Simply perfect. We…read moretried the London Timmy with extra sausage, and it was the best surprise of the night. The fenugreek added an incredible depth of flavor, tying everything together beautifully, and the sausage was absolutely delicious. Our second pizza was The Puff Formerly Known As, which was equally impressive. The hint of lemon zest made every flavor pop without overpowering the pizza. The dough deserves a special mention: light, beautifully fermented, and made with Caputo flour, resulting in the perfect texture and bite. I have to admit--I never expected to find one of the top three pizzerias of my life in Eureka, but I did. A huge thank you to Bob for welcoming us into your beautiful and authentic restaurant.

The quality of the service matches the food. Hands down the best experience you can have at a local…read morewood-fired joint. My wife is celiac and they have GREAT options and are knowledgeable about the ingredients. She has never been sick from it. Highly reccomend for all walks!

Great food! Always friendly, highly recommend for a simple meal out…read more The Vinegar & Oil Salad is AMAZING!!! Gotta try it. It's homemade there.

Great hole in the wall type place. We got an appetizer of the Mozzarella Sticks and wow they were…read moreso good, super stringy cheese I almost choked. Got a salad to start and I was kind of disappointed, lettuce wasn't super fresh and it was very watery. For the main dish I got the baked tortellini, very good although I thought there could have been a little bit more sauce. Service was top notch! Will come back as our family loves coming here.

Review Visit: June 24th, 2015…read more They say, "pizza makes the world go around". Geo's does a good job helping it spin... 8 slices at a time. It is no lie; I am a huge pizza lover. Circular. Cut into slices. Endless arrangement of toppings. I will try almost any and all pizzas. So, it's only natural that I try the small pizzerias throughout the world. Geo's Pizza was widely regarded as great pizza among some of my coworkers and friends. After some very little arm twisting, I finally made my way there. I brought along my friend who had it before and wanted to come with. We walk in and snag a seat. It wasn't too busy, so we got to pick wherever we wanted to sit. We settled down on a table and cracked open the menus. Geo's is famous for their cheesy dough nuggets. Without much more arm twisting, my friend convinced me that we should order some. After looking over the menu, we settled on the cheesy dough nuggets and a barbeque chicken pizza. The service was prompt and never overbearing or missing. The waiter checked in on us here and there, without being too overbearing or too absent. The food took a normal time to come out. About 15 minutes or so. As soon as the pizza and nuggets hit the table, we pounced on it without hesitation. The nuggets were little nuggets of deliciousness. The barbeque chicken pizza was a delight. It was a bit weak on flavor compared to other ones that I have had, but I am not a pizza snob and enjoy almost all pizza equally. Did Geo's live up to the hype? Yes, for the most part. Despite the pizza lacking a bit in flavor, it was still delicious and a good lunch with a friend. Sometimes the company is just as good, if not better than the meal.

Went and had Geo's pizza Tuesday night, we were greeted by the waitress promptly with menus after…read morewe sat down there was another table in the back of the restaurant. She was very attentive to both our table and the other from my notice. Checking on us, having a laugh and refilling drinks. The pizza was absolutely delicious, we ordered at classic combo on pan crust and the famous nuggets with cheese. My only complaint however was the dipping sauce the waitress brought us had a number on it which assumed it was a date but it dated 17 it was the 25th. The sauce has changed a lot over the last couple months but it was better. The dining room tables do seem to always have a hue on them or crumbs and the floors didn't look like it had been vacuumed, swept or mopped on the hardwoods. Last month when we went in on a Thursday, same waitress as this past Tuesday but the other employees were talking loudly in the kitchen, I could specifically hear one girl complaining about how she had better get a better tip than 2$ on a delivery, using a few choice words. I assumed it was just a slow night, the phone was ringing like crazy at one point no one was in the kitchen from what I could see but two male employees walked out of the doorway by the soda machine. One still had his apron on which struck me as unsanitary. Despite some of the cleanliness and service-area concerns, the food is still what keeps bringing us back. The Classic Combo and nuggets were delicious, and our experience this time around was much better than some of our previous visits. Hopefully the little things like table and floor cleanliness and keeping conversations in the kitchen professional can be addressed, because this place still has a lot of potential. We'll definitely be back to indulge in our Classic Combo again!

This place is such a local gem! Is it authentic Italian food...no...but is it really good…read moreItalian-ish food? YES! This is the cinnamon butter bread. It's one of the best things I've ever had...you can't stop once you start. We also ordered (as we always do) the family special with spaghetti, gondola type sandwich, garlic bread and soda ..you can't beat it for price and the food you get! Staff always nice, store clean and food ready fast. Lasagna is also delicious!

We ordered the Family Feast with spaghetti and added a salad. The spaghetti had ample noodles and…read moremeat sauce. The garlic bread was well seasoned and the extra bread was fresh. Our only complaint was the salad, for $6.99 we got a small plastic bowl with a handful of lettuce, nothing else was added. We were very disappointed.

I only get takeout here usually but it's always great. One of my favorite pizza places in the…read morearea. They are very generous with toppings and the quality is very consistent. A question though...why can't they just use pizza BOXES?? The wrapping is so complicated and for a big pizza it's very unwieldy.

It was ok- it was nice to sit down and eat. Our server was…read morevery kind and attentive. The food was ok- we had garden salads- I liked their dressing. The pizza was meh- ordered sausage and we didn't get much.

First time going here and it was great! I'm on a mission to try every gluten free pizza crust in…read morethe area; this one was great! Great flavor and a nice crisp outer edge. My husband had the regular crust and also enjoyed it. Thanks so much!

Service was great, and there was live music on Friday when we went. The pizza was delicious but…read moredid take a bit to get out to the table. They must only be able to to do a few pizzas at a time in the oven because we ordered three and only two came out at first and then one several minutes later. Was nice to try something different in the area and were pleasantly surprised by this little gem.

Hallie was an awesome waitstaff!…read more The sweet potato fries were the best I have had in my entire life! I had the brickhouse burger and my buddy got the tenderloin- both delicious. Can't wait to return....

I may be biased because this is not the type of food that I normally would gravitate towards, but…read moreour party wanted to go here. I ordered the grilled chicken sandwich, and it was decent. The burnt ends were the highlight of the meal. The service was friendly, but I personally wouldn't rush back.

Flat out best pizza in Peoria. I've had their sandwiches and salads and have been excellent…read more The portions are not for the faint of heart. Your biceps and belly will grow after a couple of pieces. Wish they were open on Sunday for football as I'd order more often. Try the meat pizza.

I love this place. Always had friendly personal service, usually the only people in there and the…read moregyro pizza is incredible. Check them out!

The Sunnyland location Bernardis has always been my parents favorite. I dont see a difference,…read moreBernardis locations are all predictably good. Service was good tonight. I had the grilled salmon, my son the lasagna, and my parents had the pot roast special. It was all good, I tried a bite of Sullys Lasagne, Bernardis sauce is really delicious. If you've never tried their fried chicken it is literally some of the best on the planet. Ive had a few of their newer menu items recently- they are trying to branch out and be a little more upscale. Bernardis consistently delivers delicious food.

Julie and I visited Bernardi's in Washington on Thursday, August 6, 2026, to meet up with a group…read moreof friends. There were eight of us at the table. When we arrived, the other six people in our group were already there, having drinks and sharing bread from the basket provided at the table. We ordered our meals, and when our food arrived, I asked for some additional bread to go with my meal. I was told, rather abruptly, that there was only one basket of bread per table. What I found particularly frustrating was that there were other tables with only two people sitting at them, and they had a full basket of bread. Meanwhile, our table of eight was expected to share one basket. I even offered to pay for additional bread, but I was simply told no, and I never received any additional bread. The policy itself was disappointing, but what really bothered me was the way the situation was handled. The waitress was extremely abrasive and difficult to understand, and there was no attempt to explain the policy or offer any alternative. A simple explanation such as, "I'm sorry, we have a new policy, but you can purchase additional bread if you'd like," would have been completely different. We have traditionally enjoyed Bernardi's and have gone there about once a week, either dining in or getting carryout. Unfortunately, after this experience, I won't be returning. Restaurants have plenty of competition, and when you're spending your hard-earned money somewhere, you should be treated with courtesy and respect. I understand that restaurants can change their policies, even policies I may not agree with. What I don't understand or accept is being treated rudely when simply asking for something as basic as a piece of bread with my meal. It wasn't the bread that ultimately made me decide not to return. It was the way I was treated.