If you think you've had great pizza, baby, you ain't seen nothing yet. The flavor combos are imaginative, but somehow work. We ordered the wrong pizza once, and it became our new favorite. Service is fast, friendly, and accommodating. Prices are fair. Crust is freaking phenomenal. Our guys tear this pizza up. The G Knots are the BEST version of garlic bread ever. We try somethin new just about every time we order, and we are always blown away. Sauces are tasty! read more

I tried this while visiting from another state and it was pretty solid. I'm not sure if this is a chain or locally owned ...ig I could've looked it up but either way I liked the menu. read more

Totally Baked is my favorite pizza shop! First off, the pizza is outstanding. I went with the Chong, a traditional pepperoni pizza with crisp crust, rustic pizza sauce and a ton of pepperoni. If you're feeling a little more adventurous, I definitely recommend the Danny Trejo, a pork carnitas pizza with a number of other fresh ingredients. There was a couple seated next to me and the lady was raving about a meatball dish calling it the best she's ever had. Chef John definitely knows his way around the kitchen! Totally Baked is active in the community, always looking for ways to give back. They are a local establishment and use nothing but fresh ingredients. A lot of people get carry out, but you can also eat in as they have a very chill and relaxing seating area. Make sure to get the lucid lemonade. The flavor changes daily. Today was a strawberry lime lemonade that was on point. I highly recommend Totally Baked Pizza. If you are in the area, or looking for DoorDash, give them a try. You will not be disappointed! read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Delicious!! The Chong pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

Finally found my way to Totally Baked. Well worth the wait. I kept it simple with the Chong pizza. Lotsa pepperoni and a very tasty sauce baked to perfection. Crust finished off crispy. Also got some Mother Cluckers. Peanut butter/habanero concoction that hit right. Pickup and delivery only. I suggest you stop in and place your order. Just sit back , relax, and enjoy the sounds and smells waiting for your pie. Do yourself a favor and get to Totally Baked. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

One of the best Pizza restaurants I've come across. If you're in Akron, you have to stop at this spot! read more

See all

If you're looking for some good pizza in Akron, this is the place. The restaurant itself is decorated for the theme and staff were attentive and friendly. The pizza was the highlight though! Boyfriend and I ordered the Mike Tyson and Chong pizzas (10in) which was the perfect size for our "garden" session. A little bit bigger than personal sized so you have some left over for later. The pork belly on the Mike Tyson was cooked perfectly giving it a bacon-like taste and the creamy sauce on top was delicious. My boyfriend enjoyed the cup and char pepperoni on the Chong. Crust is always an issue with me and I'd say this is a top tier crust with how soft and chewy it was. Come for the good vibes and stay for the pizza! Definitely going back to try the PB&J pizza next time. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Mike Tyson (bottom) and Chong (top) - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

We took a chance at work once with pizza, and it was L-O-V-E at first bite! Their take on pizza here is really freaking amazing! The dough is perfecto! Plenty of stuff on the pizza to satisfy anyone! Friendly service! This is artisan pizza! Pretty cool building and always tidy. If you think you've had the best pizza in your life already, think again. If you have not tried this place, do not wait. Chong and Jerry Garcia are the office favorites. Oh, and get the pull-a-part garlic bread!!! G-Nots! Scrumptious! The names were quite different for pizza for sure! read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Totally Baked Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

It's worth the wait when it's made from scratch and is so damn good. They cook from the heart and the music in their kitchen. Plus the doodle books/art in the corner are epic to look through. Awesome, awesome, awesome. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Art on their wall - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

See all

The pizza was just o.k. I ordered a Greek salad, but a garden salad was what was delivered. The lettuce was not quite fresh. The Cannoli was also not good/ shell was stale. Overall not a great experience. read more

Decent size pizza, the pesto just had a weird flavour to it. Didn't hit the spot. Unfortunately won't be going back. When placing the order the person seemed confused. The place on inside is kind of cool and goes with the totally baked theme, decent amount of seating read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Half Oh Martha, half my Roll Your Own Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

See all

Okay, better late than never! I was at Totally Baked for lunch back in November 2023. (At the time, I couldn't post this review or share photos or my friends and family would have known I snuck into the great state of Ohio without making plans to visit them. Whoops! Sorry!) I got the Danny Trejo. As someone who now lives in Texas I'd consider myself a salsa and carnitas snob, and this really could stand up against the best of the best. The menu names, the murals, and vibe of the restaurant was so fun--albeit a little small (lunch was fine, but dinner might not be a good dine-in time). The service was great! John was so nice and happily made small talk as I told him about my secret visit to Akron. Would happily go back any time I'm in town, secret or not! read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Danny Trejo - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

Might be the best pizza in the region. Was worried it would be a gimmick since I've had lots of mediocre pizza that people say is good since moving out here. Walked in and saw the kitchen and wasnt expecting much, but it turned out awesome. Sadly I live in shaker heights. Someone tell the owner let's open a location out here. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

See all

Everything I have tried has been AMAZING!!! Love this place! Pizza is great. Sandwiches, bowls... you can't go wrong here. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - G-Knots - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

See all

Holy. Shit. This pie is AMAZING!!! I'm not kidding. We kept smelling this pie all over downtown Akron and found ourselves walking into Akron's best kept secret. You have GOT to try the Mike Tyson!!! While you wait for your pie, do yourself a favor and check out Baxters Speakeasy (attached to Totally Baked). Such a cool vibe and they'll let you enjoy your pizza while you take it all in. I will most definitely be back for more! The only downside is that the service isn't quick and the kitchen is small so depending on how busy they are, it may take a while for your pizza to be done. read more

Man I wish I was in the Akron area more. This spot made this Pittsburgh visitor happy cause the pizza was SOLID. Would love to try more someday, some interesting items in this menu. read more

I love the vibe of this place. Very friendly staff and the pizza is awesome and not too expensive. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Salami and green pepper pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

See all

Let me start by saying if you don't wana be obsessed with a pizza... don't try it lol!!! The first time I went I was torn between two pizzas. The John Belushi and a regular pepperoni and I asked the owner/chef as he works there regularly. I really don't like pizza. I eat it about 4 times a year, well I did. The owner (who has a wonderful personality!!) told me, "whatever you get, you'll love it because I make them". Okay, I thought. Let's go with John Belushi, I love a good gyro. This pizza gets brought out and I definitely made a face . It didn't really look like my type of pizza, it was made with lettuce and said it was the wrong one. Haha it was not. So I decided I paid for it.. ima try it. OH MY GOODNESS!!! I won't get anything else!! It is the best damn pizza I have ever had. There's one pizza I've had in my almost 32 years of life that is even at this level! The place is really small, there is a bar next door that you can eat in. Otherwise, there are only a couple of tables and couches. Overall, I can only say positives. The workers and chef/owner are always friendly. It's not "cheap" pizza but the quality is worth it! ** Don't let the unique appearance of the turn you away, if you enjoy a gyro, you will love it. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - 10" John Belushi - this has extra tzatziki sauce. I prefer it with extra, the original just has a drizzle. - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

The scooby pizza sounds weird with the chocolate chips but with the spice it's amazing.

5 stars for food... service and reliability... MAYBE 2 We've ordered food from here twice, both to dine in at the adjacent bar. Both times they got the order wrong. First time, they made us a completely different pizza (I'm pretty sure it was someone else's pizza sitting at the bar). Like, not even close with the toppings. The second time we ordered a few subs. Despite being assured they would "deliver" them to us at the bar (a thing they do, not a special request), they did not. After an hour... I went to ck on my order only to find the two subs wrapped in foil and sitting atop the pizza oven! I get the fun play on words in your name but maybe, just maybe, save the extra curricular activities until AFTER you close. Not sure the sub par service is worth it. read more

Excellent pizza for the price. My goodness sooo much pepperoni!! Love it. Close to the BluJazz+. Gotta grab a slice for yourself! read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Sooooo much pepperoni! - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

I ordered via Uber. it took the 4th courier to be able to pick up the food bc it wasn't ready - so my original expected time kept increasing. Added 50 min to it - no worries on that happens more often than not :\ The Gotti Sub: good portion but priced at $21, no! not worth it - I did minus the red onions - but had lack of flavor anyways - even with the horseradish aioli That I was looking forward to and ordered extra! No thank you. to be honest, I'd give it a thumbs up if the aioli was on point. The Chong Pizza: small portion for $16.55 i love pepperoni but it was way too salty :\ I think this item was done first bc it was more cool in temp and made the dough chewy - Im sure it would have been great fresh. The Janis Joplin Bowl: small portion for $16.55 This one was the hottest item and tastiest! I give this a thumbs up. Tip don't bake the lime with it - makes it bitter. Overall, I think if I was in house and ordered I'd rank better - so 3.5 stars - I do give them that!!! read more

Here me out guys........ Here.me.out. Peanut butter and jelly pizza. Sounds weird but the Scooby and shaggy pizza is legit one of the best pizzas I've ever had. It's a buttery crunchy pan pizza with peanut butter sauce, bacon, smoked meat, onions and topped with grape jelly and chocolate chips. I couldn't get enough of it. I ate half right away and ate the other half cold later that night. I've had regular pizza from all over and I'm a big fan but this was different, original and just inspired man I just can't recommend it enough. My wife and kid didn't like it too much so it's not for everyone but man I just can't wait until I get another. All the other menu items looked awsome to so don't sleep on this place on account of this one pie. Also, it's connected to a bar and you can take the pizza over there and eat it with your drink. read more

See all

If you like your pizza, crust and pepperoni Bert, you may like this pizza myself. No thank you even my dog split it out read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Burnt pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

See all

Had a carry out order, and the pizza did not disappoint! The Lil Wayne was AMAZING! Would never have expected the combination of ingredients to work so well. The crust was a perfect thickness. 10 inch is perfect for one person! read more

Came from LA and was looking for something to eat not knowing where the hell I was going. Pizza was actually pretty good and the vibes inside are cool, only downside is the wait time to get your food waited almost half an hour. read more

One of the best pizza I have ever had in Akron. This is a must try. The Mike Tyson pizza I must say is the one I am Still craving till this day. I wish they can ship it to me In LA or give me the recipe. The pizza took a while to come out but it was well worth it. I appreciated the hospitality I was treated with while there. While you wait to next door and grab a drink. The speak easy is walking distance. Perfect 3 business all in one read more

One of the most unique pizza places I have even seen in that the flavors available are ones you will likely not find elsewhere. The peanut butter and jelly one was probably to most unusual. Regardless of the flavor, though, the pizzas are made very well. read more

I ordered, and devoured over 3 days, the " Chong, " which, according to their site, has a " s--- ton of pepperoni. " when I put in my order, the person working said " are you sure, it's kind of an obscene amount of pepperoni. " I told her I knew what I was doing and have no regrets. So, so good! Crust, sauce, and the blanket of cheese + toppings. YUM. Not even stoned, I might add. read more

Loved everything about this place. Great atmosphere. The service was great, and we had a conversation with the employees. The food was amazing. The garlic knots was loaded with garlic. Highly recommend. read more

See all

This was a great find. The pizza is top notch. Open late for that night time craving.

My favorite pizza spot in Akron! The flavors are so interesting and well melded. I've had a couple of different pizzas here and I can't say there's one I wouldn't recommend. The crust is solid and holds up so well to the insane amount of cheese and service is always quick though wait times may be a bit long. You can always kill the time walking around the connected bar and speak easy! read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

Great food! A downside is that there is very limited seating here, but they bring your pizzas next door to hop house and Baxter's, which is awesome. The wait times are always over 40 minutes so order accordingly! read more

Thought they were closed the door is just hard to open lol but everything I was hoping for!

So this was my first time trying this pizza! And I was disappointed. My pizza was burnt on the bottom both of them. The pizza was very thick and kind of hard to eat. The pepperoni was also good but spicy. I felt like there was too much dough or maybe they skimped on the sauce, I'm not sure. It didn't taste complete or cooked well. They do look just like the pics on doordash though. I would recommend this place for its excellent and kind staff. Also the restaurant is a vibe. I don't know what I was expecting so late at night but given it's a pizza shop I feel like all pizza shops are open later and should do the job right. read more

Totally Baked Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Akron, Ohio

The pizza is always delicious. But do plan on a long wait. I've never waited less than an hour for it, but was at least able to enjoy a cocktail next door! read more

If you're in dire need of fantastic quality pizza, Totally Baked is the way to go! Not only is it warm, welcoming, and fun, there is a bar next door if you want to get frisky. The employees are even better! They're super sweet and funny too. I always have fun when I'm there and I bet you will too. Thank you for giving me an unforgettable experience, and I will be going there more often. read more

L I S T E N This place is beyond amazing...beyond. We've been here a handful of times and have never had a bad pizza or experience. Our faves by far are the Mike Tyson and the Oh, Martha with sausage added - you can thank me later ;) Plus it's right next door to Hop House, where you can sit and wait for your pizza and have some delicious drinks. read more

Tired of the same old places? Try something new! You'll be glad you did! Recently ordered from Totally Baked Pizza through a third party delivery service. Not sure what everyone else's experience has been, but we usually order through third parties, and are not overly impressed with the results. I am happy to report that this was not our experience ordering from Totally Baked. We ordered the Cheech (cheese pizza) the Chong (cheesy pepperoni) and the G-Knots, which is basically a super thick pizza crust with garlic oil, cheese and crushed red peppers. So the first thing that hit us, these boxes were heavy. Like really, really heavy. I didn't know what my wife had ordered at this point to be honest, and as I was carrying the pizza to the kitchen I joked that we had received a complimentary brick in one of the boxes. We opened them up, and to say that they were generous with the toppings would be an understatement. It's like they forgot how much pepperoni was supposed to go on a pizza, and just doubled (maybe even tripled for some of the chain pizzerias out there) the amount that you would normally get. The cheese pizza too... ever order extra cheese on your pizza, and know what you expect to get, but then are disappointed? Not this pie! Ooey Gooey cheese atop a thick, but well baked crust, with thick, rustic tomato sauce. Holy cow! The pepperonis on the other pie were all crisp and cupped, the way it's supposed to be! Holy smokes! We actually had to re-cut the pizzas just to get the pieces out of the box, but not because it wasn't cut through, it was! But all that cheese was so hot, it reattached to itself. So now, the pizza is cut, and my wife went to go pull it out of the box, and I witnessed something I have never, ever seen from a delivered pie... a thick cheese pull from both sides of the piece. I was amazed! I thought that was just for commercials! But no! You can get a real deal pizza, right in the privacy of your own home! Yes! I'll skip ahead from all the additional superlatives I'd like to hype on these pizzas, and skip right to the eating. I had the pepperoni, and it was absolutely wonderful! Spicy little crispy pepperonis, a little smoke flavor, a bit of a zing from the sauce, and that crispy, soft, pillowy but somehow firm crust.... Yowza! I never did try the cheese, but I was assured it was equally tasty, minus the crunchy little pork bombs. The G-knots were really good too, but prepare yourself for a lot of garlic. I really love garlic, but after eating that, I won't worry about Dracula for at least a week. But it worked! My goodness, who knew you could make garlic bread with real garlic? I'll tell ya who, Totally Baked Pizza! That's who! I really hope Akron embraces its newest pizza shop, and nothing I sampled makes me think they won't. And the craziest thing, we ate the most vanilla things on the menu. I can only imagine how great the creative toppings on their other signature pies work. I hope to find out very soon! read more

Awesome pizza! Love this place...best pizza in Akron, Ohio. The Mike Tyson is a wonderful mouth tasting experience. The pepperoni on the Chong is the best, love how it curls up. The Willie Nelson is another great combination of flavors. Betty White is devine, another delicious combination. We just love your pizza! read more

Totally Baked has become one of my favorite pizza places! The ingredients are always fresh and full of flavor! The staff is always friendly and super helpful! My favorite pizzas are the OH Martha , the Cheech and the Great White Buffalo (without salami). Another perk of ordering pizza from Totally Baked is they will bring it to you next door if you are at High Street Hop House or Baxters Speakeasy. read more

See all