After a long day, we were looking for something comforting to eat, and since we both love pizza, Tony's Pizzeria felt like the perfect choice. We stumbled upon it on TikTok and Yelp and almost immediately knew we had to go. We are so glad we did. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted with a friendly hello and genuinely attentive service. The staff took their time explaining the menu, encouraged us to look things over, and offered recommendations without making us feel rushed. One of the best parts of the experience was the atmosphere. You can instantly tell Tony's is a true neighborhood staple. People were constantly coming in and out, and it was especially sweet seeing kids stopping by after school to grab a slice. It gave the place such an authentic and welcoming feel. The food was exactly what we needed. It was fresh, delicious, and full of that classic pizza-shop comfort. This ended up being the very first place we ate on our trip, and it set the bar high. We absolutely loved it and would highly recommend stopping by if you're in the area. With love from Georgia read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Alfredo with penne pasta - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

See all

They never disappoint I forgot to take photos from here but the pies are great I only order online never been to the place though

The pizza was good thin crust had flavor not just sauce. Cross headed, enjoyable, clutching bite to it. Toppings were flavorful and semi fresh pizza sauce taste like sauce and not just paste with water. read more

After a long day of flight delays and rebookings, I found myself in a hotel room with no desire to leave in the pouring rain. Tony's SAVED THE DAY with its delicious menu and delivery service. I was having issues placing an online order, so I called and they took care of me quickly! The woman who answered the phone was polite and quick, and the man who delivered (I wish I would have gotten his name) was super nice and called me when he pulled up. I wish I'd had more cash on me to tip more than 20%! Thank you for making my long travel day better! Your driver came through during a legit storm and handed me a lovely pepperoni / meatball & parm pie, a huge salad and some tiramisu. All soooo good! If I find myself here again you have a customer for life! read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Meatball Pepperoni Parm Pizza (added mushrooms) - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

See all

One of the best pizza spots in Newark hands down! We would order at work frequently. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - 36" Veggie Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

The best pizza you will ever eat in your life! And I've had pizza in fancy places in New York Chicago and LA.

I ordered the grilled chicken parmesan. It came with pasta, salad and dinner roll. They told me it will be delivered within the hour. It arrived within 30 minutes. It was hot and fresh. The chicken was thick and not breaded, but loaded with cheese. The spaghetti was cook just right. The dinner roll was tasty , but not hot. There was plenty of food and it filled me up, the only negative was the chicken was a little dry. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Grilled Chicken Parm - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

See all

Good pizza good service worth the stop. Will be back if we're ever in the area. Food came out quick got a couple slices and the prices were great. read more

Great pizza - ordered the sausage and peppers MOLTO BENE! and wonderful service! Ordered Tony's on a quick turn around through Newark airport and they did not disappoint. Thanks Tony's and we'll order again soon! read more

We'll Tony drop off two pies one being a grandma pie which was on the money , I love the crispy thin crust. The sausage and sweet onions was on the money !!!! My across the street neighbor Joe highly recommended the pizzas from tony in Newark! I can't wait to try another combination on our next visit . read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Tony's Grandma Pizza pie out this world thank you Tony for the pie !!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

See all

Pizza is good but don't try to talk to staff They'll just ignore you. Tough crowd:) lol

Staff, pizza, location is incredible. I will recommend this better than Joe's pizza! Location was also nice!

Ordered a cheesesteak for $8 and no meat all bread. You only paying for bread and don't ask for onions and peppers you get even less meat, ridiculous read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

Good pizza is hard to find It's Always good and fresh... I love this place and only buy from here... read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Buffalo Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

Ordered delivery on a Thursday night and it was pretty speedy which I loved. I got a plain pizza and its not the best pizza that I've had but it wasn't the worst. The average overall rating of 3 pretty much sticks with me. I'd suggest if you want something quick and reasonably priced. read more

I called to get food here because someone else at my hotel did and it smelled amazing! Took my order quick and efficiently. Delivery guy was a little late but he had an accident and my pizza was still hot and fresh! Best pizza I've had here and I will continue to recommend and come back here when I am in Newark. Some places just get it right read more

The food and service were 10/10!! I couldn't wait to give a review because my experience was great. My first ordering at this establishment they forgot something from my order. I called back to and explained that. The young woman on the phone was very polite and respectful and compensated me for the mishap. I didn't let that stop me from ordering there again because the food was amazing. The second time I ordered she recognized the number and where the order was going and put the missed item from the first order. Which really really made me happy and made my day even better. I would recommend this place thank you so much!! read more

We just finished our first Tony's Pizza experience after a recommendation from the man who checked us into our airport hotel this afternoon. The prices are reasonable, the ingredients tasted fresh and our delivery arrived quickly. We got the wings with fries in addition to our pizza and I wasn't crazy about either, but my husband and son liked them. I appreciated the fact that they gave us two large ramekins of ranch with the wings though! All in all I'm feeling pretty satisfied with a belly full of pizza- now I just need to try to keep my stuffed jet lagged self awake for a few more hours! read more

See all

Great Buffalo chicken pie! Great white pie with spinach! Tony is a nice guy!! He delivers to my zeppole stand on Oliver street! read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Half plain half Buffalo chicken. - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

PROS 1. Friendly Staff 2. Personal Pie, Mushrooms, Spinach, Fresh Garlic and Fresh Mozzarella is BOMB!!!!! 3. Reasonable Prices. CONS 1. Meatball Parmesan Sandwich needs Extra Italian Flavor in the Meatballs. Perhaps, some Fresh Chopped/Puree Garlic and Parsely, in the Meatball Mix? The Fresh Mozzarella, Marinara Sauce and Bread was Good. The Meatballs was so BLAND that he Marinara Sauce couldn't even Help the Meatball.... read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Personal Pie, Mushrooms, Spinach, Fresh Garlic and Fresh Mozzarella. Soooooo Goooood and Flavorful. - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

See all

Pizza was ok. I ordered for pick up, they said 20min. My husband got there in 15min and our pizza box was wide open. By the time the pizza made it to me (8min away) pizza was cold.. tasted like cardboard with tomato sauce and cheap cheese. I really think if I would have ate it hot then it would have tasted differently. The buffalo wings were good - cold but good. A little spicer than expected. The medium pizza was small. Only 6 slices. My husband and I finished it really quickly- we were super hungry. read more

Hey !! If you're in Newark New Jersey and you want Primo Excellent food just come to Pacific avenue and. Stop in at Tony's. This place is like a classic old fashioned pizzeria. But the food is world class. !! 5 Star Five Diamond . Every time. And I oder from them frequently! Long before Uber eats. Or Seamless. Tony's was serving up the best stuff around. The food is great the service is Terrific and it carry's over to their delivery guys polite usually early. And always. Easy to work with I Recommend Tony's. I have for over 8 yrs I am a regular restaurant reviewer I'm hard to please. Tony's is hands down the best read more

One star for having the balls to stay open. I'm not sure how they stay open, must be run by gangstas as a front for a different business. Pizza was dry, bread stale and soda was old. The cook was nice and probably a chippendale because he had a nice butt. Very firm. Hope he didn't teabag my pizza with his weinie. Never return read more

Tony's Pizzeria - This IS NOT on the menu. I wish it was - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

I've never gone to the locations, but I, always order when I'm at work or when Idon't want to cook at home so, I call for their great meals.

Ordered a pizza and garlic knots from Tony's using Grubhub. Took almost two hours to get order and it arrived barely warm and felt and tasted like it had been reheated. The garlic knots had very little flavor and the pizza was slightly burnt on the edges. read more

Love their Buffalo wings and pizza. Fried Oreos are a sweet treat to add at the end of dinner. Tony's is my go to pizzeria in Newark.

I was in Newark, at the airport and wanted something delivered. Pizza was recommended by the hotel staff- this place specifically. I ordered a large pie- margherita 16.95 Wings 12pc 16.45 Garlic knots w marinara sauce 3.00 I had a coupon for free fried Oreos Also ordered extra ranch cups 0.50 each. Took right at an hour to deliver - came to the room- which was nice. Only downside was I was missing a few items on the order- it took about another hour for them to bring the forgotten items. But the food was tasty - fresh- and prepared well. Enough food for 2-3ppl *** I'd recommend asking for extra garlic butter sauce on garlic knots. read more

Over an 1hr and 40 mins for delivery via the Slice app. No refund or credit and the food was dry stale lukewarm. Do not bother.

Tony's pizzeria was a great pizza place for ironbound pizza. Got the special which had several toppings. Great crust and taste to this pizza. The sizes are perfect for anything you need and a great variety for any taste bud. Will definitely be back just great pizza and friendly staff. read more

The food was so good about 3-4 years ago. I dont know what happened it gets worse and worse everytime I order. I use to love their food so I keep giving them another chance, just to be disappointed. It'll never happen again though read more

Terrible customer service and food. This place doesn't even deserve a 3 star overall rating. Obviously will never come here again. Their menu has a veggie pizza that doesnt list cheese as an ingredient while all the other pizzas do. What comes on our pizza? CHEESE. we're all lactose intolerant! also, we in caps wrote NO MUSHROOMS because one of us is deathly allergic to mushrooms. what comes on the pizza? MUSHROOMS. we order "no cheese garlic bread". what comes on the garlic bread? CHEESE. we order onion rings. those were just trash. tasted like frozen generic brand onion rings. we had to wait an hour and a half for delivery when the place is less than 6 mins away from us by car. we couldn't drive, and figured delivery would be a good option. WRONG. delivery.com was finally able to help us after the rude woman on the phone at Tony's kept us on hold for 30 mins AND hung up on us. We called delivery.com TWICE though to finally get the order refunded. Tony's is a joke and their staff is even worse. We got our refund, but I still want everyone to know what kind of business they're supporting. Good luck to you if you try this place. read more

The pizza was average, what was good to average was the service. This was a delivery order. I asked the employee an estimated time. I was told 1 hour, estimated. A bit long but reasonable. 2 hours and 20 minutes later, the pizza finally arrived. Even an exceptional pizza is not worth 2+ hours. My recommendation, choose another provider. read more

DO NOT ORDER!! (Cancel your order while ahead) I ordered this New Year's Day I hope for something quick and easy. It was so bad! It took way to long and I ordered through Grubhub. I know food can be average and it was SO BAD! Cheapest ingredients! The costumer service was terrible!! I am not the type to complain but it was terrible. I spend $45!! The pizza was terrible the garlic notes were JUST DOUGH!! The pasta was way below average. I'm confused how you mess up pasta this badly and PIZZA!! It made me sick!!! The guy did not believe in refunds or anything but everyone on the pizza was falling apart. read more

4/5 When I ordered on phone, the food was kinda messy? The cheese was everywhere with the pepperoni . But at least it was good!

I actually think this is the go to spot. Their specialty pizza is bomb! Had the chicken Marsala and it didn't disappoint . Glad they have fried oreos as they are my fav. Also, cute touch with the specialty sodas which are tasty too. read more

Tony's Pizzeria - Housemade Soda - Pizza Near Me - Newark, New Jersey

See all

Gotta add a star: Bruschetta is amazing. Definitely one of the best bruschettas I have had- garlicky, lots of tomatoes, crispy bread. Loved it. Also, the eggplant ricotta pizza is one of my favorite pies. I think the trick is ordering of the menu (not necessarily slices). Also the prices are amazing. Seriously. Pretty good pizza! Been here a few times and they also saved me by delivering me food on the last snow day. I've tried various slices, the eggplant parmesan plate, an eggplant parmesan sandwich, a tortellini cheese based soup, and the barbecue chicken pizza. The pizza is generally good. They usually have a variety of different slices (particularly earlier in the day) and it's all reasonably priced. My favorite was the barbecue chicken and the pepperoni. A couple of the other specialties were a slight let down (for example, the cheese steak). The tortellini "soup" was very heavy-- cheese tortellini floating in a creamy cheese bath. I had it on a cold, snowy day so it was fine but normally I think it would be too heavy. The portions are very good, especially for the price. One small pet peeve is that when you order a slice to go, they put it on a regular plate in a brown paper bag which can get messy (rather than a box). I've had some great things, some okay things, and a couple of things that did not really hit the spot. I'll keep going back though because it is a pretty good spot and definitely one of the better ones in the area. read more

I must say, I have order from many places and this spot has to be the worst so far. My Oder came within normal time but the pizza was oily and salty. Also, my order was not fresh, it was reheated. I could tell by toughness of the bread. They just need to change the quality of making their food, from start to finish. read more

My kids absolutely love Tony's pizza , always fresh dough , pizza always baked perfectly, very reasonable price , fast pick up and delivery service , their pasta dishes are also very good, love their Chicken Parm Ala Vodka , the sauce taste like homemade !!! read more

I got some food as a treat. I got calamari, mussels and an eggplant Parmesan sandwich. I told them light crust on the calamari and specifically said no lemon as I'm allergic. What did I get? Lemon soaked dry and fishy tasting and tough! The mussels were bitter meaning they are old. The sauce would have their ancestors kicking them out of the family tree! Owner called and told me not to order from them anymore! YA THINK?? Thank God GrubHub gladly refunded my money. Rude non-cooking "so and so". read more

After eating what felt like a feast for lunch during New Years Day, I relaxed around the house. Hours later we wanted something to eat, but what?!? Luckily Tony's was open!!! I called to place an order for a medium pie for delivery around 8:45 pm. They said it would take roughly an hour and 30 minutes to deliver. Umm... pickup?? 30 minutes! I understand its New Years, and they are probably super busy. Who doesn't eat pizza during the holidays--scratch that--every day? I'm about a 5 minute drive, so I thought that the better option was to pickup. I usually order from Tony's a couple of times a year, and the pizza is always great! Sometimes their delivery--New Years or otherwise, isn't the greatest, but I can tell you that the food and prices are worth it! read more

See all