The aptly named, "Cookie Jar," seduces with sweet crumbs of all variety of cookies, torts, petit four and other pastries, and a wall full of cubicles with containers to store them in. Pro Tip - Skip the jars and focus intensely on the bakery creations. They won't last as long as the plaster and clay, but taste oh so much better, and definitely make your day. My sampling of their Brownies, Peanut Butter Cookies, Lemon Iced Petit Four, Pistachio Cookies, and a few more I have forgotten due to sugar rush, was an overwhelming high. All delicious with great taste and texture. Service was exceptional from moment of entry to final goodbyes. The packaging was likewise memorable, as was the flour sugar atmosphere that totally captivated the little kid who still lives within. Five by Five. Fantastic pastry experience. read more

See all

What can I say? This place is amazing. This is the same owner as Cake chef. While I don't generally go to them for my cakes, I go to The Cookie Jar, for all of my cookies. They are consistently good. The place is decorated with cookie jars that you can purchase on the wall. The service is very good and the cookies are always fresh. They have such a great ass assortment. read more

The Cookie Jar - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Love, love, love this place. So happy I have family in Staten Island so I can come here. Great cookies, wild assortment and still haven't found one that I don't like. They also have cookie jars for sale in the store which is cool, and great way to pay homage to the name. read more

See all

There can be no greater indulgent pleasure than walking into the Cookie Jar and being overwhelmed by the aromas and the vast selection of delicious delights! Cookies cookies cookies!!!!! Selection is too vast to even attempt to relay. Of course, they have pre wrapped cookie trays but the fun is picking out a pound or two of your favorites and some new ones never before tried. read more

The glass display cases are at the perfect height for a child to admire and easily choose from. I love that you see them acually re-stocking an supplying the display cases so they are always full and ready to be ordered from. Another really nice detail I noticed was the amount of variety offered; there is a whole jelly colletion, nuts collection, chocolate collection. There are plenty of cupcakes and drink uptions as well. This visit, I saw they had a drink of the month, The Cosmic Brownie and it had a try of a matching cookie to pair with. My absolute favorite hot beverage is going to have to be the Hot Chocolate with the melted down chocolate chips. This is a rich drink, with premium chocolate in every sip. If you love coffee and red velvet. I have to recommend you order the Red Velvet Coffee - it tasted spot on to their cupcake. Next, lets get into the dine in option. So there are small tables, situated along the wall featuring their impressive cookie jar collection. Parking is on the street. Follow @kaneamomlife for more information read more

See all

Every time I go on here im greeted with smiles from Francesco and the sweet girl with the blonde hair(sorry I dont remember her name). Its so refreshing to see people in this age group go out of their way to greet you so warmly and be so nice. Its an added bonus to the delicious cupcakes and cookies!!!! If I had a business id definitely want them on my team! read more

Crack head prices, what I mean by that is I got 5 items for $9.75 in North Carolina one cup cake is 6 dollars, cookies are 4 to 5 dollars. Please keep this trend going. I love the variety as well. I got red velvet cupcake, chocolate gnauch, mik chocolate cookie, lemon square pastry and something else. I can say I enjoyed it all, 4 out of 5 for taste. 10 out of 5 for pricing. I guess you New Yorkers are smart keep the big companies out like crumbl and their tasteless cookies. read more

See all

Delicious cookies as always and amazing and helpful staff. The music I the store was a joy too loud for customers.

So good and such a gem. Please never close. I hate that Yelp is making me write at least 85 characters because that's really all there is to it. read more

One of my favorite dessert/treat place on the island. They are great and they also owned cake chef nearby that makes excellent cakes. Cookie jar items are currently priced at $13/lb. They have a full display of delicious cupcakes and goodies. Some of my favorites include their cupcakes (favorite is orange cupcake), and a few squares. They are also wrapped nicely which makes great gifts. The cannoli cookie is not bad, texture is like a marshmallow. The coffee and espresso pairs really well with these goodies as well. Currently with their pandemic, they close at 7 pm. I'm just grateful they are open to bring some sweets in my life. read more

The Cookie Jar - Cupcakes and delicious treats - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I definitely need to revisit. One of my favourite bakeries in Staten Island! And their cookies are delicious! I love the way they decorated the wall with cookie jars too! read more

The cookies are delicious!!! I had the oatmeal blueberry raisin cookies and the red velvet cupcakes. All I can say is yummy! They also have the cutest cookie jars. read more

The Cookie Jar - My Betty Boop cookie jar - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

So I started a new job and instantly became friends with this awesome lady from Jersey. I love her accent . Her some came in town an brought these delicious layered cookies. At first glance there so pretty I didn't want to bite but once I cracked the chocolate layer I was in heaven. Manhattan is definitely on my list to go visits. read more

The Cookie Jar - 2 lb Rainbow petit fours AKA 7 Layer cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Delicious freshly baked variety of cookies! Also tried their latte, little sweet but would definitely recommend their baked goods!

Really great Italian cookies, especially rainbow cookies! It's fun to be able to put together a box of different types of cookies for a little bit of indulgence. The interior is also fun and inviting, and the service friendly. Worth a stop if you're on the island! read more

While on Staten Island, my partner and I couldn't leave until we stopped by this establishment to buy about 1 1/3 pounds of assorted cookies after seeing a recommendation from a TV show on Create. Opened in 2007, this is a specialty bakery with approx. 150 unique variety of cookies made from scratch. They also offer cupcakes, brownie bites and bubble tea. They have a nice assortment of over 200 cookie jars that filled one side of the walls. We were greeted by one of the staff and everyone wore mask. The smell of sweetness permeated through the store as the kitchen was in view at the back. All looked fresh and tempting for eating pleasure on the spot. We would recommend this place to friends and family. read more

See all

Red velvet cupcakes are to die for. Delicious is an understatement. They are pricey cause it's a weighed process but still worth it. I can only eat one or two tops. They are a bit heavy but still worth it. read more

The best spot for baked goods around. One of my favorite dessert/treat place on the island. They are great and they also owned cake chef nearby that makes excellent cakes. Cookie jar items are currently priced at $13/lb. They have a full display of delicious cupcakes and goodies. Some of my favorites include their cupcakes (favorite is orange cupcake), and a few squares. They are also wrapped nicely which makes great gifts. The cannoli cookie is not bad, texture is like a marshmallow. The coffee and espresso pairs really well with these goodies as well. Currently with their pandemic, they close at 7 pm. I'm just grateful they are open to bring some sweets in my life. This place was amazing it smelled so good from the moment you walked in. Huge selection of goodies all kinds of cookies to chose from and so good. I saw the from a distance and had to check it out. Man so glad I did, highly recommend this spot for some cookie cravings. Oh and that frozen marshmallow shake heaven in a cup. read more

See all

Cookies Cookies and more Cookies and if that not enough cakes and pastries!!! Love the feel of this place! And the Cookie Jars as well!!! read more

See all

Love cookie jar! The cupcakes and cookies are a must , try them all! The workers are super friendly! The place is very cute to sit and have a hot chocolate. read more

Good cookies and also very different variety. I would go back again. Quite pricey though.

Homemade Oreos and Whoopi pies from here are pretty good. I believe they're in the Cake Boss family. read more

The Cookie Jar - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I am torn on this review...the location is great, the store is beautiful and the folks behind the counter are nice enough. the selection of cookies is second to none. there must be a million of them and they are all beautiful the problem I have is that some of the cookies just dont taste good. my favorites are the sicilian fig, linser tart and their 7 layer cookies. The other ones I had just dont cut it. the cookies I mentioned are truly outstanding. everytime I go I try a new cookie in hopes of finding another winner. all cookies are $11 a pound. read more

Favorite place to get cookies from on the island. Lucia (not sure if that's how you spell her name) was very friendly and assisted with my order today when everything looked to be gone. She was very pleasant unlike some of the other workers I have encountered there. My favorite cookies are the peanut butter crunch, oatmeal raisin, and milk chocolate chip read more

While walking out of a Walgreen's in Staten Island, I noticed the most heavenly smell. I look across the street and I see The Cookie Jar then I look straight ahead from exit of the Walgreen's and see a wall ad on how The Cookie Jar has "The Best Cookies in Staten Island". Going by the smell and the review's on Yelp, I had to go check it out for myself. There was so much to choose from and everything comes in bite sized portions, so you can sample a little bit of everything. I got a lemon bar, an Oreo chocolate covered pretzel, a red velvet whoopie pie, a brownie bite, a Nutella filled nut cluster, and a slutty brownie (layer of chocolate chip cookie, Oreo, and then brownie). All of my treats were excellent, but the slutty brownie was my favorite. I was certainty impressed. The Cookie Jar just might have "The Best Cookies on Staten Island." read more

See all

Stop Number 1 of our Borough Crawl for Staten Island! And Zaneta's pick! It took a long long while to get here from Bayridge and this may have been my first time ever on the Island that is Staten. I know. Crazy, right? But for the amount of time I was on a bus, Staten Island may not be making it into the 2014 Borough crawl unless we somehow magically acquire a vehicle of swift transportation. After our 2nd bus never made an appearance, we walked 15 blocks to the Cookie Jar while singing Bohemian Rhapsody on the side of the road. We beat the bus and warmed up inside to the most homey, adorable looking cookie shop on the face of the earth. See inserted pictures. Little ceramic knick-knacks and beautiful hand-crafted cookie jars everywhere. A huge display of different colored cookies, brownies, tarts, linzer cookies, cupcakes, macaroons, meringues. Everything. It was so exciting and I had no idea what to get! Zaneta got cherry chocolate chip. So soft and chewy. I opted for double chocolate chip and Steph got a slutty brownie square of sorts. Everything was good and everything was 90 cents or less. My word. If in the neighborhood, check out this Mom and Pop cookie shop. read more

See all

Rainbow cookies are great. Kids love their red velvet Whoopi's pies! The staff is always friendly and welcoming! You can feel a bit rushed at times if there's a line but hey it's NYC after all (yes Staten Island is part of NYC lol...) but overall I come back for the rainbow cookies time and time again! There's a wall of cookie jars that range from cute to weird and are for sale! I've been bought one but I heard when you do choose to purchase one that you can actually fill it with your favorite cookies and have it delivered. I didn't get to take photos of the box of cookies we bought cause the kids devoured them in a NY minute! read more

Absolutely outstanding cookies-the PB&J are so good. Outstanding Rainbows, Linzer Tart, Nutella, etc.... Great staff and reasonable prices. I rarely give 5 stars but this place is so much better than most. read more

Amazing, delicious, love it!!! The service is sometimes flaky but that's because it's a bunch of young girls. But they're very sweet, nice & helpful. The desserts are always delicious. My family and I absolutely love this place. Cant go wrong here. read more

Good cookies; always enjoy them. Service is excellent. Presentation is very good...they always place cookies is a nice box.

Love this place . Nice desserts and friendly staff. My wife likes coming to buy cookies

Great delicious cupcakes. Always fresh. The workers are eager to help and excellent customer service. read more

Ordered 25 baskets last minute to be delivered for my company and they did an amazing job getting it ready and delivered to them.

Best Cookies on Staten Island. Such a big variety. So hard to choose. No problem though just get a bigger box. read more

Can't say I've ever had a mediocre anything here. Love all of their cookies. Literally. Nice ambiance and always fully stocked with the goods. You should come here if you haven't! read more

Never had a thing I didn't just love from this bakery! They are my go to, love them! My favorites are the petite fours, the seven layers and pinole cookies! read more

Great gourmet cookies, lovely shop with nice staff. They will deliver and ship for you. The assortment is amazing and every one delicious. I think by this time I've tasted almost every kind. Maybe not. I'll keep coming back for more. Nancy G read more

I just love their rainbow cookies. Today, was my teachers birthday and I decided to get her some cookie instead of a cake. I got her the rainbow cookies, dulce de leche linzer, red velvet whoppie among other cookies and let me tell you everything so far is super delicious and affordable. Highly recommend it. read more

W W I decided to have a milkshake for lunch, ending the school year with some sweetness. Cookie jar is affiliated with the very popular Cake Chef bakery. Cookie jar has a few locations on Staten Island, the Forest Avenue bakery has an assortment of chocolate covered pretzels, graham crackers and other sweet delights. As well as an assortment of cookie trays, or can be purchased by the pound. Don't forget the collection of cookie jars available to purchase with or without cookies. Grab a couple of famous rainbow cookies, cupcakes and other cookie varieties for your next gathering or family function! Staten Island may have a lot of bakeries to choose from, but the Cookie Jar and Cake chef have the most desirable selection of baked goods. And do not forget to wash it down with a coffee drink or a milk shake! Frozen hot chocolate, frozen cappuccino and milk shakes are blended with a cupcake inside read more

The Cookie Jar - Cookie jars - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

The cookies are a delight and they cookie jars are to die for! The two locations are just fabulous in Staten Island!!