Food/Drink: Pizza by the slice! Pretty good New York style pizza. Large amount of options and combos. Full Italian style menu, appetizers, entrees, pizza, soups, salads, and desserts! Pizza: Needed more crunch and little doughy. Dinning Area: Pretty large, open, area. Benches, large counter, double closed off entry way so mo breeze. Plenty of seating! Prices: Relatively cheap. 2 slice and fountain special for $12.95! Parking: Plenty of space, side lot. Bathrooms: Bathrooms were clean and regular size. Atmosphere: During the weekday lunch rush, It was empty. Staff/Attendants: Staff overall was great, and sociable. Been a few times and will return. read more

Pizza Plus - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

Do the math before you order here. They tried to tell me that the small pizza was $20 and change. I'm writing a review. I'm writing a review. I called to see where the discrepancy was. And the waitress kept putting me on hold to be coached by another from that business. They tried to tell me that a small sausage and pepper roll and large. Stromboli and a small pie with three toppings came out to 64 and change.Please people do the math before ordering here. The waitress obviously didn't know much of what she was doing. She was being coached by someone else trying to fight the battle. You know when you burn good people, it comes back to you tenfold. read more

Grabbed a menu and was not rushed to make decision and the counter person was pretty friendly. My order did seem to take bit longer then I would thought. The pizza slice was great, plenty of pepperoni coverage and sauce and cheese melted well, plus the crust was not burnt, but I will say the slice itself was pretty greasy. Now the panini the bread was well pressed and toasted, plus plenty of cheese, chicken and thousands island dressing, but fries on side, were a salt bomb, I mean they seasoned alright, but way too much salt on them, I had throw them out. Otherwise I mean great beside that. Now the Nutella knots, I loved those, knots cut in half and spooned on Nutella on them like little chocolate dough sliders with powdered sugar on top. read more

See all

There is some fierce competition in this area for pizza joints - 3 on Main Street alone, with some others less than 10 minutes away. After 2 years of ordering around and figuring out our family's favorite, these guys are the winners. Daily specials (we like the Friday one the best), consistently good pizza and even a great calzone make this a go-to when it's pizza night. And I gotta say, I just love the location and feeling in the place. When my kid grows up, I wouldn't mind if she wanted to work at this place. Just a cute pizza spot. read more

Don't know how long the pizza has been sitting out. They heat it up when you ask for the pizzas on display. It's a decent size slice, at a decent price. read more

Pizza Plus - Buffalo Chicken, Pepperoni, & Sausage Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

I have been a Pizza Plus customer for a long time. The last couple of times I went I noticed the food was not as good. I went tonight and not only was the food just ok at best, they brought my pizza slices burnt black on the bottom. it was uneatable. When I ask my waitress about it she was not nice or helpful. I will not be back. read more

I was put on to this place by a good friend of mine that worked in Pine Bush. I was new to this store so I chose from a selection that hey had premade. I had the vodka and pesto pie which turned out to be spectacular. The use of vodka sauce on a pie was quite clever and the crust had a pleasantly crispy undercarriage. A real great value for an afternoon snack. I highly recommend. read more

Pizza Plus - Vodka Sauce and Pesto pie. - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

Pizza was great!! Crust was so good, thin but perfectly cooked and sauce and topping so delicious

This was our first time eating here and we really liked the food. We had a chicken parm dinner, ravioli, grilled chicken with pasta and some cheesy garlic breadsticks. The sauce was great, good flavor, not acidic, tastes homemade. The breadsticks were surprisingly tasty and crunchy. We really enjoyed those. Serving sizes were appropriate. The parm dinner fed my wife and I, but unfortunately no leftovers. They have a takeout window to limit traffic in the dining room which is great in the times of Covid. Overall we were very satisfied and will happily be back. read more

See all

I used to love Pizza Plus but the food has gone down hill and so has the service. My daughter and her friend got pizza and the slices were burnt on the bottom, when asked about receiving new slices, they were turned down and given a lame excuse as to the reason the bottoms were burnt. Myself and my family won't return there again. It isn't the same as when the original owners were involved in the business. read more

The best pizza in town with a polite staff in a historic location. My favorite go-to spot for a cheese pie.

We've been choosing this pizza place for a long while bc of the pizza quality and service. What a difference when you have one bad experience. We called for a pizza pick up and asked when can we pick up. The young woman who was very sweet on the phone told us 45 mins. So I asked should we come by a certain time so that the pizza is hot when we pick up. She told me when to come by. When my husband picked up at that time he said the pizza box was not hot at all. It was cold. So I called the shop to mention it to them. Another older woman got on the phone and she was so rude. Perhaps she was having a really bad day. She hung up on me. There are other pizza shops we have easy access to in Pine Bush and not to say we won't give it another try but it will be a long while. Costumers should never be treated that way no matter what. More training needs to be done here. read more

Just got 4 pies delivered. They told me 45 min and came in less than 30. I got a Gladiator pie and it is so unique and delicious. Will definitely order again! read more

Pizza Plus - Gladiator Pie - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

Had dinner with with our kids over Memorial Day weekend. Pizza was really good! Glad we chose this place for our weekly pizza night. Friendly staff too. Good family dinner spot read more

The lady taking my order over the phone was super nice and when I arrived they were quick and followed great COVID-19 protocol. The wraps were amazing too. read more

Pizza Plus - Honey Sriracha Chicken Wrap - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

sadly after going here for years, on a monthly basis to dine in we have made the choice to stop giving them our money - first - we understand new staff needs to be trained but our server spent more time on her phone than waiting on the table. We had to get up and get drink refills, napkins and ketchup and cheese. second - I pay attention to my money - all of a sudden they have a 5% card usage fee "that they have had for years" - Well this is the first time - since we have been going there - since they were in Walden- that my check and my receipt did not match finally - food quality has slipped and not come back up and their prices are skyrocketing. We order the exact same meal each time we go - drinks, large pie half meatball and 2 New Yorker Paninis. Every time! The bill is always 43.50 give or take a few cents or if we get an appetizer. This time we got a rice ball app that was 10$. so 53.50? nope 73.50.Then the bill was higher and I was explained to about the card charge...that I have never seen before...but I said you know us...I got an app so take away 10$ and the tx and its about 20$ higher for the exact same order - the other server repeated my order because she knows us ( our server was on her phone at the counter too busy to give me the check) and she said "yeeeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh our prices are up..I get it about the prices ...but 20$ more for a 40$ order? no way am I paying 63.50 for a large pie and 2 subs....so long Pizza Plus .. read more

I been to this place three times now. My first experience was awesome. I had great service, food was good. The past two time have completely sucked. Tonight there was three waitresses and I could not get service to save my life. They say at the counter and jaw jacked. I literally had to walk to the counter to order. Then she asked if it was for here or to go. I said I'm sitting right there. They brought my food in a to go tray. This starts my frustration. Secondly I order a cheese steak. I get roast beef with cheese whiz on it. What the heck!!!! Then as I'm trying to eat there is a guy with a dog who is smelling my crotch, trying to get to my food. How rude could people be, and how could the owner/manager allow this to happen. I would highly recommend to go somewhere else, at least a place that is proud of their job and can handle customer service. I am very disappointed!!!! Well after tonight's dinner at Pizza Plus I feel that the food was not prepared well. My stomach is completely upset. I feel as if I am going to throw up. I feel that the kids that work there are not properly supervised. Highly recommend this place be check for cleanliness, handling of the food, and properly trained in customer service. read more

Went there for dinner last night. We ordered fried calamari for appetizer. It arrived looking like onion rings and bad ones at that. The coating came off and they were slimy and smelled fishy but did not taste like calamari. We left them uneaten. My friend ordered chicken noodle soup; it tasted like soap. We ordered sweet potato fries for the three of us to share also and they were coated in salt. At that point we decided to cut our losses and go elsewhere rather than invest more money in horrid food. We choked down the sweet potato fries. My friends each had a fountain soda... we explained to the waitress that the food was simply terrible and we knew it wasn't her fault so please give us the check. They took nothing off of the bill until my friend asked that the soup be removed. I should have asked if they do the same with the calamari. Nearly $30 and a $10 tip for a waitress we felt sorry for. Never again! Steer clear! We went across the street and had a delicious dinner at Tosco's. read more

Homemade and delicious. Lasagna, fettucine, cream bacon sauce and meatballs all homemade.we will drive 3 towns over to eat here. My money is never wasted! the waitress nicole is phenomenal! You wil not be sorry. Salad is always fresh with no damn iceberg! Make sure u try the tartufo..... read more

Pizza Plus - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

Really good pizza, the crust is perfect! Garlic knots were pretty good too. The waitress was super nice and helpful.

One of my favorite places in Pine Bush. The staff is always so sweet and kind and the food is great! The restaurant is always clean and offers a welcoming environment. read more

I loved everything here! Wandered in to keep my kid from having a total meltdown and got a gluten free pizza and meatballs on the side. The food was delicious and the staff was so friendly and helpful. The tomato sauce was excellent. Would definitely go back! read more

Got their menu w/ coupons in the mail recently so I decided to give them a shot. Somehow a small pizza (half margherita/half hawaiian), a tuscan panini, and a bottle of coke turned into $31 dollars and change. I called them up when I got home, and she said "Oh sorry, we charged you for a large pie by mistake, so we owe you $2. Next time you order, we will take $2 off". I did the math quite a few times - and even still I can't see how it was $31 - it just doesn't add up. I'll be going in tomorrow to get my $2 back and to see what the actual breakdown was. (not to order more food). Regardless - this is just unacceptable in my opinion. Now, my experience with the food: My pizza was half margherita/half hawaiian (big kahuna). The whole pizza was a little underdone. The hawaiian half was pretty good. Wish I tasted the ham a little more. The margherita half was not what I'm used to. With margherita - I'm used to big fresh tomatoes, fresh basil leaves, garlic, and fresh round slices of mozzerella. That was not the case here - there was no basil, no fresh mozzerella, and the sauce they used was a white ricotta sauce. Weird. The best part of the meal was the tuscan panini - Breaded eggplant, prosciutto, on sesame bread. Absolutely delicious. Bottom line: I won't be going back - Pudgy's has much better tasting pizza in my opinion - although even then, not really too great. read more

I have gone to this establishment several times with my wife and two small children. The quality of my dinner and service has varied. Sometimes very good, sometimes down right bad. The most recent visit was so frustrating that I will not go back. I ordered a meat Stromboli with mushrooms. I have ordered this from them several times. It was burnt on the bottom. Not just a bit more done than my liking, but down right crispy and black. I said something to the waitress. She said she would show it to the cook. Upon returning to my table the waitress explained to me that it was actually not burnt, it was the way the oven cooked it. They would not be able to make another one. Wow!! I was taken aback. Now burnt food is not the responsibility of the cook, rather the fault of the oven. Why not use tinfoil to stop it from burning. I can teach you how if you need me to. It is also funny how they used that oven to make me several Stromboli's in the recent past. It was insulting and frustrating. I know the difference between black from the oven and burnt. It looked burnt, it tasted burnt, and the bottom peeled off like it was burnt. I am not the only person to complain about burnt food here. Avoid at all costs! read more

Love this place! Delicious pizzas and very large portions on meals. Everything is fresh and made to order any way you'd like. Staff is amazing and so helpful. We order or eat in once a week and miss it if we are away. Check them out! read more

Our go to pizza place! We enjoy the other items too, but it's the best pizza around

My Grandmother used to live just down the street from this place, and she always alleged that it was the best spot to eat in town. Having now visited the place in excess of a dozen times, I can attest to her claims - Pizza Plus is great! The service has always been top-notch, whether I have ordered to-go or dined in. The waitresses are amiable and helpful, and as long as you do not act like a huge weirdo they will attend to anything you need, be it extra sauce, refills, or seating arrangements. I have never had an issue with my orders, but I imagine that they would be agreeable to anything (unless you are obnoxious or rude, of course). The quality of the food, for its price, is great. The gorgonzola cheese fries and Caprese paninis are my favorite, but all of it is non-greasy, flavourful, and well-cooked. The quantity of the food is immense, too! I would strongly recommend! (also, thanks YELP for making me write this twice) read more

Pizza and service was great we were visiting from out of town. Very nice experience! Would come again and highly recommend

This place is ridiculous. Poor quality and they put out inferior pizza. They send customers home inferior slices. Avoid at all costs.

Always delicious and fresh... vet accommodating to our party!

We used Pizza Plus to cater an event for around 80 people. We ordered about five trays of food plus a tray of salad. All the food was very good. The servings were generous. Several people at the event asked me who we had used. They were very easy to deal with and very reasonably priced. For this area, I say - as good as it gets. read more

Always Burnt bottom, very little tasteless sauce,dried up cheese & price is high for this thick or regular slice. Worst pizza ever! We wont be going back they make excuses for why it's burnt, nor to they care,to offer u something else,or a refund! Simple they just don't care !! read more

We order pizza plus almost twice weekly (shameful I know) their food is absolutely delicious. I love their garlic knots and pizza. It's never overalls greasy and I don't feel like I ate a rock afterwards. Just placed my order for delivery now! read more

The pizza is great, thin crust, well worth the price. We will definitely come here again. They also have a discount night. The service was good. read more

Food and service were excellent. Server was friendly and helpful and accommodating to our party of 10. Highly recommend this local place.

My boyfriend and I love to eat here. Their pizzas are delicious and the crust is always made just the way I like it.

Traveling from out of town and this place is awesome , a like home atmosphere great service and even better food. read more

Pizza Plus - Pizza Near Me - Pine Bush, New York

Really enjoyed the meat lovers pizza, and wings are great. Service was a little slow at the counter, but that's acceptable as they seemed like trainees read more

Yummy, just had the penne a la vodka with chicken. The service was excellent and food prepared perfectly. My salad was made just the way I like it. read more

If I could give it 0 stars, that would be more appropriate for the meal I got. Got a special from their flyer - Large Pizza, Baked Ziti, Small Salad, and had it delivered. The Ziti was inedible and I tossed it. It had a bitter taste and was extremely dry. Pizza also had a bitter taste - either too much Oregano or just bad sauce. The salad was good ( as it was not cooked by them). Too bad. This is the second time I used them. The first time was fine, but this time was terrible. Sorry, but I won't be ordering from them again. There's too many great pizza shops around to take any more chances on PBPizzaPlus. read more