I was determined to find some kick a$$ coffee while visiting Nashville Indiana before heading back up to Indy so I searched on Yelp for some suggestions. I ended up at The Old Bartley House which is in an actual house. I had the Nitro Cold Brew and added Hazelnut foam. It was delicious! The pastries were tempting too. I had fun exploring the two story historical building and admiring the decor and fun merch. It's a cool spot. read more

See all

Such a fun place to visit with delicious menu! The house has a wonderful history, make sure to take time to look around. The original hardwood floors are gorgeous and the decor fits perfectly. Lots of drink option-I opted for a hibiscus tea that was great. Avocado, egg and cheese was wonderful with a unique, flaky croissant. Definitely recommend! read more

See all

The place is awesome. Well appointed bakery / coffee shop in a pretty home with a nice little patio. The food is excellent. The brown county breakfast was awesome. The montecristo sandwiche is essentially a brown county breakfast cut in half with the montecristo fixings in between. Delicious and very filling. Good coffee too. Service was friendly and fast. Great place for breakfast. read more

The Olde Bartley House - Montecristo - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

Just a nice spot to grab a coffee and some amazing pastry. The volantes are delicious. Nice break out of the heat, and if you have a chance to speak with the owner Donna she's great. Had a nice visit. read more

Delicious spot for a morning coffee with lots of local history! Our drinks were delicious, though a little pricey (~$9) but it was one of the few spots open. they seemed to have lots of food options as well. read more

The Olde Bartley House - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

We had sandwiches and ice tea here after a hike in brown county state park and it absolutely hit the spot. We split and shared the sandwiches between two of us and couldn't decide which was better. We had the monte Cristo and wild turkey. Love this place! Great to come and study/ sit/ eat/ relax. read more

See all

Everyone was telling me to get a volant at The Olde Bartley House. For those who don't know, a volant is the specialty sweet here: It's a laminated (layered) donut, similar to a cronut. They offer them in several flavors, but apparently, the one to get is the Abe Martin Apple, which is stuffed with apple pie filling and topped with streusel. You don't have to tell me more than once to order a donut. In fact, I'm probably already eating a donut as you're recommending a donut, because I love donuts so much! This donut (volant) was great, but I feel like it's a whole other beast. It's more like a pastry than a donut. A delicious pastry, though -- don't get it twisted. And so unique! I think if you visit Brown County, you need to make your way to The Olde Bartley House to try a volant. The Olde Bartley House is also a coffee shop, so it has coffee in all its permutations. I opted not for a coffee drink, but for a Moonshiner: a sparkling energy drink. I chose the Tangerine Dream, which tasted like a melted orange creamsicle! I was hoping that it would wake me up, because I was seriously dragging, and it really did give me a little pep in my step. When I visited, there were plenty of tables at which to sit, and the space was calm and relaxing. I saw a couple of people working at laptops. I hung out in the dining room for a bit, enjoying the music they were playing over the speakers while I ate my volant and drank my melted orange creamsicle-like energy drink. (They were playing some good music, which is always nice.) read more

The food is excellent. The frappes are the best in the whole wide world. We came to town for the weekend. Of all the yummy places to eat, we had two visits to the fabulous location. The staff is very nice. The atmosphere is wonderful. The only bad thing I can say is its like Tigger - ITS THE ONLY ONE! read more

I absolutely loved this spot, and I think it was my favorite place for coffee and breakfast. The Olde Bartley House is charming; and the staff were so friendly!! These donuts are beautiful and delicious, and they had so many interesting flavors. They also have a wide range of coffee and flavors too. If you like specialty lattes, this is the spot in Nashville. read more

See all

Very welcoming staff. Not overpriced. Delicious coffee and baked goods. Love the atmosphere. Perfect Sunday morning spot. read more

The Olde Bartley House - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

See all

We were pleasantly surprised to find this GEM hidden in a cute touristy town in southern Indiana! I ordered a caffeine free iced tea (Elderberry Hibiscus) and my partner got a chai. Happy to see decaf and caffeine free options as not everyone can tolerate high levels, but still like to partake in a morning beverage. My partner can be picky about his chai, but he thoroughly enjoyed this one. I also ordered the Monte Cristo breakfast sandwich and just WOW. Melt in your mouth sugary flaky maple bread, and the mustard, aioli, and jam were a fantastic combination! I love me some sauce! I would eat this every morning for breakfast or lunch! Seeing how good my sandwich was, my partner, went back to grab an apple doughnut, and it was just as delicious! Parking on a weekend is basically impossible unless you pay. Friendly and fast service at a good price. read more

See all

Nothing but kudos for this eatery. The location, the folks running the store, the decor and absolutely delicious breakfast sandwiches and coffees. Started off with walking in and seeing how quaint the decor of the inside is. Felt like being at an older relatives house where they have all the family history and pics up on the walls. Plenty of room and tables galore. Wander in and up to the showcase where we checked out the easy to read menu on the wall and the incredibly nice folks asking us if we needed any help or suggestions. Very talkative but not overbearing at all. Just very nice and never felt rushed. We order, go sit down and wait for our name to be called. The acoustics of inside were very pleasant. I am very soft voiced and tend to freak out if it's too loud in a restaurant but never had an issue because it's so quiet. We get our drinks and sandwiches. The sandwiches were in cardboard boxes which I personally think is a waste as I'd rather have a washable plate since we ordered to eat inside. I got the ham and cheese and the lovely Mrs ordered the avocado egg and cheese and these are served in their signature voilant which it like a donut and a croissant had a baby. They were soooooooooo tasty! Drinks were hog chai tea and the salt creek caramel macchiato. Again, everything was delicious and I'd for sure go again when back in Nashville, Indiana... read more

See all

Great service, great coffee and great layered donuts So many options to choose from. I look forward to coming back many more times! read more

The Olde Bartley House - Beautiful interior - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

This place was recently renovated into an upscale coffee and donut shop, which was what Nashville needed! There are two separate seating rooms with plenty of space to sit without being crowded. It's a great location on the main road right as you come into town. Prices are comparable with all major chain coffee shops. But the difference is that here, you are paying for great quality! This is honestly the best iced latte I've ever had, makes me wish I lived closer! Donuts do not compare with chains -- much different shape & texture, but so wonderful! I had the lemon hibiscus and was impressed. Service was quick, but I visited on a Sunday afternoon. Clean & easily accessible restrooms are always a bonus! read more

See all

Super cute & cozy coffee shop! We got the campfire latte & the salty creek latte, both were delicious! We didn't try the donuts, which is going to haunt me later because they looked so good! read more

Delicious coffee and volent donuts! Adorable coffee shop with great customer service. Somewhat expensive but definitely worth it. read more

The Olde Bartley House - Lemon honey hibiscus volant - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

The cappuccino was great, but the donuts were so decadent and delicious! Made with croissant dough...just fantastic. Service was excellent and friendly. read more

Amazing coffee shop with Volants and sandwiches . These Volants seem to be a cross between donuts and croissants and come in many flavors. Not to be missed! read more

The Olde Bartley House - Interior beauty - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

OMG! This coffee shop was recommended to us by Nashville business owners and it did not disappoint. These were not donuts, they are volants (different flavored, croissant-like, yumminess). We went twice. Their sandwiches are just as delicious. We had the Monte Cristo and a ham, egg & cheese on an everything volant. This will be our first stop on our next visit. read more

The Olde Bartley House - Raspberry truffle, peanut butter pie, smoked caramel, apple pie & Cookie Monster. - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Nashville, Indiana

Excellent coffee with unique specialty drinks AND excellent confections! The owners were so friendly and even told us a bit of history of the building and surrounding area. Such a gem! We stumbled upon this place in the off season and couldn't be more pleased to have found this town and all the locally owned shops and eateries. A+ read more

I got the Monte Cristo sandwich and the Cortado Miel. Both almost made me cry with goodness. The miel is small (8 oz MAYBE) but packed with flavor. The deli meat of the sandwich was nothing to write home about but the pastry...... the PASTRY..... maple glazed French something or other, honestly I don't care what its name is, I just wanted it to come home with me and never leave. DO NOT MISS this place. My phone was dead or I would've taken photos- honestly I'm glad I didn't, because it was just me and the pastry experience of a lifetime. I will always remember you read more

Best coffee shop in Nashville to visit. Vibe is great, coffee was great, and the aesthetic is on point. Job well done to The Olde Bartley House. read more

Amazing donuts and coffee and very personable employees make this a must go to when in Nashville Indiana!!

We loved the volant donuts...tried several flavors over a couple days . Loved the coconut cream....light dough like a croissant with toppings /fillings. Absolutely fantastic and even good leftover the next day they made the 250+ mile drive back to St Louis just fine didn't try any of the coffee drinks but it smelled delicious and the place was historic and cute inside and out. read more

Absolutely 1000% recommend!! The coffee was amazing and the food was even better. Exceeded my expectations! Service was great, our food and drink came out very quickly. The inside is very cute, clean, and cozy. There was a lot more variety on the menu than I expected. Considering how expensive everything is these days, I would say pricing is very fair, and food quality matched the price. You need to check The Bartley House out, you won't regret it! read more

This shop at the corner of Franklin and Van Buren on the southern half of Nashville has a nice variety of items for your home. Though many are familiar like candles and kitchen towels and cups, there are many items that are unique, many with clever sayings written on them. Although in previous uses the building had both floors open, this current proprietor has limited access to the main floor which has a generally circular floor plan around the central staircase. Although I didn't make any purchases on this visit, I did enjoy browsing through the shop to see the different items. If I had place near a lake, I could find all kinds of items for such a home. The rest of the items I would categorize as more "country" style and could bring a smile to your guests if displayed. Review #955 read more

See all

This is a great place to pick up something for yourself or a gift to give. They have kitchen rugs & towels, Mood CD's, Art etc. They are located in an old house right on the main drag. It's kinda funny, but I love to go into this place on a hot summer's day. It is always cool, & the little fountains bring a tranquil feeling to your shopping experience. read more