always delicious read more

Pizza was amazing!!!! Very generous toppings! Crust was crispy! Service was great! Pricing fair and reasonable for the amount of toppings and size of the pie! read more

Called my order in for pickup at 4:00pm and was told to pick up in 20-35 mins. I was there at 4:30 and was told that they had forgotten my pizza and that they would have to remake it and it should take about 15 minutes. I left there at 4:55 with pizza in hand but no apology or discount. I won't be back soon. read more

Their chicken patty grinder is the best there is! Onion rings amazing! And of course the ambiance of happy people always there is a family spot. read more

Outstanding pizza. It sucked to overhear the owner talking about queers. I don't mind if he has big feelings on how gay people react when we hear ignorance, but he doesn't need to shove it in everybody's face, know what I mean? I'm open to different opinions and all, and again, the food was great, but that sort of thing is just off-putting. Keep it behind closed doors where it belongs. read more

Delicious pizza! I do wish their pickup area was less cramped and better organized. Parking is much better now that the small lot was repaved. read more

Even though they're closed this week because of their much deserved vacation they need to know that they have made my week I made sure to order a extra crispy pepperoni pizza and a sausage pizza before their break. As a long-term resident of Willimantic Tony's pizza is a legend that is unrivaled. Pepperoni pizza extra crispy has those amazing pepperoni cups with just the right amount of toast on them that they snap and crunch in your mouth. The grinders (aka subs, hoagies, sammies) are a gift from the gods. whether it's eggplant, sausage and peppers or the unrivaled bacon cheese burger grinder the flavor and deliciousness is right. read more

I moved away from Willimantic 6 years ago... Tony's Pizza still provides my pizza! In Miami, in New Orleans, I still eat their pizza. The South doesn't have good pizza, but with the help of family and the restaurant, I still eat Tony's on a regular basis. I've traveled the world, and am an avid pizza lover- Tony's is the epitome of pizza, and their willingness to help serve me all the way in New Orleans is incredible! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Willimantic, Connecticut

Greek style pizza. We went for nostalgia as we used to frequent when we went to school at UCONN in the 1980s. The service was good and the pizza was OK - but after living in New Haven for 30+ years, it's hard to rave about non New Haven style. Lots of cheese and a little doughy and salty. The booths were the same. Location is in downtown Willimantic which may be a challenge in the evening. Sparking behind and across the street is adequate. We went for lunch mid-week when colleges / schools were done and I will say, the phone was ringing constantly and the take-out business looked to be booming. read more

We just moved from Providence back in July, and we're looking for a decent pizza place. After a couple misses, this one delivered as a big hit! I highly recommend for anyone coming to the area looking for pizza. Sides are good too. read more

I ordered 3 items. Those items were a pizza, small order of wings and a small steak grinder. I paid extra for cheese on the grinder, got none. At least they followed my instructions on what to leave off. The wings were not great, hard breading / dry chicken. The pizza was the most disappointing because it looked beautiful but was not tasty at all. The weird layer of mystery meat under the cheese was an immediate turnoff, the flavor was off. Sauce tastes a bit funny as well. Pizza should not have whatever was under that cheese. It was neither meatball, hamburger, pepperoni, sausage or bacon as the menu suggests was on the pizza Overall, I would not be ordering again as much as I wanted to like it. It was expensive by my standards, but I am also not from this area. Only thing done right was the delivery staff was nice, he found my apartment when most people can't & the charge for delivery wasn't too bad. read more

Tony's Pizza - Tony's Meatlover's Small $ 11.25 Large $ 20.70 - Pizza Near Me - Willimantic, Connecticut

They have great pizza and very friendly server's When in Willy stop by. You won't be disappointed read more

Good local joint. Get the extra cheese. The meat lovers one is so meaty it's almost unreal. I prefer the extra cheese only though best tasting one. read more

They are the best pizza is awesome. The buffalo chicken salad is big enough for two people easily.very nice hometown type of place

Best Pizza in New England!!! I would highly and always recommend Tony's! The pizza is phenomenal, and so are the grinders. Make sure you order a pastrami or steak grinder when you go! read more

Consistently great pizza with great variety of toppings and styles. Service is fast too. Can't go wrong with this place. They offer an awesome range of fresh pizzas. I liked dining here. Staff members are always friendly, prices are reasonable and the spot is always kept clean. read more

See all

Tony's was good pizza. But not your traditional pie. It was a rectangle pie- one pie for 3 adults for much was enough. Service was good, quick. read more

On Oct 15 went out with my cousins that live in a nearby town, at first I was only concentrated on visiting with them since we hadn't seen them in a while but when that pizza arrived to the table, oh boy it looked so good because it had every ingredient found in the kitchen and tasted even better. Was so good we fought for the check and of course I lost being the visitor. Would have gone back the next evening but had a very important event at Rentchler Field in Hartford with a tail gate party and all. Lady owner was one hundred percent correct about my feelings at the game, I nearly lost my voice from screaming and another pizza would have been good for my hoarseness and my appetite, more so for the latter undoubtedly. Thanks to my CT cousins I was able to taste this hidden gem. I will go back when in the area read more

Just like when I was 17. Thanks for always being great. Meatball grinder and French fries just as good as it was 35 years ago

We went on a Sunday after 3pm and it wasn't super full, so I expected the service to be okay... it was pretty slow, mainly because they only had ONE server (we had to wait 20 min for our drinks). Pizza is good but a TOO greasy. So for okay service and greasy pizza, this is your place! read more

Tony's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Willimantic, Connecticut

Maybe the people complaining have a point about this place needing an update....there was that one time that a fan literally fell from the ceiling and crashed on the floor next to me. Luckily, no pizza was harmed. My waitress apologized and we all moved on with our lives and our pizza. Aside from falling infrastructure, I love this place! This is your classic Greek style CT pizza. Although the heavy amount of grease can be a turn off for some I absolutely love this style of pizza! Tony's pizza in this fashion offers a little more cheese, and a little more oregano heavy sauce than others I've had. Sometimes asking for a little less cheese does the trick for me but I don't think you'll be disappointed in giving this place a try. FYI - There's plenty of seating if you plan on bringing a soccer/baseball team in. read more

Tony's pizza has always been a great pizza place and the restaurant has always served me well with great choices of food!

I have recently started ordering from Tony's. I have always enjoyed their pizza and have branched off onto a few other things on their menu. But what I want to comment on now is their spectacular service. I recently placed an order with them, and they have been very consistent with usually being on time or early. Today, however, they were late. I called and was told it was on the way,I waited another 15 minutes and called them back. They explained they were having problems with their system and they remade my order, so it was fresh and hot. When the delivery driver arrived, he again explained the problem again and gave me both orders plus a 2 liter bottle of soda. When I went to throw out my trash, I looked at my receipt, and not only did they give me both orders and the soda. They didn't charge me for the original order. That extra order fed a homeless person that day. Tony goes above and beyond for their customers. I would give more than 5 stars if I could you are the best keep up the good work. read more

Tonys pizza is Willimantic. Been there for years and with good reason. There pizza is hearty and there are many choices. Pepperoni is my favorite. Can be a little greasy at times but still very good. Subs are good and the cheeseburger plate is very good and filling. Wings are tasty and very good standard wings but great bar food read more

I heard the pizza was good but the service was awful. I sat in a booth for 30 mins with the waitress promising me she would be right with me. Never happened. I walked out! read more

Ordered here once and never again. Ordered delivery and the guy got lost, went on all our neighbors doors but ours, stated he tried to knock on my door but he never did, also said that he call which was also not true AND he made his way back to the restaurant. 1 hour 30 minutes after I called to check where he was he brought me the same COLD GREASY PIZZA! (And sure enough didn't got lost this time) I called the owner and requested a refund, got stomach sick and had a really bad experience. read more

I Lived In Windham/Willimantic Until I Was 26 I Loved And Still Love Their Pepperoni Pizza I Have Lived In Manchester For The Past 12 Years And Still Get My Pepperoni Mushroom Extra Cheese Pizza From Mr.Tony There Is No Pizza In Manchester That Compares To Tony's I Will Be Back Very Soon I Try To Get Down To Tony's@ Least 2 Times A Year As I Have To Get A Ride I Would Be There Twice A Week If I Could read more