Let me preface this with the fact that I wanted to like this place because I am getting too old to do my own repairs and I don't desire to do a clutch or subframe bushing job in my garage. So, at the recommendation of an Alex faithful I gave him a call. I was reassured multiple times that everything would go as planned so I agreed to drop the car off for a job that was well over $1k in labor alone. When I called to check on the car's progress I discovered that he had done a differential fluid change after I told him that I no longer needed it done (before even taking the car in). I had just done it myself, a month prior. Turns out that he was using an old email as his scope of work, despite my call to confirm the scope the day before I dropped the car off. When I got there to pay, he was going to charge me for it. We worked that out so we are OK there, but it shouldn't have even been on the bill.
Fast forward to a day later when I noticed a clunking coming from underneath the car. The noise sounded familiar because I had just resolved that issue by replacing the exhaust hanger bushings on the car right before it went to Alex for the clutch and subframe bushings. When I finally got time to get under the car and see if the exhaust just needed adjustment, I noticed a rather startling thing. The brand new RED bushings that I had just installed were gone and, in their place, were used/cracked/worn BLACK bushings (pic). I was livid. After I calmed down and ran all possible scenarios as to why that would have happened I emailed Alex and asked him about it (in a very respectful manner). I included pictures and let him know that I had just installed the red bushings before the service to cure the exhaust clunking on the support brace, due to old bushings collapsing on themselves. He called me a few days later and nicely told me that there is no reason for him to remove them and I was SOL... Really? From our conversation, the most he was willing to do was adjust the current bushings to see if that fixed the clunking. Not even willing to entertain the idea that the bushings may have been misplaced, broken or to look around the shop or ask his shop assistant about them.
So, let me get this straight; I just paid you a huge sum of money (that was not subjected to credit card fees either, so even more net $$) and you won't even investigate the possibility of the customer being right? I have receipts and records for them being purchased and installed, as well as the old parts sitting on my desk; the burden of proof is not on me at this point. I have decided to replace these, again, on my own dollar and move on from this. Sadly for you, Alex, the BMWCCA members that regularly approach me for recommendations will be sent elsewhere and you won't be doing my thermostat job, nor anything else for me. I have also redacted my recommendations already made to other individuals before this situation developed.
To make matters worse, I developed a nasty vibration/buzzing shortly after the conversation, so back under the car I went to discover that both bolts within the exhaust brace, where it connects to the transmission housing, were halfway backed out (pic). I also found that the cabin air filter housing had been handled without care and broken (pic) as well as the cabin air filter reinstalled upside down (pic; there are clearly labeled arrows on the filter) during the clutch bleeding. I also re-bled the clutch as there was air in the system that caused pedal inconsistency.
Bottom line; I looked to you to do the right thing (as I am told that you are a very honest individual) and you just washed your hands of it and walked away. I am a very reasonable and friendly person and I am particular about my cars and the quality of work that goes into them. I expected much more from you and, sadly, I was let down over less than $40 in retail parts and sloppy issues. It is the service and integrity that makes the difference and I hope that my experience was the outlier.
Consumers, please do not hesitate to contact me if you would like to discuss my experience further (I've documented everything).
3/16/2016 UPDATE: I would like to report additional details on this experience. As the new clutch wore-in and I drove the car more and more I noticed that the clutch pedal developed a rather odd springback and notchiness. So, under the dash I went to check components. Everything looked OK so under the car I went, where I found that the slave cylinder had been reinstalled with the pushrod cocked slightly which caused it to actuate in a non-linear fashion. I also noticed that the pushrod had been greased (that's a no-no). Once I cleaned it up, lubed the TIP ONLY and reinstalled, the clutch performs as it should. Unfortunately, the damage has already been done to my slave cylinder (sratches/gouging in the pushrod) from actuating off-axis. This now needs to be replaced and that also requires the master cylinder to be done. HEED MY ADVICE...BEWARE! read more