I called Tosco's before my 7:00 dance class in Pine Bush and ordered a pizza to be picked up at 8:15 this evening. I got there at 8:15. I was CHARGED for the pizza. I assumed it was ready. THEN, AFTER I WAS CHARGED, they admitted they did not turn in my order at 7:00 when I first called them. I have evidence on my phone that I called. This is crazy. Then I was told to SIT IN MY VEHICLE while they cooked my pizza. I live in a nearby town. I was tired from a long day and hungry, so I waited. The pizza is half cooked and tastes terrible. No, I can't drive back to Pine Bush tonight. This is not good service at best, and dishonest at worst. I was told I could get $15. off on my next order. No coupon, nothing to prove that I can do that. They have my first name only, and my phone number. So no, this is clearly NOT a real offer. I will never, ever go back there again. And the pizza? I don't think it would be good even if they did cook it, and they did not do that. Horrible place. read more

Decent pizza at a good price. Service was fast and efficient -- great if you're looking for a quick and affordable meal.

Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Large amount of options and combos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts! Pizza: Nice brick oven style and Sicilian. Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively cheap. 2 slice and fountain special for $12! Parking: Plenty of space, side lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were small and clean. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, It was crazy. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was decent, and unsociable. Been a few times and will return. read more

Food was okay, and cheesecake seemed to be old. But other than that we didn't have a chance to try pizza, but seemed to look good. read more

Pizza is delicious so can't complain here! Crust was okay and flavor deflated pretty quickly as it cooled down but still good. Our caesar was a bit old and sad but that's probably because it was late and it was probably sitting in the fridge all day. Not bad I guess but I'd probably try a different place before I'd come back here again. Food: 6/10 Value: 6/10 read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - hawaiian! - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

The pizza is so wonderful. We have gone here several times and it is consistently delicious. We always order a whole pie, but eat a few slices and save the rest. read more

Coming from NYC I am very particular with my pizza. It it's not good, I will let you know!!! This pizza, however, was awesome! Great sauce! They even deliver to Christopher Jacob Winery! Definitely recommend! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Margarita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

Despite the annoying jeep guy out front we had the best. Pizza around can't wait to comeback! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - The homies - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

i asked for caesar salad and when my food came out, i saw a tomato but i just thought maybe one fell in there and i could just pick it out. turns out there were multiple tomatoes, cucumbers, kale??? i was shocked because that is NOT a caesar salad. i went in and asked the man at the counter if there was any way they accidentally made a house salad instead of a caesar salad. he said no, and told me that is how a caesar salad is made. i have NEVER had those things in a caesar salad so i was just thrown off. i'm not sure why but if they make their salads the nontraditional way, i think they should tell their customers when they order, that it is more like a house salad with caesar dressing. read more

i ordered spaghetti and meatballs, penne ala vodka with shrimp, and garlic knots with cheese. VERY disappointed. didn't bother to cut the tails off my shrimp. pasta sauce was watered down. garlic knots had pounds of garlic. truly a nightmare. also, delivered it literally a block down the road. took an HOUR. never again read more

Honestly a terrible excuse for an "Italian" pizzeria. Paninis are awful and barely filled, pizza dough is so thick with no flavor, ordered cheese fries for $8.75 got no cheese and the girl who answers the phone says "oh that's my fault" I can refund you for the cheese. $2.20 for cheese. This place is a joke. I'd never eat here or recommend to anyone unless they just want to be out a bunch of money for crap quality food. read more

Pizza is inconsistent...good one time, doughy with skimpy toppings the next. We stopped going last year after we placed a large pizza order for a gathering and they were all terrible! We picked it up so it's not like ot sat. Floppy, doughy crust, skimpy toppings and the sauce wasn't spread nearly to the crust. When I called to complain they told me they'd give me a free cheese pie. Uh no thank you! read more

Spent $30 for an extra large pie, (1/2 pepperoni & 1/2 sausage) with a small garlic knots. Crust & cheese wee burnt. Used to love their pies but not as of late. Guess I have to start looking for an alternative. read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - $30 for burnt cheese & crust. Never again! - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

It's been a while since we've been here. Tonight my husband got take out, ordered a meatball sub, bread was burnt to a point it wasn't edible. Didn't realize this until he came home. Not sure how you can expect to eat it? read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Burnt bread - meatball parm sub - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

See all

Manager has a poor attitude would not go back! Better pizza places in the area with better customer service!!

We came in for dinner on a Thursday around 5:30 on the recommendation of a friend. The service was very friendly and prompt. The portions were HUGE and the food was PHENOMENAL. The prices were very reasonable and we left very full and satisfied!! Highly recommend for good food and good times like we had with good friends read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Calamari, Garlic knots, Meat Lovers pizza and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

See all

Great food, and service! Everything they serve is top notch. No matter if you order a salad, sub, hero or rice ball, always delicious. Staff is polite and accommodating read more

I never write reviews but if you order a pizza (simple cheese pizza) on line and it tells you that it will be ready an hour and 10 min later that's long for a pizza but ok. When you show up exactly an hour and 10 min later and it's not ready for another 30 min (all the while some is saying just another 2-3 minutes)... That's probably a good indicator I should have ordered from somewhere else. Blank stares from the staff..... read more

Mexican Pizza. What can I say? The staff is very friendly and attentive. The pizza was more like Dominoes than actual pizza. The crust was not crispy it was kind of doughy. I am sorely disappointed as I was really looking forward to becoming a regular customer on my way to the house up from NYC. read more

Ordered 2 Italian Combo cold subs which were served with an usually small portion of meat cuts compared to even Stewart's or other gas station chain. This is Pine Bush, not the city yet they charged $30. Never again....next time I will save $15 and get better quality at Subway down the street! read more

Got the meat lover's pizza from here, it was delicious and must've had like 5lbs of toppings on it. Great pizza!

I thought the cheese, pepperoni and crust were all pretty average for a NY slice. The crust was doughy and didn't have a good crisp but tasted great. An average pie through and through. read more

If it weren't for the fact that Tosco's food is the best out of the five or so other mediocre "Italian" take-out spots near my home, I wouldn't ever order from here solely based on the attitude of their front-end staff. The girls that work here are your typical, immature, townie snobs (but, you're living/working in Pine Bush, so... really?) who always, and I mean always, seem inconvenienced by you simply calling in an order... even if you're coming to pick it up. Speaking of picking up the food... please do yourself a favor and consider that your only viable option. If you absolutely must order for delivery, place your order about a week in advance. To be fair, as I started to say, their food is quite good and also reasonably priced considering the enormous portion you're given. Although the staff seems less than thrilled to be employed here, the orders have always been correct and consistently good tasting. TL;DR - Decent Americanized Italian food if you're hungry for a side of attitude and willing sacrifice home delivery and/or wait 2 hours. Hate to love it, love to hate it. read more

Went out for dinner last night with friends. There were three of us. We ended up here after a horrible start a different restaurant in town. We ordered fried calamari which was delicious and fresh cooked to perfection! Our salads were fresh and delicious with lots of great tasting additions like roasted red peppers. Our dinners were even better and we could not have been more pleased. In addition there were large portions and plenty to bring home for leftovers. We have had their pizza before as well and have been very pleased. I could not recommend them more highly, although it seemed a bit empty and I worry they might not be doing well at this location since the pandemic. So many people think to leave reviews when they are angry but truly this place is awesome and they should get lots of local support. read more

Won't be ordering from here again. What place charges $4 for a cup of sauce on top of the $20 Stromboli? To top it off I ordered dozen boneless wings and got delivered bone in which my 6yr old won't eat. Called back after delivery, stayed on hold for 9 plus minutes and had to drive all the way back to drop off the wrong wings (which they requested and it's wrong if they re-serve them) to pick up the new wings and then pay on top a $4 fee for sauce. We are never venturing away from our favorite pizza plus. We should've know better and now we do $50 Plus $7tip and $2 delivery charge out of our hands and still hungry as the food left much to be desired and left us very disappointed. I do NOT recommend!!!! Stay away read more

Best pizza I had in a while! Cheese and pepperoni was fresh and the pizza was delicious and hot! Also the delivery driver Richie was so goooddddd read more

We've lived in Pine Bush for three years and tried all of the pizza restaurants. Tosco's has been our go to every tome. Great pizza and service. Dining room has much to be desired but for pick up or delivery-this is your spot. I highly recommend the margarita pizza!! Nice big chicks of fresh mozzarella, basil, tomato and sauce. read more

Very fresh and great good. Great customer service, everyone is very friendly! Coming from out of state, wishing I could return more often

Hit & Miss Sometimes the pizza is spot on if you catch it fresh. The garlic knots are literally drowned in oil making them a little tough to eat. Staff is somewhat standoffish at time's, but overall not a bad place to grab a bite if you're in the area and in a rush. My biggest gripe......try to get a cold drink there, I dare you! All of their bottled drinks are basically always room temperature, don't bother digging to the rear of the stack...nope, not cooler back there. Its strange, they have to know their cooler is shot and no longer working, you think they would invest in a new one......? read more

John answered the phone 20 minutes before closing and offered delivery service! THAT WAS AMAZING! I couldn't drive due to excess alcohol consumption. He was so nice and patient! I highly recommend getting pizza at 9:30pm. read more

This place is always solid, except for this visit. I don't live in Pine Bush anymore but always grab food from here when I come back for a visit. Last night we ordered to-go, after speaking to the girl on the phone(who was less then pleasant) she repeated my simple order back to me, a large pie and a hero. When I showed up to pick to food 25 minutes later, they tell me they forgot to make the hero. No problem we wait an extra 15 minutes. When we get home the pizza was really sloppy looking, no cheese in spots sauce spilling over the crust. The pizza lacked flavor and the sandwich that waited an extra 15 minutes was just thrown together with ingredients all over. So I guess we will try to order again soon and give this place another chance. read more

We usually only get dinners from Tosco's in Pine Bush. The cheesesteaks are super stuffed and actually really good. I appreciate the coupon mailer magnets they send out as well!! We get food from here 1-2x a week because the salad and taco pizza (and crazy chicken or whatever it's called!) is so good! read more

Great pizza, sandwiches and wings! Toscos has a reputation in neighboring towns and they definitely maintain it here in Pine Bush. Delicious food, great service, extensive menu. I'm a fan and will choose Toscos over any other pizza in town. read more

See all

Great pizza great sandwiches fried oreos to die for, the staff are always very friendly and food is done quick but perfe tly

All we have to say about this place is YUM YUM YUM!!! The gluten free is fantastic and scrumptious too!! read more

I just want to give a shout out to Tosco's for an amazing meal! Not only were the portions amazing but the flavors were incredible too! You could really tell that they take care in the dishes they put out. We had a delicious veggie panini, stuffed shells and an antipasto salad as well as tiramisu for dessert and everything was absolutely wonderful. They even added garlic knots and fries which we didn't expect to be included with the meals. I know that it is very hard in this current climate to keep things fresh and fast and they seem to have that down to a science! Super friendly staff too! I feel bad that we hadn't been there before. Thanks guys! Can't wait to order again! read more

Hands down, my favorite pizza place out of the 3 right across from each other. Everyone working there is always pleasant and we have never had an issue except for a slice being forgotten for a delivery but they honored it the next time we were in which was great. Their Tosco slice is the best slice I have ever had! Keep up the great work guys! read more

Good pizza, No Air conditioning!!! Stopped in for lunch and it was at least 100 degrees in there. Staff said owner refuses to put in A/C. Would have stayed and ordered more pizza but couldn't stand the heat!! read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - This is there 18 dollar Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

Dont.... just dont. Especially delivery.... save yourself money and disappointment.... food is generally cold, burnt, soggy, tasteless, etc.... customer service (if you have a complaint) is like talking to a brick wall... guaranteed you will get further with a brick wall. Nobody there has any idea on how to deal with a complaint or how to deal with the public... I can go on for a decent while on why NOT to there. Honest opinion go to Pizza Plus or Puddgys Pizza or any other restaurant in Pine Bush! They ALL have BETTER food and service. read more

Burned pizza delivered. When we called to get it replaced, the employee stated it wasn't burned and asked if we ate any of it because she needed it back if they were going to replace it. Let's hope they don't try to serve it to other customers. Won't be calling them again for delivery. Poor service even more than the food itself. read more

Tosco's Pizzeria - Burned pizza delivered. Poor customer service when calling to get it replaced. - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

See all