I have ordered custom iced cookies before for other events and from other people before but this time I wanted to find a smaller, high quality, and independently women-owned business to take my order to. Thumbprints did not disappoint and Katie was an absolute gem to work with. From start to finish, she listened and gave me several options to choose from and here's where hers set her apart. Freshness! Others (also vendors reviewed on yelp) I have ordered from had icing that was hard as a rock and difficult to bite into and cookies that tasted like they had been frozen in the freezer for a while and lacked texture and flavor. I took a chance and was so glad I did. Thumbprints scored perfection 5/5! She's a little further south than some of the others but so worth it and if you need delivery to Seattle/Eastside area, she offers a reasonable add on. I would 100% order from her again! read more

Thumbprints Baking - Vanilla sugar cookies for a baby shower - Desserts Near Me

I had such a great experience working with this bakery. I was attempting to throw a last minute graduation party for a colleague and needed some kind of baked good. Most places I found required 2 weeks advanced notice (understandable, but inconvenient), had order minimums (again understandable, but inconvenient), or just had outrageous pricing. I contacted Thumbprint within 3 days of my event and asked for 15 graduation-themed cookies. Response was fast and communication was excellent throughout. She confirmed which shapes I wanted and even asked what the school colors were so she could customize them. The value for the price is really outstanding for a Seattle baker. They were cleanly decorated and yummy too. It's located in Federal Way but they offer a reasonable delivery fee if you don't live on the south side. The grad was surprised, and everyone wanted to know who made the "super adorable" and "delicious" cookies! As soon as we picked up the order I started thinking of when I can place another order... I'm going to have to start hosting parties! And I'll try to plan further in advance next time. read more

Thumbprints Baking - a table with cookies and cookies - Desserts Near Me

See all

Great service and the cookies were both beautiful and delicious! Thanks for your help in making it a great celebration. read more

Thumbprints Baking - Custom UCLA cookies - Desserts Near Me

Katie was wonderful to work with! My sisters graduation cookies came out even better then I expected!! Sometimes these types of cookies are just for show and don't taste good, but these were absolutely delicious! The cookies looked clean and well made and were perfectly well packed. I would definitely order from Katie again. read more

I have ordered with Thumbprints Baking two times (Bridal Shower + Baby Shower) and both times have been AMAZING. Katie is so communicative, creative and great to work with! I sent her some inpso and color scheme and made the cutest cookies both times - I received so many compliments at both events. I live near Greenlake and have been in a pinch for both of these events and she kindly delivered to my home for a small fee, this saved me so much time - she is a lifesaver! I will certainly keep ordering from Katie in the future. read more

We've ordered cookies for two events now and can't recommend them enough! Super easy to work with and the cookies are gorgeous and delicious! read more

Thumbprints created custom sugar cookie decorating kits for our corporate team building event. Great service, reliable delivery (extra $20 charge-totally worth it) and delicious cookies. We selected our cookies shapes and frosting colors, and Thumbprints delivered an attractive box of cookies, a dazzling assortment of sprinkles, and everything needed to make our own cookie creations (frosting bags, frosting, spreading knives). Would recommend their cookie kits for any party or event! read more

Great experience ordering custom cookies for my sister's baby shower this past weekend!! Everyone at our event enjoyed looking and eating them! We ordered 2 dozen custom cookies for a holiday themed baby shower which included rattles, baby onesies, stars, bottles and mittens - so cute! Ordering is very simple, just sent a few pictures of ideas via email to Kate - she was so helpful! Picked up the 2 dozen cookies on Saturday at Embassy Suites which was convenient, you can also have them delivered for $20 extra if needed read more

Thumbprints Baking - Christmas themed baby shower cookies! - Desserts Near Me

I rarely give 5 star reviews because I always feel like there's room for improvement. But this company was top notch and made everything so easy. Not only were the cookies super tasty, perfectly decorated and texture, but the price was really reasonable, they did it with 9 days notice, and the delivery made everything really easy. I can tell that the decorator has really good design sense and takes a lot of pride in her work. The husband who delivered the cookies was super nice. I would totally order again from them and refer my friends! read more

Thumbprints Baking - Taste test. It passed ;) - Desserts Near Me

See all

Ok, seriously go to the website right now and sign up for the cookie subscription. I got my first month's box today and the cookies are delicious! I was skeptical about the spritz with apricot in the middle because I am not fan of apricot but these cookies are my 2nd favorite behind the awesome espresso shortbread. Yum! I am also in the process of ordering cookies for my son's 5th birthday and the ladies have been very helpful with suggestions. Excellent customer service! read more

Katie created beautiful cookies for a bridal shower. We used her gorgeous larger sized cookies as party favors (bridal gown and ring). For dessert she created smaller cookies with a variety of embellishments. The cookies were a big hit and I would highly recommend Thumbprints Baking. read more

SO happy with how the cookies turned out! We ordered them as a sweet treat for employees during our move day and they were a huge hit. Delicious, professional and our logo was spot on. We look forward to ordering more in the future! read more

Thumbprints Baking - Desserts Near Me

We made a large order for macarons for a macaron tower I wanted at our wedding. Everything from the tasting to the delivery to the final product were all exceptional. Our guests loved every bite and each took plenty home to enjoy later. read more

I needed to find a bakery that would fulfill a rather odd cookie design request for a virtual team morale event. I was prepared to get questions when I uploaded my mockup image in the consultation email, but Katie didn't even blink! Her first reply was "We'd love to help you with this order." Thumbprints made communication, payment, and delivery so easy. And I'm over the moon of how the cookies came out! They are works of art. The craftswomanship of the frosting is so sharp and clean. Attention to detail in presentation of individually wrapped cookie bows (you can pick any color!) and the lovely box they arrive in is a wonderful touch. I seriously can't wait to have another reason to order from Thumbprints. read more

I had custom cookies made for a friends birthday and could not have been more pleased! Thumbprint was easy to work with, affordable and the product was beautiful and delicious. We'll be back for any cookie needs! read more

It was really great and easy working with Katie. I sent her a picture of what I wanted the cookies to look like for my son's 2nd birthday (cars, trucks, planes etc) and she delivered to my expectations. The cookies tasted good too. Katie was very prompt with the order, very responsive over email and delivered the order on the day of the birthday on time. Highly recommend her! read more

I ordered these cookies for my daughter's bridal shower and they were amazing! So beautiful and delicious too! I asked for bridal tropical themed designs and they were perfect! Everyone raves about them! I will definitely order again! read more

Thumbprints Baking - Desserts Near Me

See all

I recently ordered my first dessert from Thumbprints. I was hosting a party and our guests all had strict dietary restrictions. The Thumbprints team was super helpful and responsive! They gave me several great options that fit my budget and the final product (a gorgeous pear tart) was AMAZING! They also brought me a little thank-you box with some red wine brownies and I couldn't stop eating them. I've already told my husband where to shop next Valentine's Day! :) read more

A few months ago someone sent me a box of delicious cookies from Thumbprints (Everything was delicious but the salted caramel shortbread oh SWEET FANCY MOSES), and so when I had a special occasion come up recently that I wanted some celebratory desserts for, Thumbprints came to mind. I reallllly wanted those salted caramel shortbreads but the weather was too warm to ship them to southern California. No matter! Maggie was an absolute gem to work with and helped me come up with meaningful and pretty cookies to go with my theme. I used them in goodie bags and they were a HUGE hit. They came out even better than expected. And the best part was that they didn't just look beautiful & thematic, but they were delicious too. I find it so disappointing when a beautiful dessert doesn't taste as good as it looks. Not at all the case here. Honestly, my only mistake was not ordering more. (If you're a sugar cookie fan, the custom sugar cookies are a must. Soft with just the right amount of crumb. Royal icing that doesn't break your teeth. They are perfect.) Shipping was fast, everything arrived completely intact thanks to the careful packaging, and most importantly it was all prompt and delicious. I predict I will now be looking for any excuse to create custom cookies. read more

Delivered 8 dozen beautifully wrapped cookies on short notice! Was the finishing touch on my event! Thank you!

I worked with Katie and she created a custom cookie for my husbands 60th birthday. I gave her an old picture and she put it on a sugar cookies, and did another cookie with a 60 on it. They were a hit, but not only did the cookies look amazing they were absolutely delicious. I had them delivered and they were on time and in perfect condition. She put them in cellophane bags with a nice ribbon. I highly recommend Thumbprints, delicious, cookies excellent service. read more

We ordered two of the DIY sugar cookie kits for a work team event, and everything was great! With the two kits, we had more than enough frosting, tons of sprinkles, and even some pastry bags for the frosting to get fancy. Since the function, I have had several people request a link to the kits, and I did not hesitate to provide. The service was great, and I would recommend Thumbprints Baking to anyone that would like to have a cookie frosting party. read more

I ordered a baby shower cake from Thumbprints. Maggie was sure to get the details of exactly what I was looking for and was really helpful with choosing what size of cake I needed for my guest list. When the cake was delivered, it was absolutely beautiful and I hated to cut into it. But I'm glad we did, because it was also absolutely delicious! So glad I ordered from Thumbprints! read more