When preparing the day before Thanksgiving, I was pressed for time. Cleaning, prepping sides, and having a friend stop by. Looked online for nearby delivery. Very pleased to have found and tried Pizza Mike's. The toppings were perfectly distributed, the cheese was the perfect amount, and crust done exactly how I like it. The BLT pizza had garlic crust, great option to add! Many places try doing a bit pizza and you get a mouth full of mayo. Pizza Mike's had a great combination with plenty of bacon and was exactly what I had hoped for. The Buffalo chicken pizza had an option of ranch or blue cheese. I was very happy that the distribution of chicken wasn't overly large or too scant either. The dressing was under the cheese, giving the perfect amount with each bite. I really enjoyed how the cheese was over the chicken. Most places put the chicken on top that gets dried out. One of the best pizzas I've had in the area. Will be ordering from them again. Came in the time it said it would, kept getting updates via text, and communication was great. Highly recommend read more

See all

Very good pizza and delivered quick! One area for improvement-person who delivered didn't knock on door and left pizza on porch...like it delivered hot in an insulated container in future. Thank-you, Susan read more

Always delicious. Always friendly. The mac & cheese pizza is better than it has any right to be. Highly recommend. read more

Pizza Mike's is conveniently located at Storrs Four Corners making it easily accessible for folks at or near UConn and surrounding towns. THE FOOD -it's in the name...they do pizza! -I've had a wide variety of their pizzas and have enjoyed many of them -while they may seem a bit pricey, their large pizzas are large and DENSE (at least the specialty ones pack some weight). 2 slices and I'm done for -they're really good about getting specifications correct! I am a picky eater so I usually sub some ingredients (within reason) and they have never gotten it wrong -crowd favorites for pizza: Buffalo chicken, margherita, and Philly cheese steak! - THE AMBIANCE -it's inside a gas station so yea lol -there is a cute little table outside though if you are grabbing a quick slice on your lunch -good rewards program THE SERVICE -like I said, they never get an order wrong -they are always so so so nice on the phone and always willing to answer any questions I have -I'm in an organization that often orders 10+ pizzas for our meetings and they always do a great job and deliver on time -our last order we tried the Philly cheesesteak for the first time and I put in the comments how I hate onions but my partner wanted them so please make sure it really is half and half. I thought I was going to have to scavenge to figure out which half had the onions but they wrote in the box which I thought was so kind!! (Also---this is our new favorite pizza from them! It was delicious..we asked them to go a little lighter on the cheese so it wasn't quite as dense) Overall, it's a really good pizza and in a convenient location for us. It's not my favorite pizza ever, but definitely the one I prefer locally. When you add on the amazing service you're provided by the staff it's a no brainer!! Oh, and their mascot is a giant grinning slice of pizza. We love Pizza Mike's! read more

Pizza Mike's Pizzeria - 14. Philly Cheesesteak Pizza --my new favorite !!! - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Connecticut

See all

Best philly cheese steaks every time, the rolls are huge too, super nice workers and amazing food every time.

Came across this hidden gem during my recent move to Mansfield. Never would have thought I would have seen a pizza place in a gas station! This place has amazing pizza. Very big size for a large cut into big slices so it is defy more than enough to fill you up. Their pizza sauce has an amazing flavors they have amazing service all for a very reasonable price. It was shocking to find out how good the pizza was coming from a gas station. Would definitely recommend if you're ever driving by one and looking for a bite to eat. read more

Pizza Mike's Pizzeria - two slices of pizza on a plate - Pizza Near Me - Mansfield, Connecticut

One of the nicest local spots I've tried for pizza! Quick service and friendly staff made for a delightful experience. Highly recommend!

I like their pizza but they don't use gloves. Always see the employees wiping hands on their pants. But great people and very fast service

Must have been a new employee. I ordered a cold Mediterranean grinder which they only come cold according to their menu and she started to put it in the oven and I told her it's a cold one and she was a little rude about it and when she started to make the grinder she didn't have gloves on I asked her to put gloves on and then in the middle of making the grinder she took the gloves off to grab something from the fridge and she didn't put the gloves back on so I asked her again. And if she did it one more time I would have taken my money back. She left the feta off the grinder she left the artichokes off the grinder, she didn't know what she was doing. She should not be working there especially not knowing to put gloves on at the start of an order. Worst grinder I've ever had at this place. It's usually good but this girl was horrible. read more

Disgusting, how can the y even say it's pizza, no toppings to even speak of,maybe he forgot ,go to Domino's, way better

Dave who would not give his last name but is a co owner of this pizza chain was rude and straight out unprofessional!First time there and last!!! Food was just subpar.Went through google for information all of it wrong!!!Wrong number and prices are not correct!! Dave took order and hung up before giving price !Also google has a personal phone number for Mike Pizza in Chaplin! Daves brother Mike called me back to tell a story about not being able to fix google for the last 6 months! I will never purchase from this business!! read more

I bought Philly cheese steak pizza and I thought we were gonna eat it there but they have a tiny place to sit. Overall, it was one of the best in my life. Definitely recommended. read more

Love their cheese pizza. Prompt, cheerful delivery. Desserts are great too . Once they know you , you feel like family.

A great option if you're looking for pizza in the UCONN area. Definitely not a dine- in restaurant, it's attached to a gas station. But don't let that fool you... the pizza is very high quality. Mozzarella cheese was fresh and fantastic and the amount of chicken they give on the buffalo chicken pizza is outstanding. Only critique was that the pizza could've been cooked 1-2 minutes longer as the crust was on the flimsy and mushy side. The toppings and sauce absolutely made up for this and we will return soon! read more

Even if Pizza Mike's didn't deliver, I'd still give them a good review. But they DO deliver, and literally the only pizza joint that does in my town. Pizza Mike's has fun pizzas- the philly steak pizza is a favorite, as well as the BLT. Pizza Mike and his brother, Deep Dish Dave (twins no less) are enthusiastic, attentive, and truly customer oriented. Do not let the location put you off (they operate out of a gas station, which is understandably a turnoff for some)- their kitchen is immaculate (you have full view of it when coming to pick up your order if you're the sort who doesn't revel in delivery), and the food is always fresh and tasty. My only con is that the pizzas skew toward the expensive side, which, given a different location and atmosphere, you probably wouldn't think twice about, but it does prevent me from ordering them more frequently. read more

After reading all of the great reviews that this place has, I decided to give it a try. Honestly, I'm a bit disappointed. The first thing that I noticed was how bland the cheese was. All of the pizza places that I frequent have cheese that has a bit of taste to it, but this just tasted like bland mozzarella. The sauce and crust weren't anything to write home about, either. It's not BAD pizza, but it's nothing special, either. Not what I was expecting, from all of the five-star reviews and the price. All in all, I don't think I'll be coming back here, again. tldr; The pizza's bland. Go somewhere else. read more

My pizza was cold when I got it but I was hungry so didn't want to make a fuss, had to heat it up when I got home (I live 5 mins away) then the next morning my wife and I felt ill. Never going back. I called and the manager gave me trouble for asking for my money back so I told him I'll just leave a bad review because you want to call me a liar, he also called me immature and started yelling at me. Also left me a voice mail trying to question my food knowledge and credentials. Super professional right? Fuck that noise read more

Tried to place a pick up order over the phone and the customer service was awful. Who ever was taking the order was rushing me while interrupting when ever I spoke, and when I tried to ask a dietary question about one of the toppings he told me to go look at the menu online. I wish them the best of luck and hopefully this experience was a one time thing but WOW. read more

This place is amazing and so so weird. We have been referring to it as Monster Pizza because they have things like a BLT pizza with a mayonnaise sauce on the menu and I am fascinated. Have legit forwarded the menu to like ten people. I applaud your spirit of innovation, Pizza Mike!! One day I will be brave enough to get the pizza that has hamburger and ketchup/mustard as the sauce. In the meantime, my faves are the chicken parm pizza, and the pesto pizza with spinach and artichoke. YUM. Also, your workers are REALLY nice. Yes, this place is inside a gas station, but it is unpretentious and convenient and I love you. Good work! read more

Yeah this place literally has the best pizza around. The people are very kind and respectful and the delivery is always quick too.

don't let the fact that it's attached to a gas station dissuade you- this place is great. The vibe is like city pizza, and not to put down small mom and pops who make fantastic New England pizza throughout the area- but often there is nothing like a slice from downtown any street when you're craving one. These guys have gourmet and everything in between and it's fast and delicious. read more

The best pizza in Mansfield! As a person who grew up on New York Style pizza, I have come to appreciate the New Haven style pizza in this area...but nothing compares to a good thin crust with some cornmeal on the bottom and cheese out to the edge. The customer service is always great too! I often pick up with a baby and preschooler in tow and they will carry the pizza to my car for me. The manager - who I assume is Mike? -- is the nicest guy, and I've seen him around at community fundraisers doing his part. Good on ya, Pizza Mike's! read more

Their service is always fantastic....people are wicked nice! Their prices, very reasonable...their pizza is very good but the steak and cheese pizza with caramelized onions, super tender beef and mushrooms is fantastic! Keep it up Pizza Mikes!! :) read more

I don't like pizza but this is the only pizza I will willingly eat or want! Best pizza hands down and staff is always friendly

Tried pizza Mike's for the first time tonight, customer service was excellent! Very friendly staff. I was supposed to get 2 salads with my order but left with 1 ... After leaving I got all call from them acknowledging the missing salad, ok was happily surprised, most places would just have let it go ... Not to mention the pizza was delicious! I'll definitely be ordering from them again! Top notch service and amazing pizza read more

It is conveniently located down the road from UCONN in Storrs. The pizza is so fresh and the wait staff are all friendly people. They have pizza slices ready to go for a quick bite! They have so many different kinds of pizza with all different toppings..very creative! Caitlin and Danielle were the first 2 people I met during my first visit there. They smiled, were friendly, and welcoming. 2 other members of the staff, named Aly and Maxwell, were also extremely nice to me! The environment feels warm, comforting..almost like you are at home. Mike is the manager there and he is one of the happiest people I have ever met. I absolutely love it there and recommend it to everyone I know! read more

Don't underestimate the strange location of this pizza joint- it's definitely my favorite pizza to get around the UConn campus. Get the garlic butter crust, you won't regret it. read more

Great pizza we did take out but restaurant looked clean and enjoyable. Pizza had crisp crust and heaping toppings.

We were amazed by the reviews for Pizza Mike's being so amazing - all those 5 star reviews had us curious. We decided to give it a shot because we wanted to order in. We went with three smalls: the twice baked potato, chicken parm, and philly cheese stake pizzas (none of them with peppers). We wished that they had other things on the menu: calzones, cheese sticks, cheese bread, something. The delivery driver was calling after about 45 minutes. It came to just under $50 for the three. They were good. The twice baked potato was my favorite. Slices of potato, bacon, sour cream and chives. It wasn't overpowering in terms of flavor and the crust was yummy. My partners favorite was the philly cheese steak. It had good flavor but maybe lacking because of the missing peppers. It wasn't my favorite but he liked it. We were both thinking the chicken parm was both of our second favorites. The sauce had a bit of a kick to it which was a pleasant surprise. The chicken was great and I added a little ranch to take it over the top. At the end of the night, it was good pizza but not the best ever. We were left wondering if it's the best pizza ever, or the best pizza around here. read more

Awesome pizza! Can't wait to go back. All the specialty pies are amazing. Especially recommend the Cherico- Sriracha gives it a great kick. Chicken Parm is also one of my favorites. Not only is the pizza great, but Mike and Dave are the nicest guys. Anything you want, they'll make it happen. Service is top notch. Delivery is pretty quick, depending on how busy they are. Twice baked potato pie is also a must try! Give this place a try and you'll see why every other pizza place is competing for 2nd read more

Best. Pizza. Ever. We were new to the area and craving pizza. So, we hit Yelp and found the closest place. You'd think with this being a college town, the quality would be just okay all around. Well, Pizza Mike's was an unexpected surprise. For our first order, we had the lamb feta pizza. That thing was amazing. It's in a class all of its own. A word of caution, if you're looking for a straight up meat, cheese, and red sauce kind of fix, the lamb feta will leave you wanting. I can't tell you how good it was though, just don't substitute it for the stereotypical pizza affair. We ordered again the next week because the lamb feta was so good and we had to see how they did with the classic meat lovers. We were not disappointed. It was bar-none one of the best pizzas I've ever had. We talked to one of the owners, "Deep Dish" Dave, and really enjoyed hearing about their restaurant and how they came to be in the back of a tiny gas station convenience store. These are two guys, Dave and his brother, who are serious about their love of pizza. You will not make any mistake by ordering from them; I can't rate them highly enough. read more

PMP or Pizza made perfect as their slogan goes is one of my favorite pizzas around. I'm usually not a thin crust fan but they have such awesome and unique flavor combinations. I recommend the Philly Dave Steak for those who like meat and cheese or the Twice baked potato for those who like vegetarian options. The staff are always friendly and polite. Whether you order takeout or delivery they will deliver a wonderful meal fast and it will be tasty! They often have discounts available they will apply to your orders as well! read more

Best pizza around UConn/Mansfield. The crust and Sauce are delicious and don't taste like the cheap pizza right around campus. It is a little more expensive than other pizza places but to me it is well worth the extra few bucks for a better pizza. The brothers who run it are extremely friendly and are willing to work with you in any way they can. They do deliver but they aren't open really late, perhaps the only downside being in a college area. read more

Best pizza in Storrs-Mansfield! The tomato sauce is excellent. The lamb pizza is a very special treat. The service is always kind at Mike's, and the delivery is convenient. read more

A year later -we've had delivered several hot tasty large cheese pizza's to our home . Last week I ordered his specialty "Original Philly Cheese Steak" pizza-and my wife & I were Blown Out Of The Waterby their deliciously crafted pizza by "Big" Pizza Mike! Pizza Mikes Pizzeria has really kicked it up a few extra notches higher with better taste, high quality ingredients, customer service & pride! read more

Delivery was fast and the driver came right up to the door with 2ft of snow on the ground. Pizza was good for the area and hot! Will definitely order again. read more

Wow! So good! I was a little on edge about getting pizza located from inside a gas station but it is absolutely high quality new york style pizza. Crispy crust, very cheesey ! Got the jalapeño popper pizza and ate the whole thing! Definitely would recommend to anyone. The only thing bad I have to say is that I wish I tried this place sooner ! read more

OMG. I was expecting an ok pepperoni pizza, and what I got was one of the best pepperoni pizzas I've had in quite some time. I've lives on both coasts and several places in the Midwest, so I'm a bit of a pizza snob... Awesome buttery cheesy goodness, hit just right. read more

i have concerns over crust. too thin, too tough. omg, can the topping get chopped any smaller? but i love pizza mike. i patronize mike cuz he had passion. plus,,,, they...deliver to willington!!!!!!!!! read more

I was pleasantly surprised by this pizza place. Being a pizza snob who grew up on NY style pizza I really couldn't find anything in the area that I would consider good pizza! This changed my mind! I ordered the buffalo chicken and my boyfriend ordered the cheese pizza both were delicious. Guy who answered the phone was very polite and we were surprised to find out that they would deliver to us in Willington. While it is a bit pricey $15 for a small specialty pizza I will definitely be ordering from here again when I'm looking to splurge on some good pizza. read more