We ate here the Monday night before Christmas, party of 8. We walked through the kitchen to get to our table, which was in a cozy little room with only one other table. Service was great! We had BBQ shrimp, crab cakes and hush puppies for apps. They were all tasty. Filet mignon was tender and flavorful. That, with the potatoes and greens that came with it, were on the heavy/rich end of the spectrum, so if you don't like that you might want to sub a baked potato. People also liked the salmon with risotto and the cranberry chicken. My husband did not like the seafood pasta. Nice, cozy atmosphere, good service and food. read more

The Oyster Bar - 130 years of history for this iconic seafood establishment The Oyster Bar is not for everyone. It is expensive. The restaurant only holds about 50 dinners and the tables are uncomfortably small & close together. It's also located in a neighborhood that might make some people take caution. On the flip side...The Oyster Bar offers 130 years of history in a uniquely older facility that features fresh high quality seafood along with outstanding service. You decide what you value and how you want to spend your dinning dollars. The Oyster Bar is located south of downtown area on Calhoun Street. The vintage building is well signed, lighted and offers an easy-in-easy-out side parking lot. The restaurant only holds about 50 dinners with a limited number of tables and a small bar. I would suggest that you call and make a reservation as The Oyster Bar is a fairly popular place to dine. Inside the building has retained the historic look. The foyer is very small...just like walking into an old house. They feature lots of dark hardwoods and a vintage looking bar. The tables are located very close together as you would expect in a small area. I think the tables are smaller in size as it was difficult to accommodate all the dishes, menus, glasses and cell phones. The white table linens and attractive "sea going" decor help set the experience. The staff on this night was very friendly, professional and helpful. They made us feel welcomed quickly. The waitress was great about removing dishes, refills and stopping to check on us. It's easier when all your tables are close together. Overall the food was excellent. Fresh seafood in Fort Wayne isn't common place. The food creations were delicious & creative without being all that unique. You will find a fairly broad menu to meet most dinner's choices. Here is a run down on the items we ordered: -Calm Chowder: very creamy without being overly rich to taste; moderately thick in consistency with a mild clam flavor; several larger pieces of clam meat; very good taste -Oysters on the half shell: beautiful presentation; oysters were fresh taste; no salty or "sea" tastes/smells; a small dab of sweet cocktail sauce and ground horseradish were nice add; oysters were outstanding!! -Fried Hushpuppies: no corn meal breading here. The outside was lightly fried and slightly oily to taste. The inside was slightly sweet, soft and moist. The chipotle aioli sauce has a very mild southwestern flavor that accented the sweet breading. -Crab Cakes: two fairly large cakes packed with real crab meat; gently fried; the fresh seafood flavors come through nicely; another very good dish! -Seafood Au Gratin: plenty of chunks of scallops and crab buried in a delicious lobster cream sauce and layer of mozzarella cheese. The sauce was creamy and mild without being rich. The seafood pieces retained their original flavor. The cheese topping was nice and gooey which held the seafood & sauce together nicely. Delicious dish!! -Diver Scallops: large and plump scallops cooked perfectly; very tender and moist without a "fishy" taste - nicely done!! I very much enjoyed the dinning experience. I love restaurants that retain and feature an older buildings character. I appreciate high levels of service and outstandingly delicious food. Especially when it comes to fresh seafood!! read more

See all

The wait was so long. We had reservations but still ended waiting 20 minutes for a table. We ordered drinks and that took very long to come. We ordered appetizers and that took so long to come. We ordered dinner, and we waited forever. Yet no apology for the long, long wait. A typical meal should be 90 min max. We were there for almost 2-1/2 hours. Will not go back. Food-wise, however, it was pretty good. Oysters were good, but the deviled eggs were too fishy tasting for me. Steak was good, but thought it'd be bigger. The low rating is due to the ridiculously long wait. read more

110% recommend. Don't regret missing your chance to experience delicious food and comfortable atmosphere. The service was beyond my expectations especially considering it was a Friday night. As a non-local, I felt like a regular. You won't be disappointed. read more

The Oyster Bar - Enjoyed to much to get great photos. My first time trying oysters and a delicious dessert to complete the night - Seafood Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

See all

The Oyster Bar has great food, and we got great and friendly service. Def want to try it again soon when they're serving prime rib.

Best in Fort Wayne! This has been my favorite for a long time. We have so many dining options in Fort Wayne for sure. If you want longevity, consistency, great food & service then Oyster Bar will not disappoint!!! Another plus is it's an original building. So with it's quaint and original atmosphere it a place you are just gotta love . If you have not tried and are from or new to Fort Wayne this place is a MUST. read more

Here on a Friday for lunch ... Service EXTREMELY SLOW and it's FREEZING inside - turn the heat up! Food is amazing as always but martinis are WAY over-priced. read more

As usual very wonderful!!!! What can i say it's an icon !! Food wonderful service great very busy but we were never forgotten!! Not sure how our waitress did.what she did always the greatest!!!!! Such a special place our first love!,, read more

Amazing experience! Loved the food and drinks! Staff made it a memorable occasion! If you are looking for somewhere to impress your date or friends this is it! One of Fort Wayne's best! Enjoy! read more

Great atmosphere, wonderful service, and delicious food! I shared the crab cakes as an appetizer and had the diver scallops as my entree and was impressed with both! I look forward to going back on the next special occasion! Make sure to make a reservation! We went on a Saturday and saw walk-ins get turned away. read more

Absolutely an Indiana miracle restaurant/bar. Perfect from start to finish. Excellent service. Unbelievable quality food. An atmosphere that makes you smile and a Fort Wayne landmark. The clam chowder is one of their signature dishes and worth it by far. If you have to go to Fort Wayne, Indiana do NOT miss this wonderful golden nugget. read more

Believe the hype! I was staying down the street at the Hilton and got a recommendation from the bartender. I walked down at about 4 PM and spoke with a waitress and the bartender in The Oyster Bar about the menu, seat availability, etc. They were both so kind and helpful. We returned at 7 for dinner and had seats reserved at the bar. This is a small restaurant, so reservations are recommended. It is a small restaurant but clean and very efficient. I had the raw Chesapeake Bay oysters and the Admiral Cut Filet mignon. Both were perfect! read more

See all

Utter embarrassment establishment. What was once a decent seafood pub has been made worse by new ownership. Freezing drafty entrance, cramped seating in wobbly chairs and tables. Staff lacks warmth they once had can only be a top down problem. Certainly, must have a new cook/chef as well lacking true seafood mastery. We will not return. read more

OMG! This place is a must while you're in town. The history of the location along with the service and experience were all amazing. The food met my expectations and then some I would highly recommend the oyster bar to anyone that is in the area. read more

The Oyster Bar - Seafood Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Classic old bar restaurant. Friendly staff, fresh , well prepared seafood. Multiple choices of oysters. Excellent clam chowder. Tuesdays are burger days, the real deal. Tiniest restroom on the planet! Worth the trip! read more

Went for savor Ft Wayne but have been here several times in the past. The food is always fresh and delicious. I loved the tuna tartare. Black and bleu salmon was very good, the bleu cheese was not over powering in the dish. Cioppino flavors were decent, but on the heavier side than I'm used to. Their bread is hot and fresh too. Full bar and cocktails here are strong. Our service this time was okay but we've definitely had better in the past here. It is VERY small inside but that's what makes it the oyster bar. read more

See all

Having been a long-time loyal patron, what a shocking experience. I recently had surgery and didn't want to inconvenience a server for a small meal. I called on Friday for a carry-out order at 4:15pm when a family member could pick it up for me in my condition. I was advised even though the bar was open, food could not be ordered until 5pm. I accepted this. I called at 5pm promptly, Saturday, and was advised, today, I could not even order a carryout. Everyone who has patronized The Oyster Bar knows very well, at 5pm, the tables are rarely filled. The rules had changed and the owner who had informed me of this was lacking any courtesy. My family member was actually waiting in the parking lot to help me. She insisted on trying to accommodate me. She went in and was approached by a server and asked if she could simply place a small order for an ailing family member. The server was fair and asked the new cook. She returned rather empathetic she could not help her or the business to make a sale. This business did not want to serve two individuals. I have never experienced such poor illogical business practices in my thirty plus years as a patron. This facility was far better run by the original owners who were kind, cared about customers, and went out of their way to execute amazing seafood. I had not been in for a while as the cooks keep changing and the seafood was not as it once was. I am afraid I have determined to move on. read more

By far one of my favorite spots in Fort Wayne! It's unique, quaint, and offers some of the freshest seafood in town. I usually order the fresh catch/chef's special, but you can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Be sure to call ahead for reservations because there are only a handful of tables and maybe 8 seats at the bar rail. read more

Food is absolutely fantastic. Our waitress however was super late getting to us in the first place, then another long wait for our drinks and again, another interminable wait for her to just take our app orders not to mention the wait for our meals. She would run out to the outdoor area and sit with patrons who were evidently friends of hers and be out there while we and others waited on her. Then while we're waiting for her to just take our dinner order or bring our drinks, she is taking selfies with the table next to us. Thank goodness the food was good cause the service, at least from our waitress, was horrible. read more

I really hoped to have a decent review but I can't. We had oysters Rockefeller and they had no seasoning and were swimming in green goo. The hush puppies were ok but the "crab" on top was ground up claw meat and bread crumbs. I had the trout with crab butter and it was so salty I couldn't eat it and paid extra for the crab butter and again was ground up crab claw with breadcrumbs. But before my dinner I had the house salad with the spring mix so bitter it tasted like grass. Please don't get the ranch dressing. It was watered down. My husband had the seafood au gratin and it had large lumps of crab/lobster and it was imitation! It also had no seasoning. The Cesar salad had no seasoning and tasted like fish juice dressing. My husband had 2 old fashions and he said they were really good. The bread was really good, but for a $200 dinner you should walk away with good food not just good bread. The service was good read more

Not fresh. Seafood au gratin was very heavy and too creamy. Hardly any seafood. They used imitation crab meat as well. For nearly $35. Not worth it. read more

The ambiance is very pleasant, with a cozy atmosphere that sets a nice tone. I'm a fan of their menu and specials. Although I can't recall the name of our waitress, she did an outstanding job--welcoming and incredibly helpful. The food was cooked to perfection, and the raw oysters were a highlight; you can't go wrong with them. read more

The Oyster Bar - Raw Oysters - Seafood Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Food was incredible, especially the calamari and oysters! The wait staff was friendly. The restaurant is dark but the ambiance is calm. read more

See all

Simply awesome! That should be enough for my review!! But damn it, Yelp; you gotta have more. So.. here.. we.. GO!! : Celebrating our 24th wedding anniversary, and my lovely wife and I came to The Oyster Bar! Let's not waste time, Let's not bore you with all the details because everything... I MEAN EVERYTHING, we ordered was awesome!! Period! Done! We had the Prawn Shrimp Cocktail, a half dozen Chesapeake Oysters (one was an elephant ear...lol), Caesar salads with and without Anchovies, Seafood Au gratin, and the Diver Scallops!! We drank craft beers, martinis, and margaritas!! We finished the evening with the Carrot Cake! Everything was great! Absolutely no complaints! And I haven't even seen the bill yet, and I don't care! Worth every penny!! read more

See all

Don't usually review a place twice, but the Oyster Bar is so good I just had to. The clam chowder is better than anything I've had in the coast or Caribbean. I had jalapeño bacon baked oysters- delicious. My wife had the black and blue oysters. A bit spicy but she loved them. This place is small, tight but the service and food make up for it. Tori was our server and she was perfect. Don't miss this Ft Wayne icon. read more

Went for dinner the other night. It was just lovely. The four of us sat on the patio the weather was perfect and so was the food. I had calimari and Italian fish stew. It was excellent. The patio was great but the interior looked pretty much like it looked 100 years ago. So great atmosphere excellent food and the best server I have met in a long time. What else could you possibly want. read more

This is one of those hidden gems in town. We were here for a business dinner with a large group and I was wonder where we would be seated! Well, it turns out that they have a small room on the back where you can fit a group this size. They had a new waitress helping us and I liked that they had a second waiter taking our orders silently on the back to ensure they had it all right. Drinks were always timely provided and so was food! This is the best part! We ordered a few appetizers and both were great! Since I love spicy food, my favorite was the oyster bar shrimps. They come with a side of blue cheese which adds a lot of flavor to it! I ordered the Seafood Au Grautin and it was melting! Also it was very hot, but it was delicious. There was also plenty of it and I certainly did not eat it all... too many apps? My partners ordered different dishes and one of them loved the baby back ribs. They were tender and juicy. The filet mignon was also huge and tasty. As we were leaving they had the patio full! Weather was so nice that we entirely missed this option. The one thing you will find interesting is if you need to seat on the back room, you have to walk through their kitchen , which made me wonder how they could make these delicious plates in such a small kitchen. Bathrooms are also small but, does it matter? Coming back with my wife! read more

The Oyster Bar - Crème brûlée - Seafood Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

Best service around! Tony and crew are so creative with the dinner specials. Wonderful flavor combinations!

I want to start by mentioning the amazing server that took care of me tonight! Her name was Mary K and she was excellent with her suggestions and hospitality The food was delicious and the atmosphere was wonderful! Definitely a gem here in Fort Wayne! 10/10 would recommend read more

The Oyster Bar - Restaurant entrance - Seafood Near Me - Fort Wayne, Indiana

See all

It was Savor Fort Wayne so we decided to go to The Oyster Bar. As usual, the service was great. The entrees were so-so. Not what we've come to expect. My husband ordered the Oyster Stew ( which always loves). The consistency was like gray mush. You could taste oysters but they were mixed up in the mush. Our waitress told us that the new owner changed the recipe. It certainly isn't a winner. read more

We had a table of 5 and everything that we had was amazing! The history of the building is really cool and the ambiance is incredibly homey and welcoming. There is a big lot with free parking attached too. Highly recommend!! read more

The seafood is excellent at the Oyster Bar. I highly recommend the Black & Blue Oysters. The service is excellent and they make everyone feel like you are home. I had the Mahi Mahi special which I also recommend. read more

Excellent value from years ago and i don't know about now. They had the best shrimp cocktail that u ever had. Loved their fish entres6.Good grub! read more

Oyster bar is currently my favorite restaurant in Ft Wayne. The oysters are fresh, meaty, and top notch. I really like their very unique "half and half" which they will split most entrees and let you try 2 for a $2 up charge. What a great way to sample the menu. We will be back read more

See all

My boyfriend really wanted clam chowder, so I took the opportunity to return to a place I haven't been since I was much younger. It really hasn't changed. Neighborhood bar atmosphere, with cozy seating. The food was good. The better half had the clam chowder I had the po-boy, and served quickly by our server who was very attentive with the bread and beverages. It's a very Midwestern, what you see is what you get, kind of place. read more

A wonderful place all the way around that I always frequent when I am in Fort Wayne. The food is excellent and great ambiance, Service is excellent as well read more

Great place absolutely luv chef Dougie Ribeye perfect loved the vibe had great time read more

A longtime local standard for great seafood in a local tavern setting with solid service. Great to see the owners in the back & on the floor checking in on their patrons! read more

Food is amazing, Service always well, the ambiance is cool just a little tight when crowded!

Clam Chowder was fabulous, Seafood Casserole was Fantastic! Referred to by a sub contractor Glad I went, will be back weekly till I leave area. read more