The Holtermann's Bakery has been around forever and rightfully so! Jill, the owner is one of the friendliest people that I have ever met on Staten Island! She's got a great laugh and her pies and cakes are made fresh all the time! Go in there on the weekends and you'll find the freshest donuts and pasties made that day! Even if you go in for a homemade box of cookies, you'll be delighted with the service and old-school charm! ‍ read more

They delivered to my home in the 50's. I recently had their brides cake. It was dry small and hardly iced . The taste was not nearly the same as it once was. I only hope that they once again put quality over profit. They have become i fear an average bakery. read more

My last visit there was to pick up jelly donuts for Chanukah. They were far below my expectations in every way! Hardly any filling; very dry donut. If DD can put out a better donut than Holtermanns, I see no reason to go back read more

Never enough onion rolls...... All the bake goods are great. Going there over 45 years. They must be great.... read more

Amazing cookies and cakes. The staff is so patient and sweet. drive from NJ for the best desserts read more

I just moved to SI and discovered this bakery. Everyone is friendly and everyone I go there, there is some new addition to their inventory. What I've had here so far is delicious. Very clean and nice staff read more

Holtermann's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Huge selection, family owned team very helpful and everything is always delicious, Great prices, have to try the pickles read more

There's some hype surrounding this bakery so we figured we'd check it out. Got some french bread, lemon flip, croissant a donut and coffee. The French bread is absolutely delicious. Crispy crust and airy on the inside. My lemon flip was good also, not overly sweet. My husband enjoyed his donut and felt like the croissant was average. He enjoyed his coffee also. A line forms quick here but staff were quick and friendly. Wouldn't make a special trip again, but would come back if we're in the area. read more

Holtermann's Bakery - a grocery store - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Been craving to try your product ever since that good ball Whoopi deal....she a mess. Friend shipped me some dougnuts...wish lived close! Delicious....keep it up! read more

Made my 75th birthday cup cakes for my guest. Everyone loved them. I am a big fan. I stopped by recently . Love the walnut ring.

It's hit or miss with their products. We've had some good stuff from them. But we picked up an already-made cake today, and it was very stale. My sister told me that she experienced stale products from them before. read more

They have very good cakes and pies and their melt away is the best on Staten Island.

Delicious baked goods enjoy all of it friendly service and nice store much to choose from

Wry nice staff. The cheese cake was delicious. I would definitely purchase again. It was a cream cheese cake.

Always fresh. Always delicious. Great service. Have been going to Holterman's for years and will continue to go weekly!

I love this bakery. Smells so wonderful when you walk in the door. I want one of everything. Everything made with old world charm.

Wow as remembered. When I was younger the Holtermann's truck would come down our block and have the cupcakes, crumb cakes & awesome pastries. Went Sunday morning ended up getting all the usual favorites plus the famous Charolette Russe. Everyone was ultra kind and very knowledgeable on all their baked goods. Cupcakes were as remembered, raspberry danish was a hit as was the coffee crumb cake. Oh and their sourdough bread is excellent!! read more

Holtermann's bakery is a Staten Island legacy! If I had a dollar for every time my mother speaks about the fresh bread delivered weekly- I would have a lot of dough ! Stopped in for some Super Bowl Sunday goodies to share with my friends. The display case was filled with donuts, pastries and chocolate covered anything !! Among the baked goods was a football shaped moose cake and cute cupcakes football decorations on top. I also found hot chocolate bombs and some Valentine's Day sweats for your sweetheart ! Don't forget the bread- I had to grab some thinly sliced Viking bread- a delicious old school recipe of hearty cracked wheat and other whole grains, perfect for toast! L read more

See all

They only allow 4 customers in the store at once due to COVID so be warned there may be a bit of a wait. Staff seemed a bit frazzled but were still helpful and willing to offer recommendations. Baked goods were all around pretty solid. Had the jelly donuts, apple pie, and strawberry cupcakes. Honestly I think my favorite part was less the baked goods themselves and more the frosting/jelly haha (I'm pretty picky when it comes to frosting but the frosting here was really light and smooth). read more

Holtermann's Bakery - Strawberry cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

I have passed by this bakery so many times and wanted to give them a try. They have a many pastry options it was truly hard to decide. I got chocolate cupcakes and they were so delicious and fresh. I also bought a vanilla sponge with chocolate icing for a gathering and can't wait to try it. I will for sure return for more items. The space is not too big but everything is baked in-house. read more

See all

This was my first time ordering from this place, as it was recommended by a friend. I have only tried their cupcake, basic vanilla with butter créeme, typical and nothing out of this world. The cupcakes were not dry and the frosting was perfectly swirled. The customer service is outstanding. I asked them to insert the cupcakes in doomes and cupcake holders a day before picking them up, and they didn't object. I dropped them off and done. Can't wait to try actual stuff from bakery, like their chocolate chip tea biscuit. read more

Holtermann's Bakery - Cupcakes - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

This is a family owned bakery in Staten Island. Do you want a place with amazing cakes, cookies, and other pastries? Then come right in The Crumb Cakes are to die for! So flavorful read more

Love their walnut and danish rings! My daughter can't get enough of their cupcakes. Staple here in Staten Islands

Excellent Everything is made fresh .The service is amazing The staff is so nice they go above an beyond to help you . read more

Hotlermans has been around for eons but I never new this was a anything but an old abandoned bakery. I don't recall ever seeing a sign that says Holtermann's or Open. My family asked me to pick up a Kringle for Christmas. Apparently not only are they still in business but famous for their Kringle. I preordered it the day before and picked it up Christmas Eve. It clearly has a quiet following since it was packed yet I'd never heard of it. I also tried a Strufala, which are so beloved to Staten Island Italians I figured it must be great. Blek blah uck, not my thing. I was told by the person we gave the Kringle to that is was great. So I'd stick to what they are famous for. It's a very small but has ample hours. They were also very pleasant. I would definitely recommend Hotlermanns read more

Holtermann's Bakery - Never tried Struffalo - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

I have always loved this place, I used to buy their bagels and bread every week. Bought a loaf of raisin bread yesterday that I brought home and found green mold on, only after I started eating. Disgusting. read more

My favorite here is the Charlotte russe (: love the history behind it. Best place to go if you're ever in the area. My aunt lives here so it's always a tradition to get this treat. read more

This bakery is one of the best bakeries i've ever gone to. They have almost every single classic bakery item you have ever heard of and some surprising, unique options alongside them. Aside from their awesome seasonal items, they also have a Charlotte Russe that is considered a staple there. I have never heard of this item until i visited Holtermanns bakery and it is one of the tastiest things they have. They also have really great cheese danishes! :) read more

I went today on Sunday and had the Blueberry Muffin Very yummy I will return again and again and again read more

Not sure what I was thinking with my previous review but I visited this place recently and was quite pleased. I went ahead and had the jelly donut and a fudge brownie and both tasted great. Freshness wasn't an issue and the service here is great. There is a family vibe here that's been going on for a long time now. The prices are good too! I look forward to trying this place out again! read more

I've been going to Holtermans for years for their sugar free cookies for my father and for their charolette russes. They are my absolute favorite dessert!! read more

Long time family owned bakery with it's own products. I come here for the bread and the sweets, my favorite being the Cheese Horn cake, made with a delicious baker's cheese. A lot of Bavarian influenced pastries available here that are not as common as Italian pastries on Staten Island. I love how their products are not that sweet, from their cookies to their muffins, to their cakes and tarts. They are not overpowered with sugar. A lot of the products are made with simple brown sugar and dextrose and not all their products are laden with syrups or artificial flavors. And did I mention their bread? Their Italian bread is very good, not too rubbery, and nice and light and airy. read more

My favorite bakery on Staten Island, I've been going since I was a little girl. Items that I must get every time I go are: blueberry flips, a jelly donut, and a charlotte russe. If you haven't heard of a charlotte russe, this is the only place you should try one from--and the only place within a 100 miles that makes them read more

Love this bakery !! Everything we've bought and tried were amazing ! The prices are great The cakes are fresh The flips (mini apple and pineapple pies are incredible. The staff is very friendly all the time Which that in itself is a rarity !! Thank you Holtermann's you outshine all other bakeries on Staten Island read more

I've lived on Staten Island for several decades and never really paid any attention to this place. I drive by it several times and on a whim decided to stop in (you know, YOLO and all that). The bakery is located on an enormous plot of land which led me to believe the inside would be just as sprawling. Uh, no. The inside of the bakery is like walking into a dive bar. Small, damp, poorly lit. I think my bedroom is larger than the storefront of this bakery. I did appreciate the friendly welcome from the ladies behind the counter as I perused the sweet-smelling delicacies somewhat haphazardly laid out before me. Their selection leaves a lot to be desired with one-two-three varieties of bread. I chuckled as to the poor selection of sweets and other "baked goods" - I ordered a chocolate and cinnamon twist and left. On my ride home, I decided to try the chocolate twist and I'm sorry I did, it was gross. Too sweet and the chocolate was, well, not chocolate. The cinnamon twist I had later with a cup of tea was the only reason why this review is 3/5 and not 1/5. It was pure heaven! read more

Holtermann's Bakery - Dessert case - Bakeries Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Saw this place from the road and had a feeling it would be good. I was right. Imagine what the original Entenmann's might have looked like in the 1960s. Cute sales girls too (Staten Island is closer to Jersey Shore than NYC). I couldn't leave without buying a box of raisin sugar buns and a mini crumb cake. The sugar buns were excellent - soft and moist, flavorful, good amount of raisins. Crumb cake was good, but not spectacular. I live in Manhattan, so not sure when I'll be back, but I'll try. read more

See all

Stop by this lovely family run bakery again. I swear every time I came out of this place, it injects some positive energy to my day. The ladies behind the counter were so sweet to me and my little trouble maker daughter. I later found out they are probably the owners (daughter and mother). We got a box of classic chocolate chips Cookie, two donuts and a loaf of raisin bread. Everything taste like homemade and in my opinion the way it should me. That means u better eat them while they are fresh, cause they will grt moldy or harden if not. These stores are the once that my family will support and can trust. Hopefully they will continue their business for another 100 plus years read more

Donuts are fresh and tasty and most cakes however bagels corn Toasties tea biscuits and cupcakes were stale third time I experienced this will never buy those items again from Holtermann's buyer beware read more

The worst f***** cake. I bought a cake for my wife for Mother's Day. Never again. It was super dry and the frosting was hard. I normally never go to bakeries but this is the time you need to step it up and put your best foot forward. My wife told me to go to Sal's Bakery. Since I live near this one I said why not. OMG WHAT A MISTAKE. MY KIDS HATED IT MY WIFE DIDN'T GO NEAR IT. THE CAKE WENT RIGHT INTO THE GARBAGE. Totally disappointed. NEVER AGAIN. read more

I wish I could give this place more stars. Everything and I mean everything is delicious and deceptively so. The items all look rather ordinary but when you taste them you will be amazed. Must be the over one hundred year old Starter that they use. The best jelly and Boston cream droughts anywhere and I have had them many places but that's just a drop in the bucket of goodies offered. The price is so cheap. It's crazy. The only place I can recommend to cross the bridge into Staten Island as a foodie destination. read more