See potential, but evidently things may still be in the process of finding themselves. Was between 3-4 stars. Service was great, seated immediately as we got there like 5 minutes prior to our reservation. Mixed drinks were good and prices reasonable. Strip steak with garlic butter was good, not great. It didn't have enough natural flavor to make up for very little seasoning and it had a fat cap that was over 1 inch all down the side. My opinion is they should be trimmed to about 1/4 inch at a decent steak house. I guess that they did away with the salad bar, but side salad was very good. Sides were also very good. Wife had pecan crusted chicken and said the chicken itself was high quality, but the crust/seasoning left something to desire. I wish we had tried dessert, but did not. A few things I found interesting and almost strangely funny was no steak knives at all steak restaurant and I really wish they had a bread option just in that I enjoy some buttered bread before eating steak. Also I was going to try the Wagu steak, but I guess they no longer have those. read more

This was our first time coming to The Forge and we had a positive experience. Hubby and I were craving a good burger and after looking at their menu, we decided to order the elevated burger. To start our meal, we each had a Caesar salad that we enjoyed, we really liked the dressing and the salad was fresh. Our burgers were cooked to perfection, they were flavorful and the fries were crispy and delicious. We were greeted with a smile when we walked in and had great service from Connor. We will definitely be back. read more

Okay, first off- no pics because we dug right in and enjoyed. EVERY. BITE. Started with a chocolate martini because dessert drink first. Then stuffed mushrooms. Huge and quite tasty. My wife had their amazing beef tallow fries so she had those for an appetizer. Best fries we've ever had! For the entree, I had the Shrimp Bennett. Huge 6 shrimp wrapped in bacon on a bed of long grain rice. The side of cream corn was a generous and was sooo good. My wife had the ribeye with tallow butter - melt in your mouth and the side of creamed spinach. One of the best meals we've ever had. All dinners come with a trip to the salad bar which had a good variety. Could even have salads like macaroni or a smoky bacon potato salad. Very nice to have more than just a standard side salad with your meal. Big kudos to Chef Joey! And our server, Jordan was so attentive, sweet, and gave us amazing service. Owners Brian and Kristen have brought a GREAT addition to the Celina food scene. Keeping local history alive and using locally sourced, fresh ingredients. Definitely will be going again and trying all the great food options! read more

No what i expected. Baked potato was not hot, 16oz Prime Ribeye was ok at best. On a positive note, the caesar salad was very good and the Old Fashioned was tasty as well. I won't ever go back. read more

Just got done with my inaugural visit to The Forge in Celina. All I can say is wow. We had the steak bites, cream corn, I had a burger and my wife a chicken sandwich. We loved it all. The quality and amount of food was awesome. The service was top notch. Kudos to the owners. They have done a great job bringing more options for great food to our city and I can promise you it won't be our last visit. In fact I wished we hadn't taken this long to make our first. read more

The Forge 1912 - Steakhouses Near Me - Celina, Texas

See all

The food was great the service was great! Lot of food for the money. I got the chicken sandwich which I ate on for 2 days. The French fries are the best I've had I highly recommend them. read more

Pros: - Friendly staff - French onion soup was great! - Loaded baked potato was good although not served hot - Onion rings were decent - Salad was fine Cons: - The plates and bowls were all too small. It was very strange. Almost like everything was served on salad plates. That being said, our salads were generous but barely fit on the plates, which were the size of dessert plates. Same goes for our dinners. I know that doesn't seem very important, but with everything crammed onto such small plates, it made it hard to eat. Food was falling on to the table. It felt very messy. - The tables were big but for four people, each person had to straddle the legs. Terrible design. I looked around and people were either straddling or sitting sideways. - Pecan crusted chicken wasn't great. Bland and had a burnt taste. The 20 oz ribeye was fine. Not great and definitely not worth $70. - The lights kept flickering the entire time. I know it's an old building but it was annoying, quite frankly. Overall, I would try burgers for lunch but would probably pass on dinner. The ambiance and food are not as elevated as the prices would suggest. I know they've been working hard to get the kinks out and I hope they continue to grow and learn. It could be a much needed addition to downtown Celina. It's just not there yet. I'm rooting for them! read more

The food was very mediocre. I got a Caesar salad and there was no Parmesan cheese, hardly any croutons, and lettuce didn't seem cold. My friend got the ribeye and it was pretty thin. Wanted to like the place but will not go back read more

Service was excellent. However, with only About 6 or 7 table occupied, easy to dote on customers. Ambiance was nice, except the lights kept flickering, which was both distracting and possibly dangerous if a customer was prone to epilepsy. Food was meh. My ribeye was a poor cut: overly fatty and grisly for a steakhouse. I've had better at Outback or Texas Roadhouse. My wife's bacon wrapped shrimp entree had good flavor, but the shells had not been removed under the bacon wrap. The chef agreed and said their new sous chef made a mistake, but nothing was offered to compensate. Overall a very disappointing experience for our 32nd wedding anniversary dinner. read more

Celina needs a locally owned steakhouse. This isn't it. Their $76 wagyu ribeye is a ribeye from brookshires. It was not good and not Wagyu. Save your money and just buy one from Kroger and cook it at home and you'll have a better steak. The steaks include a "salad bar". For $76. What. Please do better so you can succeed and change your supplier. Service was fine, nice to see youth employed there though. read more

Everything was amazing! Best burger and fries I've ever had . Service was amazing ! Will be back for dinner.

Do not come here. We were so excited to try out this new place and have been waiting for months. We decided to visit for our anniversary date, but as we were getting ready to order, they played music where the F bomb was every third word "f this... f you.." over and over. Even the servers were singing along to the song! When we finally said to cancel our order and we were leaving, they acted shocked and had no idea that the song was playing. Will NEVER EVER be back! Very disappointed in management for allowing this to exist in their establishment. read more

Food was great and burger was cooked well. Those fries were the bomb and will get an extra order when Ig o back there. The building is historical and they did a good job redecorating the place. Service was good and we will be back again. read more

Went here recently with a large party of friends (8 of us)! My filet, topped with tallow butter was legit...cooked exactly as ordered! The salad bar was fresh, and was included as part of my steak order! We sampled some of each other's sides...my green beans, tallow fries were all good! The Texas Popcorn and stuffed mushroom appetizers are both highly recommended. Great dining experience...will be back! read more

The Forge 1912 - Prime fillet with tallow butter - Steakhouses Near Me - Celina, Texas

Great steaks and service; been twice and will be returning whenever I'm in the area. It's a new restaurant, other reviews are a little harsh. The chef and owners have lots of experience, they will keep improving! read more

I think this place is fantastic. Had the ribeye and it was perfect. I normally don't like salad bar but this one is good with fresh ingredients. Will definitely go back. read more

Three of us dined at this restaurant on December 15, 2024. When we returned home, my husband was looking at our check. We had been charged for 4 meals. We didn't have 4 meals as there were 3 of us. My husband called the restaurant on the 16th of December and was assured by the manager that a refund would appear on our credit card. It is now February 4, 2025. The money has not been refunded. The price of the meal for which we were charged was expensive. We would warn you to carefully check your dinner tab before you pay. We are sorely disappointed with the manager as he said he would handle it. read more

We've been a couple of times and have enjoyed it every time. The burgers and fries are amazing. We've also thought the salmon and steak were great too. Love that it's family owned and they really care about their customers. We will definitely continue to come back. read more

Spent $270 for an overcooked, tough, cold pork chop with a gritty sauce, poor service and strange sides/starters. This is a brightly lit casual restaurant, not an upscale steakhouse like we thought (though they have steakhouse prices) Really really wanted to like it but so disappointed! On the upside, my husband said his ribeye was the best he'd ever had but the reviews tell me that may have been a fluke. Way too expensive to eat what we ate and be ignored by our waitress. read more

Wish i could say we had the privilege to try this place but unfortunately we sat for an hour for a cup of soup and a burger that never came out, so we left. After waiting for 45 minutes, we asked the bartender about our food since our waitress wasn't very attentive. Shortly after, someone spoke to us and apologized and said our food was coming out next. Waited another 15 minutes and saw the people behind us who got there after us, got food. The place wasn't even crowded. Disappointed to say the least. First time there and last time there. read more

It was chilly and the lights flicker and chairs wobble. High end, no!!!!! We had a party of four. We had two filet mignon, one steak sandwich, and a ribeye. The house salad is more like a Cesar salad so I tasted no blue cheese dressing and I got a half of one cherry tomato. The ribeye was very good full of flavor but my plate was too small, too hard to cut and when I did the potato would hang off plate. The fillets were OK and the steak sandwich was slimy with onions in it. Two of us had baked potatoes that were not cooked. We complained to the waitress, and she did nothing. We complained to the owner,he only apologized and said he would tell the kitchen, but did nothing finally when somebody other than our waitress bought the bill over, and I'm thinking our waitress didn't want to have another confrontation about the potatoes, We told her that our baked potatoes were not cooked. She said she would do an adjustment, a whopping four dollars ! My goodness couldn't they do better than that no other side dish was offered. Disappointed to say the least, we aren't coming back! They could've rectified this some other way and we would've returned, but given the don't give a crap attitude we're not! read more

Not great. Not bad. Very over seasoned fries. Chicken was tough. Service wasn't very attentive.

Walked in and got seated without reservation in bar area. That was nice. The finish out/ambiance could have been nicer for sure. I will say ...the Service was fast and great! However, coming from living in Highland Park for over 20 years where the BEST steak houses are...we wanted to give it a try since we now live in Prosper. Salad bar was fresh but limited, appetizer was fantastic (had the jam Brie ). Now..on to the steak. Wasn't bad , wasn't great, for a 6oz filet which cost $48 it was marginal. I will pay that at Bobs steakhouse but this steak was about as bland as a steak that should only cost around $25 . The sweet potato sounded delicious on the menu but very bland and dry. Prices are way too high. We never mind spending $$$ on great food but would never go back again sadly. read more

I'm giving it 5 stars with the hope of change. Service was great, no issue. The prices were fine when I saw them on the menu. The issue is the product. When you have expectations derived from the prices the product comes up severely short. The menu options are great in theory but the taste and quality is not present. I hope the owner will take this into consideration moving forward. I hope this place makes it. read more

Food was delicious and the serving sizes were generous. The service is a work in progress. They were young and pleasant. The ambiance was great...a blacksmith shop from the early 1900's. We will differentially be back. read more

Ate here for my birthday a couple weeks ago as I had been wanting to give it a shot being a local steakhouse which is something we lacked in Celina. It was a Monday night so wasn't super busy but the servers were very nice and the food was fantastic. We ordered the crab cake to start and the butter sauce it sad in was phenomenal. I ordered the 6 oz filet cooked medium rare and it came out perfectly with great flavor. The Mac and cheese was one of the best restaurant mac and cheese I have personally had as it had a truly homemade flavor. The mashed potato's also had a more homemade flavor than many other steakhouses. Price was no more expensive than other steakhouses and to have this one local was great. If you are looking for a Dee Lincoln's, Eddie V's, 3 Forks, etc. atmosphere,m and service then you will need to go somewhere else. If you are looking for a local business in what will not be a small town much longer, this is a great spot. It's unfortunate some of the reviews talk about overcooked food, so hopefully the chef that worked those nights can be replaced to improve those experiences! read more

We had a great experience at the Forge! Meal and service was great! Will return often!

We did not enjoy our evening at The forge. Of four meals ordered 2 were overcooked and sent back. Then when these two meals were recooked, the steak was undercooked and had to be cooked again. The asparagus was cold and undercooked. The salad overflowed the tiny plates and fell on the table. The Moouse was powdery and poorly mixed, not made from scratch. The crème brulet was undercooked. The bright spot was the creamed spinach which should be under appetizer section, not sides. The service was sloooow, which was surprising with only 4 tables filled. Waiter did not refill water and never asked about the meals. The manager came over after meals were served and had to take food back to kitchen. She apologized as there was not a chef working, only line cooks- A Huge Shock for a 'steakhouse'! The ambiance was bright and the decor was more like a BBQ restaurant not a 'steakhouse'. I do not recommend this restaurant read more

AMAZING! The burger and fries were so good, I can't wait to go back for dinner and try the steak. The service was awesome and our large group was served perfectly. Can't wait to have another girls lunch or dinner at this awesome place! read more

I had a hard time deciding if I should leave a review. I want the very best for this place. I've gone 4 times. The first 2 times were when they opened, our steaks were over cooked (so disappointing) and my butter came out 10 minutes after I received my streak. Half of our table received their food and the other half got their food like 15 minutes later because 1/2 of our food went to the wrong table. It was a big bill for the experience. The service definitely does not match the pricing. Also, the last 2 times we all ordered burgers to play it safe. This is a great place for a burger! We will continue going for the burgers and sandwiches. I hope they work on customer service and pricing. Prices to match venue. I will hold back on posting more because I want this place to have the opportunity to make changes. They need to hire more experienced managers & employees that are on it!! Kevin was great but I haven't seen him in moths. read more

If i could give this place 0 stars i would. Waited 1 1/2 for our food and it finally came out, COLD. Steaks were over cooked for the whole table. Service was terrible and on top of that they charge 20% gratuity for a party 6 or larger. Never received refills and food came out one dish at a time. The cherry on top was that the kids meals were the last dish to come out. Do yourself a favor and go anywhere else !! read more

Food was excellent, apps were out of this world. Nice setting; clean and well decorated. Owner is super nice and receptive to feedback. Looking forward to a return in the future. read more

Food is excellent, service was excellent, ambiance was excellent! Highly recommend. Very nice selection of liquor as well.

Great new spot! Texas popcorn was especially amazing and management and server were very attentive. Need to try dessert next time. Will be back! read more

LOVELY, classy, upscale dining. The service was impeccable, the food was wholesome and delicious, and the owners have done a beautiful job preserving the history and the significance of the building. If you are looking for a memorable place to enjoy a farm-to-table, locally-sourced meal, look no further than The Forge 1912. P.S. The Spinach Artichoke dip was the best I've had ANYWHERE!! Ever. read more

I was excited to find this restaurant, I liked that they used quality meats like pasture raised chicken and tallow for frying. The decor was kinda meh, a little too rustic for the price point, but I was willing to overlook that. The server was very nice and helpful. We ordered steak and chicken. And it really was just a slab of steak and a slab of chicken. There was no sauce or seasoning whatsoever on the steak, usually there's some garlic butter or even black pepper right, but there was nothing, just an overcooked steak that was bone dry when you cut into it. The chicken was even worse, there were some decorative flakes of seasoning (didn't taste like anything) and it was dry as napkins. I was just shocked by the complete lack of seasoning and moisture. The only thing that tasted good were the fries, they were nice and crispy. I would love for this restaurant to do some kind of overhaul on the recipes. I like flavor, I'm not someone who wants super heavy super salty seasoning, but NO seasoning is simply too far. I like the idea of the restaurant, just not the execution. Will be sticking to Haywire down in Plano until Forge updates the recipes read more

Went in to sit at the bar for a couple of drinks, sat at a high top table. There were 3 or 4 people working the bar, they looked over at us a few times, no one ever came over to take a drink order. We sat there for about 10 minutes and then got up and left. Definitely will not be back. read more

We have followed the preparation of this restaurant and were very excited to try The Forge! Sadly we were disappointed overall! :( My husband, 2 boys and parents went for an early dinner. Service was good and we didn't wait at all. The spinach dip was very tasty however the bread served with it was toasted way too much and hard as a rock. I spooned dip on a piece, let it sit and still couldn't cut it with my steak knife. My 77 yr old mother could not even attempt to eat them. The TX popcorn was very good and later we wished it was a dinner menu item. Most of us had the salad bar and we all wished there were more choices on it. It was pretty plain. And signs to tell us what the 3 salads were would have been helpful - the carrot salad was obvious, the other 2 not so much. As it turned out the bread pieces on the salad bar worked much better with the spinach dip and should be considered to replace the hard burnt bread pieces! I LOVE french onion soup - however I had a very hard time finding much soup here. I appreciate having plenty of onions, cheese and bread but they should complement the broth not keep me from it! My husband, dad and older son all had steak and enjoyed the flavor and they were cooked as requested. We sent my husband's mac and cheese side dish back because it was full of grease and not edible. The waitress apologized, but for the price of the meals, I really thought someone from the kitchen or management would come talk to us about it. Nope! My mom ordered a salad with grilled chicken. The salad consisted mostly of the lettuce ends - which she picked out - and the chicken came on a side plate in large pieces leaving my elderly mom to cut up chicken to put in her salad (she doesn't want help especially in public!). It's the most basic dish and she was not thrilled at all with it. Finally desert - peach cobbler that didn't even have ice cream! Our dinner wasn't cheap but we left saying we could have had a better meal for a lot less at several other restaurants. We really wanted to love this new local place. However - for now - we won't rush back. read more

One of our favorite places! My kids love the Texas popcorn. My husband loves their ribeye and pork chop. I love the chicken Caesar salad and French onion soup. We all love their Mac & cheese! I can't remember the name of our server. She was incredibly sweet and very knowledgeable about the menu. I am so happy they are open for lunch because their take out is my favorite right now! read more

Fantastic food Great place and service. I would highly recommend this small town treasure. Try the steak bites and prime steaks