This is a nice, small restaurant. We went at 2:00 p.m. on the Monday after Christmas. There were only 3 parties seated, which isn't unusual for this time of day. There was 1 waitress and one chef (I think). Our waitress was lovely. She was gracious, helpful, and attentive even though there was one couple that was mostly monopolizing her time, asking a lot of detailed questions and switching tables mid-meal (?). They constantly were waving her over but she handled it well and managed to meet our needs and the other large party (6-8) very well.
My companion ordered the meatball sandwich and I ordered the Mediterranean Veggie Sandwich. We overheard the waitress mention how much she liked the soup of the day, a grilled tomato soup. As it was cold outside, we both ordered the soup. We were so glad we did. The soup was outstanding! The soup was clearly homemade, using very fresh ingredients. I think the tomatoes are roasted or charbroiled as there were tiny bits of roasted tomato in the pureed soup. My companion detected hints of roasted red pepper sweetness, and there was clearly a don't-worry-about-counting-calories amount of cream. The soup is served in a very small bowl with a toasted garlic baguette slice on top. It was stupendous. Had I known how delicious it was, I would have skipped the sandwich and had a big bowl of soup. As it was, I finished the soup far before I finished the sandwich and I just wished I had more.
The sandwich was absolutely delicious. It included roasted peppers, feta, crisp red onion, and artichoke hearts on a sandwich roll. It was lovely, and just the right amount of food. I also had hot tea, which was lovely. The waitress offered 4 different varieties including lemon, earl grey, and green tea. I forget the 4th option. The Meyer lemon tea was by Stash and was yummy though I wished the water were a touch hotter as it had cooled significantly by the end of the meal. The waitress did offer more hot water so really it's my own fault I didn't take her up on it.
My companion had the meatball sandwich. He said it was yummy. The meat was finely ground and well seasoned. There was exactly the right amount of homemade (!) marinara sauce. My companion rarely brings home leftovers but definitely asked for a to-go box for the remainder. Between the sandwich and soup, there was plenty of food.
The food is served on orange and gold fiesta ware, which seemed a bit odd since this is an Italian restaurant, but for me it was a quirky detail that seemed charming. There are italian posters decorating the walls. The restaurant is on the small side but seemed very comfortable with only 3 parties being served on a late Monday afternoon. There is one co-ed restroom. For gatherings, there is an alcove sort of area near the restroom which seated a big party of 6-8. If the Stuffed Olive ever moves to a larger location, I recommend a separate room for large parties read more