Really good Italian restaurant! I dined here on a weekend afternoon and sat at the bar. It's a nice, modern looking restaurant with a great menu. I started with the Saranac Blueberry Blonde, which is a refreshing beer that smells exactly like blueberry muffins - it's so good! The bartender also brought out a delicious bread basket to start and the olive oil it came with was amazing - it had chunks of roasted garlic in it. For my entree, I ordered the Penne a la Vodka with shrimp, which came with a house salad. It was fantastic! It had a good amount of shrimp in it too. Overall, the food was great and the service was a little slow but thankfully the food was worth the wait. I was too stuffed to try any dessert but I hope to if I'm in the area again! read more

See all

Our first time here. Will be back. Bread was served hot. Whole party agreed it was to die for. Great portions. Meatball and chicken parmesan so tender. I forgot to get our servers name. She was so good. Also recognized that w granddaughter was special needs and made her the first priority. Thanks for an amazing time read more

Food is good but service was awful. The waitress we had was one of the worst. Impatient, curt, and not responsive to our requests. I have no idea why she worked there. Eggplant was pretty good and I would recommend it. read more

Nicolino’s Restaurant - Eggplant with pene - New American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

service was excellent! Food was cold and disgusting. We have been here multiple times and it keeps deteriorating, sad really.

First time eating at Nicholino's ...restaurant was beautifully decorated, waitress was amazing but for a nice fancy restaurant they should be able to have tables that don't move constantly due to being uneven! The table moved to the point where it was annoying. Either the table needs to be replaced or repaired. Waitress was aware. Nothing was offered to "remedy" the issue. One person ordered the steak (medium) and it wasn't medium. It was well done. My shrimp scampi was more like "shrimp soup". Way too much liquid! My alcoholic drink had barely if any, alcohol in it. Disappointed in the whole experience. read more

We went there last night for dinner. The host told us he would try to fit us in since we did not have a reservation. It took 30 minutes to get a drink and the waitress said the bartender was backed up. We got mushrooms stuffed with crabmeat as an appetizer and they were overcooked and cold. They came before the drinks. My partner got filet mignon and roasted potatoes and it was cold. My tortellini and Shrimp was in a soupy sauce. They had a huge party come in after us and apparently they were overwhelmed. read more

My fiancé and I stopped in as a nice place for our anniversary meal, and with decent gluten-free options. Forgot the photo, but we ordered pasta as well as the eggplant Parm entrée. The gluten-free pasta was nothing super special and eggplant lacked some distinctive seasoning. The app were good and a special shout out to both the gluten-free and gluten filled breads to table. Staff was very friendly, but the inside definitely had some drawbacks with dust and cobwebs around different areas . It was too early for Halloween. Overall, this was an average meal and though not a deterrent does not make it a must stop next year. read more

The atmosphere was beautiful, the food was delicious and our server Tina was phenomenal, so funny and friendly, overall a great place to eat

I genuinely don't know how people are saying this place is delicious. It must be that up here we have some sort of misconception of how good food is because we allow people to serve us awful food and get away with it. This place is TERRIBLE, the pasta is always overcooked and flavorless. They poured a mountain of fake Parmesan on top of a 36 dollar seafood pasta. The service is BAD, waiting up to 20 minutes for a check, and hours for the food to be delivered. I've given this place multiple opportunities. But it is just not good. read more

I went to Nicolinos on Saturday night with friends. The atmosphere of the restaurant was fantastic. We sat at the bar while we waited for our party to arrive. The bartender was great and attentive. The hostess who sat us was very accommodating as she got our table ready. The waitress was very helpful when I shared my food allergies. The food was delicious and tasted fresh and made to order. This is definitely a spot to check out. read more

Nicolino’s Restaurant - Fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp - New American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

I don't give reviews very often but lunch today was so delicious I had to comment. My sister and I each had a cheese burger built to our requests. It was done perfectly, juicy and very tasty. No added cost for my caramelized onions and roasted red peppers. No added cost for a second helping of ranch dressing for my side salad. Pricing was better than reasonable for the large burger, side salad or soup or fries, and extras on the burger. Service was fast and pleasant. We will be back. read more

Some friends and I went here for Italian food and it was a huge mistake. By far the Italian pasta dishes were the worst we have ever tasted. The penne pasta was cold and hard. My friend ordered linguine and words can not describe how bad it was. Don't waste your time and money ordering pasta dishes. The next night we were at Delmonico's in Colonie and the linguine was superb as was the shrimp and clams. read more

I love that they offer Gluten free entrees & the spaghetti sauce was tasty yet they were skimpy putting any on the penne! BUT, the chicken Parmesan was tough, extremely over cooked & lacked any flavor @ all! Staff was no where to be found when I entered & service was slow. read more

Nicolino’s Restaurant - Chicken Parmesan with gluten free Penne! - New American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

Nicolino's hosts Parm Night on Wednesdays. It is a terrific value that includes a hot, crispy loaf of bread with garlic olive oil, fresh garden salad or homemade soup, and your choice of chicken, eggplant, zucchini, and others for only 14.95. You can sit at a table in their newly renovated banquet room, or you can get a cozy seat at the bar. Either way, you will leave satisfied! read more

I have come here a handful of times, and love the pasta dishes. I did order Tuna, the most recent time I was there and it was so overcooked. It was busy so I will give benefit of the doubt. I will keep coming back for the fresh bread, alone. read more

Restaurant has been open a long time but we only have gone there recently. We have had 2 delightful dinners there. The food is well prepared and reasonably priced read more

Good food, great service, and the atmosphere so nice and welcoming our bar tender was tops , we will be back again!!!!

The best meal I've had in 10 years and I worked in a restaurant in the back of the house when I was young. In Montana, where we lived, people would drive 200 miles for the meal and two hungry people could easily share as the photos show a side salad and half the lunchtime serving of the best eggplant parmigiana I have ever had. read more

Nicolino’s Restaurant - Side salad - New American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

Delicious food and family style meals are very reasonable. Really enjoyed the chicken parm. Just loved the bread too!

First visit after them reopening last week. Dinner took over an hour to get. The appetizers came fast, but then we found ourselves sitting for an hour waiting for the food. When the food came, we were very disappointed. Three of us had the eggplant dinner. The eggplant was one slice very thin and burnt on all three dinners, instead of being served with penne, it was served with linguine, not what was on the menu one of us had the lasagna which was also burnt. Myself, and one other person had the penny à la vodka. They poured a scoop of house sauce over the middle king. I have never seen that before on penny à la vodka all of the dinners were on edible and not what we expected. The people we were with I've gone there for over 30 years and we're very disappointed would not recommend this place anymore. The server was very good and not her fault that the food was terrible. read more

Great service from Jocelyn. Food was great and came out quick. Wonderful experience.

The food was delicious, the service was friendly and fast. I had no problem but wish there were more Gluten free options for others in my party. Overall a great experience. read more

I chose Nicolino's for my wife's 50th birthday party and boy am I glad I did. Some of my friends felt previously that the level of service at the restaurant was not very good. There were also a few bumps in the road communication wise, but they were all worked out, solely due to the efforts of Liv Casella. She completely turned things around and she did a phenomenal job in helping me plan this party. I can't state enough how I impressed I was with her. We decided on menus quickly and party size and all other party specifics. Day of event was just incredible. We had some decorations and they were very accommodating and let me hang up everything I had. The food was incredible, my guests loved the selections, and were even offered take home containers once everyone had eaten. I previously had not been impressed with the bartender that was on, but he did an excellent job day of party, he made me a fan when I wasn't one previously. The overall service I experienced at the party was top notch. The ladies communicated with me often and were very sweet to the guest of honor(my wife) and all of the party goers. I booked the party at Nicolino's hoping for the best. I leave the party with great memories and can confidently state that I would highly recommend Nicolino's for small or medium parties. You will be really glad you did. read more

From the food, staff and atmosphere you will not be disappointed! Cozy, clean and the menu does not disappoint

Newly renovated bar. Nice atmosphere for a drink. Nice size for larger luncheon groups. Wonderful pastas, soups and bread. We always enjoy a dirty martini and vodka penne pasta when visit. read more

Tons of food and great NY Italian favorites. Service and ambiance is excellent. Great place for a family meal or an upscale date.

Absolutely outstanding Italian food! They have many gluten-free options and the service was outstanding. I had the eggplant Parmigiana (Gluten-Free) and it was wonderful. The portions are huge with reasonable prices. read more

I was here recently for a party. The service from the waitress and bar staff was very good. The salad with our dinner was exceptional. My dinner however was a big disappointment. I ordered the eggplant rollatini. They forgot about my dinner and by the time I was served everyone at my table was done eating. That did not bother me but my dinner was cold. The eggplant was not cooked, seemed to be a slice of eggplant served over ricotta cheese and it was raw. The pasta and sauce were cold as well. It was too late to send it back as everyone else was finished. I heard later that I was not the only one who had this issue with this entree. Not sure if their regular service has the same issue. read more

Terrible ! Waited to be seated for 5 plus minutes until we decided to leave ! Drove by some pretty appealing eateries because my my mind and belly was set on Nicolinos big mistake ! So disappointed as should the man in charge be as well to have lost business and earned a poor Yelp review read more

Disappointing...I've been here a bunch of times but tonight was disappointing. The Surf and turf special tonight was 16oz NY strip with 2 fries shrimp and 2 fried scallops. Lucky if the steak was 10oz (thin and over cooked). Ordered medium and came out nearly well done. The seafood items were large but was over breaded and over fried. Ordered wine with dinner and it showed up 1/2 way through the meal. read more

The best Italian and American food in the area. Great service, and they are willing to work with you to prepare a dish a special way for you if they can. That is old-fashioned Italian restaurant service! read more

Hearty portions and great waitress (ask for Jocelyn!). Steamers and calamari were excellent and plentiful. Veal dishes were all delicious. We all left with enough for another meal. Definitely coming back! read more

Do not recommend. It was not a busy night and once we we're seated, not a single waitstaff came to our table for at least 20 minutes. When someone finally came over we didn't get out drinks for another 20 minutes. Not only was the service slow but no one checked on us throughout the service. The food took a very long time to arrive. I ended up going and finding the takeout containers myself and packed up my leftovers. Overall we were in the restaurant for over two hours.I would never go back and would not recommend. read more

I was pleasantly surprised with this restaurant. I have passed it many times and finally decided to stop in. My mom ordered the antipasto, the presentation was beautiful and she very much enjoyed it. I ordered the greens and beans. It was great! Taste was spot on. I will definitely be back to try some of their other dishes. read more

Nicolino’s Restaurant - Antipasto...delish! Loved the fried ravioli Great addition! - New American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

See all

Amazing food! The bar and dining area are up to date and modern. Attended a brunch recently and the food was fresh and delicious. It wasn't some crusty old junk in a chafing dish. The staff are welcoming and attentive. If you visited in the past and were maybe not all that happy, I suggest trying again. I bet you won't be disappointed. I look forward to going back! read more

I would like to redo my previous review. The food here recently has always been very good. Service is great and so is the atmosphere. This place has become our go to place in amsterdam. I had the salmon special and it was very good. Lots of flavor. The bread is very good and they give you a very nice glass of wine. If you haven't been here in a while please give it another chance. You won't be disappointed. read more

See all

Not very fancy on the outside but really nice on the inside. The food was very good. We had Bruschetta it was well done. The chicken wings were great and my wife got a large glass of wine for reasonable price. Dessert were good and soups were very good. Plenty of parking and the staff was very nice. read more

The bread was hot out of the oven with a nice garlic and oil dish for dipping, the waitress was not over bearing but appeared before I had a chance to look around for my second beer. The salad was awesome a bit small but so flavorful. Excellent lasagna was as good as any I have had and that's a lot of lasagna I was full by the last 2 or 3 bites I should of never taken but it was too good to pass . The wife had a tiramisu it looked good . I do not go to Amsterdam much but I look forward to going here again. And as good as the Italian dressing was. Next time I'll take the waitress advice , and try the house balsamic as you advised read more

Nicolino’s Restaurant - New American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York

Wow! They were out of the special I wanted but it was close to closing time, just missed the last serving. Meal was perfect, salad very cold and crisp and tasty, wine suggestion was spot on. Service was perfect. Ask for Ashlee!!! Over all I am traveling a long way and just happened to stop nearby for the night but I will go out of my way to come back again. I passed several nice looking restaurants that were not rated as high and very glad I used Yelp! To find the best place. read more

What a find. I am very picky with my sauce and Italian restaurants and wow. This place does not disappoint. Fresh fresh ingredients. Like Nanny made it!! Fresh bread. If you are passing on the NYS thruway. Stop In Amsterdam take the ten minutes to have a meal. I'm coming back I had eggplant Parmesan. Just like I make it! read more

Nicolino’s Restaurant - New American Near Me - Amsterdam, New York