This was my second time here for breakfast and it was just as delicious as the first time ! The restaurant is in an amazing historic building . The servers are so friendly and upbeat . Order the tomato pie it is a must try ....tasty and cheesy . I had basic scrambled eggs, roasted potatoes and yummy grain toast, very well made . The coffee is also excellent , smooth ,not bitter ! We also ordered sandwiches to go so we had something for lunch . I had a chicken and pesto panini and even cold it was delicious! read more

See all

A small group of ladies selected this restaurant because it is known for the tomato pie. We ordered to share. It was very good. One girl ordered the turkey & brie on croissant. That's where my rating comes in. It was NOT brie cheese, I couldn't taste ANY brie. When I called the waitress over, she said 'there it is' & pointed to a 'spread' that resembled mayo. After her saying that, it still didn't taste like brie cheese. The sandwich also had a slim amount of fig jam on it, not enough to bring in the sweet flavor to the sandwich. (disappointed) read more

My fiancé and I have been talking about coming back here for a year. We haven't stopped talking about their French press in that long. Genuinely one of the best cups of coffee I've had in America. I got the tomato pie turnover (omelette) and it was delicious. And he got the grain bowl..? Something like that. I love coming here. The food is fresh and healthy and about delicious. The brown buttered scone was so good. It's cute, cozy, and just feels like an elevated grandmas kitchen. 15/10 read more

See all

Philly Cheesesteak Hash with two dippy eggs and sourdough bread slice...sooooo good. Service was excellent, friendly, and fast. Coffee was great. All food was fast and more importantly, hot! Live in Lititz and don't get here enough. Sat at the window with a great view of Lititz Springs Park. read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Philly Cheesesteak Hash with two dippy eggs and a slice of sourdough bread. - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Very popular place in a very quaint area. We tried the storied tomato pie to share. Dear Lord! Lots and lots of cheese. It had the best non-home cooked pie crust I have ever had. I am a baker and I know good baking. This crust is excellent! It's the best I've ever eaten outside my home or my mother's kitchen. We also split strawberry packages. Lovely. Only issue is two small toilet rooms. There is usually a wait. Charm of restaurants in old homes. I would at least check out the menu if you are in the area. read more

See all

whoa! thats one reaaally good tomato pie! ive never tried one before so this was a great treat! crust was so good and the tomatoes were fresh and bursting with flavor. So glad we tried their signature dish! Their cookie butter was good but a bit too sweet for me. Like sugary sweet. Ham, mushroom and cheese omelette was okay. However service was great! all the staff we encountered were nice and pleasant. Parking is kinda hard but luckily we came on an early saturday morning so the bank across was closed and the hostess mentioned we can just park there on their lot which we did lol. Inside was cozy, like going into a historic house (which it probably was idk lol). The restroom was pretty small and tight fyi. read more

See all

Great food and love the assortment of tomato pie .. it's crowded and close seating ....lots of great food .. some outside sitting... I can also order to go .. read more

It is acceptable; the portions are modest, and the food was merely satisfactory. My order was incorrect, which I assume occurred because the waitress did not write it down. Certain areas of the café are quite charming. read more

I thought they were closed on Sunday's so I ate elsewhere. I then passed the restaurant and they were open! I went inside and ordered Tomato Pie (which I've never had or heard of) to go. It was one of the best dishes I've ever had. If you have never had it it's a must. It was sheer perfection. I'm not sure how to describe it other than it was better than pizza! The young lady that took my order was extremely kind and proficient. I highly recommend this particular dish. read more

I was actually looking for a local beef burger and yelp recommended this place ( tsk, tsk...yelp) but once I got inside the ambiance of the place (and ratings) made me want to try it! Young lady in the front was super nice. Barista was also very nice. Ordered a ham sandwich, panini, mango smoothie and purple honey lavender (?) iced. Everything was delicious. If I'm around this way again I'd dine in for coffee or tea, I'd try their herb lemonade and some of the desserts that I saw others snacking on! read more

The food was good! Unfortunately the service was disappointing and we had to wait an hour for our food, while others got their food a long time before us who ordered at the same time. Although good prices and cute place! read more

Excellent! Throughly loved the Tomato Pie!! Service was great and ambiance was comfortable. read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Tomato Pie - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Loved enjoying an early breakfast in the old house-turned cafe. Staff was super friendly and fast, the 3-meat flipper and sausage bowl delicious and just the right portions. Not to be missed when in Lititz! read more

Excellent food and staff. My husband raved for days about the tomato pie. But unless you enjoy drinking pure sugar, stay away from the green smoothie. I think they put a whole pineapple plus sugar in it and I poured most of it down the sink. read more

Great food and service- charming spot in downtown Lititz for food before 2! Great menu options- no matter what be sure to get a small namesake Tomato Pie - perfect for sharing even if you're getting other menu options read more

This is a really neat place. Delicious breakfast food, I had quiche, my wife had tomato pie, which is not what you would expect, excellent coffee. We will definitely be back. read more

Cozy, friendly. Awesome tomato pie! Unlike anything I've had before. I'd come back anytime

Delicious! and excellent service. this is the very best cup of chai tea latte I have enjoyed in our greater Harrisburg area in a very long time. Don't miss it! read more

Charming diner located in an old house in the middle of Lititz. There's one parking lot well around the corner or just walk there if you're close enough. The tomato pie is a breakfast dish that's particularly delicious in the summertime when its main and eponymous ingredient is in season. Coffee is perfect and regularly refilled. Service is friendly and warm. read more

Third or fourth time here. Always a pleasure, came on Mother's Day actually around 2:30 so we got seated right away. The interior design is very comforting, historic and homey as if you're eating at home with family, a charming and quaint little cafe with surprising amount of space. Unfortunately limited outdoor space but they do have seating outside! Had the pleasure of doing both indoor and outdoor and highly recommend both! Food is ALWAYS delicious. I'm the biggest fan of their tomato pie (think of like a cheesy, tomato combo with a flaky pastry crust)! I crave it from time to time! It's always hot, melty, buttery and delicious. They had a limited menu this day but we still enjoyed all our dishes. My husband got the tomato pie flipper and finished every crumb! They also have the most delicious drinks if you like fancy coffee and chai combos, some fresh fruit lemonades too! Service is always top notch. Such kind and attentive staff, always greeting you with a smile! We never have complaints here. Overall, this is a MUST visit if you're in Lititz. Great family spot, great for couples and all. Highly recommend. We will gladly continue to be a regular here! read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

See all

Parking may be the problem. The food and service is top notch. The tomato pie is worth it a lone. We also had the peaches and cream baked oatmeal with almonds and warm milk. Was the best we ever had read more

As usual pretty busy even for a weekday around noon. Not a long wait, and seated next to the window on hwy 501. The mini pie starter was a good choice ( if you haven't had one your missing out) I also got the curry chicken salad , far too much for lunch with the starter big chunks of chicken with cranberrys onion and celery, not too spicy and a herbed scone. Spouse got the double tomato pie so she would have leftovers. Reasonable for a touristy town at$30 or so. Breakfast is served all day until 3 pm or so. read more

Beautifully repurposed house. Loved the decor but the food was the real star.the beverages were warm and flavorful. My favorite among our three dishes was the grilled pear but all dishes were very good. I have been wanting to get here for years and it didn't disappoint. Service was attentive and excellent, even in the midst of the holiday season. read more

See all

The food was good. Super small portions and lower price so I guess that works out. Service was abrupt and was quick to deliver check and want me to leave at 8am with only 2 other 4 top tables. Was told from Locals that had no meaning, just the way the owner is. Abrupt. Parking is a real issue for them as they have no parking lot. read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Tomato Pie and grits cake with sea small wedge of a scone. - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

The food here was delicious! I originally ordered chia pudding and thought it tasted off... the server was kind enough to bring me something else! I had the baked oatmeal and a coffee cake muffin. Both were really great. read more

This place was incredible! If you don't like tomatoes, try their tomatoe pie! Excellent seasoning for all the food as well! Don't skip the maple burbon latte this month! Cute inside and fancy touches. read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Maple burbon lattee 16oz, - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Cute little town with a sweet spot to grab coffee, hot choc or chai. If you looking for a large cuppachino perhaps as if they can use the hot choc cup for it otherwise it will just be a sip. Had the avo toast with egg and I wasn't mad about the mayo type sauce they had on it so perhaps ask for that on the side. Other breakfasts ordered were also ok. We needed something before going to see the wolves. If you need the loo go somewhere else this one is smaller than an airplane toilet. Service and people were very nice, and wearing hats seem to be a thing here. A hip local joint it seems. read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Fall menu - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

See all

Ordered: 12 oz White Lavender Mocha (~$4) Starter Tomato Pie (~$6): red tomatoes seasoned with herbs baked in pie shell topped with a blend of cheeses 2 Eggs (~$3): sunny side up Rosemary Potatoes (~$3) Aya's take: Not to be confused with a pizza, the Tomato Pie was super unique and worth a try! Crispy on the outside yet soft and filled with flavor on the inside. The Starter size is perfect for one person and I added the eggs and potatoes to make it a fuller breakfast which was a good move. A must try if you find yourself in Lititz! read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - 12 oz White Lavender Mocha (~$4) - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

See all

Tomato pie was a nice savory brunch. It came with a scone that had a great texture. Wouldn't recommend the carrot fries. Service and atmosphere were fine enough. read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

See all

We had the honey lavender London fog and the coconut chai latte and they were delicious! Then we had the sausage, squash and rosemary potato hash and the tomato pie flipper. Everything was so good!! read more

See all

I ordered a vegetable flipper with butternut squash and whole grain toast. Pumpkin spice latte. I did not like the squash, it was similar to applesauce but everything else was fantastic! My friend had the pumpkin pancakes that she raved about. Very cute cafe and service was great. read more

You cannot go wrong with the Tomato Pie cafe. Absolutely the BEST tomato pie ever. YUM! Either eat in or take it to go, the tomato pie is an experience for all to try. Even if you dislike them, you will love them after one bite. read more

This place kept serving up the best food and drinks all afternoon! The name sake tomato pie is spectacular and nothing like a pizza, more like a quiche without the egg. Their herbal lemonade is the best I've ever had. We also shared the curry chicken which, again, was the best I've ever had. The fog chai tea was the perfect combination and end to a wonderful meal. Thanks to Susan, our waitress, who did an amazing job and timed it all to perfection! read more

Good breakfast/brunch spot. Service was good and fast. It is a cafe with a cafe ambiance.

This was a cute quaint shop with delicious pastries, and to me unique menus breakfast brunch items. It was the first time I tried their tomato pie and it was worth it! The baked oatmeal was also a cool item to try. The tea drinks were delicious but really weak to me however, I found every morning drink I have ordered in Lancaster kinda weak. It was good but, if you like strong and bitter these drinks were light, sweet and fruity. I enjoyed the butternut squash and the salad dressing a lot!! I wish I asked if I could buy a bottle to take home read more

See all

Good food, limited parking and usually a long wait but it is worth it. I'd like to see better side options with the meals and the portions might leave you a tad hungry but overall good place would recommend read more

Bottom Line: Excellent food and service but an unconfortable atmosphere. My husband and I randomly stumbled upon the Tomato Pie Cafe in Harrisburg a few years ago so when we realized there was also a location in Lititz we were all in for a Sunday breakfast! We both loved our meals. I got the three-cheese quiche and my husband got the Tomato Pie Flipper. The quiche was served with fresh greens and a savory herb scone and I opted for a parmesan grit cake over the other choices of fruit, squash or potatoes. Between the quiche, scone and grit cake its really hard to say what the star of the meal was since all three of those items were incredibly scrumptious. My husband's breakfast, the Tomato Pie Flipper, was sort of like an omelet with tomatoes and cheese inside. He got a side of fruit, some of which wasn't ripe, but he did enjoy his meal and I was happy to take a few bites of his flipper Service was excellent! Our server was friendly and efficient and our food came out quickly. We had various questions on the menu and it was clear she knew the menu very well. We opted to sit inside by the window. We enjoyed the charming interior and views of the park across the way but the noise was a bit off-putting. Sitting close to what I am guessing is a cappuccino machine we had the constant wrapping of the coffee filter on the counter to get the grinds out. We also constantly heard someone yelling for our server from the kitchen. I guess that is their process to let the server know food is up but between the constant wrapping on the counter and the awkwardness of our server being called for it wasn't very relaxing. Something else that I thought was odd was the plastic plates which reminded me of what they use in hospitals. For such a delicious meal I would have thought they would use slightly more refined dishes. If I visit this Tomato Pie Cafe location again I think I would sit outside or get it to go to have a more peaceful atmosphere to enjoy such an incredibly delicious meal. read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Cute interior utilizing an old fashioned soda shop or diner counter. - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania

Just want you to know that yesterday, your front in the door waitstaff let you down. We were so disappointed with our service. The tall man with an accent was our waiter. We were taking a little time with the menu since we were unfamiliar with it. I asked a question about what were egg fixers and he said Omelettes. I asked for a half n half but did not understand the symbol and "got it" once he pointed it out As unavailable. My son in laws coffee arrived, my daughter's never arrived. Our omelette plates for my husband and I came out...sat on the counter and were returned to the kitchen. They arrived lukewarm later. We waited a long time for our meal and when my daughter's arrived -it was inedible. Too light and gummy inside not fully cooked. We were told just a few minutes..come on it was pancakes. We finished our meal and signaled to the waiter to come over. We cancelled our daughter's order and asked that it be taken off the bill. My husband noted the 3 and 4 staff behind the counter looking at phones and talking together when we were waiting and waiting and waiting several times. This was our goodbye breakfast send off for us to the airport from visiting our daughter and son in law in Lititz. We went back to her home to say final goodbyes as our SIL cooked our daughter something to eat. Really disappointed. I believe they called and got a very non concerned "sorry". Your staff does not seem to understand that the customer experience is what a business is all about. Your waiter was not friendly but matter of fact as if our questions on the menu were a bother. He did not check if he had gotten BOTH drinks delivered and letting 3 people at the table have to eat while one waited and never got their PANCAKES as everyone else finished is not the "it will just be 2 minutes" promised. Your staff was more attentive to their cell phones than us as customers. Why are they even having cell phones while working? read more

Solid 4 stars. We got takeout brunch for a large group of adults and kids and they did a very nice job. The first question you may be asking is, what is a tomato pie. I think the best way to describe it is to say it is a cross between a pizza and a quiche. It doesn't seem to have egg, just crust, really delicous tomatoes and cheese. It comes with a "savory scone" but as delicious as the tomato pie was, the scone was a miss. It was sort of a soggy, doughy mass that didn't have much in the way of form or flavor. The pie also came with a small side salad with a tasty dressing. At $7.95 for a single or $11.95 for a double, it's a great deal. The pumpkin scone with brown butter glaze was quite good, much better than the savory scone that comes with the tomato pie. The lemon blueberry muffins were good, though the coffee cake muffin was over dry and not that flavorful. One of the real highlights was the pretzel breakfast sandwich. You can get raspberry honey mustard or sweet sriracha sauce. I went with the sriracha and it was fantastic. The mile spice and tang balanced with some honey sweetness perfectly complimented the eggs, bacon, cheese and spinach and the pretzel role was divine. The kids got the rainbow french toast from the kids menu which was fun looking and tasted good but really could have done with a little accompaniment. It was literally just two lonely pieces of toast in a container. I would suggest tossing in a little fruit, if for nothing else just to make it look less plain. All in all I would go back, especially for the tomato pie and the pretzel sandwich. read more

See all

Great food, lovely service. I tried tomato pie for first time ever, it was delicious! My hubby had breakfast bowl, really enjoyed it. Menu has nice amount of choices, something there for everyone weather you have sweet or savory tooth! read more

Tomato Pie Cafe - Almond milk latte - Salad Near Me - Lititz, Pennsylvania