Not bad for a local, neighborhood spot. Plenty of inexpensive offerings, good value, cheerful service.

Everything needs to be improved because clearly everything is nasty. How are you a pizzeria and your pizza is doughy and chewy. And the pizza wasn't even hot for the pepperoni to be burnt around the edges. It was by far the greasiest pizza I have ever had in my life to the point that it spilled all over the table all over the bag and my jacket. Now don't get me wrong. I know some pizzas have grease and they drip, but this look like they poured a whole bottle of oil onto the pizza . And the burnt pepperoni with a warm pizza means the oven is distributing heat unevenly. I was greeted when I walked in of course but you could tell they don't really clean everything correctly. But I only ordered because I haven't been here in over 12 yrs or so and the first time I went there I had a chicken Caesar salad pizza and that pizza was good But I'd also think it was around the time they just opened across the street from pizza center. The only reason why the store is open because Hispanics are very loyal to each other and they will keep going to this location but if I was the owner, I would look at my menu and fix everything because I ordered a salad also and it was disgusting. I threw it away just like I threw the pizza away. I wasted my money going here. read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Chicken Chef Salad (Large) - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

Good food with reasonable prices the new workers are much more pleasant than the last ones

Great pizza and has gotten better over the years. Quick delivery and great service. Thanks guys

I usually frequent another pizza place on Main Street but I was coming from the library and decided to give this place a try. The employees are very nice and service was prompt but the pizza wasn't that great. It's not terrible, I've just had better. read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Combo #2: 1 plain slice, 1 special slice and small drink for $5.99 - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

This restaurant is such a great place to eat. Great staff. Food is amazing. I have had items from their awesome chicken Ceasar salad to their great pizza...spaghetti and meatballs to their fabulous penne Alfredo with grilled or breaded chicken. They give you great portions at a great price. It's worth trying your favorite foods from Antonaldos! From John C West Orange NJ! read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

One word: AMAZING!!! Super fast delivery,,, Just 1 slice, I am already full, yummmm read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - 22. Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

See all

great pizza and great customer service very clean also great eats and very nice people! read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - a view of the inside of a restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

My friend and I wanted pizza and we decided to try Antonaldo's on a whim. Food: 3/5 The baked ziti was really good. We couldn't stop eating it. It was SUPER cheesy. The pizza though was disappointing. It arrived cold and wasn't very flavorful. The garlic bread was good, but I didn't eat much 'cause I filled up on ziti :p Staff: N/A Atmosphere: N/A Price: 5/5 Reasonably priced for big portions Overall, not that impressed. The ziti was good, but I would rather go elsewhere for my pizza. read more

See all

The customer service was awful he sound like he is talking rudely to you but overall the food was good but the customer service was terrible he talks to you rudely and it sounds like he is mad at you when all you want to do is order a pizza but u can't and he make you wait 1 hours or 20 minutes for a pizza that don't take that long to make read more

so we ordered lunch from out office from antonaldo's and we all ate the pizza and when my coworker bit into her slice she found a roach cooked inside of it!!!!! disgusting!!! we pulled it out with a fork just to make sure and it was def a roach we have photos for proof. i called the place spoke with the manager and he told me to " do what i want with it!" im disgusted and very upset read more

See all

Overall, the pizza was really good. The place is a little small and there was no AC, so I had to take my pizza to go. I also did not like that there were individuals standing outside just waiting and begging for money. I know that it is no fault of the establishment, but it makes me not want to return. The pizza, was everything. The crust was thin, just the way I like it and it had really good flavor. read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

See all

Came in around 7:30pm on a Thursday just to grab a quick slice to hold me over until I got home to eat dinner. Never been here before but it looks clean and I was starting to catch a hunger headache. Any who, the staff looked like they were cleaning up, maybe coming to the end of the day or business was slow. I looked at the display case and saw this yummy looking pizza. When I asked her the girl at the counter told me (in a tone that made it seem like she was not in a talking mood) that it was chicken bacon ranch and tomato. I was sold. I bought the slice and my goodness it was delicious! The crust wasn't too hard or doughy and the pizza was thin and crispy, just the way I like it. The only reason I won't give this place 4 stars is because I was extremely hungry-- I'll have to go back on another day to see if it's really that good-- and because the girl at the counter wasn't so friendly. read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Chicken, bacon, ranch pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

‍. I'll say first that the order was correct...as in they prepared what I ordered according to the written requests. Driver refused to even enter my building let alone come up to my unit. So much for social distancing. Pizza was really not good....undercooked and a serious lack of sauce. Like almost none. Thank god they sent the requested cup of sauce on the side....and even then it was seriously dry. What a disappointment. read more

First order ever... the margarita pizza is horrible and came soggy. Chicken wings are ok. Delivery was fine and prompt. You cannot mess up a margarita like this.... cheese is shitty, water in the middle of the pizza!, and the basil looks like it was chopped to death and most of ended up in the garbage...because my "margarita" has barely any basil.... the delivery person was nice...ONLY PLUS. read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

The food is good but the customer service is horrible. The way they talk to folks is disgusting just hate how good the food is but not the customer service. I always order from this place was the first time I ordered for delivery got really sassy person answering the phone. read more

They do deliver to East Orange! Please fix this Yelp/grubhub, thanks I have to call them and order via phone otherwise.

I came here when a pizza place a block away was closed and left satisfied. I posed the price in the photo I posted (2.75) if I remember correctly which was just perfect. The guys who work here had me laughing and are pretty relaxed. I've had some great pizza in the area and Antonaldo's is definitely among the better ones. read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

This was my first time ordering from this restaurant. It was horrible!! They got my entire order wrong forgot to put in the shrimp in my ravioli and did not give me vodka sauce instead decided to take it upon themselves to change it to red sauce when I bit into the ravioli I found a piece of plastic. I'm assuming that they just buy the food from somewhere else, defrosted, and then give it to you. This was literally the worst Italian restaurant I have ever been to in my entire life. Thank God Uber gave me my money back or else I would've called the restaurant myself to get it. Don't even waste your time just go to a different restaurant. read more

The food is always fresh and hot. The best pizza store in Jersey if I do say so myself. I'll never order from another pizza store again. You have to get the calzones they are big and worth the price, you can fill it with anything just like your pizza toppings. read more

I ordered three items from this establishment on Seamless. I only got 2, with a $15.99 item missing. I reported the loss to Seamless, who informed me Antonaldo's refused to issue a refund. I've never review-bombed a restaurant. Confrontation makes me uncomfortable. But if you charge me $15.99 for something you never delivered, then you are a thief. Plain and simple. The food was good (especially the pizza), but if these yokels make a mistake, you should expect that they will make it at your expense. Generally speaking, I try to avoid merchants who consider theft an acceptable option. I suggest you do too. Fiamma and Angelo's are both better in quality and delivery service. read more

Small pizza place just down the street from a school where I was presenting at a PD. Pizza slices are on the smallish side but the prices are on the cheaper side so that evens out. The taste isn't horrendous. What is horrendous is I saw a young male walk in smoking a cigarette and nobody who worked there said a word. The smell of that thing filled the air on a hot, muggy day and no A/C. See ya. Never would go back. read more

I ate a delicious slice of Sicilian pizza at Antonaldo's Pizza on the fourth night they opened on Main St in Orange, NJ. I was in town and early for a meeting so thought I would drop into this local eatery - and was so glad I did! The decor is simple but very clean. They had lots of specialty and more traditional slices available to order from at very reasonable prices. The owner (I assumed he was the owner) was there, preparing the slices and just beaming about his newly-opened place. They had all kinds of traditional Italian dinners available, freshly made to order, in addition to the large pizza selection. I wish Antonaldo's all the best in their new business and plan to be a regular customer whenever I am in the area. read more

Okay this has to stop as I want to use cuss words really bad but I respect kids might read it so obviously iam upset with this mockery of a pizza parlor I think the disturbing part is the 29 people that gave good reviews that brought me to this hell hole of a place listen to me I won't steer you wrong this place the food it leaves a dirty after taste in your mouth I'll definitely use disinfect to clean my mouth then smoke a cigarette to get that dirty taste out listen to me Yelpers they can't even deliver pizza cheese on one side sauce on the other first time experience eating from here the worst no The F____ing worst I would pay 100.00 dollars for a quality pizza than spend thirty for some sh_&@#$ don't say I didn't tell you stay away. read more

The food taste good but service is poor. I drive usually 2 miles to pick up my sandwiches here or I order on uber eats. This time I called. I just had a thyroid operation and cannot speak loudly the manager/owner said he could not hear me and take him off speaker I tried to explain I was driving and because of my operation I could not speak louder and he hung up!!!! read more

Do not order from this place. It's garbage! This is my first review. Tonight was the worst experience I had with ordering takeout of any kind. I had ordered from them previously, without any issue. Tonight, around 6:30 I placed an order for a pie, a salad, and some drinks. I got a confirmation that it would be delivered between 7:40 and 7:50. Time passes, and around 8 pm, I place a call to the restaurant, I get it it's a Saturday and all, and they tell me, he's on the way. After nobody showing up, I call again, and this time, they play dumb about the order, and while I was in mid-sentence relaying the information he hangs up on me. read more

This probably the best pasta I had in a long time. You create your own pasta from the pasta you want, to sauce, meat and any extra stuff you want, small or big bowl. I can eat here over and over again I can not get tired of it. Every single thing I eat from here is LIT! I recommend it. P.s. I'm no Gordon Ramsay or Guy Fieri but the food is the SHIT! read more

Just ordered a cheese pie through Seamless. I got there a few minutes early and the pizza was ready. The staff was very friendly. The pizza itself was decent. Nothing great, nothing bad, but decent. It's hard coming from NYC where great pizza is everywhere. read more

The pizza is fabulous I couldn't believe it took me so long to find such a wonderful place that was so close. The cheese melts in your mouth the tomato sauce is subtle yet sweet and potent. The chicken wings were a little bit extra fried but to die for. It was real chicken! The buffalo sauce had an extra hot dang with a subtle hint of Crystal hot sauce. It was definitely Crystal's hot sauce but I love crystals hot sauce so was totally worth it. It came faster than I thought it would being that I ordered delivery which was perfect because I was starving. But the whole feel of the entire meal was to die for I would definitely order here again and if I lived in New Jersey this would be my frequent Pizza Stop. I wonder if it's too late to order the chicken parm salad. Would definitely recommend this place if you're looking for great food at a reasonable price. In the end I ended up paying $30 for seven pieces of chicken wings and a large pizza with extra cheese and boy was it worth it. Happy eating folks read more

Antonaldo's Pizza - Looks delicious... Let's taste and review this bad boy - Pizza Near Me - Orange, New Jersey

I had there Penn chicken vodka sauce and it was so good. I ordered the small and it was a good amount. This place is worth trying. I will definitely be ordering from here again. read more

Writing a review for take-out & delivery only! I'm a huge fan of this place. The food is delicious and affordable. I love their veggie panini, garlic bread, pizza, and salads. You can't go wrong with this place. Their only hiccup is that it takes a long time to deliver (at least an hour) but if you go there you are taken care of right away by friendly staff. read more

Horrible customer service and I never see any of the people who make the food wear gloves !!! Do not go there !

Best Pizza I've had in New Jersey so far, Main Reason I stopped ordering dominos is because of this establishment.

It really only takes one incident to lose a frequent customer. If the front desk asks you to sign in so you can go upstairs [especially In a high rise building] just sign in. How embarrassing to tell them no. Just write the name of the restaurant and call it a day. Also your garlic bread sucks. read more

Very disappointed in my order I just received I ask for penne vodka with breaded chicken meat was mushy just horrible no flavor what so ever pizza was average read more

Love this place and delivery service is really good.

Wow food was delicious!! Great portion and taste excellent! The home made bread is amazing soft and fresh! We had the penne pasta and vodka sauce with chicken and shrimp and the chicken parm dinner!! Simply delicious!! Was delivered and was still piping hot!! Love this place read more

My delivery was early, driver was friendly. The food was amazing, fresh and hot. I would definitely order again.

Finally a pizzeria in Orange worth ordering from. Grade-A Buffalo Chicken slice. Definitely the best food near the train station. Owner is friendly, and more than that, he seems to care that I'm happy with my order. This place is brand new, and if you've ever had pizza from trattoria in South Orange, this is very similar. Worth giving it a shot. read more

I ordered yesterday the egg plant parm . I must say I was very disappointed . The egg plant was not cooked completely . The dish was ultra bland no flavor the noodles were under cooked . The garlic bread was a roll with garlic powder and butter I'm not sure if they rushed cooked the order being that it was a delivery order . I won't be ordering from there again ! read more