Tucked away in a strip mall off the interstate this place would be easy to miss but our appetites encouraged us to investigate further. Large menu with everything from paninis and sandwiches, salads, pizza, pastas, and fresh sides. Service was quick and friendly. Our food came out quickly. A pleasant surprise at an otherwise unremarkable exit on a road trip. read more

Delicious! Bus trip stopped for lunch and most went to McDonald's. Walked across the parking lot and found fantastic pizza at Tedeschi's! Homemade sauce is super fresh and flavorful. read more

Everything was so delicious and our service was phenomenal !!! We ordered pizza and shared a dish which had a divine atoma and exquisite visual presentation. read more

Cute place to stop that's open later than most places. Waitress was super nice and gave great recommendations stating everything is fresh and mainly done in house which was a huge selling point. Based off previous reviews I got the pizza rolls and the previous reviews and a beef, mushroom and cheese sandwich. Pizza rolls 10/10 would definitely order again The sandwich... eh 3/10. Meat was VERY salty, canned mushrooms. Anywhere that uses canned mushrooms is huge red flag especially after how it was explained everything is fresh and homemade. Definitely open to trying other stuff on the menu but just avoid the beef and mushrooms. read more

See all

Our group enjoyed dinner here with salad, antipasto and beers with our entrees: Eggplant parmigiana, Traditional Stromboli, Chicken Jessica, Veal parmigiana and I had Dr. Rubenstein (Reuben sandwich with fries). Everyone was served a huge hot meal...some took food home... service was user friendly and efficient, thanks. read more

See all

Very clean. Wonderful fast service . Great menu selection. Would definitely stop here again.

We are quasi-locals. Never went here, because it's off the beaten path for us. Happened upon there, because there's virtually nothing up here in the furthest and remotest part of Northeastern PA open on a Monday, so we tried it out, expecting pizza and beer. WHAT a surprise! First of all...the waitress could open a school to teach waitresses. She was the most pleasant and competent waitress...possibly the best this seasoned 60's couple has ever experienced...literally, the best that we have ever had. Throughout the entire evening, we watched her work the tables and peruse the dining room with the utmost efficiency and with a charming personality that cannot be taught. Her name I think was Madison Baker? Got that off the receipt. Next...the food. We went for pizza. We were taken aback by the menu. This is an unassuming "hole in the wall" place in a small shopping center, in a small town. No reason to go there for anything expected to be special. The menu was so much more than would be expected at a "pizza place". Essentially Italian, but varied. Three homemade soups. Alfredo. Marinara. Seafood. Steaks. Ridiculous. We had Linguine and clam sauce, and fettuccine Alfredo. It was exceptional. And Stella on draft(with several others). Seriously. That's unexpected. Clean. Clean. Place. Bathrooms basic and clean. No smell, other than antiseptic. And the bill was more than reasonable. No price gouging here! So...GO THERE AND LEAVE A WORTHY TIP! They are working hard and doing what every American should do...work hard, be pleasant, and be your best. So proud to leave this review. read more

Food is good when they make as asked other than that the BOSS OR OWNER IS VERY RUDE THE FOOD WAS NOT CORRECTLY MADE AND WE NEVER CHECKED IT Before leaving so when we got home to eat it, it was made incorrect and they said they would make it up to us and so we ordered something the next time and it was supposed to be taken care of and I guess they wrote it down or something and they would you know not make us pay for it next time when we went in they told my husband to just get out. He wasn't welcome back in there Because he made the statement that our food was wrong and they were supposed to fix it the next time that we have a charge well here we go you know we went to get our food the next time and we told him about it that's why they he said that we were not. He's not allowed back in there not even it was our fault that the food was made wrong. What is our fault that we were complaining that we paid whatever it was almost $30 And our food was not right I mean it was a while ago but still they never made it right we went to pick up our new order after placing it and they decided they weren't gonna cook it when we got there we wasted our gas our time for them to tell us that and we never got our food. That was very rude very rude. I would never say that it's OK to do anything like that. It's not fair to a customer that you take your money don't give them the correct item or even try to fix it and then be rude about it. OK sorry that's just where I stand if he does it to us then they're gonna do it to somebody else so that's not right it should be stopped. read more

Get the pepperoni rolls! Made with fried wonton wrappers like an eggroll rather than bread like a West Virginia pepperoni roll, but hot, crispy and delicious! Marinara sauce is terrific, too. My favorite sandwich is the chicken pesto panini. Pizzas are good and the pastas all look great. Never had a pasta, but I will definitely try the lasagna and Sausage & Peppers on future visits. read more

(+/-) Ambiance: petite fashion with open view kitchen ( for those who trust their eyes over front door grades); (+) Service: courteous personnel, attentive service (+/-) Food: (pizza used to be exceptional, other dishes/especially specials are on point for gourmet taste. (-)Time: read more

Found this spot right over the PA line while working yesterday. A co-worker and our customer both spoke highly of it, so it had to be tried! Pretty unassuming location in a plaza, tucked in amongst other stores and services, but worth keeping your eyes peeled! When you enter you can see the pizza warmer display built up and into the front main service wrap, and greeted promptly by staff! Definitely had a diner feel in my opinion, but a decent charm to the interior based on color and material choices. A pretty packed in house for around 12:30 on a Tuesday, which is always a good sign IMO. Plentiful pizza offerings, from standards, to Alfredo, and even mashed potato (Old fashioned mashed potatoes and creamy butter covered with a blend of four cheeses, ham and bacon)! Lots of sandwich and wrap options, calzones, Stromboli, pasta dishes too! I took a swing at their Italian wedding soup ( my jam) and it was flavorful and packed full of the good stuff! Shredded chunks of chicken, pastina, the little meatballs, vegetables, so good! For my main course I got the chicken parm-wich - a classic chicken parm cutlet with cheese and sauce and a decent quality roll, served with fries. Love that everything is made in house, all meats and manner of foods prepped daily! If you're in Hallstead, hit it up! read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Chicken Parm-wich - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

See all

Excellent! I normally do not leave reviews. I first had a salad, with Italian dressing and blue cheese crumbles. Knots were perfect. Had a veal dish with pasta. All 5 star! read more

Tedeschi's never disappoints. Relaxed atmosphere with courteous, attentive service. The food is first-rate and always prepared and presented in an appealing and delicious manner. Highly recommended! read more

Always good, pizza and pepperoni rolls are our favorites. Been coming back for over 10 years from Central MA to camp in Windsor, NY.

I was kind of "meh" about this place at first, but the more I tried, the more I loved. The Italian wedding soup is REALLY good. Surprisingly good. Not over spiced, well balanced, and with several meats and veggies. A super pleasant soup. I'm also pretty fond of the ravioli. It's not an overlarge amount, which I like, but the pillows are stuffed with good cheese. The pizza is also really good. The crust is crispy without being a chore, there's plenty of sauce and just the right amount of cheese. My kiddos like it and I just had my first piece today (I ate two and a half), and it's definitely worth the time and money. Lastly, dessert. My sons love the tuxedo bombs. They're legit tasty, but a smidge too rich for me. The cannoli is right up my alley though, without being too sweet. This is a restaurant worth your time. The staff is pleasant, they're extremely tolerant of children, and the food is just... comfortable. read more

I love this place yeah I wouldn't recommend this place. The chicken wings are not that good the pizza is but not the chicken wings.

I am totally blown away with that Philly Cheese steak sandwich!! I think Philly cant make it that good!! Seriously!.. Thank you for that, and I thank you for your friendly staff who always makes the customer feel like your the most important person . Philly is in big trouble, it is now the TEDESCHI CHEESE STEAK in my mind for now on, you own this one . DELICIOUS!! and goes so well with a cold one. See you soon!! read more

Food was very good, and they were able to accommodate our very large group on short notice. The menu has a wide range of Italian American choices including pizza. Portions were generous. I had veal parm, my "standard" Italian test dish and it was very good. The spaghetti was not over cooked, which I liked. My 14 year old cousin got a large salad that she finished, having very much enjoyed it. Another reviewer commented on the garlic knots which were excellent, but bring a roll of breath mints for everyone in your party. read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

See all

The smash burger was to die for, white pizza had a nice crust just the way you want it and the soups were great!

We love stopping here when we drive cross country. It's the last stop before heading into crazy New York and has a good station next door for fueling up. I was very thankful this last time through to see they didn't succumb to Covid closures. We'll be back again and again! read more

Ordered pizza here again. Got what I didn't want again. I specifically asked for NO black olives. They totally ruin my pizza. I asked again. Please no black olives. Still got black olives. Pick them off you say.... they were under the cheese. Melted in. Done ordering pizza from this place. read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Lots of unwanted black olives - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

Stopped here on our way to Syracuse. After 8 hours of driving this delicious dinner was heaven. I had the gnocchi and it's one of the best I've tasted and I've had gnocchi in different countries. My husband had the Alfredo and it was delicious. Complete with garlic knots. Great price, delicious high quality food!! Great service. Highly recommend! Sorry I took the picture halfway through my meal. read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

Been going here since I was really little. The food and pizza has always been amazing. I highly reccomend!!!

Wait staff is pleasant. I wish the pasta was whole wheat / optional? They don't serve pickles because the owner doesn't like them??? WHA? But I love Tedeschi's, the price is decent, the staff is nice.... I just wish the big TVs weren't there... the guys always stare at the TVs now, instead of in my eyes. The aura of the last set up before the flood was classier than the current, but none the less I like it. read more

Ordered some pepperoni rolls and two slices of pizza, it was three small pepperoni rolls that were made with egg roll wrapping , the sign said Italian cruise so I figured the rolls would be made with dough not egg roll crust. Highly unsatisfied and the price was 16 dollars and change for all of this . Everything was mediocre. Not going back again read more

Great food! Lots of choices. My Husband and one of the smash sandwiches. I had the sausage parmigiana platter.

Our favorite restaurant in the area. The beer battered fries and burgers are perfection with homemade buns. All the italian dishes are fantastic as well. Highly recommend if your in the area! read more

A surprising find in Hallstead; considering there is no sign out front. The food here is great, and very high quality. Service is hit or miss as far as speed, but everyone is very nice. Would definitely come back. read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Chicken pesto panini - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

See all

This is why I love Yelp! Never would have even seen this place. Great food. Real French Onion Soup! Great Garlic Knots. House Dressing is world class. Really World Class! Steak was like butter! Chicken Jessica top notch and the Rigatoni with Spicy Sausage was straight out of Brooklyn! What else can I say!? read more

See all

I was told 5-10 minutes for two sandwiches Togo showed up in 20 and had to wait 15 more minutes for two sandwiches. 35 minutes for two sandwiches is outrageous I can't even tell you how they taste because I'm late for work and won't be able to eat them for another 4 hours. No offer of compensation, a soda or something. I asked before I ordered because I knew time was tight. I'll never make that mistake again, know your business I cooked for 20 years it's not rocket science. read more

Ordered a large takeout buffalo chicken pizza. It is advertised as "roasted chicken covered in buffalo wing sauce and blue cheese". There were exactly 22 pieces of cardboard-like slivers of chicken on the pizza. And as far as the blue cheese, it was non-existent. And, yes, I experienced (much) better pizza just up the road in Montrose. I went here because it is closer to our home. Pump n Pantry pizza would have been better. To be fair, we have eaten here often, but usually dinners which are average, not spectacular. Their pesto chicken panini is to die for. read more

And that friends, was the best thing I ever ate. I'm taking about the pepperoni rolls at this place. You guys, I'm not kidding.. They are fantastic. It was our first time here. Place has a bit of an identity crisis - beer store, take out, sit down Italian restaurant.. But with food that good, it can identify itself however it would like. After a couple fantastic appetizers I moved on to the classic smash. It seemed like a quality snack, but I have to be honest I was already stuffed. I'll be back for those pepperoni rolls and you should be too. read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Pepperoni rolls, absolutely fantastic - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

See all

This restaurant has a very pleasant atmosphere absolutely delicious food. Everything is handmade on the premises. The Staff is extremely professional and there's a Pleasant sophistication about the restaurant. read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

See all

Had the Philly Cheesesteak. Steak and cheese was fire and the ratio worked well. Cooked well and good taste. Was a bit disappointed with the bun. Was hoping for a nice long sub bun but unfortunately it was on a regular circular bun. This was the only downside to the sandwich. Would recommend if you are in the area. read more

Flood of '06 survivors, the Tedeschi Family has outdone itself on the fantastic renovations and improved staff of Tedeschi's for the Hallstead/Great Bend area. Note that the menu prices are noticably higher, but it's still worth a drive from the triple cities area and a favorite dining spot for locals, and isn't that the real sign of success? read more

First time customer Service was good food was not so good. Steak and cheese roll was not baked done. French fries had enough salt on them to kill a horse. Should have went to McDonald's at least I know what to expect. read more

Tedeschi's Italian Eatery - Steak and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Hallstead, Pennsylvania

My brother recommended this. I'm Italian and I'm very picky when it comes to Italian food. My husband had the chicken parm and I had the gnocchi. Both were delicious. I got a side salad with mine. It was fresh, they used spring mix, not just soggy iceberg like some places. I mixed ranch, Italian and balsamic vinaigrette, all of which are home made. My husband had the chicken corn chowder, which he loved and said was very hearty, and he doesn't usually order soup. The sauce is nice and thick, no chunks of uncooked veggies and the acid level was spot on. Will definitely be back. read more

I regularly make the drive from Syracuse NY just for the garlic knots. The food is unbelievably good. You'd never guess from the unassuming exterior that you are in for some truly amazing food - ranging from Pizza to serious Italian cooking. Great service, friendly staff, and did I mention the garlic knots? read more

We stopped for lunch on our way back home. The restaurant was nice inside, we were greeted promptly, got our order in and the food came out in good time. I had the Balboa sandwich with beer batter fries and my wife had the eggplant parm sandwich with shoestring fries. Everything came out hot, my wife enjoyed her sandwich. The only complaint I had with mine was the sandwich was dry, and their was just a little to much roll. The beer batter fries I enjoyed. Overall summary prices were good, the food was good and service was good. read more

I've known about this place forever. I've had their food a few times as a kid but I've had it a lot more over the last year since this has been a new favorite spot to go when my family takes our grandmother out to dinner. The prices are pretty fair, and the restaurant itself is nice but not too fancy, you can dress up a little or dress casual, your call. They start off the meal by bringing out their famous garlic knots, which are great. They aren't over the top garlicy, and I like that, and they're also not drenched in butter or oil, they have a very clean texture with a nice flavor. The salads are ok, nothing out of the ordinary. I've tried the fried gnocchi appetizer and it was pretty good, they just kinda come out tasting like bread but they toss them in seasoned oil and give you tomato sauce to dip them in. In all honesty, while they are good, if you're already eating garlic knots then these aren't really needed in the meal. I've had 3 chicken entrees here. The chicken parm was decent, the spaghetti sauce on it is a little sweet and works well with the dish. The amaretto chicken was awesome, I loved it. It was a creamy sauce with the sweetness of almond extract added to it and there were also walnuts in the dish. The chicken was breaded nicely and it was very enjoyable. It's a tough call as to which I liked better, this or the chicken belize. the chicken belieze is part of their scorcher menu. It's pretty much fettuccine alfredo with sliced habanero mixed into the sauce with a chicken cutlet on top, and while it sounds simple, the flavor was great. I'm not too much of a pepperhead, but this was right at the boarder of the amount of heat I could handle, I was fighting it a little bit, but it was a welcomed fight. This place seems to be known for their pizza, and while it's pretty solid I don't feel that the sauce they use works well for pizza. the crust and cheese were very good, but the seasoning in the sauce seemed to work better for spaghetti than it does for pizza. The wings I got with it were good but nothing I haven't had before. They were just medium buffalo, so I'd like to try some of their more unique flavors. So far I've never had bad service. Usually we are in and out within an hour. One time I think one of the servers was a little slow, but when I was here on mother's day the server we had was great. I didn't catch her name but she seemed to be in her early 20's, she was brunette and she was efficient and friendly, she did a great job, she kept up with the drink refills very well for our large party. Since I'm from Binghamton, this is a little out of the way for me, so each visit is kind of a special occasion, and to me it's worth it, I really like it here. 4.5 out of 5 stars read more