Quickly becoming my new favorite spot. The deals are insane. The food is out of this world. The service is friendly annd wicked fast. The #4 combo can feed 2 people for $10. Highly recommend. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

The restaurant has a small footprint and had several to go orders. We were the only ones eating inside. They were playing easy listening music which was perfect for us! The cashier was friendly, but young so he couldn't really explain the difference between the two types of pizzas very well. He could have also been newly hired. We went on line and decided to order the Margherita pizza and a side salad. The salad came out 1st and the pizza arrived shortly thereafter. We loved the taste of the pizza; however the sauce wasn't spread as evenly as we would have preferred which made the top part droopy and hard to pick up/fold hence the 4 stars. The salad was good but was just your typical salad, nothing fancy. We'd definitely return! The price is steep so prepared to pay more than you would at another pizza joint in town. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Margherita pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

As a couple of nap-trapped new parents, we've been doing a lot of DoorDashing. We decided to try Williamsburg Pizza last night. I have to say, I was shocked by the price of a pizza...$40 for a 16in pizza is highway robbery! We got the apple and bacon pizza, and I added ricotta. Overall, the flavor was very good. The toppings seemed high quality and my husband and I both really liked the crust. However, I don't think I would pay $40 again for this. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Apple Bacon - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Found this hidden gem on Uber Eats and it did not disappoint. We had this for our Valentine's day date night at home and it was such a fulfilling meal. The garlic knots were a little too crispy on the bottom, but delicious regardless with a delicious marinara sauce. We got the Paesano square pie and the balance of the toppings were perfect. No complaints here! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Garlic Knots (4) - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Sadly I did not enjoy my order from my first time trying Williamsburg Pizza. $50 to try the Paesno and Pasta. I added pepperoni and the pepperonis came completely burnt.. I mean literally front and back of them black on a lot of them. Gross. The pizza itself was very mediocre to me, same goes for the pasta. There just was nothing standing out that I would ever feel like I would want to order again. We have much better pizza options in Omaha to choose from. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Paesano add burnt pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Had Williamsburg tonight for first time. I found this pizza to be absolutely delicious! We ate it there! They only have 4 tables but luckily all 4 were open as most orders are to go there. The crust has a great chew to it. The ingredients are fresh! I know people has said on here it's pricey but you get what you pay for. I didn't find the pizzas to be much more than most pizza joints. The 2 salads were for sure over priced so probably skip those next time. Can't wait to have my left overs later. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Margherita with pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

I can't speak for the service or ambiance of this place as I haven't been the one to order or pickup. Based on the food alone I just don't like the pizza here. The crust was terrible, the sauce is terrible, the cheese and toppings were terrible. read more

Food was great. Service was super nice. People said they didn't like the lack of sauce but that's kinda a New York style and it was amazing! The crust was so good on both the round and square pizza. We had the cup and char grandma, soooo good, and the Bianca pizza also delicious. Had an order of the meatballs and they were swimming in the red sauce which was great to dip crust in. They do sell pizza by the slice for lunch. I'll post that menu. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Lunch menu - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Pizza is always delicious! Having parents born and raised in the Bronx this food is a treat from my childhood. I ordered the pizzas online for pickup at 12:30pm. My husband went to pick them up. He said he sat down and just a few mins after sitting down the pizzas were hot and ready to go. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - 14" 1/2 cheese & 1/2 pepperoni well done - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Williamsburg nailed it! A perfect pepperoni pizza. The crust is great, and actually has good flavor. The crust at the end is toothsome and has a bite to it, but inside is soft and pillowy. Loved the slight heat to the pepperoni and the freshness of the tomato sauce. Nice bake on the pie, perfect crust thickness , melty cheese...just everything executed perfectly. The garlic knots were a tad greasy, not in an appealing way. I didn't end up eating much of mine. But the pizza was so great, still giving 5 stars. The pizza was huge and only $30. No wonder Paul Rudd got involved! ;) Can't wait to try another pie. read more

See all

Williamsburg has really nice pizza. They have a lot of different options, and the pizza comes out relatively quickly. The building itself is kind of small. The staff are nice. It is a bit pricey though. read more

Excited to have more pizza options in southwest Omaha. I've been a few times to Williamsburg Pizza, and have been impressed with the quality from the slightly acidic sauce to the freshness of the basil. You can definitely taste the extra thought that goes into this quality pizza. read more

See all

Kind of an unfair review as it is my first time at this restaurant and it is a pizza place. So this review is based on one menu item. We purchased the Apple Bacon pizza. It looks very delicious and pretty, as far as pizzas go. I personally thought it was blande, somewhat one note. I may go back though to try other items. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Apple Bacon Square Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

Great food and experience. I had once in NY and this has exactly the same taste. The bread is so fluffy and crispy, and not hard at all. We've picked the Paesano and Margherita with some additional toppings and they're so delicious. Note that anchovies toppings are salted but they're crunchy. You will have to wait for your order anytime from 15-20mins (that's for our order) because they make it fresh upon order. There are very few seatings so taking out is def a choice, or you can go to their website and order via delivery! read more

See all

Some of the best pizza in Omaha! Somewhat limited menu but everything I have had is fantastic! Really busy if you order in the shop - but great delivery options. read more

After my son had been bragging about this place coming to town for some time, my wife and I decided to try it last weekend. The first thing I noticed was the hours - We were trying to get this on a Saturday, they didn't open till 3 which seems kind of late. I was able to call in around 2:15 and have the order ready at 3:10. For the pizza, we got the Paesano with garlic knots on the side. The pizza was around $25, and the garlic knots were $5. All in all, they were both around $33 total, which for me is a bit expensive for what we got. However, if you're into this type of restaurant and upscale pizza, it's probably pretty reasonable. The garlic knots are easy to review, they were buttery and delicious, crispy on top and soft on the inside. They were served with marinara sauce but it was pretty unexciting. As for the pizza, The crust was delicious, and this is one thing that I am pretty picky about. It was battery and flaky, although a little too thin to hold all the toppings. It was topped fairly nicely, although I did notice the vegetables were much more prevalent than the sausage, however, I ordered a pizza that was supposed to be mainly mushrooms and peppers and this one was. Overall, the pizza was delicious, but again it had the same sauce that lacked a bit of flavor. My wife agreed on the sauce as well. Overall, I would definitely recommend you visit this restaurant if you like New York style pizza or upscale pizza, but it is quite expensive in my opinion. The flavor, portion size, and the service were all excellent at Williamsburg Pizza. read more

See all

In a word "Disappointing". With Zio's closing their West O location thought we try Williamsburg Pizza. Ordered a large pie with Italian Sausage. The crust was very chewy and tough and the toppings including the cheese were microscopic. I'm from NYC and this pie in no way represents NYC pizza. read more

Had carry out. Great timing, piping hot and very tasty. The larger is quite sizable, think of how many you need to feed. Get the cannoli!

Finally got around to trying the pizza here. First the garlic knots didn't even make it home. They were delicious, very buttery (sitting in butter) but great. We got the Paesano pizza. Lots of toppings, though they felt a little overcooked. Pizza was good, not our favorite in Omaha but still good! Uniformly topped, cut into rectangles, crust was good - not too thick but not a thin crust either. No complaints, above average but definitely suggest the knots! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Outside, no pickup parking (only for JJ nextdoor) - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

See all

I like the pizza quite a bit. Main complaint is the margherita pizza has a LOT of mozzarella, and it seems more like low moisture than fresh. Still, great sauce and dough. I just preferred the pepperoni. The interior design is New York style, but with really comfy benches. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

So happy to have real NY style pizza here in Omaha. The sauce had a great flavor but felt very light. Unlike chain pizza that has such a strong and heavy taste. The crust was great! Will definitely be coming back! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

The few times that I've been here the service is always amazing! I call to order and pick up super nice and polite. My favorite crust has been the square it's crunchy and still chewy, that's my favorite kind of crust! The location place is small had a few sit down tables. Don't question it if you have definitely go and try it! read more

See all

This place confused me a bit. It advertises as "New York style" but has square pizzas with "party" cut. Regardless, we gave them a try. The resulting pies were delicious. Flavor was ideal, texture was a bit chewier than an NY pizza, but still good. It's layout indicates they expect more takeout than dine-in. Clean and well-staffed, this was effectively done. read more

Finally a real New York Pizza joint in Nebraska. The staff are awesome super friendly and proud of their pizza. Plenty of parking, basic decor with very limited seating and tables. They seemed very busy with orders but seemed to keep up quite well. Nice size slices they have round and square pies, lots of delicious toppings, the pizza dough is fantastic light crispy, perfect amount of crunch and chew. Cup and char pepperoni with fresh mozzarella. This I'm out new go to Pizza spot. Just need them to open one in Lincoln! read more

See all

Been wanting to try this place... The pizza is very overpriced. If you don't believe me, read all comments below - they'll tell you the same thing. Very fresh, very good. Two large pizzas shouldn't cost $65. The pizzas will take some time to make, so be patient. If I ever hit the lottery, I will definitely be back, but I can't see a scenario where I wouldn't pick 9 other places prior to this next time I want pizza. I know most of my review is about cost, but let me put this into perspective for you. My SUBTOTAL was $60. The tax was only 5.5% - Not 7.5%, and no 1.5% Omaha restaurant tax. If those taxes were applied, we are looking at $70 for two pizzas!! Another cost thing... this would've been a 5 star review if the prices were in-line with other pizza joints - $18-$23 each. Would I eat it again? Yes! Would I order it again? If I hit the lottery. read more

Good stuff! A little hard to find the first time, but worth the effort. The only bad part was trying to make it all the way home with this yummy stuff smelling so good. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Williamsburg Pizza, Omaha NE - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Best. Pizza. Ever. I'm seriously addicted! It has been my weekly go to for cheat night.

This was the best slice of cheese pizza I've had in a long time. Top three of all time. Crust was perfect: bottom was crispy, the top chewy, all the ratios of crust to sauce to cheese was . Also tried the Apple Bacon pizza. Honestly like it more than I thought I would! Crust was more like focaccia than pizza, but I'm here for it. If you're into very fancy flat bread, can't go wrong. All of the elements were done really well! Honorable Muntion to the garlic knots: Again, bread was done to perfection! Crispy, with that perfect chewy pull. Only note here is that the garlic butter could be been spread a bit more evenly throughout the roll? The outer bites had almost none but the inside was glorious. Would I have eaten 12? Absolutely. All in all, super simple, done super well. read more

See all

Ordered by phone since online ordering not yet enabled in Omaha. Not a problem, snap to order and pick up. Had the Sophia Loren. Loved the crust. Firm, flat, crisp. Liked the toppings, had some character. Expensive, and the prices were not readily apparent on the menu. Will try again, getting a different pizza, but not sure when. Marco's is catty corner and while Williamsburg was a smidgen better, especially the crust, it wasn't 2 1/2 times better. read more

So I'm originally from Brooklyn NY. This place claims to offer NY style pizza. I had never tried it and was stoked to try it. We ordered the Brooklyn XL last night from your new location at 156th & Maple. It was not hot, the sauce was too tomatoey, the crust was too gummy. It had barely any cheese. The other issue is when you pick up NY style pizza you usually have to fold it to eat it otherwise all the sauce and cheese will fall off. It was not good at all. There are so many places that have better pizza. For round Sam & Louie's to me is the best Franks downtown and Zio's. Square is definitely Back Lot. I've never tried Orsi's but heard it was amazing too. We were so disappointed with Williamsburg and won't be ordering again. read more

We did take out and the vegan pepperoni pizza is so good here! The crust is delicious too! I would definitely recommend it for everyone to try. I'm already a repeat customer! read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Vegan pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Tartufo (Mushroom ‍ ) pizza was fabulous. It's even amazing as leftovers heated in the air fryer. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Tartufo ‍ with white truffle oil - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Stopped in here yesterday for my birthday. Been wanting to try this place for a while. Ordered the cheese pizza and it was delicious. It came out fast, fresh and hot. Service was very friendly and the place was nice and clean. Will definitely recommend and be back read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Overpriced and bland. They forgot to add the remainder of ingredients so I was left with eating a crust that tasted like cardboard with tooo many pepperonis. (I did order the gluten free crust.) The others in my party also felt it was over priced and not that great. (They had regular crust.) We won't be back. read more

Williamsburg Pizza - Gluten free pizza that was supposed to be there Cup & Char Grandma. They forgot the basil and Parm. - Pizza Near Me - Omaha, Nebraska

Phenomenal Pizza. Meatballs are pretty good too! If you can't afford it, don't complain about it! read more

So so tasty and the service was great! I really liked the vibe inside of the restaurant as well, very clean and welcoming.

Without debating what style of pizza is the best (Brooklyn, New York, Chicago, thin, deep dish, etc), I can confidently say the pizza is outstanding. I've not yet had any of the circular pies, but we ordered two different square pizzas, and they were great. For me, crust wasn't too thick or too thin. Excellent crunchiness and chewiness. Flavor combinations on the pizza were more interesting than "standard" are definitely worth a try. The service was exceptional. Cashiers went out of their way to make sure that our wait for pizza was comfortable. The kitchen help were more than friendly and helpful and making sure that food was delivered while it was nice and hot. As far as ambience goes, the restaurant is geared more for carry out than for dine in. I think there were only four tables indoors to sit, and there were a couple places outdoors to sit. I wasn't quite prepared for that experience, but our wait was comfortable. We showed up on a Friday night and had to wait 40 minutes for a pizza, which really isn't too bad all things considered . read more

We tried Williamsburg Pizza for the first time last night and loved it. As a vegan, I love that they have several different vegan and vegetarian options, including vegan cheese and pepperoni. The crust was delicious as well. My daughter lives in New York. (where Williamsburg Pizza originates) and she said it is their favorite pizza there as well, which is saying a lot! read more

Ordered multiple pizzas for a party, it was our 1st time but heard great things, those comments were very helpful as this pizza was a huge hit with all. Some very unique flavors like apple /bacon but the OG like pepperoni was delicious! You just picked up many new customers! To all, please ignore the 1 star review, I have no ties with this place but boy does that review sound fake or someone looking for something read more

Fantastic pizza that you can't get anyplace else in the Omaha area. Basically a take out place even though it's got a few tables. Always order ahead. I've been there when they have a 2 hour wait for a pizza. But if you call ahead you can schedule when you want to pickup your order and they've always been on time that way. read more