The cake was delicious as well as very pretty. My daughter and her friends loved it. The quality and presentation was outstanding. The blue velvet cake was tender and the icing was to die for. The delivery process was easy and the cake arrived in perfect condition. All we had to do was add the candles and the cake topper. I ordered the candles from them to eliminate one more task off my "to do" list. If I had known they offered cake toppers, I would have bought that too but I had already purchased one. The customer service was top notch and they really go out of the way to make it seamless and customer friendly. I would definitely order from Evercake again and will recommend Evercake to all my family and friends. I also love that it's a small independently owned business versus all these chain bakeries. Thanks to the Evercake team for making the event so special for my daughter's Sweet 16th birthday. read more

The Evercake - Posie Cake - Custom Cakes Near Me

Super disappointed in the cake. I ordered a cake for my boyfriends 27th birthday in April around a month in advance. It was a custom cake that was supposed to be The Weeknd themed with a logo and my boyfriends name on the cake. The day the cake arrived, I opened the box to double check and the logo looked like it was drawn on last minute (I even included several sample pictures for reference) and they had put the wrong name on the cake. My boyfriends name is Austin not Jack. I was extremely disappointed as I had reiterated several times through email confirming my boyfriends name is Austin and even went so far as to bold his name multiple times in our email exchanges. The logo was even more disappointing. I had paid an extra $15 just to have the logo put on only to have to scrape it off because it didn't look anything like the reference picture. I ended up having to scrape off both the incorrect name and the logo because it just looked so bad. In regards to the actual cake, I went with the chocolate flavor and everything looked nice on the outside, but the cake was dry and overly sweet. No one at the party was a fan of the taste. Most of the cake went untouched because it was way too sweet and it was incredibly embarrassing and disappointing because I had a lot of high hopes based on how it looked on the outside. Maybe the chocolate cake wasn't the right choice, but would not order another cake from here again. There's a huge lack of attention to detail and they provided no support after I had let them know that the logo and name were incorrect. read more

I'm not a big fan of sweets, but I absolutely enjoy Evercake! They strike the perfect balance -- never too sweet -- and I adore their textures, which remind me of "Chantilly," one of my favorite childhood bakeries back home. Also, their creative designs make them a perfect and stylish gift for any special occasion. We can't wait to place our next order for our twins' birthday! :) read more

Best cake and best service ever! During this challenging time with COVID-19, I actually gave up the idea of having a cake on my birthday. You made the impossible possible. My beautiful cloud cake got delivered by itself via Lyft at my door right on my birthday. The strawberry shortcake tasted amazing! Highly recommended! Thank you Evercake for making my 2020 birthday a memorable experience! read more

The Evercake - Custom Cakes Near Me

The most beautiful, delicious, and fresh gem cake for my son's 21st. On time delivery. Fantastic.

Ordered a chocolate cake for my partner's birthday - The cake 1) arrived on time, packaged incredibly well, 2) looked absolutely gorgeous with a beautiful fresh flower, 3) tasted lovely - not too sweet, which is what I was concerned about. However, I do think the price is fairly steep - paid $150+ for the cake and delivery. Other cakes of similar caliber clear for 50-75% of this price in Manhattan. I did really appreciate the team's communication and the cake was lovely, but still feels quite expensive. read more

I would definitely recommend The Evercake, The cake arrived perfectly. It was very delicious and moist. The lady who delivered the cake followed all delivery instructions!! Thank you read more

The Evercake - Strawberry Shortcake, Clouds & Posies. - Custom Cakes Near Me

See all

I ordered a cake for my boyfriend's birthday and the cake was completely dried out. The bottom layer was relatively moist, but the top two were completely dried out and crumbly. I got the strawberry flavored cake, and although it looked nice, there was definitely something wrong with the way the cake was made. After one slice, the whole cake was falling apart and leaning to one side. The strawberry was a cheap glaze and the frosting was too sweet. I can honestly say the quality and taste was on par, if not worse than a $10 store bought cake from a grocery store. I love, love desserts but after taking a couple bites, I threw it away. I asked for some sort of refund or repayment and Alexis asked if they could come by and pick up the cake. I agreed, but the cake was never picked up. She asked for photos of the cake instead, which I sent. I then had to chase for a response and after two weeks, she finally replied. No credit or refund was given as they were able to "track when it was made, frosted, and delivered, which was all within our 24-48 hr timeframe." Even if they were able to track this, the cake was completely unsatisfactory and poorly made. It ruined a special day and the store offered no help to remediate this. I'm extremely disappointed with the experience, especially having paid $140 for the cake. read more

Fantastic. The cake was beautifully decorated, tasted delicious and was delivered early. Many thanks. Can't wait to work together again on another occasion. read more

The Pink Champagne strawberry chiffon cake was not only beautiful but delicious. The Happy Birthday sign with sparklers was a real show stopper. I highly recommend this reliable company. read more

The Evercake - Birthday cake with sparklers! - Custom Cakes Near Me

If there was ever a place where you want the most impressive, modern and tasteful custom cake, it's Evercake! I had a bachelorette party in nyc and didn't want a cake that was too raunchy like the typical ones you would see. The cake I received from The Evercake was so clever and beautiful!!! Not only beautiful but so delicious as well. Usually custom cakes look good but doesn't taste as good. The girls called it the "Lux Labia" by the photos you can see why. Can't wait for future parties and milestone events in my life. I will be calling Evercake during those times. read more

The Evercake - Can't get passed how awesome this cake is - Custom Cakes Near Me

See all

We received a beautiful cake from a friend for our wedding anniversary and while it was not the correct item, it was delicious nonetheless. Our friend reported that Evercake was very gracious with the order mishaps and I wanted to let Them know as a recipient of a gift I wouldn't have known. We will be ordering from here for our next big celebration. Their product and customer service is unparalleled. read more

I ordered a cake for my daughter's engagement, so I really wanted it to be special. It was delivered to the restaurant, as her fiancé had arranged for both sets of parents to be nearly in NYC when he proposed. Evercake was amazing! Their service was good and the cake was beautiful. We all enjoyed a slice after dinner and the chocolate was scrumptious. My daughter and her fiancé took the cake that was left home after dinner and they loved finishing it off over the next couple of days. I am using them again for my daughters 30th birthday - the delivery to her apartment today will be a surprise to share with their guests at tonight's party! read more

The Evercake - Custom Cakes Near Me

See all

'A commitment is a commitment and backing off isn't professional conduct. My friend was deprived of a birthday cake surprise and the person(me) sending it to him was deprived of adding a happy moment to the birthday boy.I placed an order on 7th October' 2020, they accepted my order , an order number was processed, a delivery schedule was given for the 9th (the birthday) and my money was deducted. They cancelled my order on the 8th inspite of repeated requests and me clearly explaining that I do not live in the United States and I would be extremely inconvenienced. Sadly, all this is my fault 'for trying to support a small businesses' . Clearly there was no respect for sentiment and blatant disregard from an industry that's being offered support post a huge effect from the pandemic. The experience of dealing with 'The Evercake' was unpleasant (I have an email thread to prove this). Unfortunately 'The Evercake' has 0 ethics, accountability & ownership!! read more

WOW! We ordered a 10" clouds and poises with dulce de leche, topped with specifically requested yellow roses. Our guests, even the ones who avoid desserts, finished their cake serving and offered their compliments! Working with Alexis and Clyde was prompt, attentive and very successful! We reached out to Evercake 17 days prior to our event and all was delivered on time with out any issues! YES WE HIGHLY RECOMMEND EVERCAKE! read more

Didn't spell name right in the frosting despite writing it correctly everywhere else!! Pretty careless for a $100+ price tag might as well have just gotten from whole foods... read more

Absolutely AMAZING. My order was extremely last minute and I was fully expecting to not be able to receive this cake but I did! The cake was made the same day they delivered and it came absolutely gorgeous. The flowers were fresh and the cake was bigger than expected! The price for this cake was not bad at all and totally worth it. My parents loved it for their anniversary. Really made it more special. read more

See all

I would give negative stars if possible. Either the proprietors can't tell time/read a calendar or lack the understanding that when one pays for a service, one expects that service to be delivered. ON TIME. Thanks for ruining my daughter's 18th birthday, Evercake!!!! read more

FABULOUS SERVICE AND PRODUCT! I live in NYC. At the last minute I needed 2 cakes offering SAME DAY DELIVERY. When I googled "cakes near me" several websites popped up but The Evercake cakes looked beautifully artistic and the reviews were outstanding. At 4:00am I emailed Alexis and by 8:45am I had received a response. Via email I decided on 2 cakes and Alexis made it so easy! They delivered my cakes to the restaurant within the time frame I requested and the cakes were beautiful and delicious! Only in NYC can you order last minute cakes receiving amazing help AND DELIVERY nonetheless! Many thanks to Alexis! read more

We ordered the Vanilla and Lemon mousse cake for our wedding ten days ago and it was, by far, one of the BEST cakes we've ever had. We ate it for three days straight and were so sad we finished it. Now we're just looking for an excuse to order from them again. The Evercake team was also super friendly and communicative. It was such a pleasure to work with them. Thanks guys!! read more

The Evercake - Pink Champagne. Vanilla and Lemon Mousse - Custom Cakes Near Me

See all

The cake itself is very good , and does taste very good, fresh. It doesn't seem to keep very well into the next day, however. My peeves are with the charges - they charge an extra 20 bucks for ordering the day before , which I thought was pretty weird considering the cake is definitely expected to be made within a 24 hour window -by the time this is delivered to the door, after all the charges, you have to wonder about the cost read more

My co-workers and I got the pink champagne cake for our team member's birthday and she absolutely loved it! She said the cake was delicious (vanilla cake with french cream and rasberry) and that it really made her day feel special. The Evercake did a great job with everything from taste and presentation to delivery read more

The Evercake - Pink Champagne Cake - Custom Cakes Near Me

I used The Evercake for my cousin's bachelorette back in August. I ordered the Clouds & Posies cake Vanilla with French Cream & Raspberry Filling. I emailed a couple of times to confirm my order details and Alexis was so responsive and helpful. The cake was delivered on time to the restaurant and was really pretty. It also tasted way better than I expected! There weren't a lot of reviews on the taste, so I was slightly nervous. There was truly nothing to worry about - it was delicious! It's a very light cake. The frosting and filling are really well-balanced (and I'm not usually a frosting fan). There also were some decorative sugar crystals added, that actually were really delicious. I highly suggest The Evercake and would order from them again! read more

The Evercake - Custom Cakes Near Me

This was, hands down not only the most beautiful cake I have ever received but also the most delicious. From the moment an out if town friend had this delivered for my July COVID birthday and I was beside myself with this cake. It was just beautiful down to very detail and tasted amazing! Moist cake and delicious raspberry filling and buttercream frosting. Like other reviews here I agree less sugary and not as over the top sweet as other buttercream. The few reviews stating it was SO sweet, I don't get and you may want to remember...it is. Cake! Ha! Would definitely recommend and order from Evercake again AMAZING!! read more

The Evercake - My beautiful birthday gem!! - Custom Cakes Near Me

Thank you so much, my friend loved her small wedding covid cake. Her and her husband said that is one of the most delicious cakes they ever tasted. She would want to get you as a cater for the official big wedding once all of this covid is done. Now I really want one delivered to me in Atlanta so I can judge the cake . I'm a big fan of cakes. I'm glad the first wedding cake I ever order was perfect. I really appreciate the effort. Loved dealing with you guys. You were so helpful, thanks for the flowers. Thanks for the card. My friend loved the hand writing and that added a personal touch to it. Thanks for being there for my friend when I'm miles away. read more

The Evercake - Cake, flowers and card - Custom Cakes Near Me

Everyone raved about how delicious this cake is! The company is run by wonderful people who go the extra mile. 4 stars instead of 5 because of a hiccup with my order, but they made it right and were very responsive when resolving the issue. They actually care about their customers. It's so refreshing. ***NOTE TO BUYERS*** If you email for next day or same day delivery, make sure to double-confirm all the details. I needed a cake to be delivered for a birthday and emailed at 7pm the night before the event. The fact that they even offer this service is pretty awesome, and the customer service through the process is amazing. They emailed me back within an hour and we communicated about the details until midnight and then they got back to me at 7am the next morning. Really responsive and helpful. Unfortunately, they mixed up the delivery window and the cake was going to come over an hour after the delivery time I requested. In a lot of situations, that's maybe not such a big deal, but for me in this case that was a big problem. Once we realized the mix-up, they were on top of it, hustling to get the cake delivered as quickly as they could. There were so kind and apologetic and did everything they could to make sure I felt taken care of. We ended up missing a special moment, but the everyone did get to enjoy the cake eventually, and the company refunded my delivery fees as an apology. So what could have been a giant disappointment turned into something that was still pretty nice. These folks are great, and I would definitely order from them again. read more

Ordered a cake to be delivered to celebrate the birthday of one of our team members. The cake was on time, gorgeous, and delicious. Everything was on point - but the only thing keeping from 5 starts would be the $. 1.5 - 2x what we've paid from other providers in the past... read more

I live in Houston and needed a birthday cake for my daughter who lives in New York City. It needed to be a surprise and to be delivered (on a Sunday!). Evercake was amazing from start to finish. Excellent, prompt communication via email (thanks Alexis!) the delivery was on time and finished cake was amazing both in beauty and taste. She was thrilled and I can not recommend this company enough! Will use them again next year! read more

The Evercake - The "pink champagne" cake from their website. - Custom Cakes Near Me

OMG! OMG! OMG! I ordered a cake for my Mom's 85th Birthday. Our family tradition is cake for breakfast, and The Evercake made sure the insanely delicious pink champagne cake (dark chocolate with hazelnut mousse) was there for 9am to surprise her! The cake itself was stunning...so beautiful we had to force her to cut it. And it tasted even better. Thank you, The Evercake, for your incredible customer service & the amazing start to my Mom's 85th! read more

Disappointed. Cake was ok, though the bottom layer was under baked (real mushy like batter). It was overly sweet to my taste, but maybe just a preference. What was most disappointing was the strawberry filling, or lack thereof. It was nothing like what is pictured on the website. Instead of luscious fresh strawberries filled with cream, there was only strawberry jam! and maybe a couple of strawberries at the edge of the cake, if you were lucky to get a slice that contained it. The cake itself was pretty on the outside, I suppose. And it was delivered on time. But definitely not worth the money. read more

See all

Perfect delivery, kept me updated and the cake was just gorgeous. Friend was so nicely surprised read more

The Evercake - Big enough to feed 8! - Custom Cakes Near Me

These cakes are simply amazing. They taste delicious. They look spectacular. The company is responsive, reliable and enjoyable to work with. They're an absolute pleasure in every way. Can't wait to order our next cake! read more

The Evercake - Custom Cakes Near Me

Cake was just OK - dry and a bit too sweet. The bigger issue is reliability. Cake delivery was late. Tried contacting ever cake through phone and emails - both went unanswered. Created a sense of panic - no one needs it on the big day read more

Do yourself a favor and order from the Evercake! Alexis went above and beyond to make sure I received this cake. Although I live outside of the Evercake delivery zone, Alexis allowed me to pick up my cake in store. Alexis responded quickly to my emails and sent a follow-up to make sure I received the cake. The cake is both stunning and delicious. The best part is that the frosting isn't too sweet. I highly recommend the Evercake. I will be ordering another cake from this company in the future! read more

The Evercake - Pink Champagne Cake - Custom Cakes Near Me

I was in need of finding a birthday cake last minute. Came across Evercake in my search, outstanding customer service and their cakes are beautiful as well as delicious. read more

First off, the attention paid to every single detail in this cake was phenomenal. I sent a picture of a Chanel bag and it was nearly identical to the bag in the picture. Not only did it look good, but it tasted as good as it looked! Everyone was so professional and so nice!!! Cant wait to order from them again! Thanks Evercake read more

The Evercake - Custom Cakes Near Me

Overall: The Strawberry Shortcake itself was tasteful and satisfying. The gold metallic on the icing was nearly recognizable (a good thing). The icing in general was not too thick nor too sweet. I did have a issue with delivery arriving 2 hrs. earlier than the agreed scheduled time. The Happy Birthday signage was a bit flimsy. The Birthday person's name on the cake was also very thin. read more

Our cake from the Evercake was the culinary highlight of my bridal shower!! The geode design was almost too gorgeous to cut into, and the berry cream filling was so delicious (beats out Milk Bar any day) and tasted dangerously light. Will definitely be ordering from them for our next celebration. read more

The Evercake - Custom Cakes Near Me

If we could give 10 stars we would. We ordered a cake for our daughter's bridal shower! The Evercake "experience" from the ordering to the delivery was excellent in every way. Not only was the cake beautifully decorated, it was absolutely delicious. We can't recommend Alexis and the Evercake team enough. Thank you so much for a wonderful service! read more

I'm obsessed with this bakery. I was in such a tight time, and all the way from Saudi Arabia, I was trying to send a cake to my sister whose in Manhattan. Apart from their cake presentation, Evercake has the most amazing customer service. Amazing hands down. Nothing impresses me more about a company than their customer services. I emailed Alexis back and forth countless of times. And, she was really patient with me and tried to do as much as she can to accommodate me in my situation. My sister says the cake tastes amazing!!! Definitely going back for more of that Chocolate Gold Foil. Again, Alexis if you are reading this thank you so much for your help really appreciate it. read more