I've driven past this place a bunch of times. There's always people dining outside, particularly…read morewomen of various ages. They always look as though they're having fun. This time as I drove by, I had a friend and my dog riding along with me. Would they let us have dinner outside with my dog? I pulled up and walked into the restaurant to ask. Sure. We could sit at the high picnic tables near the front lawn. It was a nice, relaxing setting. Our server was Juliet, a very nice and helpful young woman. I ordered a Rustic Mule which was really a Moscow Mule and a Turkey Reuben with garlic mashed potatoes. My friend ordered a half pound burger with Dirty Fries. The food was delicious. We had a great time. I couldn't finish my meal. I ate half and took the rest home. Too bad. I was hoping to make it to dessert. The restaurant is famous for some sort of ice cream "flavor bomb," which I'll have to try next time. The dog, meanwhile, got a nibble of turkey from my sandwich and then sat down beside me. Juliet said the dog was so quiet she almost forgot the dog was there.

We stopped here for the first time today, pulling in the restaurant has a modern rustic feel and…read moreinside again rustic with just the right touch of whimsy. The menu is your usual bar food with some interesting touches. We had the seafood chowder, delicious and full of seafood, meatloaf and lobster Mac and cheese. There was plenty of lobster claw meat on the Mac and cheese and very saucey. My husband enjoyed the meatloaf, homemade mashed potatoes. Two downsides, there was an up charge for gravy on the meatloaf???? Questionable. I also ordered crème brûlée for dessert, when it came out I immediately knew there was an issue, it wiggled. It was literally just custard sauce with hard sugar on top. The waitress came to check on us, and this is why I bring it up. She let us know it was the best they could find as far as solidifying and when they served some yesterday people were ok with it ?????? Really, so you are aware it was not as it should be but you chose to serve it anyway, a hard no. She was very polite about and obviously it was removed from our bill however it does make you stop and think what else is going on in the kitchen that they are trying to pass off on the customer.

i called and got Two order of chicken wings both 12 piece one hot honey & bbq and the other C&J…read moresauce both were crunchy and very saucy the last one the phone was excellent and even sold me on a peanut butter pie which was delicious.

Waitress was super awesome! Food not so much! French onion soup needed more flavor and some Swiss…read morecheese! Wings were good! Chicken tenders are frozen and over cooked.

We visited them over the summer. We had pizza to go that took over an hour to be ready. The pizza…read morewas very good. The salad was also very good. Returned in September only to have the worst service ever. We sat there waiting for a drink for about 20 minutes while the staff were doing shots. We decided to have a drink to see if the service would get better. However, it did not. We waited 15 minutes after asking for our bill. Ordered some takeout on November 28, We ordered chicken wings, a tossed salad and buffalo french fries. The wings were definitely a triple fried, there wasn't any meat on the bones because it was fried off. The salad was welted and may as well have been just a little lettuce with two cucumbers, and that was it. The cucumbers were wilted. The french fries were soggy as to be expected for takeout, but there was nothing fresh about anything that we ordered. Will not be ordering again. We received a phone call 20 minutes after our order asking when we were going to pick it up because apparently they were closing early due to no business. Just not the best experience or what we were hoping for to get this place a third chance. Three times and that's it!

I really wanted to like this place, since I remember coming here as a kid. Our waitress wasn't…read moregreat. We sat for 5 minutes before being greeted, she came and got our drink order and came back 10 minutes later with only half of our drinks. The dining room is dirty, the carpets stained and the tables sticky. The food was just ok. The owner thanked us for coming and was very friendly. It's great to see this old place open and I wish they would clean it up a bit and fix the mediocre renovations that were done.

Both food and service were excellent! The vibe is very quaint and cozy, too! Highly recommend.read more

I gotta say I was pretty disappointed in the food. Bacon was so cooked it barely had any flavor,…read morehashbrowns had zero seasoning in them and hadn't been thoroughly cooked. Eggs were fine as was the toast. I felt I could have made it ten times better so next time I will lol. A very upstate vibe lol. Service staff was friendly and attentive even though they were busy.

Excellent food,everything is fresh to order. The owners are…read morereally nice and make you feel at home.

Nothing fresh about it ... ate there once ! Place was cold and looked like it needed to be closed…read morefor cleaning ... I ate my food but won't ever go there again .

Sushi chef does a nice job here. Restaurant is pleasant, I think the kids section is better than…read morethe adult only section, it has a nice big window. The salad bar is pretty stacked, the desserts are good, Not great but there is ice cream

The water is delicious. The service is great and so much to eat and the braces are awesome. I love…read morethis buffet.

The food was ok. My chicken sandwich was great, but the rest of my table's orders were just ok. My…read moredad ended up being sick all night after his salad, but that could be the salad's fault - not the restaurant. Our server was a new kid and he was as nice as could be, but the sauces we asked for were either late (like after I finished) or never came. This family owned restaurant was a great find after our flight up.

Honestly not the worst but not the best. The server was on top of everything, place kinda smelled…read morelike old urine. Long wait time for food and check. The bun to meat ratio on the burger is kinda ridiculous and kinda just sat like a brick. $51 dollars for tasteless food, got charged almost 2 dollars for onion and 4 for cheese on a cheese burger. Will not be back.

Delivery is always a little slow but the food is good. We got a good portion size for the dinner…read moreand the pizzas (although cold by the time we got them) were tasty.

We recently moved to the other side of Amsterdam and we couldn't be happier at our new options for…read morepizza! First- I appreciate that they deliver. Our only option in our pervious home was always a last resort- but as we've had Goodfellas a couple times now, we feel much more excited about ordering delivery than we used to! They're friendly when you call, and never make you feel bad for using a card. The delivery guys are also friendly. Most importantly- the pizza! We have tried three versions: Chicken Frescura (which has a white sauce), chicken alfresco (with Alfredo sauce) and a sausage pizza with the regular red sauce. Each pizza held their own with flavor. Very distinct, but equally delicious. The crust on all 3 was also great- soft and fluffy but just a little crusty. Absolutely delicious! I'm also appreciative of any place that keeps the pizza bubbles in tact! I also go Their wings are super crispy, and the mild has just the right amount of kick. The garlic park wings were a little less "parmy" than we like, but ultimately it still tasted good. We look forward to ordering from here for a looooong time!!

Best pizza in the county!…read more Crust= hand tossed, chewy and cooked to perfection. Sauce= Slightly bitter but just enough, plenty of tomato taste here. Cheese= they don't cheat you on cheese. Good quality mozzarella and plenty of it. Get a square cut large pizza here, it is a great buy.

Wings were phenomenal. Ordered the 10 piece - hot- and boy were they. Perfect & crispy…read more Ordered a large pizza. Pretty good as well. The guy that took our order when we called in was very friendly and helpful/ even gave us our total when we placed the order. Love that.

We came back on a Saturday night for dinner and it didn't disappoint. It is hard to take our…read moretoddler out to dinner at a "nice Italian restaurant", so as a three-way compromise we came here. There were trains outside the window and a kid's menu for him; there were sit down tables and a limited dinner Italian menu for the wife; and there were trains, college football on all the TVs, and the menu for me. Score! I had their veal parm. (with light sauce) and it was absolutely fantastic. Cooked perfectly, flavorful, not tough at all, and the sauce in its limited capacity was very nice. My wife had some pasta/eggplant dish and she seemed to enjoy it though she had the regular amount of sauce and it pooled with a lot of water on the bottom of the plate. Not as nice. Our son's "chicken fingers and fries" turned out to be two separate plates: one with a huge amount of fries, and one with breaded chicken cutlets cut into strips. Apparently, that is how they make "chicken fingers" now. He wasn't really into that, but man let me tell you they were great! I know only kids can order this but PLEASE tell me that adults can get this too. They were so much better than frozen, breaded chicken fingers. I'm calling my shot here: the next time I am here I am going to order Buffalo wing sauce on those chopped up chicken cutlet strips and create a NEW variation of boneless chicken wings!

Tried this place last month after passing it for years on my way to Johnstown. There were four of…read moreus for an early dinner on a Saturday. The staff was definitely friendly, and very attentive. They were raving about their seafood bisque and brought a sample to share. Dipping their in house bread was great, and the soup itself was decent. I got adventurous and tried their "Italian Sushi". Not bad, an interesting idea. Jughead ordered a burger as usual, another ordered the ravioli, chicken parm and for me the drunken chicken. Everything was decent, but lacked a lot of seasoning, especially salt. I'd try it again but am skeptical.