Always exceptionally flavorful cakes and pastries. Dense and delicious cakes! Definitely my go to!

The staff were super friendly and helpful. The store is well lit and has lots of options. The price is worth it. One of the most amazing donuts I've ever had. read more

Great selection and friendly service. I have been a customer for years. The seasonal selections are awesome.

I love this place! My mom discovered it and we have been going for years ever since. It has a very homey / vintage like feel to the place. It's very cozy, but has so many yummy options to choose from. Always great customer service! read more

So all things sweet and good you gotta come here! I've been patronizing Taylor's Bakery ever since my oldest daughter's birthday which was in the late 90's and she's a Halloween baby to boo! So now it has come full circle now I went to pick up my granddaughters birthday cake.. it reminded me the days when I would go to pick up her mom's birthday cake! Their cakes are gorgeous and super moist.. and this was completed in 24 hours you can't beat that! It's a little pricey but it's going to be so worth seeing my granddaughter's face.. service there was great everyone was friendly and we had to take advantage of National Donut Day it was buy 6 get 6 free! I really like the Fishers location but I've been to the Allisonville Road location too! So if you're ever in the need for a quick sweet treat Taylor's Bakery is your place! read more

Taylor's Bakery - Sweetheart cake for my sweet heart - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Taylor's is getting sloppy. I noticed it on the rush to service and get me out of the door a few weeks ago, but this may be the last straw for me. Is this a bakery cupcake I bought or did someone bring it from home? Barely frosted- and the frosting is hard read more

Taylor's Bakery - Taylor's bakery- fishers IN - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

2 stars. In a word: disappointing. I was in the mood for a delicious piece of wedding cake, so I popped in a grabbed a cupcake. Then, added on a sugar cookie on a whim. Neither was outstanding. Definitely did not live up to the hype. The cake was moist and had a perfect crumb, but lacked that almond flavor that is expected. The frosting was perfectly smooth and proportional to the cake, but was so sugary it made my teeth ache - literally! The sugar cookie was a nice size and had a good texture. It was right between soft baked and crispy. But lacked flavor. It was really bland. No lemony or vanilla notes were detected. None. It was dough and sugar. Customer service was great. Store was bright with good merchandising. Location is convenient. Parking is ample. I'm deeply saddened to learn that this bakery just doesn't get these two confections correct. But, I'll go back and try something else. I hope I can provide an updated review in the future. read more

Taylor's Bakery - Nice crumb! Good frosting to cake ratio. - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I've always known Taylor's bakery to have great cakes but now I've experienced their donuts! Such a variety of both cake and yeast donuts. Couldn't decide so I got one of both and threw in a cinnamon roll as well. So delicious and great icing to dough ratio. Dangerous to be living so close to such a delicious bakery! Very clean and nice inside. read more

Taylor's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I came in after being told by Kroger that a chocolate cake with white icing "isn't a thing." What? lol Taylor's had a huge selection of cakes of all different kinds, including the supposedly nonexistent chocolate cake with white icing. They also have adorable mini birthday cakes you can get to go! I opted for a single layer cake that was decorated with poinsettias. They offered to write a message on the cake for me and took it back and did it right away. My daughter LOVED her cake and we might have had some for breakfast today as well. Definitely worth paying just a little more (seriously, it's not that much more expensive than a grocery store cake!) for such a great product from a local business. read more

Taylor's Bakery - Online order pickup area - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Great place for a sweet treat. Every time I am near. I always go. Their cupcakes yummy

Taylor's is great for donuts on Saturday morning or cake for a big birthday celebration. They have a great variety of fillings for their cakes. read more

Great local bakery one of the best cakes in town. Several types of cookies and all the gotos for donuts and danish. You will also find popcorn. Carry out or order ahead Taylor's is conveniently located right off 116th in Fishers. Lots of parking,. You can also order ahead. read more

Taylor's Bakery - Turkey cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My son's Spiderman cake was awesome! Will certainly order again in the future. Thank you for making this event a success! read more

Taylor's Bakery - Spiderman cake - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Outstanding bakery products. Highly recommend. Reasonably priced in today's high inflationary market.

They have a pretty large selection of baked goodies and the prices are fair. I only tried donut holes and they were yummy! read more

Taylor's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

This was the third stop on my personal donut challenge. I tried to stop in on Black Friday but it was closed that day :-(. They have various donuts there, it was almost too hard to resist the pecan roll, but I was craving a simple glazed donut along with some donut holes. The donuts are made at the 62nd street location and delivered to fishers store. The parking is ok at this location. The staff at the store is prompt and friendly. I bought my selections and almost started to eat in the car but resisted. I enjoyed the donut, but it wasn't as good as I had remembered. It didn't have that just made experience for me, even though it may have been made that morning. However, after I ate a few donut holes, none of that mattered. They are cake donut holes. The nice thing with them, you can buy a box and the ones you don't eat the first day are just as fresh and tasty the second day!!! read more

See all

Taylor's Bakery cakes have starred at both our children's graduations, birthdays, and all our other events for over 30 years because they're just that good. This is the only place I will purchase a carrot cake because, perfect! Their éclairs are delicious as well. read more

Thank goodness for thoughtful coworkers who bring you a dozen donuts (to share) on your birthday. I sampled a few of the donuts in our box - cinnamon twist, cinnamon roll and red velvet - and they were all really good. And I'm generally not a big donut person. If I find myself in the Fishers area hankering for donuts, I will stop in Taylor's for something sweet! read more

Taylor's Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We stopped by Taylors bakery after my grandmas dentist appointment as she loves sweets. She bought 4 cupcakes and various other sweets. I personally only had a cupcake but it was fantastic.... She was not impressed with her other sweets. read more

Taylor's Bakery - Cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My drive to visit my cousin in Fishers is a straight-shot down 116th Street. I take the single road from Carmel to Fishers with the music blasted, mostly because there isn't anything to see. Well, wasn't, actually. Fishers has blossomed and transformed in a multitude of ways over the last few years- much more than I could have EVER imagined. New restaurants and breweries have sprung up like freshly-bloomed flowers, and places like TopGolf draw the attention of Indy residents from all over town! Taylor's Bakery has been around for quite a while- it's a favorite of many Fishers locals and if you ever visit the bakery, it doesn't take much to guess why. Craft-made chocolates, sweet treats, snacks and desserts line the pastry case and stud the store: you have MORE than enogh to choose from. Wee just picked up a few seasonal goodies on this specific occasion and that was enough too tell me I'll be going back soon. read more

See all

Wow! Taylor's Bakery did an excellent job on our cakes. The cakes were beautiful to look at and yummy to our tummies! The flower theme on the reunion cake was full of happy colors which matched the happy family vibes we were all feeling. The cake was half white half chocolate--- everyone was happy. The next night we needed another cake--- a larger cake to feed 100 people. Taylor's Bakery did not disappoint. Beautiful and yummy! If you have an upcoming event and need a cake go to Taylor's Bakery. The Fishers staff was so helpful and friendly. They always have yummy samples to taste while you shop. They will take good care of you. read more

See all

Quality bakery! We love their baked goods. The first time I went in three years ago was based on the recommendation of a friend who is a great cook. I knew she would point me in the right direction. I have never had a bad or even so so item from Taylors. We've had the baklava, cookies, donuts, cupcakes, tortes, eclair, cream puff. Everything I've ever tried has been great. I usually visit in the afternoon, so it's not crowded and not on a weekend. The staff is friendly, courteous and their prices are in line with other bakeries. I just read a great article about how they have been in business for over 100 years! You don't continue to be successful unless you've got the right recipes and the right customer service. I highly recommend this bakery, for anything you need special orders or everyday regular bakery items! read more

Service was 5 star! Stopped to pick up a plain white cake with white icing. while there also purchased an eclair and cream filled donut. The eclair was DRY, like dust and was bland. The cream filled donut had maybe a tablespoon of filling, also very bland. oh well, not why we came. Was exited for the cake, a bit pricey, almost $40 for a simple two layer cake. Cut it, looked good. Took first bite and was SOOOOO disappointed. had a VERY strong LEMON flavor. Why?! White cake should be vanilla flavored. Had I know I would have never purchased it. it was moist but our family are NOT lemon fans. I doubt we finish this cake. What a waste. read more

I ordered my husband's birthday cake and it was moist and delicious! The staff were very friendly and helpful

Taylor's got me with their deflate cake offer. As a tribute to Tom Brady, they offer a delicious football cake with chocolate frosting and your choice of white or chocolate cake. Unfortunately, some of the air has been let out of the football so it's a bit deflated. But they let some of the air out of the price, too, so you get it for $12 instead of $24. The promotion's totally attention grabbing for those of us disappointed Colts fans or really anyone who thinks Tom Brady's recent antics are worthy of a little derisive humor. Promotions and gimmicks aside, the cake was absolutely delicious! The cake itself was moist and just the right level between dense and fluffy and the frosting was very rich and lively. The staff were super helpful and more than willing to accommodate my same day cake order. Looking around at what else was available as I waited for them to box up my cake, I couldn't help but marvel at the level of aesthetic beauty this bakery brings to each of its confectionary creations. If you need a cake or just some sweet treats, I'd definitely put Taylor's on the short list of bakeries to try. Great service and great food in a very clean and inviting store. What more could you want? read more

Taylor's Bakery - The jury's still out on whether or not Tom Brady had a hand in baking our cake. Whoever's responsible, it sure does look low on air ;) - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Taylor's is a family owned business that takes pride in their work. It's evident by the creativity and quality of everything they make. I was always familiar with their 62nd/Allisonville location that was close to home & easy access for weekend donut runs, but I've grown to love them having consumed their cakes on a regular basis as our 'preferred' bakery at work from their 116th/Fishers location. A few days ago I needed to grab a cake for an impromptu birthday celebration and was able to call the same day and have it decorated and ready for pick up within hours. Upon arrival, I was greeted with windows full of festive harvest, fall and Halloween decorated cakes that would be perfect for any party. Considering the Frankenstein cake may not go over well, I stuck to the chocolate on chocolate 1/2 sheet. It was beautifully decorated with sunflowers and piped in orange, but better yet - everyone RAVED about how delicious it was! Helpful hints: They make their own homemade ice cream and give 10% off with any cake order. They also make their own popcorn and had samples of Pumpkin Spice for me to munch on while I perused the store. Oh, last but not least, they have cards for those who don't want to make another stop! read more

See all

Not any more expensive than Krispy Kreme but with way more options! You seriously can't go wrong with anything and the staff is always super nice and welcoming. read more

I was impressed with Taylor's Bakery. Not only do they offer a lot of cakes, but there are counters full of pastries, and displays with popcorn, house ice cream, and assorted other snacks. I didn't show up until nearly noon, and was impressed that there was still a nice selection of pastries to choose from. I picked up a crispy flat nutty one that I knew my wife would like (I just had to make it home without eating it so that she could enjoy it!) They also had some really large "alligator" pastries that were more than I wanted on my visit. But I did find some other items that were sized more for the individual. I picked out an apple Danish that had a nice balance of chew, sweetness, and tartness to make for a tasty treat. They also had mini-Danish which are rolled like a cinnamon roll instead of laying flat with a pool of jelly in the center. I picked up a few of these that only take a couple bites each: Strawberry and Pecan. I appreciated the easy parking in the lot in front of the place, though getting out of the lot onto 116th can be challenging. Hint: If you want to go west on 116th, use the road south of the business to get to the side street which has a stop light intersection at 116th. Much easier and faster! Review #1288 read more

See all

It was very simple to order a cake here, and it was made absolutely perfectly! The cake was DELICIOUS, and my parents loved it! Great experience! Thank you!! read more

Taylor's Bakery - Delicious cake! White, 2 layer, 8 inch - Bakeries Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Our experience here was not good. My wife and I are from out of town and here for a sports tournament. Have a lovely Vietnamese lunch and decided to top it off with a bakery item. Taylor's bakery reminded me of bakeries of my youth. I had a biscuit type item and it was ok but not fresh tasting but my wife decided to splurge and have a chocolate eclair. She had never had one. I remember in my youth just how delicious they were and encouraged her. We took it back to our hotel and she decided to cut it and share with our son. This was not going to happen. It was FROZEN solid. No kidding. Solidly frozen. So....these are not made fresh and how careless to put them out frozen for the customer. read more

Despite its simplicity, or maybe because of it, the chocolate iced cake donut is my favorite. Crispy outside of you get there early enough, icing that's thick and not too sweet. I will drive past other donut shops to get this donut from Taylor's. Their cinnamon danish is also yummy and full of cinnamon flavor. An Indy institution. read more

I'm so glad we found this place today! Stopped in to pick up a pie for a Father's Day bbq. This pie was the best key lime I've ever tasted, hands down. Everyone loved it! Smooth as silk, not overly sweet , just the right amount of flavor & the crust didn't fall apart, it was delicious. We will definitely be back for another one! read more

I loved Taylor's but the pumpkin pie was over baked and had a think scum on the top. Good flavor but... I really miss the cream bread and sesame bread. Miss the mini cake donuts. I feel certain that the part needed could be manufactured for the broken part. read more

Taylor's Bakery has been around a long time, and there are many very devoted fans. "I got the cake from Taylor's Bakery!" has long been a prideful statement spoke by many. I had lived in this area for a long time but had never been to TB. When I needed 3 desserts for a bridal shower last weekend, I could only find them at TB. I was very grateful to find that they had a means to order online, which was super convenient. I ordered the bride's 3 favorite desserts: cheesecake squares, brownies, & donut holes, and picked them up before their 5:00 closing on a Saturday (served them Sunday morning). They had many items to choose from, and it was easy to order online (saved me a lot of time). I called twice with questions & someone helpful quickly answered each time. So high scores for convenience in ordering & selection offered, but I only gave 3 stars because they are not conveniently located to me and because I think the quality/taste is just average. I would like to see them raise the bar a little bit. They are kind of in the middle of bakeries; they don't need to go as fancy/expensive as a CakeBake or Gallery Pastry shop, but seems they should differentiate themselves a little more from a grocery bakery. I know there are many a fan of frosting in bright colors, etc., whereas personally I'd rather never see red or blue balloons made of frosting again. But who am I to argue with success? Taylor's Bakery has long been very popular. I'd vote for high-quality homemade, natural, creative, beautiful & interesting desserts --- made with chocolates, nuts, caramels, mint, fruits, etc. I wish TB continued success, and I think most would be very happy there. read more

The cake was so delicious, and the marigolds are exactly what I wanted. Colors were outstanding. Happy Birthday was written on the side of the cake. The cake was a white cake with chocolate icing. The cake was moist and creamy. The top of the cake was written, Mom 90 and Fabulous. Thank you. I thought you might like a picture of the cake for your gallery! Thank you!! Delivery went perfectly. I text you a photo of the cake. Was not able to paste a photo here. read more

I wanted to try something new and I saw great reviews for Taylor's Bakery and I bought a cake and it was amazing. I will continue to buy from them now. Everyone was really nice and great customer service. read more

I stopped by Taylor's Bakery after it was highly recommended to me. Their selection is pretty impressive and it all looked very tasty. I came in with hopes of putting in a large order and made sure to let the staff know so I could get the assistance I needed regarding pricing, potential shipping as well as any and all other details that needed to be covered. I waited on the manager to come back from lunch as the person helping me didn't have all of the answers for me. When the manager did return, she was never introduced to me and when I asked a question, she never answered me directly, instead answering the person who was "assisting" me. Similar to the customer service, their baked goods were okay. There was nothing special about the cupcakes (red velvet and chocolate) and the cannoli was stale, but the baklava was good, if not a little too dense. read more

Donuts look and taste like factory-produced donuts you can get at Kroger. Pies are production-line pies too, as is easy to see by the universal pattern of the pie crust... and they look like the flat, non-flaky crusts that one gets from the Pilsbury canned crusts. read more

They're lucky the food is good! This is the second time I have gone in to pick up an order and been treated badly. Clearly overwhelmed and overworked, the team member who helped me was short and cold towards me. I watched the guest next to me be treated IDENTICALLY by a different team member. We all shared glances of "wtf". Sounds like an issue throughout whole team. Disappointing! Will try to find another small business bakery to support for next special occasion. read more

It's my local bakery and it is excellent! From birthday cakes, to breakfast pastries and gourmet popcorn as hostess gifts to dog "cookies" Taylor's Bakery is a treat for my entire household. They can be very inventive with their cakes- it's a matter of your imagination. The 62nd & Allisonville location is the original & some staff work at both. read more