My husband and I went to our Easter dinner to the Ship Lantern Inn. My initial report was bad. The service was exceptionally great. My only complaint is that I did not get what I expected. The only thing that was really bad is that I ordered NY Style cheesecake with raspberry glaze When I had it when we got home there was no glaze and the cheesecake was not good. Overall I cannot complain on the service and attention. Thank you Matt for talking to me. read more

We went to this restaurant twenty years ago and never went back. Heard it had been renovated and decided to try again yesterday. Walked into the first door to be greeted by fake florals and Christmas tree lights. Opened the second door and saw the same dark place and was overwhelmed by an all encompassing odor that made us turn on our heels and go to Crew in Poughkeepsie. I'll take full responsibility as it's obvious that others love this place. It's not you, it's me. read more

Found this gem while visiting the area. Such a great old school steakhouse. The building is so beautiful, much history there for sure. The service and food were beyond on point. We will definitely be back. read more

See all

Great food and ambience at this place. I tried the escargot, was expecting the typical butter/oil and garlic so I was a little disappointed. It didn't register well in my brain. Whenever I have a chance, I always try the Osso Bucco. It wasn't as good as the best ones I've tasted, but it's still good. The meat was tender and the sauce was good. The rest were the meals of the rest of the family. They seemed to like it. read more

See all

My go-to Kingston venue. Good food and wine. Cozy atmosphere. Attentive service. Nice date place.

First time at ship lantern. Escargot boring. Not enough garlic. Baked clams no flavor. Unfortunate. With so much steak on the menu you would think they would make bernaise sauce. Staff friendly and attentive. Atmosphere pleasant. Filet mignon excellent. Didn't order dessert. Full. My husband ordered Fish stew. Thought it was very good. read more

I was just there for my birthday a few days ago. Had been there once before and really enjoyed the seafood sampler appetizer. Decided to make that the main course for my birthday dinner the other day. This time the food didn't quite match up to my first visit both in freshness and taste. The clams were chewy and the oysters were dry of any juices on this visit. The rest of the platter was enjoyable. I think a mignonette sauce would have been a nice compliment to the shellfish. I didn't mind any of that as much as I was offended by the unmistakable smell of a used adult diaper as soon as we entered the restaurant. Which immediately gave a flash back of my previous/first visit. We were seated next to an older gentleman and his family and I was looking daggers at him throughout my meal, thinking he was to blame for the stench I was smelling. Turns out he wasn't at fault. I felt so bad for hating him that first dinner. The servers were very attentive, but must be nose blind to that smell. I sincerely marvel at how no one else seemed bothered at all by the odor. I was breathing through my mouth the entire time. Besides the questionable clams and oysters, the rest of the food was good. I would need to eat outside if I ever dine there again. read more

The Ship Lantern Inn - Seafood platter - New American Near Me - Milton, New York

I've been going here my whole life and it's an instant go-to on my list of places to eat when I want a GOOD dinner out somewhere. The service is unmatched. You can tell all members from the hosts, to bartenders, to the wait staff are all passionate about their craft. Always cleanly dressed in suit attire. Very attentive, they can also impressively recite the menu from memory. The food quality is of the highest order. I've never had one complaint about this place in 30 years. The calm and relaxing atmosphere is accentuated by the just bright enough, but not too bright lighting, rustic aesthetic, and old time vibe read more

The place is very charming with accents all around which are boat themed. Our server was very nice and attentive and she was very knowledgeable about the menu and specials. The overall atmosphere was a bit more on the formal side but reminded me up upscale golf club vibes. A lot of polo shirts & button ups on the men and a lot of dresses on the women. It was quiet and made for a relaxing dinner. We opted to get the 100 year anniversary dinner for two which consisted of two surf & turf meals with filet mignon, lobster tail, potatoes and seasonal veggies and it came with two salads and two desserts! Before our dinner came out and almost immediately after we sat down we got half a loaf of fresh bread. The salad was nice and the dressing tasted homemade. The dinners were perfect! The filets were so tender they fell apart with the touch of your fork and the lobster was a good size and served with butter which had its own little tea-light chaffing dish. The mashed potatoes were creamy and the veggies were a nice touch! Overall great portion size as well! We took one dessert home but ate one there and it was a chocolate torte of sorts which was served with whipped cream and some berries! It was very rich chocolate and the berries tasted fresh! We also ordered an espresso which was nice with minimal bitterness so you know it was made correctly! Overall we had a wonderful dinner and if I'm ever back in the area I would love to come back for another meal! read more

The Ship Lantern Inn - Surf & Turf - New American Near Me - Milton, New York

I can't believe I have lived 30 minutes away from this gem for years and tonight is the first time we went. To be honest my wife and I were saving the inn for a romantic night away but tonight we were shopping as a family right by the restaurant and everyone was dressed nice so we decided to try it. Are you kidding me with this joint? I'm so glad we went in. The service was over the top, we had a waitress and a maitre'd waiting on us hand and foot. The food was also an excellent experience- I started with a shrimp cocktail which had 2 different cocktail sauces. I then had the osso bucco on a bed of risotto - not to be missed. And I ended with the bananas foster which was served old school with the tableside cooking presentation. My wife had the filet mignon which was cooked perfectly. She also had a crock of French onion soup which she loved read more

First time coming here. You definitely can feel the history of this restaurant. Everything was really good. The cocktails were great. Can't wait to come back. read more

Had a wonderful wedding anniversary supper. Everything was delicious including the ample cocktails. We ordered a dessert sampler thinking it was a small portion of three desserts but it turned out to be three full-size portions (we took the cheesecake home)! Looking forward to our next opportunity to visit. read more

Reminded me of diner food not the quality I had been used to over the years. The servers were overwhelmed and not properly trained. Didnt clear the table from one course to another. We're told to request the 7:00 pm seating because the the earlier times were "crappy "tables and that would be better at 7:00. Turns out our table was next to the silverware table and the clearing of tables area. read more

The Ship Lantern Inn - Slopped the potatoes onto the plate like we were in the Army field mess kitchen - New American Near Me - Milton, New York

As always, every restaurant begins with five stars. On the plus side: lovely ambience for a winter meal with the roaring fireplace in the three season room. The restaurant has been here for a very long time and could use some minor updates. I love the, pine paneling and the clubby vibe, but some of the tchotchkes really need to go. This was a special supper for my birthday celebration and the host was my son and daughter, so I do not know what the total tally for the meal was for five of us. Most of the items on the menu ranged in the $25-$35 per plate range for an entrée. Service was very pleasant, and the weight staff was dressed appropriately. Tables were crammed a bit too close together, but otherwise it was a cozy environment, and the crackling fire made for a lovely backdrop. We did not get into too many appetizers - just a Caprese salad. Unfortunately, the mozzarella was spongy and almost tasted like it had been frozen previously. I would pass on that one. Entrées: my daughter and sister ordered the short ribs, special with butternut squash, risotto, and steam vegetables. Nicely presented, and they were very pleased with the dish. My niece had the salmon, which appeared to be a bit overcooked. In fact, I don't recall the waitress asking for a temperature on the salmon. The glaze looked nice, and she seemed pleased with it. Now, for the disappointment: the special was tomahawk steak for two. my son, and I decided to go for it. What a total disappointment this was: all of the meals arrived to the table and sat getting cold in front of our guests, while the meter D fumbled with the tomahawk steak across the dining room. Table service would have been much more impressive and serving the tomahawk steak cut and placed back on the bone in the center of the table would have been the right thing to do. Unfortunately, the steak was carved in a very clumsy fashion, and the temperature was significantly off.we ordered rare to medium and got rare to raw. There was no sear on the outside of the steak and the pieces were dumped on ceremoniously on our individual plates with fat side on appealingly present. The fat on the steak was not properly rented nor cooked. This made for a very unappealing experience - chewy and rubbery texture on the steak. I do not know what my son paid for this special cut, but whatever it was, it was not worth it. The dessert options were very nice - they had a dessert sampler for two for about $29 which included three selections. Our table of five did well with two of those and we all shared but the waitress forgot to bring individual plates so the devil was in the detail. this is a solid 3 1/2 star restaurant but you do have to be careful about what your selection is. Nice for a quiet, family gathering, date night, but please leave the kids at home. read more

See all

What a beautiful Christmas Eve dinner!! It was just going to be hubby and I so we decided to treat ourselves to a really nice dinner. The Ship Lantern Inn is a beautiful restaurant- inside and out. Such a rustic and charming building and decorated beautifully for Christmas. The fireplace added the perfect Christmasy glow. We were so warmly welcomed as we entered and brought to our table right away. Warm bread was brought to our table and our waitress came right over for the drinks order. I opted for the Orange Sunset - so delicious! Hubby and I both had prime rib - both steaks were cooked to perfection and so flavorful and tender. With the house salad, bread and dinner, I was too full for dessert. The waitstaff is so attentive and friendly. I'm truly looking forward to going back. Worthy of all 5 stars!! read more

The food is amazing. The service is wonderful and I go there every year for my birthday and special occasions.

I was at the ships about 1 month ago with about 12 people I ordered the chilean sea bass $42.00. It was terrible it was about 4 or 5 Oz about 1/4 in thick it was hard on the outside. inside was like mashed potato.must have been old other people ordered filet mignon it came out well done and dry ordered medium The last time I was there it was nothing to talk about,don't think we will be back again! read more

Food- beyond bland and cold. Service- good Ambiance- Old and dated. Cause I can't give No stars! So I took my boyfriend here for his birthday, neither of us had been here before. It was his choice. We had the appetizer- stuffed clams, we enjoyed them. I had the flounder with crabmeat. The flounder was fried with a flour breading and had no taste. It had 3 lumps of Cold crab on top and a white sauce and 2 large asparagus sticks. I must have put salt at least 3 times. The mashed potatoes were cold on the inside and the veggies consisted of one carrot slice and 2 spears of squash, they were room temperature But the plates were very hot. Clearly they had the food under lamps, not entirely sure why and there was one other table occupied. The place looked and smelled OLD and musty. The price was high for the subpar food they provided. Will Never return- awful! read more

We took my father here for his 70th birthday. Everything was just ok. My duck was dry (as was the weird wild rice/chickpea thing on the side) , my husband's steak was meh, the caprese salad was a $14 half a tomato with a small chunk of mozzarella, the escargot was not great. My mom (who has a notoriously very small appetite) finished her sea bass, "not because it was good per se, but because it was tiny". The staff was nice, but they definitely forgot about us a few times because we were outside (water, taking our order, the bill etc). The food was simply not good enough for the price they were asking for. If you want to charge that much, either do something innovative or do something really well and they did neither. read more

Last evening we rediscovered how great a meal can be. I must begin with the staff and its attention to the diners, its knowledge of the menu and the pleasantness they exuded. From beginning to end they were the glue that made a wonderful dining experience possible. We had a quiet corner table in a side dining area that was just perfect for us. The food was outstanding. We had clams casino which was a good as any we have ever had. Goodness as I type I'm salivating just remembering the taste. The soup of the day came next. Vichyssoise! Cool, refreshing and delicious! We had forgotten how good this potato soup could be. For the main courses we went our different ways. My wife had the Slow Roasted Mallard Duckling with an Orange sauce with a medley of vegetables and Toasted Orzo and wild rice pilaf. It was cooked to perfection and tasted great. I had the Pan Roasted Double Cut Hatfield Pork Chop with a Burnt Orange and Maker's 28.5 Mark Caramel Pan Au Jus with a medley of veggies and Hudson Valley Apple Chutney -- WOW! is all I can say. What a great tasting piece of meat with a wonderful combination of flavors. While the desserts part of the menu was very tempting we were full and very happy and satisfied. We will be back!. read more

Service was great but the food that night was rough. I sent my fish back- I think it went bad. They were very nice about it but definitely cannot recommend. read more

We came here for a nice dinner during my sister's bachelorette weekend. The bread served came with a fantastic dip made of olive oil and various spices, perhaps sundried tomatoes? I wasn't exactly sure what was in it. I shared the ahi tuna tartare appetizer with someone and it tasted delicious. I got the seafood stew for myself. There was an insane amount of seafood in the stew, which was great. It said it was served over angel hair pasta but there was barely any noodles at all. However, the quality of the seafood was superb. My sister did not like her cocktail, saying it was very syrupy and another one of the girls in our party complained about her drink as well and sent it back. I personally did not order a cocktail. While the cocktails weren't great, the food was great! read more

The Ship Lantern Inn - Calabria Seafood Stew - New American Near Me - Milton, New York

I am so disappointed that my previous five star reviews are now a thing of the past. It seriously pains me to give this place 3 stars, but I really have no choice after last night's visit. I made reservations for my partner's birthday celebration dinner for 6:00PM. We arrived to a packed parking lot, so we knew it was crowded and it seemed there was a private party going on as well. We were seated promptly and service started on point as usual. We asked for the wine list, made our choice, and that was taken care of. We were told about the specials and decided on our menu. We both ordered soup, and decided to share the stuffed clams as our appetizer. The next few minutes seemed to have set the pace for this 3 star review. Our soup was brought to the table with our appetizer! Seriously? Even low end restaurants don't commit that type of major service error! I was going to ask them to take it back and keep the appetizer warm until we finished our soup, but who wants dried out stuffed clams! Normally, our waiter (or someone else) comes over after each course is delivered and tasted to make sure everything is ok. That never happened. No one even glanced our way. We finished our soups and our now room-temp clams, poured our own wine, and waited. Someone cleared the table and within a minute we had our salads, dropped off with a bang (almost thrown), wordlessly. Soups were good. Stuffed clams were really good, and would have been better had they been hot. Please let people know, when they ask to share an appetizer, that there are only 3 clams. We would have changed it had someone told us. Salad was ok - just lettuce and a few bell pepper strips. I forgot to mention that the bread has changed, and now it appears to be sliced white bread. It was still warm and delicious, but not as good as our previous visits. Also, during our meal, we had to move our chairs so a couple of waiters could get tablecloths out of the cabinets behind us. Really? Entrees were delivered quickly. His osso bucco was absolutely delicious - exactly the same as in previous visits. I went with something different and tried the Calabrian Seafood stew over angel hair pasta. It looked amazing when they put it down in front of me. Then I looked closer. Before I started eating, I had to remove one unopened mussel, and a couple pieces of broken shell along with a broken mussel. The person plating the dish would have noticed it had they been paying attention. The seafood was pretty good. The shrimp were on the verge of being overcooked, along with some of the clams. Mussels and lobster were good. The angel hair pasta was perfectly al dente, but it didn't seem like the right pasta to go with the sauce. The sauce was pretty good, but completely overloaded with onions. I'd never get that dish or any seafood entree there again. Someone who I presume to be the manager asked how everything was after we started our entrees, and when I said "pretty good" he asked if he could do something to fix it. At that point we long finished our soup and room-temp apps, and I had already dealt with the bad mussels and so there was nothing he could change or fix. Once again, we ended up pouring our own wine for the entire meal. The only time someone poured (after the first glass) was when they cleared the table and noticed a tiny bit left at the bottom of the bottle. After they cleared the table, I stepped away for a moment. I went over to the gentleman who was seating people to ask him to let our waiter know that it was my partner's birthday, and that I would like a candle put in his dessert. He stepped away, and came back a moment later to tell me it was all arranged and taken care of. I thanked him and went back to join my partner. (I found out later that one of the waiters, the woman who started a day before, actually walked over to my partner at that point before I even got back to the table, and said "I hear it's your birthday". Well thanks for blowing that surprise!!!!! Someone please teach her some common sense!!!) So anyway, he ordered creme brulee and coffee, and I ordered a cappuccino. Coffee came out - and it was excellent. Then came the creme brulee - with NO CANDLE. Nothing. What the heck happened to my SIMPLE request that was "taken care of"??? At that point, it was the last straw. I got up to look for the gentleman who "took care of" this, and instead found the manager. I will say they handled the apologies well. The person I originally told apologized, as did the waiter who apparently dropped the ball AFTER she mentioned the birthday to my partner. We were offered a free drink, and our dessert and coffees were comped, which was nice. Unfortunately, my partner still never got the one small simple thing he enjoys - a candle for his birthday celebration. All in all, we will likely put this place at the bottom of our list for any future visits. read more

See all

When my wife & I travel upstate we are so happy to see that the Inn is still operating...we're hopeful that it will go on forever. On a busy weekend late afternoon, a small crew kept everything together and good drink, good food and service were all ours. We each ordered the prix fixe menu and got great value. Food was delicious and sitting by the fire was a treat. Highly recommended. Now, if they could find an old-school craftsman or woman to fix their lovely old neon sign.... read more

Very good food. The ambiance is perfect for all occasions (dress coat or not). Service is always spectacular. The menu changes during a holiday. Mother's Day menu for example was great this year. read more

Dear foodie friends this one is so bad it's beyond review. Please TRUST me when I tell you don't even think about stopping here !! Someone needs to blow out the LANTERN so that nobody finds there way INN to this sunken SHIP !!!! I'm done !! You've been warned. Reviewed by Foodie N Friends read more

See all

Came here on a Friday night for dinner and I have to say it was all very well organized.. we were seated immediately (yes we had reservations) and since it was restaurant week, we partook in the menu. The choices all sounded delicious. I ended up getting the shrimp appetizer and the orecchiette with crab meat for the main course. As for dessert, I got the tiramisu. My hubby ordered the truffle risotto for the app and the steak for the entree. He got the apple crisp for dessert. Our waiter was very attentive and the food was spot on. The ambiance was also very cute, romantic and relaxing. An absolute great time. Such a hidden gem. read more

See all

An average diner in NYC would easily beat out this place, if it were a side by side competition. The food is bland, & lacks seasoning in general. The quality & presentation is lack luster. The prices are a bit steep for what they're offering. This is a once & done for me. read more

Great service the food was right on on the ambience was unbelievable Great service the food was right on on the ambience was unbelievable read more

Service was great. Certain facets of the meal, like the sauces, seemed like they came straight out of a packet. Just guessing, but they were so salty that it didn't seem possible if they were house made. Next time I would stick to a steak. read more

Service is always Class-A! The professionalism of waiting tables and providing excellent table service to dining customers is emphasized, from the moment you walk through the doors. The attentiveness of the staff is a consistent reassurance that your dining experience will be the top priority. The food presentation, starting with the freshly baked, warm bread loaf and small dish of butter is a great start. A side dish of the roasted pepper and tomato dip is a perfect accompany to the bread. The baked clams as an appetizer were cooked with the perfect balance of crab and stuffing. The portion size of the meals from appetizers to the main course and the dessert are just enough to leave full and satisfied, without to go containers necessary. Presentation of the main course is plated with thought and mindfulness of the texture and proper portion of the main dish and sides. As a vibe, the Ship Lantern inn is a classy, old school soul with frank sinatra radio with a glass of wine near the fireplace or a semi-relaxed, professionally dressed with an old fashioned or martini. My one critique would be a slight modern update to the flooring and an individual table seating arrangement aesthetic, rather than a grouped room feel. If you are looking to experience fine dining that is legendary local culinary cuisine that will not disappoint, look no further! read more

Everything was so, so good. We started with the French Onion Soup, then got the Black Angus Sirloin with Bone Marrow Butter, and Braised Beef Shortrib. The short rib was one of the best I ever had- just so, so tender. The steak was so good, I thought it should've been more expensive. The soup was picture perfect, and also not too salty. The child's mac and cheese literally looked like it was from the blue box, but if the kid ate it fine, that's all you need. The side salad was honestly a little sad, but the entrees and soup made up for it. The restaurant has a lot of charm and history. It also was decked out in Christmas decorations and had a real fireplace! A great place for great meals. read more

The Ship's Latern is a well established, old school historic restaurant on Route 9W south in Milton, NY. The table service is friendly, informative and attentive. The food is classic in style, and presentation. We enjoyed creatively delicious cocktails, Pellegrino sparkling mineral water, as well as the Boylans Creme soda. The seafood risotto with crab and shrimp appetizer was tasty, but was not cooked with arborio rice. The double cut pork chop was nicely seared and quite large. The short ribs looked great but were not tender, and a bit stringy in texture. The soft shell crabs provencal special was good and the sauce included sweet red and yellow cherry tomatoes. We enjoyed eating outside under the tent. Although we didn't have dessert, there seemed to be a good list of offerings. The bar inside is classic nautical style and quite cozy. Overall we enjoyed our dining experience. read more

See all

Excellent as always. Top notch service and food. Great for a special occasion or birthday.

This place was okay. My salmon was slightly dry and didn't have much flavor. The service was great and everyone is so nice I just wish the food was better. The ambience is nice and classy. The food is not worth the price. You're paying for the ambience. read more

Old school CLASS. Food is incredibly delicious with a nice and varying selection. Great specials are available, great place to celebrate holidays with family over a meal that is a real crowd pleaser. Whether it's a group, or small intimate dinner for two, there is always a place within TSLI that offers that ambiance ... where you leave feeling like you had the royal treatment. The bar area offers a nice spot for drinks/apps on its own or prior to being seated. read more

Great place, great food. What more could a person need, they have been there for years and I only hope they are there for many more years

never a bad meal, been going there for years. We love their bread and desserts too! They make a great prime rib and you have to try their crab meat cocktail if you go there. The service is top notch as well! read more

4.5 stars. No reservations- they took us anyway. Amazing service and awesome food. Great flavors demonstrate amazing cooking skills and technique. Myself and half of dining room had short ribs! Other dish was seafood fra diavolo. Would definitely return. read more

The Ship Lantern Inn - Short ribs - delicious amazing sauce. - New American Near Me - Milton, New York

See all

Great Ambiance. I had the Short Ribs and my fiancé had the Salmon. Both were Amazing and so flavorful. Portions are very large, we definitely could have split an Entree. Servers were very knowledgeable and very friendly. We are Gluten Free and they were able to accommodate us. Wine & Dessert were Fabulous. Would definitely come back! read more

The Ship Lantern Inn - Inside Table - New American Near Me - Milton, New York