The decor and ambiance inside is much more elevated than I imagine when I hear "pizzeria". Gold accents, mirrors, and nice marble ~ no red checkered plastic table cloths here! The menu had lots of great options without being overwhelming. I couldn't even decide on a pizza, they all sounded so good! We got a Caesar Salad Chicken Cutlet which was satisfying as a salad and as a protein. I liked that it was served with fresh lemon. We also got the beggars purse pasta with a sausage cream sauce. I felt that the pasta had a bit too much sauce but all meals were served with pizza bread so I used that to soak it up. The pricing was fair for the quality and vibe of the restaurant. This restaurant has its own spacious parking lot as well. read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - the Caesar Cutlet - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Great food and friendly service. But $9 for a draft beer with a 1" head of foam on it is "in your face" obnoxious. Businesses that do this are hurting themselves in the long run. We know costs are high, but this is the wrong way to close the revenue gap and isn't providing customers with a "good value" feeling. There are still several very good places where a beer is $6 or $7. We'll go there. read more

I love coming here, especially grabbing a seat at the bar. The food is consistently outstanding, and I have to mention the meatballs appetizer...they are absolutely incredible and a must-order every time. The staff is always friendly and attentive, even when the place is packed which it usually is (for good reason!). The energy is great, the service never skips a beat. If you're looking for a lively spot with amazing food, this place never disappoints. read more

We'd heard good things about The Pizzeria so decided to give the one in Babylon village a try. I had a good vibe immediately since it has its own dedicated parking lot with free parking for customers. Huge perk in Babylon Village. They were upgrading the back entrance so we had to walk past some ladders but inside you couldn't tell work was being done. Everything was so clean and welcoming!! There's a huge bar, which sets it apart from other quick service pizza places. The variety of specialty pies was incredible. I ordered regular slice and it was excellent. We have many choices in good pizza in this neighborhood and The Pizzeria holds its own against any of them. My son's friend got a chicken slice that tasted like General Taos on pizza with a tangy sweet Asian sauce and red hot peppers for spice. It was delicious and heavy - we ended up splitting it 3 ways in addition to each eating a regular slice. Will definitely be back next time we are around that way. It's hard to impress me with pizza and I was impressed! read more

See all

Came here for lunch after a team outing. It was pretty quiet when we walked in but started to get busy shortly after. We got the lunch special for 15 dollars. Now usually lunch specials are these half servings BUT NO not here. Got a full heart chicken censer wrap and a massive bowl of butternut squash soup. It was at super noisy. They had good music playing in the background. The staff were friendly and attentive. read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Chicken Caesar Wrap - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

The Pizzeria--what happened?! An eggplant parm hero with cut-up bits instead of real slices is just not it. Super disappointing!!! It was really gross bread soaked in way too much sauce YUCK HARD PASS read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Sorry, excuse for eggplant - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Jake was great behind the bar and made sure our drinks were full and fresh! Truly a nice and attentive bartender even though it was busy. Food came out hot and timely. Not a first time, but will be back again! -Peter and Mike read more

Unusual experience tonight. First of all my husband and I go to this place every other Monday night as a date night. We were always happy with the food and the experience. Today was so different, ordered the chicken dish which was not the same as usual, no onions and basil leaves mixed in with arugula. Very strange combo and taste. Ordered our usual Babylon personal pie with basil well done. The pie took over 25 mins to come and the place was not crowded as it usually is at that time. When it came it was crispy on the edges and on the raw side in the middle. It was not the fresh mozzarella it was the regular pizza mozzarella. I ate half a slice then took the rest home in the box and threw it out. My husband did not want me to say anything ( he does not return food) . Now the bill comes and the menu states 14.95 for the pie, I am charged 19.95. I asked the waitress and she said maybe it was because you wanted basil on the pie but she would ask. She then came back and said no it wasn't the basil her manager said the price went up but it's not on the menu so we are ONLY charging you 16.95. Very disappointed in the service, timing and pricing tonight. Not really happy with the explanation of the increase in price. We get the same order every other week so I know what to expect. I brought my niece to the pizzeria in lindenhurst and she loves it!!! She goes with her family all the time, she recently went to Babylon and didn't find it as good. I'm not sure what's up there all of a sudden but tonight really bothered me read more

Beautiful restaurant with a huge bar. It was crowded for a Thursday night. Quick service & great food. We had the Caesar salad & chicken dinner & Penne al vodka which were both delicious. read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

So pretty inside! Super spacious dining area. It was really busy when I went so I knew the food was going to be good. I ordered the chicken and broccoli rabe for a lighter meal and my husband ordered the tricolored chicken parm which was really good! read more

See all

The food was poor. I always loved this place but twice in a month it's been really bad. Rice balls are literally mush with no flavor and drowned in sauce. Ordered baked clams were fishy. Ordered gluten free pizza that was soggy burnt and could not eat it. My son ordered chocolate brownie d couldn't even get his fork in, it was hard as a rock. I could go on the whole meal was a disappointing disaster. The manager was nice enough to destroy the whole check. I unfortunately will not be going Back it seems like the quality of food that was served when they opened has changed drastically. read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Gluten free pizza dough raw crust burnt. Sloppy and not good at all - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

I usually like this spot because the pizza is normally great. Last friday, we got the large tri fecta pizza in which the bottom was not crispy like usual and it was more soft. It was not that busy yet and our server, Kassandra, was extremely unpleasant. Did not check up on us once. We had to keep finding other works to get chili flakes, get another plate, and to get a refill on the beer. My husband had to track her down for us to even get our check. Might have to reconsider going back here. read more

I attended my friend's Bridal Shower here at The Pizzeria of Babylon and it was amazing! The service and staff was super attentive and the food was so good - meatballs, prosciutto and bread, salad served as appetizers for the table and for the main course, penne ala vodka, chicken parm, and eggplant rollilini. I paired all that deliciousness with a drink called the Little Silician. Very refreshing and light - Limoncello, Prosecco, lemon and mint. Very tasty. The desert was cake, which I believe the host brought in and the restaurant cut into slices, with rainbow cookies (too sweet for my liking) and cannolis. I love the setup of this spot, very open and bright with a bar smack dab in the middle. A great time was had by all. This was a nice spot to host an event such as a shower or will be a great selection to cater your event. Looking forward to my next visit! read more

The Pizzeria of Bab is my new favorite restaurant! Great for a date night or a causal dinner with friends! I love vibe, like an upscale pizzeria! The pastas and pizzas are amazing and they have a good selection of wines! Cant wait to go back! read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

This place was crazy busy for a 7pm on a Thursday night. But the food was fantastic for take out. The staff were really nice, they even gave us extra knots! There wasn't as much tables for the amount of people eating in, but that's what happens when you're so busy I suppose. Great place, huge variety of food. Would love to come back here! read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Absolutely FLOORED by the service 10/10: our server Regina was on top of it; she asked us if we needed refills when needed, very kind and courteous. The appetizer was amazing, we had the hot honey whipped roccota and lemon honey bread 10/10 soo soo good! And our drinks were out of this world amazing! Highly recommend the little Sicilian and the Main Street drink! Entrees were perfect! I had the endless summer shrimp pasta DELICIOUS!! And the crumbling vodka personal pie was insane!! Would recommend to anyone. We came on a Friday afternoon it was perfection read more

Great martinis and even better food. I came here with a friend for a nice dinner and drinks and we loved it! We both enjoyed our meals and had many leftovers to take home. The drinks and service were fantastic as well! read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Espresso martini - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

FINALLY a pizza place in the village where you can dine in comfortably. When you walk in, you'll see framed superhero pizza lovers created by local high school students. I love that they incorporate the community into their decor and ambiance. We've ordered via the online ordering system, by phone, have sat in for dining service and have also grabbed a few slices on the more casual side. Everyone here is always super kind, helpful and friendly. Our favorite is the Babylon pie - hits the spot every time. The fried raviolis are a fab appetizer to share. If you dine in with kids, they have questions on the back of the menu. If they get enough right, free Zeppolis! So, brush up on your pizza knowledge and hit up the Pizzeria. Ciao! read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Babylon Pie - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

The homemade meatballs appetizer truly tastes like they were made by 'Nonna'. We also ordered a Vodka Margherita personal pie; hands down the best personal pie we've ever had. I happen to like thin crust, but this was not only thin, it was light and tasted very fresh! Looking forward to our next visit! read more

The Pizzeria of Babylon - Homemade Meatballs Appetizer - Italian Near Me - Babylon, New York

See all

Amazing food no matter wha you order. Form slices, to sandwiches, salad and entrees you will not be disappointed. The price is and portions are very generous and fair in my opinion. Has an upscale ambiance but also very practical and laid back for families. The service is phenomenal and always welcoming. Highly recommend the summer spring! read more

Update...so, this is a top notch pizzeria in town, the pizza is delicious as always. Customer service was a hit and a miss! I bring special needs adults into the community during the day for work, and usually, I have great experiences at "my spots.". This time, the older man that was taking "his" order was rolling his eyes and was totally impatient. He got mad that he didn't order mozzarella sticks before we got there for a sit down order?!? He was saying "what?!? You didn't call it in?!?" And walked off angry. Another man jumped and took the order, and the first man rang him up, then ignored me and took the next customer so i couldn't order a slice. I had to jump in and tell him I needed to order. The second man was very kind and brought it to the table. Again, the food is delicious, but they are not always the friendliest. read more

See all

I ordered takeout here on Monday and it was excellent as usual. I had one of the family meals. It was hot and ready when I went to pick it up. The cashier was very friendly. The restaurant was very clean and well kept It was a great experience as always. read more

I usually have pictures - I wish I did because this place rocked! We had a party of 22 on a Saturday at 3:30! Not only did they handle (9 kids!), but also they crushed it. The food: The chicken parm rivals your best restaurants around. Might even be the best I've ever had. The sweet chili chicken pizza (I think that's what it's called) was so tasty and hit in levels. This is not your average pizzeria! Even the salad rocked! Staff/ambiance: Everyone who worked there - not just our waitress - was so sweet and accommodating. The place is beautiful, fresh, and clean. Thanks for a great experience! read more

Came here for a date night and sat at the bar. Our bartender (wish i knew his name) was really kind. We got our drinks fast. Ordered personal pizzas and it was so delicious! I had a good time at the pizzeria will definitely be coming back. The food and the employees are great ! Have also done pick up and food is always fresh. read more

They have the best gluten free crust I have ever had!!! So good, this is a must try!!!

The ambiance is nice, place is very well lit. We got 2 appetizers, the mozzarella sticks and calamari. The calamari was HUGE and delicious. The mozz sticks were so goey, mozz cheese tasted so fresh and homemade. The wrap was also fantastic, the dressing was light but delish. Only complaint is the bartender didn't add a rim to the margs & the wrist fell apart when i picked it up buuuuut we made do! read more

See all

Delicious we love the meatballs & Ricotta.. We've ordered a few different types of pizza, always delicious! Very happy and satisfied when we leave kudos! read more

Great food, great big open and lively location. I even messed up and ordered pick up from the wrong location!!!! But Joe, here is so cool, he called Lindenhurst and told them to cancel it and had us sit down while he made a fresh order for me and the kids here. Five stars for being awesome. The 3 kids all loved the plain pie. I loved the Sicilian and the Mezzi rig with Eggplant. Definitely come try it out! read more

See all

I have been to the Pizzeria in Lindenhurst and in Bay Shore, and this location is just as great. There is plenty of seating and lighting, which is nice and helps the restaurant feel very open. The menu has a little of something for everyone, including summer specials. Finally, our server was super nice and attentive throughout our meal, which I really appreciated. read more

See all

Good food at reasonable prices. Loved the braised short ribs w/ risotto Good bar situated in center of restaurant read more

We came here for a quick lunch and sat on the counter side of the restaurant. The sit down side had a bar in the middle which was a different vibe than your typical pizza place. My husband had a buffalo slice and I had a chicken caesar wrap but it was made with a thin pizza dough and topped with some Parmesan cheese and a little dressing. It was definitely different and very good. My only complaint was the girl behind the counter was not very into working I suppose. I asked her if the drinks in the top row of the fridge if they were iced tea and green tea and she just glanced and was like "I think it is unsweetened iced tea." Why not just go look in the fridge? Everyone else was friendly and helpful. read more

Awesome food and great service!!! Would recommend to everyone! Takes the normal "pizzeria" to a whole new level!

Really good wings, the pizza doesn't disappoint either. Service was good and the atmosphere is upbeat. Definitely will be back here.

Food is delicious. Service felt warm, till the bill part. Paid with cash and got back whole dollars only, no coin. I asked about it and was told they don't do change, Felt a bit off, like nickel - and - diming in reverse. Then I was told they will be going cashless in the future. Just wish they had said this upfront. A good meal shouldn't end on that negative note. Spoiled my visit a little. read more

I really enjoyed my experience here. The staff was very friendly and accommodating as well. The cannoli are some of the best I've had, definitely recommend. I had pasta which was good as well. I also enjoyed my spritz. read more

Pizza was an average doughy overpriced pie. Definitely not what we expected. The Arancini were mushy with no crispiness. It was a very busy nice open dining area and even though we sat by the takeout area we were attended to very nicely and service was prompt. read more

First time there. Good atmosphere, very good food. It was an enjoyable time. I'd certainly go again.

Sitting at the table for 2 on Main St side Saturday night. Our server Regina was awesome. Helpers to her were also great. Attentive but not bothersome service. The food was outstanding. Pizza the best! Dinners fantastic! Can't wait to come back. Our only complaint is that it was freezing cold where we were, right underneath the air ducts. The food got ice cold in no time. That was definitely a downer. Will not be seated in that area again. Just too cold for such a nice place with great food. read more

Ordered 2 pies for dine in. Asked for it to be cooked well done. When the server brought it to the table it was barely cooked with soggy mushy crust. Although it was tasty I know these places just want to rush rush rush and get the food out but for heaven's sakes come on! read more

if you're looking for a Great personal pizza or a great hero ..don't come here..we ordered each and it was TERRIBLE..it wasn't pizza..we also ordered a Caesar salad that was wilted and maybe left over from the weekend.. Service was very good but couldn't make up for the terrible food. Ambience was OK the restaurant is all stone so it was very loud... read more