We had a lovely dinner here on New Year's Eve. We go out with our son and his girlfriend every New Year's Eve and she has never been to the Oaks so we decided we needed to go here for our dinner. She loved the experience and no one was disappointed. The wait staff was ready to greet us and offer wonderful service. Checking in to make sure our food was what we expected etc. What I really loved was that we didn't feel rushed or that everyone was seated close together. The restaurant was calm and not loud at all! This restaurant is like stepping back in time and I wouldn't change that. The customers appreciate the pictures on the walls and the decorating of the times. read more

Absolutely phenomenal!!! This is the top Italian restaurant in the Binghamton/Endicott area. Ithaca greens are a must! Marsala is my favorite. read more

Amazing food and experience. You must book well in advance. Will definitely come here again!

The best Italian food west of NYC in the southern tier! Phenomenal service, amazing food, and a great staff, and the ambience was unbelievable!! I'm a Brooklyn girl by way of Long Island, who hasn't had a real good Italian meal since I left there six years ago! Sooo happy, I forgot to take pics, but they'd be the same as those in YELP! read more

The food and service is outstanding. The food is consistently great from week to week. Best Italian food in Broome County

This is a solid and hidden treasure in the Southern Tier of NYS. Always vg food in an old style 1900's Tavern setting. I could go on and on but just go and enjoy this classic, comfortable and reasonably priced Italian/American gem! read more

Best Italian restaurant in Broome County, no contest. I know there are those that prefer Cortese or Little Venice, but the meals prepared at Oaks Inn show skills not displayed at the others. They are old school with specific days open and hours. No online presence and serving a dedicated and loyal customer base, get a reservation and try. read more

Was visiting Binghamton with the hubby this week and we had dinner at oaks inn. We followed previous reviews and was sure to make a reservation. They were busy, so glad we did. I loved my meal with the vodka sauce. It was good in the restaurant and my leftovers the next day tasted even better. The Marsala chicken was just okay per my husband. The clams casino was great. I could taste all the flavors. The greens were good too, you get a large portion and they were filling. I will say it did take a while for our food to come out but I think it's because things are made to order and fresh. I would definitely go back. The waiter was nice and made good suggestions as well. read more

See all

Restaurant of your dreams great food great atmosphere great service-- if you want more commercial fare and are looking for discounts go to Olive Garden. Call for reservations this place is popular and the dining room is modestly sized read more

Oaks Inn is always my go to restaurant when I am in town. My mouth waters for the chicken saltimbocca! Hope to be there next week!

All of the staff, hosts and servers are always so kind. I've been here a few times every time I come in to town and it never disappoints. The shrimp scampi is a must-have. It is delicious. This time I got the chicken marsala and it was great. I love that there was bell peppers in the dish I had never had it like that before. The drinks are always good and the prices are even better. What a reasonable priced spot for such amazing Italian food. I've never had anything bad here and I will continue to go every time I'm in town. I do wish the lighting was a little different / dimmer or they did something more to add to the ambience but it's a Classic spot that can't be changed and that's okay too!! read more

Oaks Inn - Shrimp Scampi - Italian Near Me - Endicott, New York

See all

Food was delicious but the service was terrible- We waited over 2 hours - server got the order wrong / begged for bread / begged for drinks / begged to correct order / server was very arrogant and had no clue what he was doing.. rude and begged for the check. I don't see how you can run a business when you have a hap ( Ryan ) being the biggest disaster in the fro t of the house. Really should consider getting fresh blood that has the business as a priority read more

We return to Endicott several times a year to see family. One of our favorite restaurants for Italian food is Oaks Inn. Yes reservations are usually needed as always busy. Six of us had great meals. Nothing was lacking in quality or portion. green salads, chicken Parm, Meatballs, Lasagna, Gnocchis, lemon chicken, shrimp appetizer and pasta fagioli. Did I mention the generous mixed drink pours. Omg and the prices so reasonable. We had the pleasure of having Lea as our server. They were short staffed but you would not know- she was so attentive, friendly and accommodating ( A+ employee) It was a great evening and we are returning in two days. read more

I was in town for a few days and this place was recommended to me by a close friend who I trust greatly with food recommendations and she did not steer me wrong! This is true old-school Italian restaurant and the food was fabulous in a quiet and inviting, charming environment! Unfortunately they were out of Clam dish I wanted but I ordered the Rainbow Trout and it was amazing--it was cooked perfectly and was a really nice portion (I asked for just a regular olive oil sauce on the fish and they were happy to oblige). We got some nice bread on the table with a a nice dish of olive oil to dip the bread with some spices. I also got a glass of wine with the dish which was delicious. Now this price is so reasonable I was shocked--the glass of wine was only $6 and my fish was $15. My friend got the Eggplant Parm and said it was the best he has ever had. The staff was friendly and inviting and we left with a bill that was only $40 for two of us which was so nice being that restaurants have gotten so expensive these days! Thank you Oaks Inn for a wonderful meal-I will definitely be back! Make sure to make a reservation if you can because it does get full and you must call after 4P as they do not answer the phone before that time. read more

I found the atmosphere the be relaxing and engaging and the food was just marvelous. I had the Veal Francaise with a glass of Chianti and it was everything I had hoped for: cooked well, full of flavor, nothing dried out, and the wine selection was well-chosen. The quality and amount of food were well worth the price and I have wanted to come back ever since. Covid has kept me at bay going anywhere for a while, but I'm sure that the Oak's Inn has maintained their high quality regardless of the pandemic. read more

This is another let down. The food is good, but the place lacks ambiance and character/coziness. It's almost like sitting at someone's house for a holiday with 20 people gathered around tables pushed together stretching from dining room to living room to eat and getting the table by the beeping ( no it beeps )kitchen door and someone clearing tables and spraying some horrible solution on the tables that would gag a horse!! Really!!! We're eating here or trying to. There are so many Italian restaurants that make good food, have some coziness. Nope, one and done. I don't understand all the hype for this, to me, mediocre place. Maybe once upon a time it was great, it died. To each their own. Sorry, just not for me... read more

We now live in Texas. We come back to upstate NY every year to enjoy the scenery and great people and food. Our #1 eatery is the Oaks Inn! Over 30 years of going there once a year. It's always the same quality and the best food ever. Chicken Chablis or Saltimbocca! Amazing!! Top it off with some delicious Italian deserts! The place is amazing. Must have reservations or eat at the bar. read more

Once again at the Oaks post Covid. Still completely amazing. Now the Bartenders are taking your food orders and the service is still spot on. Another 5 stars for you! Lee Ann at the bar is the best! read more

My boyfriend and I like to come in for dinners periodically. The food is always delicious, the bread is great, we even love their wine selection. We were always greeted in a friendly manner, And the staff is always polite and accommodating. The atmosphere is romantic and homey. I highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Had the occasion to have dinner with friends last night. I have lived in Endwell since 2005 and this was the first time that my wife and I had dinner there. What a wonderful surprise was in store for us. The service was excellent. The waitress was super nice and made us feel like family. I had the veal saltemboca, and it was the best I've ever had. The waitress suggested for an appetizer we have the chicken meatballs and they were excellent. My wife had the trout and it was just as good as my veal. I would recommend this restaurant without any Reservations. This restaurant is now on my go to list. read more

Excellent Italian food. Some of the best the area has to offer. Everything on the menu our party tried came out delicious in-spite of a full house. read more

Always fabulous. Staff and food are outstanding, never a bad bite. It's all good always!

This is one of my evening favorites. Always a great meal. Authentic. Delicious. Great environment. Very friendly and family feel.

Took food out but found it to be very average Italian food for all the hype! I was quite surprised. Best item is the "lamb lollipops." The sauce was not that great and the gnocchi's were too large and tough. The lasagne not tasty. The fish though was very good. The hostess was very uncaring and off putting. I am sad about this but I'll have to pass on this restaurant next time we have guests. read more

tutto finisce a tarallucci e vino (it all ends with biscuits and wine) I heard this means everything is going to be ok. I am taking this literally with me favorite (yes, you read that) Italian restaurant. It's not even in my home state. I have to come across the United States to get here. I first came to Endicott New York a few years ago for a work trip and heard this area had great Italian food. Sounds like a challenge right? Well I dug in and began the search by checking Yelp (yep awesome app) and recommendations. I found it, the one, la luna dela pasta. Not sure that translates correct but sounded good. This place is the real deal. Old school pictures, Italian American music, and plain good Italian food. I have tried a number of the special and they all are great. Tonight before this review I am being fueled by homemade spaghetti, sausage, and some vino. It did not disappoint. I was smart tonight (ok might be stretching that one) by skipping the soup and adding one of the last (snap!) of the slices of cheese cake. I got some raspberry sauce on the side. My waitress Natalie was a rock star and provided a great experience. I recommend you to fly to Ny and try this gem in the rough and relax. Remember - tutto finisce a tarallucci e vino. read more

Oaks Inn - Homemade spaghetti. Basic, but great. - Italian Near Me - Endicott, New York

See all

If you like a great Pasta sauce this is one the best I've ever tasted and I like a sweet sauce which this is not, but this was perfect.. Great service and very friendly wait staff and cool retro atmosphere took me back to old school..you won't be disappointed.. . read more

Can't say enough about this place. Great food, service, drinks! A must visit if you are in town!

Food is good however service is terrible from the time you stepping into the door waitresses and a bartender with 0 personality not sense of argency that puts you to sleep. If you have a day and a half to go there. You going to spent an average of 1.5-2 hrs there for sure. The only reason that this place is doing well is because is not other decent restaurants around Kind regards read more

I am proud to be the first person from the Los Angeles, Hollywood California area to review this restaurant on Yelp. It is a gem and worth the drive if you are not close. The food is excellent, the service excellent, and the ambiance very good. It's on the second floor of a non-descript building in a area that looks sketchy. They have their own private parking lot. White table clothes. You can dress up a bit and feel comfortable, but casual is fine. Tip to owner: Dim the lights a bit at dinner time in the dining room, and you will have excellent ambiance. It's so bright that film production would not need lighting if they shot here. This Section For Guys Only: If you want to impress your woman, want to easily build some romance, and not blow the budget too big, take her here. You can't miss. Perfect setting. They also have a nice quaint bar. We talked to folks at 2 tables next to ours and they were major regulars, and knew the menu by heart. We would definitely dine here again. read more

Excellent Italian food. The salad that starts their entrees is generous. I had the Eggplant Parmesan and my husband the Veal Francesca. He has been around the world as a Merchant Mariner and he claimed that this was "the best veal ever". No small praise. The restaurant is on the second floor, up stairs. I am not sure if it is otherwise accessible. There is its own small parking lot, and just across the street is the lot for the George W. Johnson Park (complete with one of the 6 carousels in the area), which is used for parking by patrons in the evenings. We were there on Wednesday about 6pm. Although they asked if we had reservations -- we didn't -- they were able to seat us. We had tried it on a previous trip on a Monday and it was not open. Highly recommend, and suggest making reservations to be certain. You will not be disappointed. read more

See all

Simply the best Italian-American cuisine in the area. The throwback atmosphere is also a plus. They are very old school re reservations (a must to get in), which can be frustrating when trying to reserve a table, but certainly worth the effort. Buon appetito! read more

I've eaten here many times.. I forgot just how good Every last thing is here.. had Utica Greens for appetizer and it was amazing.. veal bianco for dinner and my wife had the rainbow trout. Fresh Battaglini bread on the table and a nice slow pace for a meal, allowing time to enjoy, digest and have good conversation.. white table clothes , fresh linens, great dinner salad, attentive wait staff, nice bar crowd also ... one of my all time favorite restaurants.. can't recommend it enough !!!! read more

went to dinner last night based on a recommendation from my hotel. I have to tell you it's a charming place, great bartender very nice. there was only 1 problem my dinner was awful, two bites in and I was done. it was a chicken dish can't remember that name and I apologize for that!!!! read more

Best chicken parmigiana in Broome County. Can't rate any other dish, I've never wasted a trip on anything else. read more

One of the best restaurants I've had the pleasure to dine in. The food is always fantastic, the service is always welcoming, and the atmosphere is great. If you haven't had the pleasure of having a meal here, make a point to get there. It's a little on the pricey side, but not so much that the average person couldn't afford it, and take my word for it, when you walk out, you won't care what the bill was. read more

Best Italian restaurant in Endicott. Lemon chicken every time...and the atmosphere takes you back in time, in a nostalgic way. Thank you for not changing anything. read more

Went to Oaks Inn while on visit to the town. They were a little short staffed but our waiter was still attentive and cheerful. Tried several items and were not disappointed by any. Broiled Trout was a delight. trout is not very common but was grilled to perfection. Speedy Lamb was easily one of the best lamb I've eaten. Gnocchi is staple and and did not disappoint. Nice wines. read more

Delish! Homemade pastas, the vodka sauce was worthy to bathe in. I had the Chicken Saltimbocca... oh my. Great flavors, great service, great wine list. Happy Happy Happy! read more

Went with my lady friend for a nice dinner a couple of weeks ago and found them closed on a Wednesday night with no sign out or anything. Have called multiple times (always after 6pm) since then and never received an answer. Perhaps they've closed up shop? I don't want to believe this because it is truly delicious. What else are you supposed to think though when a business doesn't answer their phone and is inexplicably not open in the middle of the week for dinner? If they're actually closed for good, then RIP. If not, then frickin' pull it together guys and answer the dang phone! read more

My wife and I went here for Valentine's Day. We try to get Italian every year and this was a place that we heard good things about. The place was a little cramped, but we were seated promptly. Our waitress came by a few minutes later, offered us a wine list and kinda disappeared for a while. Then, when we ordered wine, they didn't have what we ordered and tried to pass off a cheap substitute, which I declined. However, the waitress was very gracious and gladly got us a different bottle. The food was pretty good. We didn't order appetizers, mostly because there was nothing on the appetizer menu that was horribly original or interesting - mostly just clams casino, shrimp cocktail, stuff like that. But we were given bread with a very good dipping oil. I ordered a bone-in ribeye. My wife got veal. Their veal section was very decent. Just about every veal dish you can imagine. Our entrees were perfectly done (I can't stand steaks that are overcooked) and well presented. The portions were definitely large. Overall it was a pretty good meal. Best of all, it was pretty cheap. A good bottle of wine and 2 entrees for under $80. Can't really beat that. I'll go back. read more