Made reservations for 7 of us at 6 p.m on Aug 8th for my daughters 51st birthday. I requested an experienced server. We arrived on time and were seated immediately. I chose The Olive because none of us had ever been there before and I wanted it that way so we all shared the same experience without any expectations of previous visits. I looked at several options and decided on The Olive solely upon Yelp reviews. I take this app very seriously, and have been with Yelp for many years. We were seated right away and forgive me I didnt catch my servers name because there was enough noise all around that made it a little harder for us to hear but it really wasn't intrusive or a major problem. We all could hear each other and thats all that mattered. Our server took our drink order and my oldest daughter ordered a peach sangria that served atcleast 4 people, it came in a bag with a little valve, but there was no fruit, just peach flavored semi sweet wine. It was,tasty but not traditional,would've been great if it had some peaches and a couple berries, but I made a mental note to not order next time. We ordered 2 orders of the bang bang shrimp, 1 order of fried zuicchini and an order of 5 mini crabcakes served with a butter dipping sauce, and it all was absolutely delicious! The shrimp was moderately spicy with a killer sticky sauce coating it, sweet and piping hot, the zuicchini super hot and crunchy served with the most delicious marinara sauce, the crabcakes were lump crabmeat and we were off to a delicious start!!! Our server then took our orders, and myself and my niece ordered the seafood supreme, LUMP CRAB, scallops and shrimp in an Alfredo sauce over linguine done totally on point and saucy, a very delicious Alfredo made right!! My oldest daughter had broiled sea scallops, perfectly cooked with a baked potato and house vegetable medley, my son in law had clams in white clam sauce, but here is where they could've done better as,far as quantity of clams, they only gave him 6 little necks in shells, 8 would've been better however it was completely delicious!!! My daughter ordered the ribeye steak with mashed potatoes but the potatoes weren't that great however, that steak was char broiled to perfection, 16 oz and one that will become memorable because of its intense deliciousness and char flavor, my nieces boyfriend had pasta in marinara that was beyond delicious! Their pasta fajiola soup was to die for, we all had house salads that came with the meal, and overall this restaurant really delivered!! Hot rolls and butter and dipping oil came with the table, and The Olive delivered in every aspect and exceeded our expectations!! Service, decor, cleanliness and overall experience made all of us agree we would highly recommend this restaurant, it was very busy, hard working efficient servers, friendly managers,and staff, we look forward to our next visit! Bravooo Olive!!! Prices,are absolutely fair, menu has something for everyone!!! Steaks, pasta dishes, seafood, all made to perfection!! You must not miss this place on your next dining out plans!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Enjoy!!!! read more

The Olive - Sewell, NJ We went to The Olive on a Saturday night and left feeling disappointed. Our server rushed the entire meal -- salad came out before the appetizer, and before we could finish the calamari, our entrées were already on the table. The calamari and marinara were actually very good, but my entrée missed the mark. I ordered the filet pieces with fettuccini, and while the cream sauce was flavorful, the filet was extremely tough and not enjoyable. The combination of rushed service and a poorly prepared entrée made the experience less than ideal. Unfortunately, we wouldn't plan on returning. read more

Celebrating my sister birthday. Everything we had was delicious. Apps were piping hot. Entrees were flavorful. Service was excellent. Will be back! read more

The Olive Restaurant - Peach sangria - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

See all

The food is always so good. Their bruschetta is the best! Fast service. Clean environment. read more

So very disappointed in their New Year's Eve!! It was absolute bedlam, with people waiting well over an hour for their reserved tables. I get it that this is a small restaurant and perhaps have inexperienced staff and kitchen. Still, New Year's Eve is a big deal and they shouldn't take reservations in the case they can't honor them in a decentamount of time. I consider that 20 minutes max. So disappointed...thankfully the Barnsboro Inn could seat us and we had a delicious meal. Olive. You need to figure it out! You would have ruined our NYE with your chaos. read more

The service was wonderful. The food was very good, from the Ceasar Salad through our entrees and finished up with a salted caramel gelato. I had the chicken parm and egg plant parm with linguine spot on. read more

See all

I love coming here when I visit my family! It's one of my favorite local Italian restaurants in Sewell I love the customer service, the people that work there are so professional and kind, and the environment is so welcoming! It always feels like a huge Italian family dinner! And of course, the food. Needless to say, I live in San Diego and haven't found a good "Italian American" restaurant, the ones I'm used to while growing up. So it just brings me back to childhood. Their chicken Marsala is out of this world. I am not even exaggerating when I say it's the best I've had in a while. You can tell everything is homemade. Really enjoy this place and I hope nothing but the best for the owners! read more

The Olive Restaurant - Spaghetti and Meatballs - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

See all

Intimate, cozy, well patronaged restaurant with adequate parking. Multiple writings on the wall in case you don't know to live love laugh. Seated immediately for our party of four (reservations encouraged). Left for a bit with our menu perusal. Restaurant was crowded and cacophonous. Calamari and garlic bread (definitely not house made bread) for starters which were good. French onion soup with very little cheese served unnaturally hot still boiling in container. Everything served was UNDER seasoned. Pasta fra diavolo I have never salted so much in my life and unbelievably hot (think microwave hot). Everyone was underwhelmed with their choice of entrees. The desserts were adequate had raspberry cheesecake and tiramisu cake. Limited competition locally so probably will return. read more

Excellent food and service in a friendly unique athmosphres, highly recommended if you love Italian food

The fried flounder was over cooked and mushy the covering just fell off the vegetables were hard - I wasted dinner, My wife's dinner was tasteless Salads were not chopped at all Rolls were warm the dipping oil for 6 people was 1 tablespoon As soon as we got home my wife had diarrhea Meal for two came to $84 Biggest problem was the air conditioner was broke temp in restaurant 80 - 85 Believe me we will not be back read more

Went to dinner on Sunday with three friends. First time at that restaurant for all of us. Three of us got a special of chicken parm, lasagna and manicotti. It came with the three choices piled in one lump. The lasagna was the strangest I have ever seen. There was a pile of plain crumbled meat with two very small lasagna pasta pieces on top of the meat with a small amount of cheese mixture spread between the two pasta pieces. What a disappointment for the three of us! The fourth person ordered shrimp scampi and said that it was delicious. The server was friendly and attentive. read more

The place has a neat old world meets new style. Lots of quotes and great calm colors. The desserts at the door gave a diner feel but were amazing to look at. I guess you can pick them up and grab a gelato to go. The lunch menu was vast. Everything was around 15$ which isn't bad. They charge for everything extra. My mom wanted a roll for her salad and it was 1$ more. But I guess in this day and age, that's common. I tried a panini, good bread. The fries were very crispy. Had honey gelato for the first time. Good experience overall. I understand why my parents raved about it. My only negative was the waitress. She seemed less than happy, and was kind of overly short. Not unpleasant but definitely not happy we were talking and not eating and going. Even though we were there maybe 30 mins. read more

See all

Great ambience, server was great, everyone loved their food. Chicken parm was absolutely delicious.

A local Italian restaurant with a fun vibe. Eggplant parmigiana is a family favorite.

We celebrated my mother in law's 90th birthday today at The Olive. Not only is the food always excellent, they allowed us to bring in a cake and even gave us a knife and a server read more

BYOB establishment. Family friendly. Food was very good. Will definitely be visiting again soon.

First time there. Word of mouth was it's a good restaurant. It is. From the crowd on a Wednesday night- I'd recommend reservations. Nice atmosphere- a little loud, but lively. Excellent service. ( +its BYOB). Lots of menu choices including several specials. Started w/ french onion soup. Tasty. I had delicious strip steak w/ grilled shrimp. Others had more pasta oriented dishes. All good. Desserts- super. Several choices from Juniors NY. All in all- great place- just as others had told me. read more

Great food as always. Everyone is always very nice. Wish the place was bigger always over crowded.

Great menu! Food cooked to perfection . Extensive desert menu! The tiramisu was to die for. Good wine list of local wineries! Service was wonderful. Price was very fair Nicely decorated read more

The food was very good. I enjoyed my chicken parm with a small salad. The problem was that I went with a group so we had to order off a small menu . The tip was already included and our waiter took full advantage of that by disappearing for long intervals . When my friend and I I ordered the half bottle of wine he put it on the group check. Really poor service and prices were inflated by forcing us to order from the banquet menu. Not a good experience. read more

A warm and cozy vibe space with decent service staff, although more communication would improve the quality. The menu has a great variety and sets up great expectations. However my first dinner experience revealed very average food. Plus the prices for the quality and portions was unimpressive. My dinner of chicken Marsala was exceptionally salty and the pasta is likely dried and not fresh as it was somewhat hard and stick together. The other diner had the pasta with vodka sauce plus added chicken. $21 for a small penne dish and then add $7 for chicken. Flavors just basic We are frequent diners at many places. There are a lot of Italian offerings and I was disappointed I could not rate this place higher. I will say the dessert selection is wonderful. read more

They were super nice. Food was amazing. I had the salmon special. My husband had chicken parmigiana. They were cooked perfectly. The salads great the bread rolls warm and great! Highly recommend this great dinning location for great Italian food!! read more

Extremely disappointing. -Menu: Extremely limited. Not a single veal dish, for example. -Portion size: Too small. I had the Lighthouse Scampi and the portion was embarrassingly small. -Quality (1): Poor. Both dinners, (mine, and a separate lasagna we ordered), were served only warm. Not hot at all. Did it sit around too long because of the server? Doesn't matter. It was served at a suboptimal temperature. -Quality (2): Poor quality continued when it came to the flavor. My choice was bland. The description of the scampi sauce was found to be false when the food seemed devoid of any of the spices listed. -Value: Poor. Pricing on the dishes was not commensurate with the sizes or quality of the meals. $13.00 for a slice of dessert cake? C'mon! Skip this place. Much better choices around. read more

I went here on a Sunday afternoon with my family. I had the salmon and while it was good, it wasn't anything to rave about. The service was okay too. I would definitely come back another time to try it again though. read more

The Olive Restaurant - Salmon - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Casual and comfortable yet really good flavor and portions. Great value. Friendly staff. Excellent service.

Came to the olive on a recommendation. Very disappointed. To start off the restrooms were ice cold. My ravioli was frozen my sauce on the ravioli was Jarred and very acidic burned terribly.Salad dressing was out of a jar also. The olive oil dipping sauce smelled and tasted stale like it was very old. The Ravioli were definitely frozen. If you're going to use frozen raviolis use a good brand like p & s. I understand times are tough and people have to cut corners but come on quality I can't with this place. The decor inside was lovely but I won't go back and the fact that people give it high reviews I don't understand it. My husband's soup pasta fagoil if you're Italian you know it doesn't have beef in it. Very disappointed. read more

Tried it a few weeks ago with my wife and had a fantastic experience. Chicken Parm and Chicken Marsala were amazing; the mozzarella caprese appetizer was large and amazing. We decided to go back again today and our meals were just as good. My wife had the crabmeat pomodoro over angel hair and I had the chicken francese over linguine. Highly recommend The Olive. read more

We've been here a handful of times. They sell wine but you can also BYO. The restaurant is spacious and the staff is friendly. Highly recommend the Buffalo calamari or the Bang Bang shrimp as a starter. As for dinner, you can't go wrong with the chicken dishes particularly the chicken French onion. I was easily able to get two meals out of it. Didn't order dessert but it looked awesome and I hear the gelato is great. Get here early. It got super busy around 6pm. It may take a bit for the food but it will be worth the wait. read more

The Olive Restaurant - Chicken French Onion - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

I'm going against the grain of all the rave reviews from here, OpenTable, and Google, but my meal today was just...not good. I can't justify a higher rating while I'm still sitting here regurgitating it. Maybe they were having an off day, but I'm in so much pain right now that I'm unlikely to consider a return any time in the near future. The Olive is located in the same restaurant space as Nina's and Val's Seafood before it. Like Val's, they didn't renovate the interior, so it was like stepping back in time (gosh I still miss Nina's). The vineyard themed decor works since it's an Italian restaurant. It is still a BYOB. They serve Pepsi products. When we walked in, I informed them I had a reservation, but no one else was there midday so they seated us without notating my name to check in via OpenTable. I hadn't eaten yet all day so I was ravenous. I ordered the fried mozzarella, a small Caesar salad, and a cheesesteak sandwich - added mayo to that. The salad came out first in a bowl too small for it. The lettuce didn't include any romaine hearts - it was just the outer, less desirable part. The dressing was average. The mozzarella sticks were clearly of the frozen variety and not special at all. But the cheesesteak? Yikes. As I picked it up, I noticed it was dripping grease. I was so hungry I ate half of it, but looking back I really should've just sent it back when I noticed how soggy the roll was to start. Plus I figured they'd blame it on the mayo -- which was not the culprit. The beef just was not drained. There was a pool of grease on the plate. The fries were pretty good, however, and my mom enjoyed her meal -- the chicken Caesar wrap (though she was surprised by the lack of cheese in it). When the server asked about boxes, I said just one and pointed at my mom's plate. She still brought two, so I picked up the latter half of my steak and said it was way too soggy to box up. She didn't reply; just took the second box back. I then asked about my OpenTable points, since I hadn't (and still haven't) received a confirm. She replied she didn't know anything about OpenTable, but she was sure it checked me in. Oof. We were the only guests there, and I just expected better. I'm hoping the restaurant can use this review as constructive criticism, as I've been suffering for the past several hours. Tums and peppermint tea did not help. TLDR, tips for management: - Serve better lettuce parts. - Drain grease from food. - Confirm OpenTable points. read more

The food is AMAZING!! Everything they serve is fresh and delicious. I especially love their seafood and their seafood options. The wait staff is very helpful, friendly and accommodating. The restaurant is lovely and very welcoming. Additionally, we've done takeout and it's just as good as eating it in the restaurant. If you haven't tried The Olive, you're missing a delicious treat! read more

Oh dear. The Olive. Let me first say that "Italian-inspired" is stretching it, like someone on minimum wage saying they're "rich-inspired." The only thing that I'd consider Italian is the cliché God Father references and lyrics to "That's Amore" on the wall. I ordered what I assumed would be a safe dish, the lasagna, as this is an "Italian-inspired" restaurant. I was surprised to find what amounted to an entire LAYER of large chunks of hamburger helper plopped on my plate with a few noodles and scant sauce to hide the shame of it all. It was recognizable as lasagna only by the fact that it was cut into a rectangle. The moment this image gets out is the moment we experience the true wrath of mama Italia. (Seriously. Think of what you imagine as lasagna and tell me you don't have to struggle to make my picture match with the image in your head.) What's worse? Saying "ciao" to your wallets as they overcharge you for this experience. Don't be a baciagaloop and avoid The Olive. Head over to the other Olive--at least there, you're family. read more

The Olive Restaurant - The moment I saw this hit the table, I knew there would be trouble. - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

See all

Food is ok. I am Italian so that's makes me a hard judge on Italian food. Soup all tastes the same to me. No real distinction in taste between pasta, Fazo and vegetable. Salad and bread sticks are good. Main course was good. I ordered shrimp scampi. Service was Ok. Our server must have been new. Overall rate it at a 3 read more

Wow! My first time here was great! As another reviewer says, it's a diamond in the rough. The food is great here. For my appetizer, I ordered Fried Mozzarella. It was amazing! The cheese was totally melted, and when bitten into, created strings. For my Meal, I got a Crab Cake Sandwich. It was one of the better Crab Cake Sandwiches I have had in a while! The other people at my table ordered dessert which looked quite scrumptious. The only reason I give a four-star review is that my food was a bit pricy but well worth it! Try this place when you are in town! read more

The Olive Restaurant - Crab Cake Sandwich w/fries - Italian Near Me - Sewell, New Jersey

Dinner Food is awesome. Before you get a slice of dessert though, ask how long it has been in the case. I've had a dry/old slice a one too many times. read more

I tried this place for dinner. The food was good and the waitress was extremely friendly. It took a bit of time to prepare the food but it was worth it. My daughter loved the Alfredo sauce. The gelato was excellent ! It was a bit pricey for "ice cream" but worth it. read more

The food was outstanding, if it was just that alone this would have been a 5 star review. The service is painfully slow, we waited over 30 min to just place our order. They also charge a corkage fee for your own bottles in a BYOB...RIPOFF. I would give them another try but the fee is a real turn off as almost EVERY OTHER BYOB doesn't charge this. read more

We've actually been twice in the past month. Food is very good, served piping hot. Reasonably priced & good portion sizes. It's BYOB. Have recommended to others. read more

See all

Terrible...!! Appetizer.. calamari to tough .. bang bang shrimp too sweet .. Server surly and uncommunicative.. Seafood broil unseasoned and undercooked.. Cheesecake dry .. small piece 12.50... Never go back !!! read more

The food was exceptional the service was great. But they charged me .50 for a roll. It's byob I didn't know either of the above. I would love to go back now that I know what's what. read more

What a fantastic local restaurant. The staff is amazing and competent. The food was fantastic.