Stopped by The Bagelry in OTR on my way out of town the other morning & am so glad I did! This is the best bagel sandwich I've had in the city so far! The setup here is efficient and primed for them to crank out delicious bagels for everyone! I hadn't had a bagel sandwich with ketchup before, but the Skillet is a game changer!! If you're a fan of a traditional "skillet" at breakfast joints; this is a bagel sandwich you will LOVE!! The Asiago Cheddar Bagel is packed with cheddar flavor & is toasted to perfection. If you're thinking of getting the Smoked Turkey Bagel Sandwich, I highly recommend adding the bacon to make it a read more

See all

We stopped here on our way home from the Reds game for a quick breakfast before hitting the road, and it was the perfect choice. There isn't much seating--it's definitely more of a grab-and-go spot, and we ended up eating our bagels on the road. But honestly? The bagels are so good, you won't mind one bit. As a vegan, I really appreciate when a bagel shop offers more than just plain options, and their Vegan Herb Cream Cheese absolutely delivered. I ordered an everything bagel, double toasted, with the vegan herb cream cheese, and it was incredible. My non-vegan husband had the cinnamon raisin bagel with strawberry cream cheese and loved it. Whether you're looking for a quick breakfast or just craving an exceptional bagel, this place is absolutely worth the stop. We'll definitely be back! read more

The bagels were quite good! I had two. The Asiago and an everything bagel both toasted. The everything had turkey and lettuce. After seeing the pictures on here and google I was hoping for a bit more filling. They both tasted great so not too big of a letdown. The jalapeño cream cheese was a winner for me. They also were fully staffed which kept the line moving. There is no place to sit. They have a stand and dine counter that goes along the windows. Overall a decent place for breakfast bagels. I would gladly come back. read more

See all

Stopped by The Bagelry in OTR for a Saturday morning breakfast and now I get why this place stays busy. I ordered the NYC Lox on an everything bagel and it was chef's kiss. Honestly felt like I was back in New York. Everything was fresh, balanced, and just done right. I also grabbed an iced cold brew and it was exactly what I needed to start the morning. No ambiance, It's definitely more of a grab-and-go kind of spot, but they do have a standing bar if you want to stay and eat without heading back to your car. Nice option if you've got a few minutes. The staff were hustling the whole time, keeping up with both in-person and online orders, which was impressive to watch. Parking is pretty manageable with paid street parking and nearby public lots. If you're in OTR and want a solid breakfast bagel, this place is worth the stop. read more

The Bagelry - Side view of NYC Lox - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

My sister and I stopped in here on Monday before our drive back to Indy. It was so nice to have a warm breakfast after shoveling the snow away from my car and packing everything up from the Airbnb above. The inside is small, with no inside seating options. They have drip coffee, bottled drinks, etc, but no lattes or anything like that. The staff were friendly, the food was made quickly, and it was hot and delicious. The only thing I wish is that each side of the bagel still had a cream cheese smear on it, but otherwise an excellent bagel sandwich. I got a breakfast bagel and my sister got a lunch bagel and she loved hers as well. It was also cool to see that they use Tinker Coffee beans from Indy for their coffee! read more

The Bagelry - The Skillet + BLT - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Forever my favorite bagel Everytime I visit I get it the gecco no egg I think I've had at least 50 hahahha I am loyal and miss it since I live out of state but LOVE IT FOREVERRRR read more

The Bagelry - The GECCO no egg - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I stopped in here to grab a quick lunch while I was downtown. I have been to the Oakley location once and I looovvveee their bagels, so I knew that lunch was going to be the Bagelry today. I got two lox bagels for myself and a friend which was a good price for what I expected. The order was quick and the employees were very friendly. The sandwich itself is delicious! The bagel is nice and toasted but not too hard and falling apart. The salmon is very fresh and perfectly cold to go with the yummy onion, tomato, and capers. The cream cheese is creamy (haha) and not overpowering because I always feel like the lox are the most important part of the bagel. It was super yummy, didn't fall apart and a really great and easy go-to for lunch. read more

Such a cute place. This location is to go style so you order it at the counter. I ordered the pizza bagel with pepperoni and it was so good!! The service was fast and everything was reasonably priced. I had heard good things and it didn't disappoint! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Awesome bagels, and friendly staff. Definitely going back next time I'm in Cincinnati.

If you're looking for a great bagel, this is a good spot. It's very crowded on the weekend but they've got a full staff that is churning out bagels really quickly so you don't have to wait too long. Even if you had to wait a little longer, it's probably worth it. Tried an egg sandwich, classic bagel with cream cheese, and a lox bagel. All met expectations and were delicious. More expensive than a chain for sandwiches, it infinitely better. It's small and a bit cramped, so recommend you take your food to go. read more

One of my favorite spots to grab a bagel in the morning after a night out. They always have lots of staff members working. I will say if you go at a busy time and don't order ahead it can be a little of a wait but not too bad. My bagel breakfast sandwich always hits and I can tell the bagels are made fresh daily. read more

Best bagel sandwich I have had. Great bagels, coffee was OK. Service is great, considering the volume of people they were serving, the wait time was reasonable. This is a go to place for bagels. read more

Fan for life. Great food. Amazing service. Dynamite staff. Please open Thursday-Sat nights. read more

The Bagelry - PIZZA bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Get this place damn near every morning it's very good and amazing food quality. Would recommend to anyone that needs a good breakfast

If an outstanding Bagel or breakfast sandwich Bagel that is inline with a Brooklyn, New York in OTR. Great and efficient service with a city a great feel to it. read more

If you want something quick this is the place to go. They have decent options and were priced well. The staff was friendly and the food was done quick. Would definitely return if in the area. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Came Sunday morning around 10am and I thought it would be packed so I ordered ahead but maybe people were still sleeping and this place gets busier towards 11? I was a little sad I ordered ahead because even though my order was correct, it definitely doesn't hit the same as ordering it fresh in line. I enjoyed the wide variety of bagel sandwich options and that you can design your own egg or regular bagel sandwich. I do think the bagel is a little on the hard side and not as squishy as I had hoped but still cool the bagels are made fresh. read more

The Bagelry - Inside - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

This is a great place. It was really busy. People coming & going the whole time we were waiting on our bagels. When you walk in you go to the left to order. Then wait on the right side or for picking up to go orders. I got the BLT no mayonnaise on an Asiago Bagel & added the onion & chive cream cheese. The bacon was cooked perfectly & I loved the flavor of the cream cheese. My husband got the sausage egg & cheese on an everything bagel. He really enjoyed his too. We will definitely go back sometime when in town. They had Really Great prices too. I will note there isn't a restroom. Just a heads up. read more

The Bagelry - BLT no Mayo on Asiago bagel with onion & chive cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

This is my go to place for pre-work breakfast. I love the avocado toast on a Rosemary bagel! Don't order this ahead, it's much better if you just walk in and grab it. Honestly though? Everything is great here, and the service is fast, efficient, and friendly. Go crazy on the carbs and then walk them off while checking out the other amazing restaurants in the area! read more

This is such a cute bagel spot! The people working were so happy and nice. Bagels were delicious and came out very fast. I highly recommend. One thing I will mention is that there is no seating. I cant wait to go back and try the other sandwiches. read more

The Bagelry - Lox - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Loved the ability to order online. Only took about 10 minutes and everything was ready when we arrived. Made fresh, hot when we arrived and great flavor. The coffee was also really nice. This is a great place for a quick breakfast. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

As a native New Yorker. Here in Cincinnati I am always on the hunt for a real bagel. Not just any bagel but a bagel with lox and all of the other items they go with it. Baby when I tell you I found that at the Bagelry, I mean that. The lox sandwich was EVERYTHING! Can't wait to try their other offerings, read more

See all

Fun Indy bagel shop in OTR....bagels are delicious with great crust and chewy inside. I tired a local favorite Goetta for the first time, not sure what to expect. It was an interesting meat grain mixture with nice flavor and texture . The fact that they source their coffee from tinker in Indianapolis is a plus. Being that it is in OTR parking isn't the easiest but that's to be expected. Will be back. read more

The Bagelry - Everything bagel with sausage - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

Very yummy bagel option! I got a basic egg and cheese bagel sandwich on an asiago bagel. The bagel was crispy and chewy at the time time. A little thin, though. The sandwich was toasted to perfection and satisfying overall. Service was pretty quick even though they were busy. It's a very small place with no outdoor seating so I had to wait outside in the sun with my doggy while my order was prepared and eat it on the go. But would be a good place for takeout! read more

The Bagelry was one of the first local businesses when I moved to Cincy a few years back, and it has consistently been one of my favorite spots to grab breakfast. If you're looking to get a large order of bagels for a weekend morning, or even just a couple of breakfast sandwiches, I definitely recommend ordering ahead the night before. You can do so on their website, and then just bop in and pick up your order at your set time. Of course - you can't always plan when you're going to be hankering for a bagel. I've found that they're extremely busy on Saturday's and Sunday's, so if you're stopping by spontaneously, be prepared to wait. Don't worry though, it's definitely worth it. There's also a big parking lot nearby. I believe it's around $8 to leave your car, but if you're coming for bagels with a buddy, I would recommend having someone drive around the block while the other places the order. My favorite of their bagel offerings is definitely the Rosemary. I've never had such a flavorful bagel from the likes of Einstein's or Chompie's ... and the Rosemary paired with the Strawberry cream cheese is a match made in sweet and salty heaven. read more

See all

Great little bagel shop: it is now go to when we come from out of town and from North Carolina to go to Bengals football games another event in Cincinnati. Nice people great atmosphere they get it right wonderful selection of bagels sandwiches and offerings. We stopped going to another well-known bagel shop at Findlay market that has disappointed multiple times over the last four months and this is our new go to. They're up-and-coming and will probably be a new staple in our plans whenever we are in Cincinnati we highly recommend them. read more

We got the rosemary bagel and everything bagel. They were some of the best bagels I have ever had. The rosemary bagel was a unique choice and did not disappoint. We did opt for extra cream cheese and it was perfect. The place was cute and small, no tables for sitting. And everyone working seemed super nice and happy to be there. Can't wait to go back read more

The Bagelry - Rosemary bagel with onion and chive cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Awesome little spot in a good location with great food! Truly a bagel I havent had before. I loved the outer skin of the bagel. It was the perfect texture. The onion cream cheese was delicious! Service was professional but not necessarily friendly. read more

Best bagels in the city hands down in my opinion. Their bacon, egg, and cheese on Asiago is *chef's kiss* perfection for a hangover meal. Highly recommend ordering online so you can just pop in and grab your bagel to-go. read more

I wasn't looking for bagels, but this shop looked appealing enough that I stopped in and got a half dozen to go. It was into the afternoon, so they had run out of some things, but they are smart enough to at least make sure to have plenty of plain bagels, so I got those and a couple of experiments, including a pumpkin one. The surface of these bagels was nicely boiled. The interior didn't quite have the depth of sour flavor I'd hoped for and surprisingly I wasn't as full after one bagel as I thought I'd be and ended up eating them in pairs. The non-plain flavors I got were fairly subtle in their differentiation from the default. If they had whole wheat or rye or anything really different, they were out of stock on it. Anyway, solid bagels, didn't totally blow me away but would go back. read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

Great bagel spot! We were in town for a wedding and grabbed breakfast bagels the morning of here. They don't have seating so this is a grab and go joint. Service was quick and friendly--we had to wait maybe 5 minutes for our groups bagels. The actual bagels are great! Overall would recommend coming here from some good bagels! read more

The Bagelry - The garden bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

There are very few truly good bagel shops in Cincinnati, which makes sense for Southern Ohio, but in my opinion, The Bagelry is the best. Whenever I'm in the mood for a nice, chill Sunday or Saturday, I get their loxs bagel. My fiancé has tasted every other bagel on the menu and enjoys them all thoroughly. The Bagelry is one of our go-to places in Cincinnati. Even with its popularity and the frequent crowds, the staff manages to turn out a great product efficiently. Despite how busy it can get, they consistently deliver high-quality bagels, making it a standout spot in the city. I would suggest ordering online with enough time if you're in a rush, but I do generally appreciate the walk over to get a bagel, waiting on my phone or maybe doing the crossword. So to each their own. read more

This was such yummy spot! Everything was so reasonably priced. I loved their cream cheese! read more

The Bagelry - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

I've been patronizing this business for over a year now and I'm boring because I get the same thing every time. But omg, the avocado bagel is just so good that I'm sure I won't give anything else a chance. Writing this review makes me want to order one now! read more

Perfect to grab a quick Sunday morning breakfast bagel and coffee. No GF options, but they have goetta! read more

The Bagelry - Coffee perfection - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio

See all

One of my family's favorite spots for breakfast and more recently lunch! I highly recommend ordering ahead online to avoid any wait. Everyone loves the Gecko sandwich. It's the perfect amount of all things tasty(and Cincy) in one. read more

So the morning started with a craving for a steak egg and cheese bagel from McDonald's for our cheat day and boy am I glad we didn't settle for that. My wife found this awesome place and we ordered carry out. The bagels were fresh soft and savory, we got our sandwiches made on the Asiago bagels. The GECCO (goetta, egg, cheese, chive, onion.) bagels were out of this world good! They were hot, fresh, and packed with great flavor. The pizza bagel was no different than eating a slice of pizza and was absolutely phenomenal. If it were possible to give more than five stars this place would get it. I'm sure they have a bunch of great options but the two we got today were 10/10 and it's going to be hard not to get them and try other things at our future visits. read more

See all

Great bagels fast service!!! This is one of my favorite local bakeries. If you like everything bagels you won't be disappointed here. i was taken care of by Jess she was very friendly and knowledgeable about the different food that The Bagelry offers read more

This place has the best bagels in all of Cincinnati! They are the perfect combination of soft on the inside and crispy/crunchy on the outside! The strawberry cream cheese is to die for! read more

My friends and I stopped here for lunch and enjoyed the food. There was a decent choice of bagels choices but I expected more choices from a cafe that specializes in bagels. The walk to this cafe was a bit nerve racking because it's not in a very good neighborhood even during the daytime. We had an Asiago bagel, pizza bagel sandwich, and Italian bagel sandwich. Everyone liked there food but we all agreed it wouldn't be a normal visit location due to fear for our safety. read more

The Bagelry - Asiago Cheese Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cincinnati, Ohio