Service was subpar, food was good. The atmosphere was ok. Tables were a little tight and a bit noisy. Probably won't go again. 1Star for service. 4 Stars for food. 3 Stars noise. read more

They do their meat extremely well here to the tune of the birthplace year of this country - no surprise. My friend asked for a bigger table and they weee nice enough to give it to us despite being busy on a Saturday night. My friend also was concerned about the lamb being too gamey but wanted to give it a try. He was a big fan. I got to try a piece of his and it was good too. I went with the Denver steak- I never had this portion of meat before and I see why it is advertised as a separate item now. It is likely this was randomly packaged before or the cattlers kept it for themselves and just sold the masses everything else. Japan has been known to sell this meat portion decades? Ago known as 'zabuton' apparently. It isn't really a new "invention" per se, but apparently a meat association helped with the marketing and accessibility of this meat to make it what it is today. It appears many places do not offer this but a handful of places do offer this. The doors are nice and the signs don't strike me as stand out but they are nice easy to read aigns. The decor inside creates a beautiful ambiance of the classy restaurant that represents the food they served. The asparagus, carrots, Kennett mushrooms, were cooked well. The lamb was tender and juicy. My Denver was tender, juicy, and flavorful in a way that you don't need to add sauce and it might even be a faux pas to do so. I suggest medium or medium rare. I got mine medium well but for this kind of meat. I think medium rare is probably best. The key lime is 3 layers which is a cake and then key lime layer times 3 layers. My friend said it was a bit dry but we both thought it was good and all desserts are made in-house. My friend thinks a lot of butter is used in a lot of places to make the food taste truly good and I believe that. I don't really think about these things and just try to eat and appreciate what is in front of me, but it certainly is good to be mindful of these kind of ingredients used as well. The alcohol was fine. My friend's drink was not too sweet and my espresso cocktail had a good balance of flavor and booze. I asked for a shrimp add on and maybe the waitress didn't hear me but I didn't get that. However I also wasn't charged for it and by the meal's end when I realized this, I did not want this add-on. The bathroom apparently could've used some cleaning. read more

See all

We were celebrating our 10 year anniversary. The renovations were wonderful. The restaurant and bar are beautiful. We were seated in the dining room, close to the bar. It was very loud but we knew that from previous reviews. Our server was new. We ordered drinks and didn't wait too long. The maple bourbon old fashioned was on point. We ordered and enjoyed our drinks. Apps came out quickly. The oysters Rockefeller were delicious. The tuna tartare was extremely salty. We would have mentioned this to our server had he checked in. As we were finishing, he brought steak knives and I told him about the tuna. He said he would tell the chef (I doubt he did). He didn't clear our plates. The food runner brought our entrees but we still had our app plates. It was very awkward trying to clear our own plates while he also put our entrees down. Multiple servers, bus people, hostesses, etc. had walked by and saw our empty plates. I would think someone would have cleared them. The filet trio was cooked perfectly and was fabulous. My husband's ribeye was also cooked perfectly. At this point, we finally saw our server again. We had no water and I had no drink for about 15 minutes before he came back. I ordered a rosemary old fashioned and asked for more water. He brought more water but I waited 10 minutes for my drink. Had our server been back sooner, I probably would have even ordered a third drink. We finished our dinner but needed some wrapped up. He brought us a box. I do know many people prefer to wrap their own food. I've worked in many restaurants- both upscale and casual. We always offered to box leftovers. We then ordered the banana cream pie and devoured it. It was amazing. Overall, food was delicious (except the tuna). Service was just bad. Our server couldn't multitask to save his life. He barely touched the table. Also, when I had asked what the sides were, he mentioned 4 and said "and many more." I thought that was funny. Other staff also walked by and no one else touched the table. It seemed like there were multiple managers, but again, no one touched the table. At this price point, service should be impeccable (as it used to be). We may try it again (most likely happy hour). It also didn't help that two tables away a guy kept dropping loud f-bombs while there was a family with two teenage daughters sitting next to us. I'd give 4 stars for food and 1 star for service. Up your training game. read more

The highly anticipated reopening of 1776 Steakhouse has not only lived up to the hype, it has completely blown past it. This is, without question, the best 1776 has ever been, and that is saying something. While the stunning renovation immediately catches your eye with its elevated colonial chic aesthetic, the real story goes far beyond the design. The entire experience has been refined and elevated in a way that feels both fresh and deeply respectful of what made this place special to begin with. The steaks are on another level. You can instantly tell the quality of the meat has improved. Every bite is incredibly tender, deeply flavorful, and cooked to perfection. These are easily the best steaks in Delaware right now. Long-time fans will appreciate that the soul of 1776 is still intact. The perennial favorites are still here, and some have even been elevated in thoughtful ways that make them feel new again. At the same time, the new menu additions are both delicious and visually stunning, adding a layer of excitement and discovery. There truly is something for everyone. The cocktail program deserves its own mention. The menu is thorough and thoughtfully curated, delivering creative craft cocktails just as well as it executes the classics. Whether you want something familiar or something inventive, it hits on every level. What makes 1776 especially impressive is how it balances being high end without ever feeling pretentious. It is polished, warm, and welcoming all at once. The team is incredible, and the service is impeccable from start to finish. This place has already surpassed expectations and will continue to do so. It is very clear that 1776 is about to become the go-to steakhouse for the Delaware beaches, and honestly, it has a strong case for the entire state. An absolute home run. read more

See all

This was a really nice place that was unexpected. When you go to a strip mall, the last thing you expect is a nice steakhouse. When you enter in, it's very bright and cheerful, but it is loud.. we started with drinks, which are very good as was the wait staff and service. It wasn't terribly crowded considering it was Fourth of July weekend. We both opted for the filet mignon. We didn't want a huge portion of steak and it was just enough and it was cooked perfectly. I did order the baked potato, which was sad to find out they had sold out. They did offer the twice baked potato but I had my heart set on a baked potato. They did bring steak to the table and came by with butter selection for you to finish off your steak.. it wasn't really necessary because the flavor was so good. All the food came to the table hot the service was excellent.. We can stay with confidence that we would definitely come back to 1776. We had a good solid meal here.. read more

See all

I really would like to leave a better review but the problem is service. I'm a big believer in it as I've been in the hospitality industry for over 30 years. How do you not clear any of the silverware, (used or not) and keep additional more. Empty cocktail glasses just left there while we are having our wine. Bottom line is that it comes down to training and I'm starting to believe people either don't know or they just look the other way. The place is decorated/designed nicely. The food is good but not over the top and I believe when getting a filet with Béarnaise with lobster there should be more sauce and lobster. The server came around a bit late ( half way through my meal) offering complimentary compound butters. That comes down to lack of training and service once again. read more

See all

This place is a gem service was great, thank you Frank. Food was delicious and priced just right. Don't let the storefront fool you. It is decorated well and the piano man was a great touch to the ambiance. read more

10/10. Best experience. We were from out of town and went for an anniversary. Between the food, the service, and the live music .... We loved it!!! read more

See all

We ate there a month ago and I thought I would post my thoughts about the evening. We had reservations and were seated fairly quickly.....the problem.....where you enter the restaurant is very tight, the desk to check in is stuck in a corner and the noise from all the people was awful. You could not hear your name being called or get thru the crowd. Whoever was responsible for the redesign of the restaurant did not do a very good job. The tables are way too close together and there are so many of them the noise level is really awful. We could hardly talk across the table to one another. In addition, there is really not a nice area to enter in the restaurant....you walk into the bar and if it is busy...good luck.....you can hardly move more or less get to the hostess. The menus are ridiculously large and unwieldy to look at. I didn't even know where to put it when I was finished. On a positive note......our food was excellent and very nicely prepared. We will go back and perhaps try it in the afternoon and see how it is. Unless they take a few tables out and have some breathing room for the diners it will not be our choice for dining.....no matter how good the food is! read more

Went there for the prefix meal with my wife the other day everything was top-notch cocktails were delicious. Steak was cooked perfectly. Will be dreaming about that crème brûlée cheesecake. read more

1776 Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

We had our neighborhood ladies lunch here this month while the dining room was closed. It is the first time I have eaten here. The inside is lovely, they had drinks set up self serve for water and tea and the bar was open for anyone wanting a cocktail. I had the a chicken dish that was excellent. The service was good, my only complain was our space was limited so we were packed into the tables. I know they are changing hands soon so not sure what things will be like in the future. read more

Recent changes in ownership definitely hit their mark Environment went from old and rusty to updated comfort and class Their Prix Fix menu for $35 is the best bargain on the beach, which comes with appetiser and desert The Oyster Rockefeller was or should be Best on the Beach Food and service were excellent - Thanks to our waitress Taylor who was very attentive Reservations really are a must read more

I agree with the other reviews being wholly confused how this place is so highly praised. My husband and I visited for a special event. There was an issue with every single course we ordered. Wrong drink, bad oysters, foul fish, undercooked steak. I'm dumbfounded how this place can get so much wrong while claiming to be a high end restaurant. Even the sides were so underwhelming it was shocking. Our waitress was trying, but she mentioned she was brand new. Realistically she absolutely wasn't ready to be on the floor. Such a shame. Considering how terrible everything was, it's not even worth a second chance. read more

1776 Steakhouse - My "medium-rare" steak. - Steakhouses Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

We've been going to 1776 steakhouse for over 15 years and Ever since new owners took over this steakhouse went downhill fast. The prices went up quite a lot and the steaks along with the appetizers didn't taste as good. Sorry we had a good run but we won't be coming back read more

All around amazing experience! Staff were very professional and the food was delicious. Our waiter made a great recommendation for the lobster baked potato. We had a great time the pianist was a nice touch! Overall great experience and plenty of leftovers! We saw a few people dressed super casual definitely not the place for that. read more

1776 Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Rehoboth Beach, Delaware

We're not regulars my wife and I travel down once a year from Pittsburgh and always go to 1776 we always enjoy it. this time we had 6 o'clock reservations for June 26 Thursday we were sat promptly to a very nice atmosphere with the gentleman on piano, which was very nice My wife and I played name that tune between ourselves. My wife gets the fillet trio every time without fail, and it was wonderful. I ordered the New York strip, medium my steak came out well done no issue my wife and I were having such a lovely evening together and her meal so enjoyable I did not fuss. I ate my delicious onion rings and when my server finally came and asked if everything was OK I said my steak was well done and I did not want it but I told her everything else was wonderful my server left the table went to speak to the her manager with the very long hair and a red blazer she never came to the table and then my server returned. She said they wouldn't charge me for the meat and then proceeded to lectured me on how I should return a steak and that I should have told her and why did I cut it so many times I feel I was polite and not saying to server you never returned to the table so I could not tell you your meat was severely overcooked. I also cut it so many times out boredom I did not want a replacement because two hours is enough in fine dining. I could not have done a third hour my only recommendation you don't make your customer feel bad when you overcook their food I wouldn't have even left this. I never even ate a piece of this steak bullies. Finally, I did tip on the original bill before it was adjusted in retrospect. I should not have. I should have altered the tip for the service which I received. PS my server blamed the cooks for the late service and the overcooked steak and as a back of the house manager myself. That's some weak sauce. read more

We were part of a wedding party of 20+. The service was excellent, the food was excellent and the bill was shockingly reasonable! Highly recommend!!! read more

This is THE place to go in "Reho" for fine food steaks and especially prime rib. We've gone here for years to celebrate birthdays and special occasions. One was able to (& smart to) reserve cuts of prime rib along with your reservation because they would actually run out very quickly. The ownership has recently been handed to very capable hands but I am unsure whether this policy will continue. The Caesar salads is very traditional and delicious. Every time I visit I must have the tempura-like battered and finely seasoned onion rings - just perfect with a nice cut of prime rib! The oysters Rockefeller are some of the best I've had. Large, plump oysters roasted in a cheesy spinach topping are an East-coaster's heaven. The prime rib is slow roasted,, tender, savory and juicy. I'm talkin' melt in your mouth prime beef! Desserts are fantastic as well! Our go to is the banana cream pie but the creme brulee is also very good. This place is in a strip mall but the interior has just been redone by new ownership and is upscale. Service has always been very accommodating and quick. Make reservations well in advance. It's a tad pricey but for some of the best prime rib and fine food in the region, IMHO 1776 is hands down the place to go. Time will tell whether this quality of food and service will continue as promised with the new ownership ....fingers are crossed. read more

Always an enjoyable experience! Dining food quality is always top-notch, and the wait staff takes care of your every dining need!

First time trying 1776 since new ownership. We had the $35 , 3 course meal which is available from 3 to 5 pm. Also apps are 20% off during that time. Summer was our waitress and she was fabulous. She brought us a free glass of champagne to toast our anniversary. The food and the other staff were equally fabulous. The new decor is brighter than the old one. Will definitely return. Thanks for making our anniversary special. read more

We were at 1776 a couple of weeks ago, first time since it was sold. Our party included 4 adults and 1 toddler. Here's the pros and cons... Pros: 1) Service was great...went out of their way to make sure we had what we needed for our toddler, drinks came out quickly, and checked back to be sure we were happy. 2) Two of us ordered the filet...was cooked perfectly, had good flavor, and was a good cut. 3) Caymus is still available at a very good price! Cons: 1) We were big fans of the escargot from 1776...they've changed it up...and in our opinion, not for the better. We really miss the sauce, and the bread that was key to sopping up the sauce. We could live with this, as there are many other appetizers to choose from, if this was our only issue. 2) Probably the biggest faux pas was two folks from our party ordered the ribeye. Big bucks and the ribeye that was served was very thin...we are farmers and routinely deal with butchers...the cut was definitely less than an inch thick...perhaps 3/4 of an inch, and it was chewy. Not sure where they are sourcing their beef, but I hope for their sake, that they get this right in the future. There are many good steak houses in the area...Houston and White, Theo's, Parkway, Nantucket, Harvest Tide, etc...I hope this was just opening jitters...but I have to say it was so bad that we already changed future reservations for our family. read more

I would excuse this if it were busy, but there were 4 total people at the bar plus us. No attention. No waters. Couple who sat down behind us 10 minutes after us got drinks before even being acknowledged. Not even a hello how are you. Bar was sticky. Not sure why they weren't paying attention to paying customers but your bartenders were sloppy on 7/2/26. We left and went to KAJA. They served us right away. read more

Had dinner reservations for five people yesterday. Everything about our experience was fabulous. Our server, Michelle, was excellent, not only was she efficient and on top of everything but she had a great personality. we ordered the lobster ravioli and scallop chips as appetizers and everyone loved them. Three people ordered the fixed price salmon and no complaints from anyone. I am a steak eater and I have to say they set the bar on how to cook a steak. Delicious and cooked perfectly. I just returned from vacationing in Key West and I have to say 1776 blew Bagatelle out of the water. It was truly one of the best steaks I've ever had! Even the sides and soup were delicious as well as the warm bread. The restaurant was packed and I can see why. Kudos to the kitchen and warm friendly staff. It reminded me of a New York City steakhouse. Thanks for a great dining experience. read more

Unwelcome and Rushed, Pushed Out in 100 Minutes! We have been 1776 patrons for over 3 decades, including 4 visits to the new 1776. Until now 1776 was our favorite steakhouse at the beach. On May 8, 2026, we met another couple for a 3:30 pm reservation. We were initially seated by the piano. The restaurant was pretty empty and we ask for a table in the main dining room away from the piano. The hostess balked several times from moving us at all, but finally relented and moved us to a table across from the piano, but not in the main dining room as requested. Our server was unfriendly, never smiled through the entire meal service, and kept asking us if we were ready to order drinks despite that there were 4 of us and only 1 drinks menu. We pointed out that we had to share 1 drinks menu 4 ways and it would take a minute to select drinks. Once we ordered drinks she kept pushing us for our food order. We told her we needed a second "Pre-Fixe" daily specials menu as the table only had one to share among the 4 of us. We finally ordered a starter and our dinners. The scallop chips arrived quickly and were delicious as always. They were followed by salads. The wedge salads were nicely chilled, but this time were skimpy on portions, blue cheese crumbles, bacon, and dressing. Entrees were mostly delicious, but one "twin beef tenderloin medallions" plate was served with 2 oddly shaped tenderloin tips that were tough and hard to chew. The restaurant / chef / kitchen should know better than to substitute cheaper "tips" for "medallions." Dinner was followed quickly by desserts. During the starter and all 3 dinner courses our unfriendly, unsmiling server hovered and removed dishes before other diners had finished the course. During dessert she threw one check down without asking if we wanted to split it. When she brought 2 checks back she had the split wrong. We settled amongst ourselves and left angry and upset. Sadly this was not a fine dining experience. read more

NEVER GOING BACK Service was slow and never cleared the table in between courses JOHN the sever was good that is it Lobster bisque tasted like tomato soup with nice amount of lobster Dry age steak had a bad test had to get a new steak The new steak was not much better Long horn has better steak Cream spinach should be called soup spinach Baked potato was the best thing about dinner read more

I feel very lucky to have been able to get a reservation here on a holiday weekend no less! I made a reservation few days prior. My friend is a big steak lover and so he too was super excited about this place. When you walk in, it is decorated beautifully for the holiday times. We were sat at a table for four in the corner and they hade like a divider so you couldn't see people walking in and out and it gave a feel of privacy. To start our cocktails were tasty. I had a lemon drop martini. Sugar on the rim and strong! I had never seen how they serve the extra martini for you to refill when you are ready too. It comes in a small bottle like container as you see in my pictures. my friend had I think an Old fashioned. He too said it was good but very strong. For food I had french onion soup that was superb to start. Probably the best I have ever had. It wasn't too cheesy, just the way I like it. We also got served warm rolls with two different butters. One was regular and the other was an herb honey butter If I remember correctly For my main I had a 6oz filet with a side of asparagus and mashed potatoes. And As you can see in the pictures my friend also had steak but I don't remember which he got. We both like cleared our dishes. That is how good it was. To top off the great meal we had we also had a wonderful waitress who took my allergies into consideration, she was personable and was funny too. When I told friends I was coming here they said how lucky I was and that it is on their list of places to go to down there. So this is a must go to place! read more

See all

Agree with the reviewers who were left wondering what the hype was about. We had an early reservation and the place was already full. Wonderful job on the renovations but that's where the high praise ends. First miss was the $16 cosmo that was half full and sadly lacking in any alcohol. Shrimp cocktail was nicely presented in a chilled goblet. Service was mediocre. When the table next to us got bread we looked forward to ours but it never came. We did finally ask the runner who served our meals and he brought us some. Steaks were dry and overcooked -- asked for medium and there was no pink. No seasoning either apart from a little flaked salt. Creamed spinach which was an upcharge as a side was literally spinach with cream. Not a composed dish at all. Bernaise, also an upcharge was gelatinous and had no flavor. Bottom line -- we were expecting a lot based on the hype and some of the reviews -- and it didn't deliver. You can do much better elsewhere. Kindle, Harbor or Lewes Oyster House are all great choices. read more

We had an amazing experience. Love the new decor, we got the prefix menu, was wonderful. We were waited on by John, such exceptional service and personality. I wish this new adventure for the new owners much success. We will definitely be back. read more

Great place! Amazing food and service at a price point that is less than you would expect. Upscale but not pretentious. This is an outstanding restaurant! read more

Easter dinner the atmosphere & food were excellent only 1 caveat the 2 seater table is a little cramped our server John was great and Jim the bartender was very friendly overall excellent experience read more

See all

Food and service was excellent!! We've been there twice now and 2nd time was just as good as the first. Waitress was so accommodating and they didn't rush you out. Great desserts too! read more

I can't begin to tell you, even though it's under new management last night the four of us had a reservation we were told when we made the reservation our table would be facing the wine cellar or near the piano.We were in a corner Put them at table 5 or 12 . People couples.that had No reservations got seated where we had requested to be seated at the time of our reservations . My husband was sitting practically in a doorway where people were coming in. They were busy I understand. But our server, Rob B was absolutely terrible. He tried to push things that we didn't want he did not have a personality. We spent over $400 for dinner and he was so unprofessional . I will say the ambience on the remodel was very nice. However we will never be returning there read more

1776 has been expertly remodeled, and it has the ambience of a modern fine dining steakhouse. The bar was extended in order to accommodate its many customers. There was no wait for us to sit for our 6:30 reservation. The popovers served before our meal were tasty and a nice touch. My old fashioned and my husband's dirty martini were very well made. The wine list is greatly improved. Our waiter, Stephano, was pleasant, well versed, and speedy. The escargot was delicious. My husband's 7 oz. filet was good. However, I was disappointed with my rack of lamb. More than half the meat was nestled in fat. I would not order it again. read more

If one could choose a negative 1 star tacky vinyl covered restaurant with leftovers you would only take home if you had a pet, this is how low a good restaurant acquired by a corporate local chain can go better to stay home and have a grilled cheese sandwich. read more

I and my party dined there. My family has owned Five-star restaurants for decades, and I tasked them with an unusual and verry complex request. The result was beyond superb. The result was beyond what I would expect from Ruth's Cris, or even Peter Luger. This restaurant is well worth the trip, and well worth the price. read more

P Great steaks and sides. Super service. Very noisy. Had a great time. We were there the first weekend it opened after renovation. It looks fantastic! read more

The upscale steakhouse is perfect with the ambulance, steaks,the service was awesome and the piano entertainment added to a delightful experience read more

About a month ago five of us went to this restaurant after it opened under new ownership. Yes, most of us got the happy hour menu. I was not impressed. I had the oysters that were horrible. They were overpowered by wet spinach and one tiny piece of burnt bacon. No flavor whatsoever. A few got scallop chips which were basically fried. They were like some kind of potato chip... and I still don't get it. It took all of the mayonnaise sauce to make them edible. We went to the old 1776 House last fall... there is no comparison. Not sure if we will ever go back. I hear that Rare in Lewes is much better. read more

Probably the most mediocre steak restaurant I've been to ever. Lobster bisque was delicious with a huge lobster tail but the steaks were completely unseasoned such a huge disappointment no crust no flavor I had the ribeye wife had the strip. Also staff was inattentive and we felt looked down upon all night because we were a table of two and they focused on larger tables. Had better steak at outback. read more

Food was good, but we had an awful waiter and nanahement seemed not to care. We waited quite a while before he came to table, and over all he was very brusk and nattentive and - we had to ask for bread basket 3 times. This was a birthday dinner and while we saw other waitstaff being very attentive (bread baskets with appetizers, and complimentary drinks being served for anniversary and birthday) there was no acknowledgement of our table birthday. Most disappointing was when we spoke with a manager. We complimented the food and then explained what transpired. His response..first he argued we reserved on open table so they wouldn't know there was a birthday, at which time my husband interjected that he told the waiter there was a birthday at the table. The managers response was sorry, enjoy your birthday. He did nothing to see how he could mitigate the situation, inquire as which waiter. Very disappointing . The food was good but if management handled a situation this way I'd rather spend my money elsewhere. read more