Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails is a hidden gem and after eating here several times, I can confidently say it never disappoints! The food is consistently delicious, and their cocktail menu is absolute top-tier. I usually go with the Lychee Coconut cocktail, which is wonderfully refreshing and smooth. My husband recently enjoyed the Two Sheets to the Wind. We have had their fresh east coast oysters, tuna tartar, the crispy and flavorful Bang Bang Shrimp, and the Prosciutto Flatbread topped with arugula, fig jam, and goat cheese. You also cannot skip out on their "Quebec Famous" poutine, it is completely divine with crispy fries, mozzarella, and savory gravy. If you are looking for an incredible vibe, stellar drinks, and elevated comfort food, this is the place to be. We will definitely be back again soon! read more

See all

My cousin and I tried Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails for the first time last night, and we really enjoyed it! We decided to order a bunch of shareables, including the Thai Peanut Calamari, Oysters Rockefeller, Poutine Fries, and Hummus, which was served with cucumbers, tomatoes, and crackers. Everything was delicious! The cocktails were yummy, too! The service was attentive and added to the overall experience. The restaurant itself is super cute, with a nice ambiance. We were actually surprised it wasn't busier for a Friday night, but we enjoyed being able to catch up and talk. As the evening went on and the restaurant cleared out a bit more, the music got louder, shifting the atmosphere into more of a bar vibe. It was nice to experience both sides of the place! Overall, a great first visit and we'll definitely be back to explore more of the menu! read more

Came here for dinner on a weeknight and had no issues getting seated quickly without a reservation. I liked the ambiance of the restaurant, and the servers were all very nice. Our food came out quickly as well. My main thing is we enjoyed the appetizers, but the entrees were just okay. The Thai Peanut Calamari was my favorite -- I hope this never gets taken off the menu! The Shishito Peppers were also good. When it came to the other food, the Mac and Cheese as well as the Short Rib unfortunately just didn't hit the spot. That being said, I would still recommend checking this place out and trying the calamari! read more

See all

Love Pearl! Delicious menu and great espresso martinis! Cozy, chic bar and dining area. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

I have been going to Pearl for a couple of years and always had a very nice experience. The food was always great. I was there this past week for dinner and ordered a salad with grilled chicken. The chicken was very rubbery and the avocados were hard -almost like apples. The quality of food has gone down hill. Very disappointing. I will take Pearl off of my list for a while with hopes that they make some adjustments to the quality of the food. read more

Great esthetically pleasing modern atmosphere at this local restaurant with good selection of food and drinks. Was pleasantly surprised by the food and service was awesome! Jay, our server recommended this Belgium ale Delirium which was crisp and refreshing! Highly recommend the Beet bowl and Thai calamari. Fish and chips were ok. Hope to be back to try some other food items! read more

See all

I came here last night (Saturday) with three other friends. One of them made a reservation for 7:45pm though it wasn't busy so not sure if a reservation was necessary or required. This place is located in a strip mall with plenty of free parking and looked like it was closed when we arrived so don't turn away! It's just how it looks haha. We were seated right away and the modern style decor inside was beautiful! The wait staff was very attentive and our water was always getting refilled. The menu had a good amount of choices but I ended up choosing their Shrimp Scampi in Spaghetti Squash (I forgot the exact name because it was one of their specials). I chose it because it sounded unique and it tasted as well as looked amazing! My friends got the Salmon, a Louisiana Chicken dish (one of the specials so I forgot the exact name) and a Burger with Sweet Potato Fries. For appetizers we shared Truffle Parmesan Fries and the Thai Peanut Calamari. The Fries tasted okay but the Calamari was absolutely delicious and came with a good amount. Prices were reasonable and I liked that it wasn't too loud so nobody at our table had to yell while conversing. We were there roughly two hours and it never got very crowded. I had a great time there and would definitely return! read more

The staff seemed nice when we came in, and the place definitely has a local spot vibe. Also, really cute decor. If you don't already know about it, you could easily miss it since it's tucked in what looks like a strip mall. The food overall was just okay. I had to ask for replacement utensils because mine had stains, and my plate had some spots that looked like more than just dishwasher watermarks, which was not the best first impression. We all tried different things, but no one at the table seemed blown away. One friend ordered a medium rare burger and got well done, another asked for well done and it came out burnt. The shrimp tacos were described as "just okay." I got the fish and chips and though they were edible, they were not well seasoned. It honestly tasted like the fish was just battered and fried without much flavor. On the bright side, they give a huge portion of truffle fries, which everyone seemed to like, (I didn't try them), and I did enjoy the lychee mocktail because that was really good. I'm not in Long Island too often, but if I were back in the area, I'd probably try other spots on my list before circling back here. read more

See all

Wow what an amazing place! The ambiance and decor is beautiful and unique! The service is perfect. The food is SO delicious! I've had everything from brunch (pancakes, egg tacos and bagel lox yum!) The lunch and dinner I've had includes the bang bang shrimp! (Much better than toku!), pad Thai calamari is so scrumptious and fresh with a delicious sauce. Ceasar salad with perfectly grilled shrimp, lava cake, poutine, everything is so good! Perfect for a date spot or family get together! Also great to have a spot at the bar with a beautiful cocktail . Don't hesitate! read more

Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails - Ceasar salad grilled shrimp - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

I am honestly impressed. From food, to decor, to drinks, and service--everything was great. I went with another couple and we ordered a bunch of appetizers. Everything was fresh, made to order. My favorites were the calamari and shrimp. Owners were welcoming and accommodating as well. I will definitely be back! read more

Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

Surprised by the lovely, bright & open bar and well made cocktails & food. Bartender Madison did a great job and has a promising future mixing up some fabulous drinks. Unassuming would be the correct word, in a strip mall where years ago we must have visited for one of the original AYCE sushi places. More recently, there was a pub that had live music. You may know it as the strip with the Post Office & Bottle Values (what I picture a liquor store in the former USSR feeling like. Lee & I made the mistake of not heading East into Carle Place/Garden City for a celebratory cocktail, we attempted to try The Foundry in Hicksville, but that was incredibly short lived. Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails turned out to be a nice choice. I enjoyed a Bee's Knees, perfectly made in a Nick & Nora glass (a way to place less spirits than a coupe) and Lee enjoyed a Mezcal concoction on the rocks which he enjoyed. We had some fabulous Mussels in a white broth and the Thai Calamari with peanut dressing. Both memorable. The owners are not novice restaurateurs. I believe if this is correct, one is of KYMA and the other was somewhere that I was familiar with the bunch of names. We would return, yes..but the overall setting and vibe was true to a strip mall. Lots of parking though ! read more

This was my first visit to pearl. Quaint little place in Bethpage strip mall. Nice bar , spacious couple TV's. Service is friendly and courteous. I had oysters and Fish tacos for apps. Oysters were great! Fresh, shucked perfect and chilled well. Fish tacos were deep fried a bit heavy but tasted good. I had seared Ahi tuna for main. It was cold and a bit tough but seemed fresh. It was decent but I wouldn't order it again. My girl had Salmon which was fine, unseasoned but was decent as well. Prices were fair not too expensive. I would return but I'll order other options . read more

I have wanted to come here for some time after noticing it and am sorry it took this long. Went for happy hour and had Jay as our bartender. He was amazing and made great drinks, you can tell he cares a lot about how he makes them. They have a great menu and a lot of options. We tried a number of things from oysters, mussels, calamari and poutine. Everything was absolutely delicious and reasonably priced on happy hour. Will definitely be back as it's a great local spot read more

See all

Came by for happy hour and got oysters, a flatbread and a cocktail. The bartender Jay was very nice and made an absolutely fantastic mule. The restaurant was cozy and perfect for date night. Will definitely be returning. read more

See all

Ok this place is unassuming- it's tucked away in a strip mall - you have to really look for it otherwise you wouldn't know it's there - but once inside it's decorated beautifully and very welcoming - there's art on the wall, pretty light fixtures and a welcoming bar. We arrived for happy hour / it was pretty empty -2 folks at the bar and a table with a couple. We sat at the bar and the staff was very attentive and informative with the menu items and drinks. The wine I wanted wasn't available and they offered a Tasting to make sure I liked the alternative- the bartender was very knowledgeable about the drinks and made great suggestions - we ordered fish tacos, poutine, meatball, margherita flatbread all were amazing . I saw another review mentioning Jay the bartender and have to agree his customer service and people skills are top notch - we really enjoyed hanging out talking to him read more

See all

We had all wanted to come here for Christmas night, it looked perfect and everyone loved the menu. It was for my grandma's birthday so I jumped and made the reservation online. It was a glitch and they were actually sadly closed. As they called to tell me they offered any other time and a credit or something I cannot remember lol. Day after Christmas most of my family left so it took us a little to actually get to come here as my mom refused to let us go without her lol. My grandma was back upstate so she didn't get to go have her birthday dinner but we all did and very much enjoyed it! Ambiance was perfect. My grandma did enjoy the leftovers! :) read more

Another great meal at pearl kitchen. The cocktails are great and attractive to boot! Service is good, atmosphere is wonderful, decors beautiful . Food is delicious. So glad to have it in the neighborhood read more

See all

Had a group birthday celebration just us ladies. Started with happy hour awesome bartender and drinks! Delicious apps all at the bar. Then moved to a for dinner. Delicious food! Can't wait to go back! Awesome atmosphere too! Owners very friendly. read more

What an amazing experience! Our server Peter was so handsome and charming, the espresso martini's were to die for and the Oysters were fresh and delicious. Definitely coming back and would recommend to a friend! read more

We went Friday nights with our family and with a close friend and his family. The ambiance was modern and perfect for a family dinner. For appetizers we ordered the Thai peanut calamari, fish tacos and shisito peppers. The adults also got a Ceasar salad to share. For entrees we shared the Ahi Tuna, short rib and Chicken Milanese. The kids each had cheese burgers. It was all delicious with no complaints. Everything we tried definitely tasted good. The server was happy to give us her suggestions as well. It's in an unassuming place but a must try! read more

Went here for my birthday dinner with a party of 7 people. Everyone loved their meals. Excellent food and service all around. The cocktails were expertly crafted. The thai peanut calamari was surprisingly delicious and the mac & cheese ordered for the table was gone almost immediately. Definitely recommend the fish & chips. Thank you! read more

If I could give 3.5 stars that would be the most accurate rating for it, so out of kindness I will round up to 4. Went to dinner with another couple. Our dinner was at 6 pm and the crowd at the restaurant was older (we are in our mid-40s) which is understandable. As it got closer to 8 the crowd changed and the restaurant got significantly louder. So loud we found ourselves yelling to each other. The atmosphere is nice. The waitstaff was fine but we found ourselves looking for our waitress from time to time. Also the refilling of our water glasses was pretty infrequent. The food was fine. Definitely nothing to write home about. We shared hummus, Caesar salad and a flatbread pizza to start. All were just okay. Entrees were burger, fish & chips, tuna tartar and one of the chicken dishes. Again it was fine but nothing I would rave about. read more

Jay was amazing. Highly recommended. Calamari was amazing, bang bang shrimp was also very good as well.

Great great great Small but cozy. Food is great - so is service and cocktails. It is so nice when the owners/managers greet you on your way out to thank you. Refreshing to have a local restaurant that cares!! read more

Friendly barkeep who is knowledgeable about tequila. I went for happy hour, their food is good too.

Super chic & gorgeous new restaurant! Absolutely love the vibe. Came in for lunch & there was a minor hiccup with my friends dish, but other than that, the service was impeccable & they remedied the issue expertly. I can't wait to go back for cocktails & to try more! read more

Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails - Bang bang shrimp - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

Came here on a Friday night - live DJ! The staff were so welcoming and friendly; they gave great recommendations! If you go and Jay is working you must get Jays Margarita (the hostess's fav). Food ordered was the Garlic Parm chicken wings - light and flavorful and not greasy at all.. juicy! Also order two flatbreads - the West Cost (my ultimate fav), and the Prosciutto/Fig great paired with a glass of wine! Lastly you MUST get the butter cake ;) Will be coming back! read more

See all

Live within walking distance and had never been here until a few weeks ago. Caught Friday happy hour early with husband. There were few customers at the time so we had the bar and bartender (Jayson) pretty much to ourselves. Nice! He was friendly and personable. I had a mojito and him a beer (only serve bottles). My drink was yummy. Fresh mint from their own plants. We ate a few bar items on special (poutine was one) and a shrimp cocktail. Everything was very good. Haven't tried to get in for dinner but we will at some point! Recommend you try it this place. read more

Good food good service. No complaints. Nice ambiance. They also work great with vendors. I was a dj here for a private event and they took care of the Vendors with great care. read more

The place is beautiful and in concept is such nice addition to the area. The food is just ok, I have not loved anything I've had the few times I've been but others at the table have enjoyed theirs. What will most likely stop me from returning on my own were the very strange interactions between the employees/management/owner(?)... the conversation consisted of management complaining to the bartender that even though he mentioned he was feeling sick that he wouldn't be able to go home, management complaining about an employee who did not respond to a text about showing up for a shift and other strange conversation while they sat a few seats from us as the bar. It was a very confusing experience for people taking their time to spend money on a nice time at an otherwise empty establishment. I don't feel great about giving my time and money to a business that seems to not be a great place to work. read more

Place is really nice, cocktails were good and reasonable priced, attentive host(maybe owner) but created right away and got table ready himself when saw the staff was busy. Food was better than okay didn't fit the rest of the place if that make sense but to be fair only had flat bread and a few diff apps (wings could've had a little more sauce ans be spicier but solid ) Brussels Def needed to be crispier but reheated then next day and we're great. Overall def a must check out for a few drinks and maybe some apps at the bar they had a DJ and she had the music at a good level where ppl could still talk. Will try dinner there one time to be more fair read more

Tonight's date night spot we wanted to try somewhere new for us. Only having opened 6 months ago Pearl is a restaurant you gotta make your way to. Bartender Jay was so welcoming and took great care of us. The rest of the staff and owners were also very friendly. While I didn't get pictures of the food it was all very good. You're not going to find anything particularly different or standout on the menu from any other American restaurant. Has your American restaurant classics but they're done well. We got the bang bang shrimp to start. The sauce was killer. Jay also brought some out for us to dip our fries in. Amazing. For entrees we got the pork chop and the grilled chicken sandwich. The pork chop was huge and cooked perfectly covered in some hot peppers that paired well with the richness of the chop. I went back forth on the chicken sandwich because they can be bland and dry. Honestly it was the best seasoned grilled chicken sandwich I ever had. We got several of their cocktails and they were all so good. It's in somewhat of a random location but make your way there. read more

Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails - More than gold - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

Great cocktails, food and service. Burger and Bang Bang Shrimp were delicious. Hidden gem. Strongly recommend.

Wonderful time at Pearl Kitchen and Cocktails. Amazing team. Hospitality A-1 and the Food OMG amazing from start to finish. Walk no run to this place. The calamari amazing! (Though if you have a nut allergy I would ask to remove the topping) ate the old bay wings slamming, the bang bang shrimp too die for! The Italian meatball soup perfect starter. Thank you so much for such a warm welcome as first time guests I can say you have me as a customer for life. Thanks again! read more

See all

Came here for happy hour and can't wait to come back for dinner. What a great spot! Bartenders were made some great drinks and food was delicious. read more

See all

Went to Pearl for the first time this evening for happy hour.... So glad we finally stopped into this place..... great cocktails, great food and a great value! Warm atmosphere in a cool local spot. Will be returning often! read more

We had a great meal with friends last night at Pearl. Delicious cocktails to start the meal. Appetizers and main dishes were all well prepared. I had the pork chop and it might have been the best pork chop I ever had. Only downside is that it it's pretty loud even without live music. There was background music playing that wasn't necessary. Overall should be a great addition and prices were very reasonable so should become a regular neighborhood place. Service was also very good. Dishes came out in reasonable times and staff was attentive. read more

We love going to Pearl. Delicious food, wonderful atmosphere, servers are awesome and the cocktails are fantastic.

Everything we got was delicious, calamari, shishito peppers, pork chop, salmon, fish and chips, Mac n cheese flatbread. All so good drinks were also delicious. The atmosphere was beautiful. Service was fantastic. Highly recommend read more

Pearl Kitchen & Cocktails - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

Great scene! Great vibe! We've waited a while for Pearl to open and it didn't disappoint. Thai Peanut Fried Calamari was great. Everything we ate was delicious. My cheeseburger was a bit overcooked but delicious. The owners are all over the dining room schmoozing with every table. You're made to feel like a welcomed guest from all the staff. Lara was our server and was spot on. So why just a 4 star review? The place is busy and it's a very social scene. They could use more service on the floor. My suggestion...at least one more runner, another bus person, and the hostess shouldn't be afraid of refilling water glasses around the room. All hands on deck! We'll be back. read more