Foundry Tavern in Hicksville was a HUGE surprise for me. I knew the place had been completely renovated, but I honestly wasn't expecting the food to be as good as it was. First off, the inside is beautiful. They did an incredible job with the renovation, and I loved all the little details, especially the custom 300-pound manhole covers they're using as tables around the bar. Even better, everyone working there was incredibly friendly and welcoming. Now the food! We started with the Baked Clams, and these were legit. You could've served them to me at an Italian restaurant and I wouldn't have questioned it. The Nonna's Ribs were probably one of the biggest surprises--slow-braised pork ribs with cherry peppers and finished on the grill. Fall-off-the-bone tender, tons of flavor, and I loved that they weren't just drenched in BBQ sauce. The Firebird crispy chicken sandwich was fantastic, and the Steakhouse Sandwich with sliced NY strip, mushrooms, provolone, crispy onions and horseradish aioli was also very well done. But that Manhole Burger deserves some special attention. Beef, American cheese, caramelized onions and dijonnaise on brioche. Simple combination, executed REALLY well. This was an outstanding burger and absolutely something I'd order again. And I can't leave out the fries. They're hand-cut in house, super thin and crispy, and exactly how I like my fries. Think that addictive thin fast-food style, except made fresh and much better quality. If you remember this location from its previous ownership, give it another shot. This is a completely different experience. Beautiful restaurant, genuinely friendly staff and food that exceeded my expectations. Foundry Tavern is a Hicksville hidden gem that deserves more attention--especially for lunch. I'll definitely be back. read more

Went to the Foundry Friday night. Off path location and not great parking. We had no reservations so we ended up sitting in the outside area. Cute little spot. Heard the guy next to us order a French dip and the waiter said great, we have only 2 left. So when he came to us I ordered and he said great timing it's the last one. Took 45 minutes to get our strawberry salad which was delicious. Another 3o minutes go by (and the guy next to me who ordered the other French dip had already finished and left) So the strawberry waiter, after more than 1.15hr walk over and says "hey, we ran out of the French so I ordered you the steak sandwich. Huh? 1 hour and fifteen min later you ran out and the other guy already ate and left? I said great, but I'm not paying for it. 10 min later the owner came out. He could not have been a friendlier, responsible and all around nice person. It wasn't that he not only covered my meal but the table but it was the way he handled it. Owning a restaurant is not easy and problems happen. Food - 8/10 Prices 9/10 Place 8/10 I would not only recommend this place but they have absolutely earned my business. I obviously can't give a 5 because of the incident but I will change this to a 5 when I go back and get the service I have a feeling I'll receive. This owner deserves the business because he knows how to run a business. Money follows the people not the other way around. read more

We had a pretty average meal overall. The service started off on the wrong foot when we were greeted by an unfriendly hostess who ended up being our waitress. It really felt like they were short-staffed. After she took our order, she basically disappeared and we saw very little of her for the rest of the night until she brought the check. The dining room itself is cramped, with tables pushed quite close together, which made the space feel crowded and noisy. The bus boy tried to clean the table 3 times and we were still eating. On the food side, we started with the calamari, but the portion was disappointingly small. They also forgot to bring our bread to the table. When we finally asked about it, it arrived but wasn't warm. The side spread that came with it, however, was genuinely very good and one of the highlights. The Rigatoni Short Rib was a solid 3-star dish, decent but nothing memorable. Pasta was not cooked Al dente, and the amount of save was skimpy. The Steak Sandwich Sammy fared a little better at around 3.5 stars. It was tasty and the steak was tender. I ordered sweet potatoes well done, and they weren't. My biggest disappointment was the menu itself. It's quite limited, and as someone who eats a lot of salads, I was let down by the very few salad options available. There just wasn't much variety for lighter eaters. Overall, the place has potential and the food was acceptable, but the service issues, cramped seating, and limited menu kept this from being a great experience. Unfortunately, returning again wouldn't be my first choice. read more

Ok food off the wall The wings gave me back in the day feel House made buffalo sauce with the Bleu cheese perfect mix The spinach artichoke dip I definitely definitely am worth. I'm not a big fan of pita chips so I substituted for chips and it definitely accommodated it really well. The drinks were well balanced as far as the place looks really amazing. Very quiet. I just me and my cousin in here for his birthday staff's pretty cool. I'm gonna be service recommended the wings. I'm actually taking some wings to go. Everybody get here to the foundry as soon as you can when you can peace and love. read more

The Foundry - New American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

If this review was only for drinks and food it would easily be 4 or even 5 stars! I do need to account for service, however, and that's why it's sitting at 3. We made a reservation via OpenTable. When we arrived the host looked frazzled but eventually found our reservation. We thought he checked us in until I received a call from the restaurant, while I was sitting a few feet away at a table, to ask if I planned on showing up. Oh okay! Once that was sorted out, our waitress came by (not even halfway full and all other sections had received drinks by now) and asked about a drink order. She mentioned there were specials but she did not want to share them until we ordered our drinks. That's fine. We went ahead and ordered the mojito. Waited about 20 minutes to receive our drinks and that is when our waitress asked if we wanted to start with an app. We chose the dip. She left and we sipped our drinks, which were delicious! Halfway through our cocktails a basket of cold bread showed up. The red pepper spread was delicious, though! Waitress came back to ask how everything was and I mentioned we were still waiting for our dip. Sure enough the dip arrives along with the people next to us, who ordered the same thing. I believe this was perhaps a kitchen issue? Regardless the dip was delicious and the homemade pita chips were a delight. We ordered our entrees. She never mentioned the specials. We decided to not ask and just try the menu since this was our first time visiting. The food took about 45 minutes to come out. Rigatoni for my dining partner and the brick chicken for myself. The food did arrive warm so again a kitchen issue? I'm not really sure. The chicken was good - it's not chicken breast as advertised (it had a sizeable bone attached to it) but I do prefer dark meat so that was fine. The candied carrots were incredible! The mash was a good item to round out the dish. The rigatoni was good, the short rib was delicious. As we finished our waitress asked if we wanted dessert. We had already spent 90 minutes here and wanted to just leave at this point so I said no. She left the check then came back to receive payment. I still gave a good tip all things considered but the service was atrocious. There is definitely a miscommunication somewhere. I will give this place one more shot but they really need to work on training their host, wait staff, and kitchen. read more

This was my dinner for my birthday this year with my fiancé and I was glad I mentioned it, because apparently she had been here before for dinner and loved it, and this was my first time. A really intimate place, with probably like 15 tables max inside, and a little bar that can sit also about the same amount of people, but still looks new and fresh, and also be on the lookout because when you're driving the place sneaks up on you. The friendliest service, Lauren who seated us and served us was truly genuine, and I told her I really appreciate that as most restaurants don't have that sense of personal customer service, actually noticeable and appreciated. The food was also really good, the dip was flavorful, could be a little warmer but still very good, the chips were next level, and this was a huge hit. The calamari was lightly breaded, and also I do appreciate the two sauces to choose from when dipping, either Kung Pao or Marinara. I got the Pastrami Rub Tuna over Scallion Mash, and when I first looked at it I thought the fish piece was a bit small, but after eating it, it was the perfect size, and the mash was delicious, and the Wasabi Sauce to dip the fish really made the dish Pop. Drinks were okay, started with a kick and boozy but finished a bit watery for my first one, the second one I had with Mescal was a 10/10 though. This place needs attention, and the fact that it is still pretty low key and food influencers haven't descended to blow up it's spot is awesome. read more

The owner was so nice to my girlfriends and I!! We traveled from all parts of Long Island to meet centrally at the foundry! Thank you for being so kind! We will be back! read more

Came here thinking it's more of a sports vibe ambience, but really it's just a local spot with a good vibe seems to generate an elder crowd. That being said, we got 3 seats at the bar. Our bartender / server were Rosa and her daughter both whom were amazing. Very friendly and extremely attentive. We ordered their wings and calamari as apps, all of that was incredible. Super delicious, crispy and wet. Ordered a bunch of drinks, they were playing some good music as well. For my entree I got the fried chicken sandwich which was cooked to perfection. Nice hidden gem which is close to my home so I will definitely be returning to try more of their food here. read more

See all

We had a wonderful lunch today at The Foundry, and it exceeded our expectations! From the moment we arrived, owner Sammy and his staff provided exceptional service and made us feel truly welcome. We enjoyed the French Dip, the Beet Salad, and finished with an outstanding Key Lime Pie. Every dish was fresh, flavorful, and clearly prepared with care using high-quality, premium ingredients. If you're looking for a top-notch dining experience, make the trip to Hicksville and visit The Foundry. Great food, outstanding service, and a warm atmosphere make this a restaurant you'll want to visit again and again. Highly recommended! Regards and enjoy,,, Mark & Karen read more

The Foundry - Beet Salad - New American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

See all

The short rib taco was excellent. Some of the clam oreganata was burnt. My old fashion was good, I was happy that they had the good cherry brand to put in it. read more

We went last night for dinner and thankfully had reservations. It's a small, cozy place. The menu is small but with good choices and daily specials. We started with spinach artichoke dip and it was creamy and delicious, served with crunchy pita chips. We both got the Shepherds pie special and it was also so good. The only downsides were parking tight and they should hire more servers as it was very busy. But the service is good, they're working very hard. I'm glad i found this local spot! read more

The Foundry - Spinach and artichoke dip - New American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

See all

Back again and will never complain, the food really is amazing. It's just way too good. Their music is amazing too. They have an outdoor patio now also to drink in the sun. Kat and Ike are fantastic, they're so attentive and friendly. It's always a joy to return. And we were lucky enough to try the special off the menu French dip, WOW. read more

See all

Saw this sort of newish place in Hicksville and saved it to go to eventually. Wanting a casual night out with good food in a cute place, we decided to come here. Service was great, dinner was delicious. Parking was easy. We were happy. I'd recommend. read more

Went for the first time last night. The atmosphere was cute and cozy on a cold evening. We got the dip appetizer but the real treat was the deconstructed chicken pot pie and the short rib pasta special. Both perfect comfort foods. Parking was a little difficult because of the snow but we came pretty early. Plenty of options for anyone. Will definitely be back!! read more

See all

Absolutely delicious food and great atmosphere. The french dip is the best sandwich I've ever had at a bar/bistro type place. The wings were also outstanding and the blue cheese was excellent, that's a huge factor for me when ordering wings. Literally the only thing I would change or make a suggestion about is the type of music they play, needs more classic rock/80's-2000's. Too much house music and radio pop. But that is my only critique. This place is amazing. read more

The Foundry - Jerk chicken Crispy Wings - New American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

See all

The Foundry is an amazing restaurant in Hicksville. The ambience is very nice with a beautiful bar and a couple of TVs to watch a sports game at the French dip and sweet potato fries. Amazing can't wait to go back. read more

The Foundry - French dip and sweet potato fries - New American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

We are major foodies and found this restaurant on Instagram. Despite seeing mixed reviews about the food and service, the restaurant looked charming, so we decided to give it a try. When we arrived, we were seated right away and our server took our drink order within about five minutes. Unfortunately, after our drinks arrived, we didn't see her again for nearly 50 minutes. We eventually had to ask the hostess to take our food order. The place was really not crowded and we overheard the couple next to us complain that our waitress tried to overcharge for fries and onion rings... We requested that our dishes be brought out as they were ready, but it still took another 35 minutes for the food to arrive. We ordered the clams, burrata salad, and the $9 burger special (with added cheese and grilled onions). The clams were inedibly salty...so much so that we couldn't eat them. It genuinely tasted as tho someone opened the salter shaker and poured it on top. The burger arrived without the grilled onions we had ordered and was otherwise very dry and average. The burrata salad was good. After waiting another 20 minutes for our plates to be cleared, our server finally checked in. We explained that we couldn't eat the clams because of how salty they were. When the check arrived, we were told that the burger had been removed from the bill. While we appreciated the gesture, it was confusing that the item removed was the burger rather than the dish we couldn't eat. We also weren't given an opportunity to review the bill before being asked whether we were paying together or separately. The space itself is very cute and has a good atmosphere, which is why this experience was so disappointing. Between the extremely slow service, the issues with the food, and how the situation was handled, I don't see myself returning. read more

We stopped here for happy hour and ate at the bar. Highly recommend the espresso martini (they have a few. I just have a classic one ) and the meat candy.appetizer! I will definitely be back to try dinner. The staff was welcoming and warm and the decor was very inviting. read more

Very disappointing. Service from walk in was non existent. Love you tell you about the food or drink but after 15 minutes of not even seeing our server we left. read more

I didn't know what to expect at this new restaurant that is a few miles from my home. The restaurant is very beautiful both inside and outside. Basically, the menu and food, in my opinion, is highly elevated bar food. The menu is short and simple. Drinks were good, but $2-3 pricier than many restaurants. We started off with the multicolored beet salad. Very nice and tasty, but lacking something. Needed more vinaigrette or olive oil for taste. Entrees arrived before we finished, not a good sign for me. I guess that they are still working out the kinks. My wife ordered the crusted tuna. She thought that it was excellent, but the mashed potatoes were lukewarm. I ordered the chicken pot pie, which came out hot and delicious. Other food around the restaurant looked good and people seemed to be enjoying their meals. Overall I enjoyed the restaurant, but I think it requires more attention to some detail. read more

First time visit here last evening. Went there early around 4:30 and was quiet. Good Happy Hour prices for drinks. Excellent staff and very personable. The bartender Rosa was knowledgeable and pleasant to talk with. Very pretty place with an upscale vibe yet accessible to everyone. You'll feel comfortable blue or white collar. The food...in a word- EXCELLENT. For an app we had the Yellow Fin Tuna Tar Tar. Very, very good quality tuna which was the clincher for me to order the Pastrami Rubbed Tuna for dinner. That was excellent as well. Great whipped potatoes with scallions underneath. The side of spinach with leeks was very good as well. The wife ordered the Fried Pork Chop and it was communicated when ordering that there is a wait time as they prepare it. (approx. 1/2 hour turned out) She was getting a little "antsy" waiting but suffice to say when it arrived it was so good that she said she'd wait 3 HOURS for it. Yes, it was that outstanding. And my wife is in the business and normally doesn't give out compliments that generous... Our bartender told us it's a very popular dish there and always consistent. Highly recommended place. read more

See all

Checked this spot out on a Friday afternoon and we were very pleasantly surprised. Unassuming from the outside but very tastefully styled on the inside. Food was very good and the service was excellent. The owner introduced himself to us and chatted with us for a bit. All in all very pleasant experience. read more

The food was so disappointing. We went the day after Valentine's day. They had many specials including one that came highly recommended by our server, so I ordered it. It was supposed to be short rib. What I got was mushy beef with almost no flavor on top of giant noodles with a big unnecessary piece of burrata. I've had short rib many times at other restaurants that have had so much delicious flavor and the meat is definitely fresh. It seems like they recyled the Valentines special into the next day but it was not special at all. I barely ate my meal and the server asked if we would like to take the leftover home and I quickly said no. She realized I probably didn't enjoy my meal. My husband had the scallops special with risotto and he enjoyed his meal. However only half the party enjoying their meal doesn't make a very good experience. read more

Today we found the foundry and we're so glad we did. After reading other reviews, they're not lying about the exceptional and friendly service. The place is very modern and has a nice date night appeal. There's even a cute patio that would be nice to eat aim if this weather could cooperate. We skipped on the cocktails today but they sounded great. For appetizer we got the clams oreganata. The sauce was standard but plentiful to sop up with the bread. For entrees we got the pastrami rubbed tuna and the burger. A boring burger you're probably thinking, not quite. It was smothered in cheese and sautéed onions and it was served with the nice crispy fries that you want. The bun is fluffy but not overbearing. I always think ketchup served on the side in a cute dish is a nice touch. The tuna I got cooked medium rare and it was absolutely perfect and a generous serving. The nailed getting that smoky pastrami taste. The potatoes saved the best for last. Star of the meal. They were whipped scallion potatoes. They were so velvety had a zing from the scallion. They were certainly indulgent but a great partner to the tuna. I hope it gets more attraction because it's in a random spot with not too much foot traffic but definitely make your way there for good food and service! read more

The Foundry - Pastrami crusted tuna - New American Near Me - Hicksville, New York

See all

Hope they make it! Love the ambiance! It's nice to have a place like this in the neighborhood!

We came in for drinky poos and to check out this new restaurant. Loved the wine selection. Had what I like. My husband MUST have cold beer on tap. It was perfect. The glass turned frosty as soon as the Peroni hit the glass. Looked at the menu. Love what we saw. Will come back for a try. read more

Don't let the bland exterior for you, the interior is elegant, the service was attentive and friendly and the food was absolutely amazing. Went for brunch and was not disappointed. Will absolutely return for a full entrée for date night read more

The ambiance and service were top notch. The salmon was delicious and the drinks were amazing

Went early for dinner at 6 pm. The food and service were great, but the nightclub levels of obnoxious music volume as a bit much.

Service was terrible. Even with a reservation, we still waited for twenty minutes. Then they made us move tables. Food was okay...my husbands pork chop was amazing. But the rest of the food wasn't worth the prices. Won't be going back which is sad because we like to support local businesses. read more

Came here on a Friday around 5:30 PM with a couple of friends. The food was very good and the waitress was very attentive. My only complaint is that they had loud club music blasting, and it didn't seem right for a peaceful dinner. read more

Decided to go to the foundry for a birthday dinner. The food was so good! and the ambience was like an upscale pub vibe. Alexa our server answered all questions and was professional. The mussels in vermouth were clearly a winner as was the artichoke and spinach dip . We had the burger with loads of onions that was one of the best burgers I have had in a while. ! read more

My wife and I met our friends for dinner at this restaurant. We were recommended by another couple to give it a try. The dinner started well enough as we enjoyed our drinks and we placed our orders. After waiting for an hour we asked the waitress where our appetizers were. She said she would check, but after 30 more minutes there was no sign of our appetizers. My wife once again asked the waitress and finally the appetizers came out. Suddenly upon delivering the appetizers, the waitress told us that they ran out of the French Dip sandwiches so neither my wife or I would have dinner. No offering of making something else, no apologies. After waiting an hour and a half to suddenly just tell us we would not receive our order was simply unacceptable. To make matters worse we went to speak to the owner who told my wife and I that they ran out of the food and did not offer any apologies, did not say he was sorry, did not even offer a menu to make something else for us. He berated us both and made us feel badly for raising the concern. When we both challenged him he merely told us to get the hell out of his restaurant. We eat out a lot and have NEVER experienced such unprofessional behavior from an owner and such poor customer service. STAY FAR AWAY from this restaurant. DO NOT eat here. read more

What a great new find! The food was excellent and the staff and vibe were all welcoming. Definitely will be back.

When you walk in you are instantly struck by the wonderful warm Ambiance and you are greeted as if you are with family and friends. The food was exquisitely presented and tasted absolutely outstanding which includes all the dishes starting with the warm bread and Olive Oil with sundried tomatoes served while looking through the menu right through the appetizers and main entree's . read more

THE FOUNDRY: Friday Night Went to the Foundry Friday Night with friends, and overall had a great experience. The ambiance was very nice-stylish and comfortable. We started at the bar for happy hour; their special martini was strong but really hit the spot. Our party of six was seated at a nice round table which made it easy to chat and share appetizers. We ordered the Kung Pao Calamari & Artichoke Dip - both were excellent. For dinner, I had the Pastrami Crusted Tuna and WOW, it was outstanding. The only downside was that at 8:00, a DJ started playing music, it got quite loud which made conversation difficult. Other than that, everything was great. I'd definitely go back, maybe a bit earlier to avoid the loud music. read more

New Restaurant Tavern since March (2025) opened up on Woodbury Road in Hicksville NY . They were open today Sunday till 9pm. They are closed for Memorial Day. My server was listed as Rose. But Steve ( owner/manager) sat me and took my order. A young man working there names Servio chatted with me as well. The place is clean and new inside. They did have outdoor seats though I didn't see anyone outside at this visit. Upon entering, I noticed at the podium a list of to do s. On it I saw , put up signs for bathrooms. ( see pix) I ordeed the Kale salad and added chicken the later was cooked and spiced perfectly. Steve, upon request, got me a few slices of bread with a container of butter. I asked about the listed Chicken Franchise. No noodles or sides come with that. Dessert was a tartufo and a cappuccino. Bill without tip was near 50 dollars. (See pix) It was very loud in there with no sound barriers. There were no phone charging stations as my battery went dead and I found a plug to charge it. They have a sign noting no smoking or vaping. They have a Happy hour listed on the outside sign. I'd stopped in again. read more

See all

After reading excellent reviews, we met friends at The Foundry Tavern for an early dinner. The parking lot on the side of the restaurant faces a commercial area. Don't let that turn you away. Upon entry to the restaurant, we entered a bar area followed by an attractive dining area. Our waitress was pleasant, helpful and attentive; she gave us recommendations when asked. The consensus was that our dinners were delicious with generous portions. Couldn't resist trying a few desserts, which were well worth the extra calories. Highly recommend this restaurant. Will not hesitate to return. read more

Love the Foundry! welcoming atmosphere and attentive, friendly service. it's perfect for a relaxed meal or special occasion, great experience read more

We stopped in on the fly and had a great time from the moment we walked in. Friendly staff, fantastic food, and lovely decor. We had spinach and artichoke dip, calamari, beet salad and strawberry burrata salad. Dynamite across the board. Super fair prices. Highly recommend! read more

See all