An amazing find in the back of the store. A+++ ingredients in delicious treats well worth what they are charging. read more

We have been to Hot Toddy's multiple times. My husband and I always get a different dessert. I'm pretty sure we have had everything multiple times. While I love everything they make, my favorite is their carrot cake. It is beyond moist and the icing is perfect . Don't miss out on heading over there and trying LOTS of things!!!! read more

What a wonderful hidden gem Customer service still exist and the German chocolate cake was phenomenal, also truly enjoyed the key lime bars I'LL BE BACK!!! read more

Hot Toddy's is a little hard to find at the back of Broccoli Bill's. But it's worth making your way back to. Great cookies and treats and friendly staff. A great dessert option if you're eating at Broccoli Bill's. It's a little cramped, but there's plenty of room up front. read more

Hot Toddy’s - a hand holding a cookie - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

If your looking for the most amazing carrot cake, you've got to try Hot Toddy's. They are located in the back of Broccoli Bills and Slapfish in Nobelsville. The cake is bursting with all the flavors a carrot cake should! And the frosting is to die for! Oh that cream cheese frosting! It compliments the cake perfectly and is not to sweet. The portion size is perfect to split as well. Just an FYI, I have been here and they have been sold out so if your heart is set on carrot cake you may want to call ahead and make sure they have some. They do have other desserts but I'm so in love with this carrot cake I haven't tried anything else, as good as this is though I'm sure their other desserts do not disappoint. read more

Hot Toddy’s - Carrot cake - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Cool little bakery which adjoins a nice fish restaurant. The guys were fun to visit with. Of course, they jokingly wanted us to purchase one of every item in the bakery. When all is said and done, we walked away with a small peanut butter cake, key lime bars, and some tasty cookies. The owner came out with a small sample of candied pecans. Wow.....wow....wow!!! They were hot off the press and perfectly roasted or toasted or whatever they do to them. I am hopeful they continue to make them and sell to their patrons. All items are very tasty and very reasonably priced. Do it.....!!!!! read more

So happy to have found this bakery! Perfect carrot cake--dense, moist, with walnuts and cream cheese frosting. Triple Chocolate Cheesecake that satisfies your chocolate craving without overpowering you. Key Lime Pie with graham cracker crust is just the right amount of fresh and tart. The people working here are just great. You need to give this place a try. It's in the very back of Broccoli Bill's and Slapfish Grill if you come in the front--or to the right if you come in the side entrance. Highly recommend! read more

Hot Toddy’s - Key Lime Pie slice - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

See all

I stopped into Broccoli Bill's to meet someone and shopped around as I was waiting. There were several sweet treats tempting me and I ultimately chose a brownie. I record everything I eat on My Fitness Pal so I carefully consider everything I eat. I ended up choosing a brownie to indulge in. I took it home and ate it half the same day as purchase and the remaining half the next day. I zapped it in the microwave for a few seconds and it was pretty tasty both days. They had a good selection of sweets to choose from including a variety of cookies. read more

Hot Toddy’s - Brownie :) - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

OMG! I have been looking for a really good carrot cake for the past few years and today I found it! Very moist, not overly sweet, and delicious! Just the right amount of cream cheese icing and again not too sweet. Coffee was delicious also and served with real heavy cream. Will definitely be back! read more

What a great find! Their carrot cake is delicious and my favorite is the key lime pie. So flavorful and has the perfect amount of tart and sweet. The area also provides a great shaded patio for studying or conversation. Will come again! The ladies also working are so sweet and friendly every time we go. read more

Thanks to Yelp (Chrissy C) for letting me know about this small bakery at the back of Broccoli Bill's grocery. After lunch at Slapfish (also in the same building), I decided to stop by the bakery to see what I might like for dessert. The bakery space is quite small with a display case and a free standing display of baked goods. I like that they have many of the items available in reasonably sized slices at prices that are less than what you would pay at nice restaurants for dessert. I picked up a Key Lime Pie slice and a Carrot Cake for $7. The baker was there and was friendly to deal with. He also has full size pies and cakes that are for sale too. It may not be the biggest bakery and have all the items you are looking for, but if you want something for dessert, it's a good place to check out! Review #3695 read more

Hot Toddy’s - Small bakery at the back of Broccoli Bill's grocery - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

If you want fresh baked cinnamon rolls, Todd's famous carrot cake or German chocolate and the best cheesecake I've ever had, go check this place out. You won't be sorry. I live in Fort Worth, TX and I always stock up on jams and jellies to bring back with me. read more

Hot Toddy’s - two jars of black raspberry jelly - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Best German chocolate cake ever!! Ordered a cake on Tuesday for Saturday pick up for my moms birthday. Oh my goodness!! It was absolutely, ridiculously good! Not over bearing chocolatey, very smooth and creamy frosting and just the right amount of sweetness that I like! It is a very heavy and rich cake. Total indulgence! It was sooo good , you gotta try it! read more

Heard about this little gem and finally visited last night- visit being the operative word as Todd and Earl were delightful and I feel like we're friends now! We bought cinnamon rolls, which we had for breakfast this morning, and bought slices of Key Lime Pie and Carrot Cake, which was dessert last night. Now I see why they're rated 5 stars! Everything was delicious. They also make all of their own jams- including the best apple butter we've ever had, which they let us sample. Also made are a variety of cookies, granolas (including gluten free), cupcakes, brownies and more. It's tucked away behind Slapfish and Broccoli Bill's (in the same building!) on Gray Road. I suggested more signage, which they agreed, because unless I knew of them from my friend I don't think I would've seen it, much less tried it- and that would've been a huge loss! read more

See all

Quaint little shop with a variety of treats available. We opted for a bag of chocolate chip cookies and coffee. The cookies were a fairly large size, soft and tasty. The coffee was better than average and the service quick. We were just passing through the area, however I would come again if an opportunity arose. read more

Their cinnamon rolls are breathtaking! This amazing bakery is located in the back of Slapfish and Broccoli Bills. 10$ for four AMAZING CINNAMON ROLLS is a price you just cannot beat! I posted a screenshot of my Instagram story because I was so eager to dig in that I forgot to save a photo! You all won't regret these! read more

Hot Toddy’s - Cinnamon rolls - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

You'll find Hot Toddy's tucked in the back of Broccoli Bills. They got lots of different desserts to choose from. We had the carrot cake. We were taking it to go so they bagged it up nicely and sealed the top. You do have to pay for your Hot Toddy items there rather than at the main register. The layers were moist and the icing was not overly sweet. Nice big slice but not insanely so. Enough for a sitting. I can't wait to try more things from there. They all look delicious read more

Hot Toddy's has been inside Broccoli Bill's since Fall of 2019! I haven't actually been there to the store in a long while so I was surprised they were remodeling again, but in the end it was a good surprise that we found Hot Toddy's which had amazing carrot cake! The case actually had many amazing looking desserts. It was hard to narrow it down, but I had been thinking of carrot cake and was told it and the key lime are the biggest sellers. The cheesecakes also looked very good. The black raspberry looked so pretty. They use their homemade preserves! They also sell preserves! The carrot cake was the perfect dessert after our dinner at SlapFish. It was the prefect moist and dense cake that was very flavorful. The cream cheese icing was just perfect. We split a piece, but I wish I had gotten my own. We will be back for more and to try the other desserts. Not only did that have desserts but they had iced cinnamon rolls, muffins, cookies, and coffee cake. They was gluten free options as well. I thought everything was priced really good. I also liked they had the preserves and homemade granola! They had coffee as well, but not being a huge coffee drinker I didn't even notice what kind they had to offer. read more

See all

KEY LIME PIE. Best I've ever had. Nice and strong lime flavor. Forget Florida for Broccoli Bills

Just finished lunch with a coworker and we were craving something sweet. We Yelped the closet place to cure a sweet tooth and Hot Toddy's was close. The Key Lime pie is fantastic! Not too sweet and not too tart. The crunchy crust is just my style. read more

So excited I came across this place today while at slapfish. I tried their key lime pie and it was fantastic! The crust was so delicious and it was one of the best key limes pies I've had in the area..only $3 a slice! I also grabbed some homemade granola and it's delicious as well and again so reasonably priced for being made in house read more

I have been a steady customer of Hot Toddy's for a long time and I have never never found anything that I haven't liked. I buy lots of the Key Lime Pie!!! I have even watched them whip the cream for on top of the pie! (It is the real thing)! The German Chocolate cake and Carrot cake are so good. They also sell it by the piece and makes great treats and thank yous for your friends and neighbors. This fall you must try the pumpkin chocolate chip muffins. Guys, I am anxiously waiting! The bonus is all natural ingredients. You will not have any trouble reading the ingredient label! Plus, Earl and Todd are wonderful people that work right on site making and baking the products! Order your Thanksgiving and Christmas pies early so you are sure to serve or take the best desserts for the holiday! read more

Easily one of the best carrot cakes I've ever had. I'm so glad we discovered this place!!

I'm so thankful to have stumbled upon this wonderful bakery booth inside Broccoli Bill's. I tried the brownie and the carrot cake and seriously it was the best brownie I've ever had and the carrot cake ties for the best I've ever had. (I've tried a lot of desert). They had some amazing looking cinnamon rolls and key lime pie as well. Try them out so we can keep a good bakery in business! read more

I don't want to tell you how good the cinnamon rolls are because when I go in to buy them, Hot Toddy's will be sold out. So.... The cinnamon rolls are meh. read more

WOW!!! Just had a piece of Hot Toddy's key lime pie!!! Used to live in Florida and this is the closest to the real thing - might even be better! Love! read more

This bakery is in the same location as Broccoli Bills produce and Slapfish--I would definitely recommend both. I went in to buy some fresh produce and ended up buying carrot cake from Hot Toddy's. Super delicious, moist cake and cream cheese icing. We will be back to try more from the bakery! read more

If you are looking for a pie that you can convincingly pull off as homemade by your German grandma this is it. Not overloaded with sugar or corn syrup like store bought and other bakery pies -so you can really taste the other ingredients. I can't say enough about how good they were. 6 stars! We got apple crumb and pumpkin and some granola. All superb. Yum! read more

Hot Toddy’s - Picture are hard to take when you're gobbling up this pie. - Bakeries Near Me - Westfield, Indiana

Best Cinnamon rolls ever. I received them from a friend as a gift and I can't wait to pick up more!

The hub and I love this bakery thats tucked away inside Broccoli Bills. The carrot cake is my Absolute Favorite. The hub loves the Chocolate cheesecake. Key lime pie is delicious. Chocolate chip cookies taste like homemade. Everything we have tried has been yummy! read more

WOW!!! Love at first bite!! I visited this vendor 8/13/20 for the first time at the farmers market at Ft Benjamin Harris location near 56th st & post rd & omg it was well worth it!!! The snicker doodle cookie was the best I ever had, and "the brownie" chocolate, with chocolate chips was so pleasing to my taste buds- a melt in your mouth delight!!!!! I am so excited to go back next week & purchase a whole box of brownies & more cookies, in fact rumor has it the "key lime bars" are great too- I will try those as well :) I hope these are fat free ;) oh & the treats were so fresh!!!!! thank you, mr.... I didn't get your name but you were patient &courteous!! Katina M. read more

The Carrot Cake and Cinnamon Rolls are the best in Hamilton County! Next time we will try the Key Lime Pie!

Amazing cakes! Had a chocolate devil's food cake custom made for a birthday and it did not disappoint!

Stumbled across this little bakery And brought home a slice of carrot cake for my husband. He was in heaven it was very very good