It is my go to pizza place on this side of town. Always quick, and always tasty. The pepperoni pleaser is my favorite! read more

Used to love this place ! But not any longer! Order 2 medium pep pizzas,we're ok! Ordered a chicken salad and a Italian salad and a sirloin steak grinder! All three and some substitute for lettuce that totally ruined the taste of the salads and even worse on the grinder, just nasty! Looked and tasted like they plucked weeds from their yard! Gross! After about 20 yrs of great food, I will no longer get anything there! So sad! read more

Service is good, but the food is crap. Pizza not enough toppings and overpriced. The grinders are like the 1980's gas station torpedos that are stuck behind the two year old burritos. read more

The food is always good and hot when we have it delivered... The spicy Italian grinder is really good

Prices are to high and they don't give coupons anymore for years so I don't go there anymore and when we did go a while back it was good

White pizza and French fries for the win! Great food and amazing staff who treat you like family, even if they've never met you. read more

The pizza was ordered for a coworker's birthday and the transaction required Apple Pay upon delivery. The delivery worker did not bring the Apple Pay device and had to go back to get it for me to pay. The pizza that was brought was entirely raw uncooked dough in the center). It was so embarrassing because it was for a birthday. I spoke with Beth and she was very apologetic at first but became very defensive when I asked for her to have Kimmie the manager call me. Beth was unwilling to work with me regarding having Kimmie the manager call back and simply yelled on the phone for me to call her. read more

This place is a little further from me than I usually go for carry-out, but I still keep coming back, especially late-night. Consistent good quality pizza served up on time by friendly staff. read more

There pizza is really good but I think my favorite is the grinders. I have tried multiple kinds and they have all been great!

Just moved to the area and wanted some local pizza joint over a chain. Was not disappointed! Friendly staff, decent prices, and a really solid pizza. Couldn't ask for more and couldn't recommend more. read more

Buffalo chicken grinders are absolutely amazing perfect for lunch or dinner. I've tried several of their grinders and never disappointed!

Came up to Cleveland for the game and wanted to try some pizza we didn't have in my hometown and it was really good! The spaghetti was also just as amazing! Highly recommended! Good pizza in the area !! Woohoo read more

The best place to get food from in Garfield Hts. Great customer service too, the only thing missing are tables to sit...

Not what it once was.... Ordered me a Grinder - which I haven't had in 18 years. What a let down. Morons made Sandwich half ass; no lettuce, tomato or onion . Pass on Tiffany's - just not What it once was... read more

My work orders this pizza all the time and I LOVE it. Amazing pizza! No dine in, but that's fine, because it's just a small little place. read more

Tiffany's Pizza - pepperoni and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cleveland, Ohio

My roommate brought back some Tiffany's Pizza today. He was working on a job site out in that area, brought a huge sheet pizza home. It was just sitting on the kitchen table, at cold, room temperature, so I tried some. I have to say, it was good. The crust was a little thick, sauce kind of sweet. I was a little hungover and this did me some good. I am very thankful and happy right now. I am back in the bed typing away with a full stomach. read more

I will never patronize this place again due to bad customer service. A simple issue turned into a nightmare for me, and the owner lacks respects for his customers, or maybe he picks and chooses who he wants to show respect to who knows. read more

I order pizza every month for our office from Tiffany's. They are always on time and the food is always great! It's the only pizza place i can order from that will get no complaints from my coworkers. Everyone likes it! All of the staff that works there is great and provides great customer service. You can tell that they care about their customers. read more

The staff is wonderful. The food is always fresh and delicious. I eat here near daily and have never once had anything other than exceptional food and service. read more

The girls and I at work always get Tiffanys grinders for take out at lunch!! These subs are amazing! I can never stray from the spicy Italian: ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, hot peppers (banana peppers that are not hot...just the way I like them :o) red onion (no thanks) lettuce, tomato (hold please) mayo and italian dressing. Their bread is made fresh daily and let me tell you these grinders are to die for!! Delivery is VERY quick and pricing is perfect! Grinders are $5.49 or they now have 2 for $10!! I have also tried their pizza which is good, nothing to write home about........its their grinders that keep me coming back! read more

On a mission to try every pizza shop in the Cleveland area. It may take a long time, and cause me to visit every hospital in the Cleveland area as well, but dammit I have goals. After trying this pizza, I think I will just keep on searching. Don't get me wrong, not bad pizza, but the reviews aside from Andrea just seem llike lies. I haven't tried the subs yet, but next time I'm in the mood, I might have to give it a try. They crust was ok, but the sauce didn't have much flavor to it, and there were barely any toppings on it either. read more

Very good food fresh. Just if you don't want your grinders too much sauce or dressing make sure you tell them easy on the sauce and they will cook it the way you want read more

I really love Tiffany's pizza. We order for work frequently and it's always been very satisfying!!

Love Tiffany's pizza! Not far, affordable, and great service. Try the pan size!

Not very good pizza at all, the only reason I gave it two stars instead of one was it was so damn cheap. But honestly I didn't like it at all. read more

Great pizza and grinders! Have gotten delivery and carryout many many times since we live so close and never been a bad meal or service! Yummy! read more

A mistake every time!!!! So my review on here last time was that I ALWAYS have problems here. Anytime I pick up, I NEVER have problems. I debate on ordering here everytime! My three year old and I stopped there last week on the way home and everything was perfect. But, of course tonight, I had to get delivery because I decided to have some beverages before and couldn't pick it up. The time before this, my son was sick and I couldn't pick up. They quoted me 45 mins this time. The pizza showed up after 1 hour and 15 mins. When I called to check on my pizza after an hour, the lady that answered the phone couldn't tell me how much longer it would be. I declined the pizza when it got here and sent it back. DO NOT get delivery. Pick the pizza up if you order. The food is not cheap but it is good. Tip to Tiffany's: your delivery sucks, get it together. Smh. Update: store is closed and NOBODY has even worried about me declining the delivery. Not a phone call from the manager or nothing. That exactly why we have no good places to eat over here in Garfield. Customer service is AWFUL. read more

NOT A FAN. When they first moved to the neighborhood, one of their delivery drivers almost ran me over in a parking lot. My Mom called to complain. We ordered grinders with extra mayo-there was SOO much, it was literally dripping off the sandwich. We called to complain and were told if we wanted new grinders we'd have to pick them up ourselves because there were no deliveries scheduled on our side of town (about a mile away). I emailed the manager & never received a response. Pizza is awful, I can't choke it down. Grinders & cheese bread WAS THE BEST, but won't be returning after such awful service & disrespect. read more

I ordered a grilled chicken grinder which upon opening the packaging, I noticed that it was saturated with grease. I immediately became sick to my stomach trying to eat a small portion of this sandwich. I called the store to request a refund and the customer service I received was awful. Upon arriving to return the grinder the owner was extremely rude, as he laid out a napkin and took his time placing on gloves on as to inspect the sandwich, insinuating that I was lying about the condition of the grinder. He then rudely said "NOPE" and repackaged the sandwich and turned his back on me. THE WORST CUSTOMER SERVICE IN RESTURANT HISTORY.... read more