Large restaurant with lots of space and plenty of parking. Seating indoors and out. Outdoors is really nice but be prepared for sun down your back at certain times. Would recommend they get a rolldown shade for one side of the restaurant because the outdoor dining is lovely. Pricing isn't bad, expansive menu. There is something for everyone. Service is great. We went twice and had Logan and Connor. Phenomenal service. Salmon $29 - good amount of veggies but felt like the fish was small for $29. Sliders - just ok, passed on the second time we dined here Mac and cheese - great, very creamy. The mac and cheese that came with the side dish was even better. Flatbread - eh it was ok, pass on the margherita but open to trying the others. Nachos - their play on their "natchos" was really good. Each bite had plenty of ingredients. read more

See all

Review for "Steak Frites" and Atmosphere at Three Notch'd Brewery & Craft Kitchen Disappointing Quality: Ordered the steak frites entree, and the beef was severely overcooked, dry, and resembled beef jerky rather than a proper steak. Flaw in Preparation: Pre-sliced thin meat pieces lost all their juices during cooking, resulting in a completely tasteless and tough texture. Confusing Presentation: Putting a pat of butter on top of already dry, lukewarm shredded meat makes no culinary sense and completely fails to add moisture or flavor. Bleak Atmosphere: Visiting on a Saturday night revealed a completely dead vibe--no music, zero atmosphere, and just sports broadcasting on screens, making it feel more like a sterile diner or waiting area than a vibrant brewery/pub (brewery). The beer was delicious. I thought it was brewed somewhere else and brought in. Because the area near the vats for the beer was more like equipment that the new owners don't use. Maybe I'm wrong. But that's just my personal impression. read more

Three Notch'd Brewery & Craft Kitchen - Show me where the steak is in the photo? I can tell the difference between steak and beef jerky. - Brewpubs Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

We recently tried Three Notch'd Brewery in Rehoboth Beach, now located in the former Iron Hill Brewery space. We sat ourselves at the bar and waited about three minutes before the bartender acknowledged us. Once she did, she was friendly and helpful, explaining that three beers on the menu had already kicked and recommending two new selections instead. Both beers were excellent. We also ordered the bourbon BBQ wings, which were delicious. Unfortunately, the service experience quickly declined. During our visit, we watched four people walk out due to the lack of service. There was only one bartender covering the bar and another handling restaurant orders. Our bartender suggested the restaurant was extremely busy, but that didn't appear to be the case, as the dining room was less than half full. As the evening went on, our bartender became increasingly overwhelmed. A guest sitting next to us was even served the completely wrong cocktail. At that point, we decided to ask for our check and leave because the overall atmosphere had become uncomfortable. It's disappointing because the food and drinks were very good. However, poor service and apparent understaffing made this a place we won't be returning to, especially with so many outstanding dining and brewery options available in Rehoboth and Lewes. read more

The food and service here were great! We had an awesome time with six people and all had amazing food. The beer was great, I had the biggie smores stout which was a great beer unlike anything I have ever tasted. Logan was our server and she took great care of us! read more

This is a very chill and spacious brewery on Route 1 in Delaware. They have indoor and outdoor seating. We opted for inside. The staff were friendly and we had a great waiter. I came here with my dad so we wanted ti try a few different beers so we each got flights. We both enjoyed what we picked. We also shared pretzle bites. He enjoyed them alot more than I did. They did have a big menu for being a brewery. I would come back to try out some other food choices and beers that they have. read more

See all

Our party of 7 was asked to sit at a high top with stool without backs. We asked the hostess if we could have high back chairs. She said yes. No one helped us move the chairs which was fine since it was a special request. While moving 4 of the chairs, the manager was very rude to us about changing out stools at the bar. We told her the hostess told us we could. We saw her then speaking to the hostess and then loudly switching the chairs with other ones in the restaurant. The manager was drinking with the bartender and appeared to be drunk by the end of the night. Her rudeness set the tone for the night. We almost left and went to eat next door because we felt uncomfortable. Also, it was off season on a Sunday night with very few patrons. Our waitress was so nice which helped make up for the managers rudeness. We ordered calamari, pretzel bites and 2 types of wings for appetizers. Most people ordered burgers. I got the sliders which came in a cute tower and opted for the side salad over the fries. The salad was delicious! read more

Three Notch'd Brewery & Craft Kitchen - Beef Sliders with side salad - Brewpubs Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

See all

The food was horrible. Pretzel bites were literally just bread with no salt. Slow service. The atmosphere was bleak. No music outside. Dirty bathrooms. Would never go back. Very disappointing. read more

The food was just really disappointing. It was bad. Service was great but the food was very very mediocre. I was expecting an improved updated interior having previously been the Iron Hill brewery but it looked/felt the same. Didn't really have a brewery vibe. read more

Food and service was good! Very nice on the inside. . read more

See all

Went to happy hour today and sat in the bar area. Unfortunately, the service was extremely disappointing. It was a Monday around 4:00 p.m., and the place was relatively empty, so there really wasn't an excuse for the lack of service. Our server was nowhere to be found for most of our visit, so it took a long time just to get our drinks. The bartender actually made them quickly, but they sat on the bar getting warm because our server never brought them over. We eventually had to walk up and get them ourselves. When we were ready to leave, we asked for the check, but our server disappeared again. After another long wait, the bill finally arrived, but none of the drinks had been priced at the happy hour rate. We ended up finding another server to track down ours so the bill could be corrected. The beer was good, but the service completely overshadowed the experience. The server seemed inattentive and rarely checked on their tables despite the restaurant not being busy. Based on this visit, I wouldn't recommend coming here if you're looking for a relaxing place to enjoy happy hour. read more

Three Notched is Top Notch Great Food Great Service Wings were excellent . Kids chicken tenders were large and tasty. read more

Absolutely phenomenal experience! I would recommend this place to my great grand kids and all of their related family members. I absolutely adored Savannah and Hannah the managers, and I guess Dante, I recommend the house Coke a cola. Bravo. And the shrimp fra Diavolo. read more

The food, the atmosphere and the people, perfection all the way!!!! Ryan the House manager was so professional checked on us many times. Leann the bartender was also just as professional. everyone was so kind and made you feel so welcomed. The place was spotless and the food was spectacular. read more

Food and beer were solid. If I had to guess, they are struggling with staffing, as they very recently opened. If they can get the service side working, there's potential here. However, currently, expect some delays and slower service. read more

We stopped by Three Notch'd Brewery while on a family vacation, excited to try somewhere new. We arrived around 1:00 p.m. on a Wednesday, and the restaurant appeared to be fairly slow. We were seated immediately, but unfortunately, that was the last interaction we had with the staff. Over the next 15 minutes, three other families came in after us, were seated, and received service while we sat without anyone acknowledging our table. We never received water or even a quick, "We'll be right with you." We tried several times to get the attention of a waitress but were ignored. After waiting 15 minutes without any service or acknowledgment, we packed up and left. We went to First State Brewing Company just down the road and had a great experience from the moment we walked in. I understand that restaurants can have off days, but simply acknowledging customers goes a long way. Unfortunately, the service at Three Notch'd was several notches below what we expected and we won't be back. read more

Amazing food and great service and atmosphere!!! Very friendly staff and helpful and nice environment!! Recommend fr 10/10!!! And AMAZINGGG FLATBREAD read more

Great food! Beer selection good. Staff is working hard to bring this place up to speed. Give them a try!

We had high hopes for a new restaurant in the area, but left very disappointed. This was our second - and last - visit. We chalked up the first poor experience to it being a new restaurant, still getting their footing - but upon returning about 1.5-2 months later and receiving the same poor service and bad food, we realized this is just par for the course with Three Notch'd! Our Notch-o's arrived cold- we asked if they were supposed to be cold and upon returning with another cold & dissembled plate, the response was that the beans they put on them are cold and stored in the refrigerator, but the cheese is hot... they were still cold- because we did not eat them after realizing they were cold (cold queso, no thanks!), they were returned to the kitchen and removed from the bill. The food (BBQ chicken flatbread and buffalo chicken salad) were nothing to write home about. Try it out for yourself, maybe your experience will be better than ours, but we will spend our money at a place where the service is friendlier, the manager checks in on tables that have expressed displeasure and the food is edible. read more

Three Notch'd Brewery & Craft Kitchen - $13 Notch-o's (served cold, do not recommend) - Brewpubs Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

Loved it!! Went for lunch, had old bay wings, flatbread pizza, chicken Caesar salad and shrimp tacos! Everything was hot fresh and yummy!! Our waitress Amber took good care of us. We will be back! read more

See all

My family and I thought this place was dirty and the food had a very bad taste the Mac and cheese had a weird cheese the lettuce was gross and the bun was terrible I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS RESTAURANT read more

I would have given a 0 star, if I could have. I have been there twice. Stay away for now. First time, there were fewer beers than would have been expected. Service was spotty--we had to ask for everything, from water to salt to napkins. Food was ok. Yesterday we sat at the bar, only one or two others there- we waited for 10 minutes to be noticed. The beer list had more "kicked" than available beers, the bartender did not know her beer and did not suggest alternatives for the absent IPAs. The mussels came out warm, not hot, the sauce was thick, and weird, my beanburger was mushy and literally oozing over the serving tray. The lettuce on the burger was melted. The cheesesteak looked like it had been prepared in a kindergarten kitchen. The bread and the contents were covered with cheese. There are too many good places to eat to waste your time here. I NEVER had a bad experience at Iron Hill. Only bad experiences at Three Notched read more

You can only order burgers pink or not pink. Ordered pink burger and it was so over cooked Ordered lemon pepped boneless chicken and it was sooo salty I couldn't eat them. And nachos were just not good, nothing to them. Waitress was very nice, but wont be going back read more

We went on a Sunday around 5:30 and had an amazing dinner! Our server, Jennifer, was phenomenal...happy, cheery, welcoming and very knowledgable on the beers, drinks and food! The music was fun and very upbeat, not too loud and a great mix of good tunes. Food was delicious, very tasty. I will definitely be back! read more

Haven't actually been able to go inside, AC was out per the sign on the door, no biggy it happens. Tried to place a takeout order online, the website just reloads the same page, tried to place a takeout order over the phone, apparently they don't do that. Hopefully it's just because they are newly opened, but they may just be a mess. read more

Stopped in for the first time since they opened a few weeks ago. Great vibe and beer. Downside - sat at the bar to watch soccer but the TVs are mounted way too high. Can't imagine trying to spend a couple hours there. Asked to move back to one of the high tops near the bar but were told "no". Those are saved for bigger groups. At the time there were zero people sitting there - exactly 30 open seats but still we could not move. Management should rethink both of these issues. read more

Eww. Even Iron HIll was better. It was so loud the waitress couldn't hear our orders. Suggested the music be turned down and she said "that ain't happening". her fingernails were so long she had trouble entering our order on little machine thing. Even lost one order so we had to go through the whole process of screaming at her again. Food was gross. My adult son puked. One and done. read more

The staff is marvelous!!! Leann, Robert and Savannah were very welcoming and nice!! The drinks and calamari were excellent!!!

Great server, happy and welcoming!! Not so great, no greeting at hostess stand, a black bean burger that was mostly rice and cumin, not at all edible! The restaurant felt drab inside, a new paint job and seating refresh would be great. Our booth seat was in need of repair. read more

Ordered a flatbread with only cheese and bread. The waitress told us she typed in nothing on the flatbread. Flatbread came out with toppings. We told them we requested cheese and bread. They took it back, removed the toppings and covered it with cheese again, bringing out a flatbread with baked in toppings. Not worth requesting a fix. Won't got back. read more

This was right across from our hotel and so glad we came for dinner and drinks, had a great time! The food was amazing and the envrioment was very welcoming. They let us taste beers we were interested in and had a great selection of cocktails. 10/10 read more