Once again, I was so impressed with the food and the service. Anas was our waiter and he was awesome as ever. Raul spent time with us at our table making us feel warm and welcome. I love dining here. Simply one of the best experiences in SOMA. -Fr. Jim Worth Pastor of St. Joseph in Maplewood read more

Upon walking up to mozzarella, you're greeted with this corner property that is dark and alluring with beautiful lighting & red napkins, first thing through the windows. When you enter the front is like any other pizzeria where you can order a slice for take away. Once you come around there's a full seating area, equipped for small and large groups. My partner had a margarita pie and a kale Caesar salad. Both were beautiful and tasty. I had the pesto with homemade pasta and grilled salmon. Also beautiful and tasty. I think the food is reasonably priced and the servers mean well. They want you to enjoy your experience and get exactly what you want. Although our server missed the mark a couple of times everything was OK. I'll be back to check out other items on the menu. read more

Mozzarella - MARGHERITA pie - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

Mozzarella is truly one of the best italian restaurants I have been to in New Jersey. Everything is made fresh, the atmosphere is calm, intimate, and super clean. I have to commend the team for making us feel so welcomed. The pizza was my favorite, and the entire party enjoyed everything that was ordered. I highly recommend their black cherry soda along with ordering a nice pizza pie. I was very surprised to see that this place hasn't been reviewed on here yet! read more

See all

Mozzarella has amazing food, service, atmosphere, and decor. Inside, outside patio or enclosed patio expect expert friendly service serving decadent and lavishly presented food that is consistently delicious. I love this little gem in South Orange. read more

See all

I was in the mood for Italian recently because I haven't had it in a while, so I ordered from Mozzarella for my Italian fix. Got the chicken Francese with Angel hair pasta. I enjoyed it, however, the chicken wasn't very saucy..but it was still delicious and fresh nonetheless. If I order from here again, I'll probably request that they make the chicken a little bit more saucy or put it in a separate container. I believe the sauce from the chicken was absorbed by the pasta since the pasta sat right underneath the chicken. I definitely wouldn't mind trying more dishes from here.. read more

See all

Service was amazing. My friend and I went here for lunch on a Wednesday and they were empty. You walk in and it's a pizza counter but then to your right is an elegant dining area. My friend said they mastered a balance of casual and fancy dining. He also said he'd give this place five stars based on service. Andrew was our server. He was super informative and personable. I got the crispy eggplant sliders and penne vodka. The crispy eggplant sliders were delicious. I enjoyed that the slider is on garlic knots. I would get this again. The penne vodka was good, but I'd try something else. My friend got a salad which looked super yummy. This is a good place for a date. Just a heads up, there is service charge of 18%, and tipping is optional. Excited to go back and try something else! read more

See all

Love this spot! Mozzarella in South Orange is such a gem -- cozy, welcoming, and BYOB (which is always a win in my book). The service was super friendly and attentive without being overbearing. We tried a few comfort food staples and everything hit the spot. I'm definitely coming back to try the pizza and mozzarella sticks -- heard they're a must. The interior is really cute too, and it works well whether you're coming with a date or a small group. Great vibe all around. read more

See all

I've been to Mozz two separate times. I enjoy the modern Italian menu. I like a good red sauce joint as much as anybody else but we have enough of 'em around here. I think I accidentally got the same thing or similar both times because all the ingredients appeal to me so much. I ordered the Mediterranean pasta (I chose the pappardelle) which is tossed with a slow-roasted cherry tomato confit, capers, Kalamata olives and crisp, seasoned toasted breadcrumbs. I've also had the same server twice and he is VERY attentive and will carefully describe items to you and suggest his recommendations. The ambiance is casual and the decor is a sleek clean modern situation. There's a lickee store right across the street if you want to BYO. I also appreciate their eco-friendly to-go packaging. read more

See all

Food was delicious and the waiter was very kind and friendly. Definitely recommend for an intimate dinner. The ambiance is very welcoming and cozy. read more

We visit Mozzarella for lunch on a Saturday. The space is very sweet and elegantly decorated, especially for the holidays. The lunch was fine, it wasn't anything we would have to return for. We had the ribeye ciabatta and the blackened caesar wrap. It all tasted like anything from a local deli would taste. The service was friendly. I would come back to try dinner, as the pasta plates looked great. read more

See all

Our Favorite Neighborhood Date Night Spot. Great service and healthy servings of all the items we order. BYOB. read more

See all

Beautiful interior and the service was very friendly and attentive. We made a reservation and they were very kind to accommodate us with little notice. We ordered the eggplant parm, chicken Marsala and the fish with risotto and veggies. Everything was delicious and the prices were extremely reasonable. A quality sit down family restaurant. I would absolutely come back. read more

See all

I wanted to like this restaurant but it fell short, especially for the price. The pizza (10" margherita) for $19 had a crust alike store-bought white bread and toppings that were flavorless. The two desserts, tiramisu and brownie were $8 each and pretty average. If the prices were lower I would be less critical. It's possible they shine with their pastas or other menu items, but I was dissatisfied with what I ordered. read more

Mozzarella - Brownie - not their strong suit - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

The pizza is great here and the fried calamari is delicious.amazing decor around the place too.the waiter was kind and engaged in small talk.beautiful restaurant overall. read more

I have never eaten here, only ordered online. The food is great tasting, fair price, fast delivery.

Triple floyds brewery was well represented here a great place for BYOB & Italian fare.

Tried Mozarella for the first time tonight to meet up with friends. Pros: Convenient location Street parking available Accepts walk-ins Reasonable pricing Nice staff Nice ambiance Cons: - Bit of long wait for food - The food was missing seasoning/flavor - Known for their mozzarella sticks, but the breading was very dry and average I had an okay experience. I wish the food was better in the flavor department. The food wasn't inedible, but it was kind of bland and dry, in my opinion. Long story short, I would say i would grab maybe grab some appetizers for llunch if I was in the area, but the food doesn't really stick out to me, so I wouldn't go out of my way to eat here often. read more

Mozzarella - Mozarella sticks - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

Maybe I just had a bad run of it because I see this place is usually busy but I ordered a cheese pizza and it tasted /felt like the dough was bought premade from a grocery store . The calamari was rubbery and had a weird stench to it. Maybe entree items are good but a definitely would try other places for pizza and calamari . read more

Good place, cute design. FYI it's no longer halal. Pros: - no reservation needed for a weekend group visit, lots of space - not that expensive for the amount of food you get - lots of street parking - food tastes good! The pastas and pizza are great, the dessert and mozzarella sticks weren't that great Cons: - no longer halal, and they didn't have that update advertised when we went. We just happened to be told by the waiter that it changed - took a loooong time to get the food - the mozzarella sticks were large but not that good tbh, tasted plain and dry It's a nice place to visit if you're in the area! But I wouldn't go out of my way to go again. read more

See all

Just tried this place tonight for the first time and it was sooo good!! Hands down my favorite pizza in Long Island! It my new go to! I definitely want to try other things on the menu as well, but for now I'm stuffed! read more

Super good and the service was awesome! Really cool vibe to the place and food was good. Steak seemed to be good too ! read more

Mozzarella - Eggplant Parmigianna with Pasta - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

I. always try to support local businesses when possible. Hence my wanting to visit Mozarella again. First time I visited was about a year ago. I can't remember what I ordered and don't think I left a review, but I do recall that whatever I ate tasted good. I also remember the very large calamari rings that were very chewy and only 2 or three was what I could eat. I prefer the smaller ones. So back I go and visited yesterday, May 19, to this cute and homey restaurant. Our server was the very polite and sweet Halit, who we didn't see again after he delivered our very meager salad. I'll forgive him this time. He was the server last time and was polite then. So I'll cut him a break for being a Houdini. Our order (to be shared and brought out by another server) was as follows: Appetizers: Greek salad. Ordered the regular at &14.95, not an appetizer. It was supposed to arrive with lettuce, tomatoes, red, green, bell peppers, red onions, feta and kalamata olives. What I got was more like a cheap salad. It resembled one of those little salads that you get on a little side dish with just lettuce and tomatoes at a local takeout pizzeria. I so wish I had taken a photo. But the person that I was with immediately started serving the salad and we started talking, which is when I realize that I forgot to take a picture, when we were foraging for the promised items that were not delivered. For $14.95, I got two little Kalamata olives. Lots of lettuce, a few tidbits of green and red pepper and two itty-bitty pieces of feta cheese. Seriously, no lie I am not exaggerating here. Fried calamari with the red sauce. Still the big rings, but with extra crunch and less chewing. A bit over fried for my tastes. Wild mushroom ravioli: listed as having a filling of ricotta and wild mushroom, fresh Italian herbs, and wild mushroom truffle cream sauce on a bed of baby arugula in lemon poppyseed dressing. Oh wow this sounded so delish! It was good, but on paper! Someone must have mixed up the lemon poppyseed and gave me balsamic. I don't like balsamic vinaigrette unless it's balsamic fig. Nowhere did I taste mushroom truffle cream sauce or any type of lemon poppy. It just tasted like balsamic. I did see poppy seeds but I know for a fact that some balsamic was in there. The other dish we got was a Ricotta cheese ravioli with pesto sauce. The pesto sauce was definitely lacking in flavor. It needed salt. It needed flavor. It needed to taste like pesto. Maybe the basil wasn't fresh. I'm beginning to feel very cheated. Thankfully, that is all we ordered. This time around the meal was not so great. I think Houdini knew this, which is why he was hiding. He must've been onto something I don't know. I did call him over and told him about my meager Greek salad that really wasn't Geeek. He said he will speak to the manager and get back to me. So he returned and said that they can order me a new salad to take home. At this point, I no longer want a salad. I requested 50% off the salad and he said he will speak to the manager. He returned and said that they can only offer us 25% off, which turned out to be $3.50. So they would have rather give me an entire salad than to remove at least 50% and chance a less than stellar review. Did I tell you folks that I feel very, very, very cheated? Would I return maybe, last resort if I can't find another place to eat last minute. I don't know. Maybe try the pizza pies, which looked good. I want to give them another chance, but... PS: bread is not offered here. For the broke folks, there is a five dollar liquor fee for byob. My bottle had a screw cap, but they did bring two glasses and one of the tall thin buckets of ice. If you want to savefuve bucks, skip the ice bucket and glasses and take a swig out of the bottle and maybe you will. read more

The inside of Mozzarella is very homey and decorated really nicely. I would suggest having a reservation, we went on Tuesday and it was empty on arrival but completely full mid dinner. The food here was alright which was disappointing. A lot of the dishes were missing flavor or salt. We had the mozzarella sticks, truffle fries, calamari for appetizers which were okay. For my entree I had the chicken fettuccine. The chicken was good but the pasta was very bland. read more

See all

Excellent service, (our waiter was super friendly, knowledgeable and engaging) superb salads, great mozzarella sticks and we had the homemade cavatelli and meatballs ! Plus I love the decor. Can't wait to go back and try more and maybe next time sit in their garden room or whatever they call it. We will be back soon for sure ! read more

sat outside for the first time here & our server was so kind & attentive! the outdoor area was also lovely. food was excellent as always. the best part of the meal was the dessert, tiramisu in a glass. the cavatelli & broccoli rabe was also 10/10 read more

Mozzarella - tiramisu & crème brûlée - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

See all

Food is good. They added an 18% dine in charge. I guess it makes sense because their take out biz is huge and the cost to serve inside is higher. So they have essentially set a higher dine in price. The 18% goes to the restaurant, not the wait staff... it's not a tip. They also pay the wait staff a "living wage," as explained to me by our waiter. So tipping is optional. None of this is explained beyond the note on the menu... "18% charged for dine in." So that's my criticism... it should be explained. Don't make me have to ask the waiter what it all means. Don't make me risk over or under tipping. Don't make me uncomfortable to visit again. read more

Sat on outside patio. Very comfortable with the warm weather, did sit on folding chairs but they had a cushion so definitely was not uncomfortable. I split the twin heart pizzas, eggplant sandwich on garlic knots, side of parmesan risotto, and hot honey chicken wings. Pizza was delicious and cute that both came out in heart shape. Vodka pizza and regular were both good. Eggplant sandwich was fun on the garlic knot, wish it was bigger. I thought parmesan risotto didn't have a ton of flavor but maybe would be good paired with a meat dish instead of just on its own. Chicken wings were fine but if I came back, I'd definitely get pizza. Service was fine, nothing bad to say about it. read more

Food was awful. They put anchovies on the kid pasta! Even with the anchovies removed my kid refused it. Who can blame her. Who wants spaghetti with essence of salted fish! They can't read or follow instructions either, I noted no Parmesan for the meatball side and of course it came with Parmesan. Both of the pasta entrees for me and my husband were bland with barely any sauce. And all dishes were cold. Even the chocolate fudge cake was a bust and was so dry. read more

See all

It's jammed packed tonite the poor waitress sherry is running to get to everyone..God Bless her she deserves a raise immediately!!! We love everything on the menu it's sooo good Not just a pizza place the menu is amazing Very innovative read more

See all

The two stars are for the grandma pie. The sauce is flavorful, crust is crunchy and not overdone. The basil adds freshness. The pie was oily though, not sure if they drizzled oil on top? The classic cheese pie is very basic and nothing special at all. Tasted a bit bland. Mozzerella sticks were awful. The breading had no flavor, felt like I was eating cardboard with cheese in the middle. This place is $$$ for the quality of food you're getting, not worth it! Our server was friendly but there was another server walking around with her mask under her nose...this was disappointing to see. read more

See all

After seeing a friend visit this spot and a couple of Tik Tok-ers I had to visit as I LOVE mozzarella sticks! Ambiance: Warm and cozy. They have Christmas decor as well as a tree up right now. There are a couple of tables as well as high chair seating facing the windows. Tables are social distanced which is a plus as well. I overall loved the ambiance. Parking: Plenty of street parking. I visited on a Sunday afternoon so it wasn't busy at all. Food/Pricing: They give complimentary bread and marinara sauce to start. The bread resembled a garlic knot. For apps, we started off the mozzarella sticks which come with 4 in an order ($9). The cheese pull? IT'S SERIOUS! The mozzarella sticks were nicely breaded on the outside, cheesy on the inside. Paired with marinara sauce for dipping it was a great start to our meals. This spot has so much to choose from so it was hard to narrow it down. I decided on the fettuccine alfredo ($15) with shrimp ($6); super good! The portion was enough to take home for dinner too. $6 for shrimp was cheap for the size and amount they loaded in my pasta. My friend ordered the eggplant parm and let me tell you, the eggplant, delish! I love how they give you your own water pitcher, plastic cups and utensils. Service: The lady was quick and friendly. She continuously cleaned off our tables which was great/ Will I come back? Most definitely! I'm already planning my next visit. read more

Mozzarella - Mozzarella Sticks - Salad Near Me - South Orange, New Jersey

Pizza and customer service was good. Cute establishment to take friends and family. Will return even though my trip was for take-out.

The Rhode Island calamari is out of this world! Tender and scrumptious and the sweet peppers make it the best dish in the house. Love it!

Waiters rushed our meal to the point where someone was eating sandwich on the walk back to the car. There was no one else in the restaurant. Mozzarella sticks were great. The rest of the food was ok, a little plain especially considering the price. Some were too salty and some not salted at all. Ambience was nice, good for big parties. read more

Location and ambiance is great. Food is amazing. Best seafood pizza! Wish they had more pizza options.. BYOB kinda place. Will be back for sure read more

I've only gotten take out here but their food is really good. The kale and quinoa salad is my fave! Fresh kale, avocado, tomatoes with a tangy dressing (but not too tangy!). Pizza is great also. Decor reminds me of rustic charm, cozy and inviting. Servers are always pleasant. One of my go to local places. Check it out! read more

Cute and casual spot to grab lunch or dinner! Definitely a bit tight in the seating area (I thought it was larger when looking up pics), but the service was quick and the place was clean so I was a happy camper. My friend and I weren't super hungry so we split a pasta dish and salad. Ordered the roasted cauliflower arugula salad and wild mushroom ravioli. Both were good and I appreciate that they didn't skimp out on the mushrooms in the pasta dish. FYI - BYOB read more

Really good find! We actually found this spot from no eats tik tok LOL, definitely lived up to the hype. It was byob so we brought a bottle of wine to enjoy with all the food. For pizzas we got the spinach pie which was amazing, has feta and olives which adds a nice flavor twist. We also got the pesto pie which was really good. You've GOT to get the mozzarella sticks here, that cheese pull was unreal. And finally we got the eggplant parm special with vodka sauce pasta as our side. All the food was really good, definitely recommend this spot, and it's in a very cute town! read more

See all

I can't believe that I waited this long to try this spot. Beautiful & rustic ambiance, friendly & prompt service, and delicious food. The pizzas were on point, the brussels sprouts are to die for and the calamari is cut thick and spicy. Would absolutely return! read more

I've come by here a few times while in town. I've tried the franchise, salmon , and garlic knots food is always great.