I was so happy to find this little spot in downtown Eureka. The space itself is super fun with wonderful energy and really cool aesthetic touches. We were served right away and the hostess was very nice and located at two top for us. The wait person was lovely and immediately accommodating. The menu was interesting and inviting. I had to laugh out loud as there is an item on the menu referencing Pee-wee's Playhouse from my childhood. I even asked if it was a Gen X restaurant and sure enough the chef is of my generation. I'm including a picture so IYKYK! The waitress had shared all of the specials, and I was intrigued by the flat iron steak option. It was a flat iron steak with marsala mushroom sauce, and mushroom risotto and asparagus. It was delightful! The meat was perfectly cooked and tender with a lot of beef flavor, offset by a rich marsala mushroom sauce. It was perfectly complimented by one of the top mushroom risotto I have had in my life. It was delectable. And the grilled asparagus side paired nicely with the beef and marsala sauce. It even had a little bit of lemon on the asparagus, which is my preference for it! Overall, this is probably in the top five of all of the restaurant meals I've had in my life. My husband had the mixed beef burger with fries. He said he really enjoyed the burger, and I did steal a tiny taste, and it was perfectly cooked and had a slight gameness that gave it some depth. My husband said that the bun was very nice as well. The fries were perfectly cooked. The burger was perfectly cooked and it wasn't over juicing nor dry. Overall, a really great burger! Funniest thing we noticed was that all of the chairs that were sitting on a cement floor had been given rubber caps for each of the legs so that when you moved the chair, it didn't make a horrible sound. Literally extra 10 points for that alone! I wish this location well and look forward to stopping in the next time we are in the area. read more

See all

Up here on business and looking for a good place to bring my team. Ordered a couple of pizzas for the table and some other various items. Servers were pleasant but some people got served way after others. Food was good. Loved the two pizzas we ordered. Crust was perfect. Inside of the restaurant was nice with a cool view of the pizza oven. read more

Pretty good pizza. Liked the crispiness and flavor of the pizza called sam the butcher. My partner asked for ranch and that was really good. Tasted fresh and enjoyed the dill with it. The salad we got was also decent, nothing special about it but still good. Overall it was a good choice. Staff were friendly and attentive. Didn't have to wait to be seated. read more

Slow service, I think we sat there over an hour waiting for our food on a Thursday and it wasn't very busy, food also wasn't great, the brick oven pizza took the longest and every time my bf tried picking up a slice it just folded and all the toppings slid off. It was gross. we got boxes and threw it away later.. Truly the most disappointing meal we had on our 5 day vacation, and the most expensive. Save your money and go somewhere else. read more

I think for me I prefer more fine dining. The food was really good, the staff great but I am more of a near the ocean vibe diner. This is a great neighborhood dining experience. read more

Good food and it was my birthday . I got the margarita pizza dn it was amazing. The server was kind. The artwork makes the vibe fun. read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

Service was great! Pizza was even better than expected! Super fresh taste sauce and basil. The place was almost empty when we got here, but filled up entirely. read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - Cauliflower crust margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

We were in Eureka three nights and ate here all three nights. Pizzas were amazing. Husband had a Rueben sandwich one night and loved it. Atmosphere is a cool vibe, yet relaxed. Staff is friendly. You won't go wrong coming here. read more

First off to start, I'm unsure why they have bar in their name. They only have beer, cider and wine. That's fine. Was just misled by their name, expecting more. I had oven roasted salmon with what was supposed to be a teriyaki glaze on top but it was more like a syrup. The mushroom risotto was good. The pizzas that we ordered were good. The price for the child's slider was crazy for the tiny thing that we received. My personal opinion otherwise are the chairs. They are cold and uncomfortable. read more

See all

A work trip brought me to Eureka, so I had an opportunity to try out some of the offerings here. This was our choice for dinner before heading back. Really amazing pizzas arrived at our table, straight from the cool-looking brick oven! I really enjoyed the garlic and clam pizza - super garlicky and tasty! My coworker really enjoyed his cup pepperoni pizza, too. The server was helpful and quick to get our orders in, but wasn't pushy or intrusive. The decor is really amazing. Lotsa antique diver-related photos, plus huge canvases and other art by local artists. And the ceiling is pressed tin, with cool light fixtures. All around, awesome spot! Add it to your list! read more

See all

Great experience. The food and service were excellent. We arrived around 6:30 pm on a Thursday and the place was bustling, which is always a good sign. We started with the charcuterie board. The crostini were so yummy, and there was a generous assortment of meats, cheeses, nuts, fruit, spreads, crackers, etc. Three of us ordered the flat iron steak with Marsala sauce, grilled asparagus and mushroom risotto. All delicious. The risotto was so flavorful that we were still talking about it the next day. One of our party ordered a pizza, and was very happy with it, but I can't remember the details. This was a bit of a splurge for us, but we were celebrating a graduation and are so glad we took a chance on the Diver. It was a memorable meal. read more

Probably the best pizza we've had outside of Italy! Sean the owner is super friendly and we were sitting close enough to the pizza oven to chat with him while we ate. Burger was delicious, salad was huge and fantastic, and the pizzas are handmade and the dough is perfect. Sean even built his own pizza oven. Great beer selection. The Diver is a must when you're in Eureka! read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

Called ahead and got there wouldn't seat us. They could have split our group but instead said they can't seat us.

We've been looking forward to this all day. This sesame ahi salad was so good--super fresh, with perfectly seared tuna and just the right mix of creamy and tangy sauces. The veggies underneath were crisp and added a great crunch, and the black sesame seeds gave it a little extra flavor. It felt light but still really satisfying. read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - Sesame Ahi Salad - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

Had the rueben sandwich which was ok. Bread was overly toasted. Service was good and server was enthusiastic

New date night spot! My Popeye Burger was scrumptious. And so was my partner's Calico Cowboy Burger. As well as our sides of potato leek soup, and fries! American food but as it SHOULD be. Leveled up, unique, intricate. I was closing my eyes, taking in fully each bite. I want another one and I'm full. Our server made sure we got our food & drink how we liked it. Going to sleep tonight with a happy belly. read more

The food at the Diver Bar and Grill was excellent! I had a Caprese pickle sandwich with a berry spinach side salad. Both were excellent! The raspberry vinaigrette on the salad was great and the berries were fresh and ripe. The sandwich had a very nice pesto and balsamic dressing. I was skeptical of the pickles, but they worked well on the sandwich. My husband had the pastrami sandwich, which was also delicious. The portions are large and the service was great. It's not a fancy place, which suited us well after a day of hiking in the redwoods. The tables were comfortable and not crowded together. I will go back next time I am in Eureka! read more

Friendly, pleasant atmosphere in Eureka on F Street. Had a really tasty salmon fettuccini and prompt and attentive service. Will definitely come back. read more

After initially passing The Diver by due to reviews which spoke of the excessive wait time, we are SO glad we gave it a try! Not only was the wait reasonable for a busy Friday night (10 minutes to get seated and 30 minutes to get food once order was placed) but the service was AMAZINGLY friendly and efficient! Every dish was delicious but the star was the wood fired oven pizza! The Salty Sweet pizza was a slice of culinary heaven with 3 different types of cheeses (blue cheese sauce, mozzarella and Gorgonzola crumbles) and the salty and sweet dance of the bacon jam and medjool dates. Restaurant had plenty of seating and can also accommodate a large party. read more

See all

Farm to table rustic vibes! While visiting Eureka I stopped to have lunch here & it didn't disappoint. I'm not a fan of sweet potato fries but these were crispy & fluffy on the inside. They had good wine selections but no pinot grigio. I asked the server for recommendations for something similar on the dry side & you could tell he wasn't sure which is totally ok. I selected another style of white & it was too sweet. The server was accommodating and let me try another that was perfect. read more

See all

Waiters were nice, but the kitchen needs to organize better. We got there around 6:30pm, got seated right away... but phew, our appetizer took like 30 min to appear, then another 40 min or so for the entrees! We were exhausted by the time we finished dinner. We had 2 little kids, and glad we were able to grab one and only crayons for them to entertain during the looong wait!! Food was so so in my opinion. Not worth the wait. We finally walked out of there around 8pm!! read more

I love just about everything I've tried here, including the specials - they had a curry soup once that I wish they would bring back. But my favorite item is the ahi burger. Great dish and great price. Love their pizzas, burgers, and salads as well. read more

My usual 1 night stay Eureka restaurants let me down, so I found this place on Yelp, I had never been. This place was amazing!! They have a small bar in the back, ordered a Pilsner, and the 2 bacon pizza, it was the best meal I have had in forever! I travel every week, and have my favorites, this establishment blows them all away, with the service staff, and great atmosphere. A reason to come back to Eureka soon, well done. You won't be disappointed. read more

The whole experience was great from the friendly waitress that knew all the beers to share to the appetizers that were amazing to the burgers that we shared so we could taste a little of each. I'd say the Popeye was probably my favorite. Next step would be the black and blue followed by the one with the pineapple on it that was really good as well. Great experience, fun crowd. Will have to try the pizza menu next time. read more

This was a great place to have a nice dinner at a reasonable price. We both had the grilled ahi salad and shared a crustini appetizer with bacon and blue cheese. The salad was fresh with nice ingredients including fresh bean sprouts. I definitely highly recommend this place. No, it's not a high profile place on the waterfront, but it's great food at a good price. The service was outstanding. I recommend the Old Growth Sauvignon Blanc by the glass. read more

Amazing food and service. Met here for lunch with some business associates. Everyone had the smoked salmon Club. The fish was fantastic. The sweet potato fries were some of the best I've ever had. They were actually crispy but not overcooked. The service was great. My Diet Coke glass was never empty. And the server could not have been more tolerant of our delayed lunch start - - one of our party had a delayed flight. I love the neighborhood. Old Town and eclectic. Convenient, free parking right outside the door. Definitely a great choice for lunch. I will be back. read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - Smoked salmon club - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

After walking over from the Redwood Curtain on a dark Tuesday in March, I was famished. Happy to say The Diver more than met my requirements, starting with the young hipster server wearing an A's cap - I found more fans of the formerly-based-in-Oakland franchise in Eureka than I normally like to count. Their move to Vegas via Sacramento to this guy? Meh Of course that has nothing to do with the experience, which was across-the-board fantastic. Delish beer (from Oakland no less), scintillating pizza, and what is perhaps the best sign, a diverse yet consistently happy group of patrons. And by extension, me. read more

I wish had the opportunity to review the food. We came in after a long day on the road with 3 kids. They said they could put a table together for 5 people but couldn't seat us for 15 minutes due to their head chef being out and the kitchen being backed up. There were several open tables. We were 100% fine waiting. I asked if we could just sit and wait to order, the hostess said no. I said we really would love to just sit and really don't need to order. She said no. About 5 minutes later my 10 year old who was very tired sat in one of the chairs at the table we would be sitting at. She asked him to get up. I said again we really would just like to sit because we were very tired and don't need to order. She said it's only going to be a few more minutes. At this point my family was very frustrated and my husband suggested we leave so we did. read more

Great food and great service! Between three of us we have the ahi burger, ahi salad and catching the day (excellent black cod) am a brownie Sunday. Everything was fabulous! read more

When my fiancé and I were visiting Eureka, California, The Diver was probably our favorite place we ate! It had the grandeur of being a fancy restaurant, but paired with some funky art (that we loved) and a casual atmosphere. (TL;DR- it felt nice but we didn't feel out of place in our shorts and tee shirts) Derek got a spicy burger of some sort and I got pasta with so much goodness in it??? It was a special that day, and it came with shrimp, scallops, and chicken, as well as SO many fresh tasting vegetables! (Although I did pick the carrots out like a four year old because cooked carrots are yucky ) The noodles were thick, which gave them a handmade vibe, and the sauce was perfectly light and complementary to the toppings without stealing their thunder. All in all, it was a DELICIOUS plate of pasta! read more

See all

We were a party of six. Once again I didn't get our waiters name. He was very thorough and explained the specials to us before we ordered. I ordered the special which was halibut.. it was moist and flaky, very tasty and accompanied with nice mushroom risotto and grilled asparagus. Also we selected the pasta with mussels, another order was the chicken sandwich, a nice Caesar salad and two delicious burgers. A person in our party was having a birthday in a few days so we ordered desserts. They were also delicious. The owner Shawn has done a wonderful job keeping this establishment relevant within the community. His prices are reasonable and the experience is always positive. read more

Awesome food. I've been before but tonight was just as awesome. I had the calico she had the el diablo. She may later regret her decision but, at the time, super good she said. I added bacon jam to my calico as it was an option. Worth. Such a nice place to eat. The local art is such a nice touch. Big open room. My only change would be a paper towel dispenser in the bathroom. Someone tried to grab a paper towel out of the stack and the rest of the stack was soaked from it my server was also very nice and remembered me and my group from last time! read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - I looked at this and said "wow that must be a painting by Sonny Wong?!" Sure enough. It was. - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

Definitely one of my faves. Service and food are always fantastic. They always give me extra anchovies on my Caesar salad and the buffalo chicken pizza is perfection. read more

What a great find. Comprehensive menu with lots of homemade options. The soup had a little spice and the sandwich was quite lovely. The staff was wonderful. Helped me right away and was very attentive through my lunch. Wonderful decor. Beautiful tin roof, local art for sale on the walls. I'm so glad I stopped in for lunch. What a treat! read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - Creamy chicken and rice soup with the smoked turkey sandwich sans the bacon. - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

The best, absolute BEST burger and fries in Eureka! Their food is craveable yummyness. I order to go. I have not been disappointed yet. Excellent quality of beef always cooked to my standard. Staff both on the phone and in person are a 5 star rating. We are so lucky to have this restaurant in our city. Thank you, Deborah read more

Excellent, casual dining with a fun atmosphere and friendly service! Highly recommend! Both the Ahi burger and the Classic burger were cooked and seasoned perfectly as were the traditional and the sweet potato fries. If possible, call ahead and make a reservation. The restaurant was full on a Thursday night. read more

Stopped by on a whim and so glad I did! Loved the vibe and the food was so good. I had the gorgy mushroom pizza (in pic) loved the crispy crust and the salty Gorgonzola. My husband had the mushroom burger with sweet potato fries, 10/10. Service is usually very prompt and the staff are courteous. Definitely a place worth many returns. read more

The Diver Bar and Grill - Iced Tea - Pizza Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

I love this place. They are so friendly and they have a wood fired oven. I have not YET tried their pizza, but I can report that there is no better Hamburger. Seriously, they grind the meat right there in their kitchen, it is short rib, I think NY steak and some other premium beef. We had the Popeye burger. AMAZING ! ( I only order classic burger, normally ) but I took a chance. It has a lot of caramelized onions, spinach and goat cheese, but it is the way they do it. Generous meat, I have never tasted such a delicious hamburger patty. We had to savor every bite. The fries were excellent, the wine was great, and the service. Eating this kind of special hamburger is an experience. Looking forward to trying their wood fired oven pizza. read more

So delicious! We even order a pizza to go! Best Lunch Ever! Great Service and Amazing Food! Cheers!

Wow. The food gets 5 stars, know that up front. Fantastic food. Our server was personable and sweet. What we didn't count on was waiting 90 minutes for the salads and entrees to be served. 2 hrs for dinner. We arrived at 5:30, left just before 7:30. 2 hrs is a long time to sit on metal chairs. The food is amazing but be prepared to be there for a long time. read more