Chef Woody makes fantastic food. I worked with him and he has always made great fresh delicious dishes. I'd recommend trying their menu.

Newly opened and we were so excited at the cleanliness and restoration work that had gone into this space. The decor has a classic upscale vibe, gorgeous bar in a space rich in history. Great food at a reasonable price! Great place for meeting friends for dinner and drinks as well as special occasions... you should definitely check it out, you won't regret it! read more

See all

Had a great dinner! Drinks were good and the service was stellar. Very cozy restaurant read more

Had such an amazing dinner here the other day! The staff was very kind and caring, the restaurant is beautiful and has a rlly nice calm vibe to it. I had the duck breast entree and it was heaven. A really wonderful fancy dinner out that is actually priced well! Highly recommend read more

Tavern 1888 - The duck breast with polenta, asparagus, shishito peppers, and amazinggg locally foraged mushrooms! - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

I'm only giving this place four stars because there really aren't many choices in Eureka California. The food was OK. Nothing to write home about. I did get great service from our waitress while I was there for the Canafest. The ambience had a fairly nice vibe also. read more

Wow...the food came out perfect and the atmosphere was super epileptic and romantic. Great date night for sure!

I had great experiences at Phatsy Clines next door and was excited to try this place when it opened. Sadly, the veg entree I got was small, oily, and disappointing. I could have made better zoodles at home for way less money. Service was good though. Phatsys has better food & drinks imo. read more

Tavern 1888 - Veg entree: zoodles with asparagus - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

Just had an amazing dinner here with our two kids. I don't remember the name of our server, my receipt says Linnea, not sure if that is her name. Thank you for being amazing! Without knowing you made our evening better after having a crappy experience at a different restaurant. You were so kind to us. We will never forget you! The food was amazing as well as the drinks!! read more

The service and ambience is good and waitresses are super friendly. However, the food is not worth it. We ordered the steak but it was dry. The scampi was skimpy on the seafood. Cocktails were great. read more

They gave us a bill with an extra beer on it and after we pointed it out they brought another check and added a 20% gratuity Also they forgot to bring two items Also also they totally patronized my friend who was upset at their lack of decency Y'all suck ‍ Clam chowder was pretty good read more

I keep going here hoping it will be good and it sadly never is, the food was subpar and cold, the service was mediocre with snarky server's, the bathroom's were gross and the decor is art that looks done by middle schoolers. I dont reccomend this place to my worst enemies, if I could give a zero star review I would. read more

We came up to Eureka from Oakland. Tavern 1888 is attached to their sister restaurant Fatsy Clines. When we arrived the hostess said we could sit at the bar for cocktails, but they could not serve us food. There was a large party and they have a pretty small kitchen. We were fortunate that the food service opened up and we were able to eat dinner. Food: We got the bruschetta with duck confit...the blackberry hot sauce really made the dish. The duck was smoky and flavorful. Shrimp and grits....our favorite dish....shrimp was cooked perfectly and they served it with a incredible corn salsa. Got the filet mignon which was cooked to a perfect medium rare. We got the Roquefort cream sauce..100% recommend. Cocktails: I got the Irish coffee which was well done...the bartender gave me a mini french press to top off my coffee and a lovely vanilla bean whipped cream. My partner got a cocktail made with whiskey which he loved. Dessert: We got the mini creme puff tower with a sugar twill. It was adequate. The puffs seemed like they were refrigerated and a little stale. Service: our bartender was excellent and I appreciate how the hostess and the front manager took care of us. Vibe: They had dancing in the space between the restaurants. Good for date night. read more

It was really fun here! They had really good food while the service was very quick! They welcomed me and they were really kind, the ambiance was nice and cool as well, I recommend going here with friends. read more

Drinks and appetizers are terrific. Fun place. Possible to have a conversation and still have some cut-loose fun.

Wow. My wife and I went to dinner here this weekend and everything was ON POINT, which is impressive considering they had only been open 8 days. The menu made for a hard decision on appetizers, entrees and desserts. The cocktails were second to none. The ambiance was high class, elegant yet relaxed. The Filet Mignon was cooked a perfect rare, the mashed potatoes were excellent (this coming from an Irishman), summer squash delicious! This restaurant is a great addition to the Eureka culinary scene and will be a cornerstone of Old Town for years to come. Look forward to taking out-of-town guests to Tavern 1888 when they come to visit. Congrats, Tavern 1888. You nailed it. read more

Tavern 1888 - Filet Mignon, mashed potatoes, asparagus and a top notch cocktail. - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

Tavern 1888 is my new favorite restaurant here in Humboldt. Let's start with the atmosphere. The people in charge of the design killed it. The place is stunning. I enjoy every little detail, down to the dark colors, the moody lighting, the throw pillows, and the gold accents. Once seated in this sexy atmosphere, you get hit with the cocktail menu, which is an adventure all it's own. The tavern has perfectly curated cocktails, which are just as beautiful as they are delicious. I was swooning over my "Well Hello Ginger Rogers" cocktail that presented itself to me with a large ice cube in the shape of a rosebud. In addition, a toothpick adorned with a piece of candied ginger and a piece of candied cherry was on the rim. How fun is that? The poke tower is a must, if you're into poke. Not only was it beautiful, but it was bursting with flavor. We've been lucky enough to have kitchen staff meander to our table as we finished up to ask us how we liked the food. It gave a personal touch that made the experience itself feel more intimate. I can't wait to work my way through the entire menu! It's been fun to take friends to this spot and it has the type of wow factor people seek. Our last guests we brought proclaimed they would bring their parents back when they traveled to Humboldt from out of town. My husband loves the bison short ribs, and one evening I had a 4 cheese ravioli with crab added. Two of the cheeses were burrata and Brie and when sprinkled with the juice from my lemon wedges, it provided an otherworldly amount of flavor. I wholeheartedly love this place and am grateful for the apparent love and thought that go into every recipe. I've also had the friendliest wait staff every single time. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Wow! What a find. We had one meal in Eugene and hit the jackpot. Food is fresh as can be. We asked about the aïoli and the chef came out to talk with us. They make their own mayo, their own sweet chili sauce, their own pasta. We had the scallop appetizer, which was to die for. The lemon meringue tart was fabulous too. Great service and nice ambiance too! read more

A fantastic experience from the charming, boho, speakeasy vibe to the professional and attentive staff to the excellent cuisine! Lovely, brilliant cocktails! The bar tender makes delicious Old Fashioneds on request. Wish we lived in Eureka, would haunt this place regularly if we did read more

I gave it 1 star because the parking isnt that bad, the food was warm but it tasted like it was pulled directly out of a microwave. The waitresses were understaffed so everything was slow, the decor was alright. read more

Great ambiance in a historic building. Food was very good. My wife had the pork belly and even the polenta was tasty (I'm not a polenta fan). The lamb was very good. The Pina colada mouse was dynamite! Definitely a good choice for a "fancy" meal in humboldt. read more

I was sadly very disappointed with Tavern 1888. They started out really strong but it was all downhill from there. We got a really yummy poke tuna tower for an appetizer. This reminded me of food I had eaten in the bay and in LA. This was the best thing about our dinner though. The $50 steak was mediocre at best (not a great filet and overcooked in some parts/ undercooked in others). The shrimp and grits were also pretty bad. The food seemed under seasoned and generally bland. Finally, desserts were ok, but I've had better from Local diners. The inside of the restaurant is beautiful, but That only gets you so far when the food just doesn't measure up. Our server was very friendly, but fairly inattentive. The chef was walking around all night and chatting with people - which is nice, but based on the quality of the food and how long it took to get to us, it seems like the kitchen could have really used his help!! For a $200 meal, we left feeling very disappointed. 1 star for ambiance, 1 star for the poke tuna tower. read more

We had a great experience! The good, service and ambiance was more than what we expected.

New and delicious! Brand new in Eureka and amazing! In a world of mediocre, try something new in the historic Eagle House! read more

First visit to the tavern, it is open again post pandemic. What a great place and ambiance, comfortable chairs, great service! We arrived well after the kitchen closed at 9pm and couldn't order from the promising menu. Enjoyed a few cocktails. Great times, and will be back for more. read more

SO ENJOYABLE! We went here for a light dinner of small plates and a cocktail. We were not disappointed. We had a crab cake that was just excellent, and delicious cocktails. Finished up with a wonderful dessert of rich crumbly crust and mousse filling. Everything was wonderful, and a just-right amount. As tasty as the food and drinks were, the real stars here are the setting and the service. The room channels early 20th century, with comfy chairs and couches, a few tall tables, and rich dark colors. The bar is old-school, long and wooden. The service was wonderfully attentive without being intrusive. We will absolutely return when we are back in the area. read more

If I could give this experience more stars, I would. From reservation to dessert, it was spectacular. The bathroom was spotless. This is my first try since renovation and I was so excited to walk through those doors. Everything about this establishment is fresh. With the airy updo of the main entrance and update of a gorgeous bar space. It was so perfect with wonderfully calm lighting and top of the line table service. We were blessed to be waited on by Linnea. She was pleasant and fluent in what the establishment had to offer for the evening. She sold the Rock cod and grits as a "perfect display of our restaurants use of fresh ingredients." We also chose Dungeness crab ravioli that was rich, yet not too rich to finish the plate. Dessert was a mouth watering Pot de crème, thick chocolate mousse with a spicy ending, decadent. Nice job all around Tavern 1888! We WILL be back. read more

My husband and I decided to try this new restaurant for a date night (*reservation recommended). Holy goodness this was an amazing experience. Drink selection was incredible and the house made cocktails are phenomenal. We sat at the bar while waiting for our table and the bar tenders were so attentive and fun to chat with. The kitchen is open so you can see the food being prepared and the Chef was so approachable and accommodating. We were asking how spicy the curry dish was and he brought out an array of spicy peppers he picked up at the local farmers market to choose from. At the bottom of the menu there is a long list of local business where they source all their ingredients and wow does it show in the food quality. Once seated our server was so kind and attentive. We ordered the Bison and shishito peppers to start and wow...just wow. Bursting with flavor and so tender, it's a must try. Husband got the filet and he said it was the best he's ever had at a restaurant; melt in your mouth like butter kind of steak and perfectly cooked. I got the duck and green curry and wow! I didn't want it to end. I got the Mexicali cocoa martini for desert and we savored ever drop it was so good. If you are looking for a fun date night or a true dining experience this is a MUST. We even made our next reservation before leaving it was that good. We will be seeing you all at 1888 Tavern again soon! Thanks for a truly incredible experience. read more

Watch out for unannounced surcharges and check your debit card account numbers after eating here. Great food though! read more

Jake is the best! He made the best whisky drink and his humor is on spot. We need more kind and interactive bars in our community. read more

Tavern 1888 - Amazing music - Cocktail Bars Near Me - Eureka, California

Tavern 1888 is amazing! They hosted a Surprise Birthday Party for 15 with the help of Chef Margaret and her fabulous German Chocolate Cake! Everything was perfect from atmosphere, to setup, timing, and good service!! Chef Jason joined us to be sure they had meant our expectations and they certainly did!! We found that the exceptional staff included where not only the wonderful Wait Staff but also Chef Cole, Woody and Dominic. We owe all a Special Thank You!!! read more

See all

Excellent food and wonderful ambiance. The seafood platter and poke tower were very tasty, as well as the specialty cocktails.

Amazing atmosphere and the staff were incredible. It was my daughter's birthday and the chef created a special vegan dish just for her! Lots of local, fresh produce on the menu. We will definitely go there again. It's a great place to have a romantic dinner or celebrate something special. read more

Great food but service has been very very slow. Ambiance lovely. So if you are not in a hurry, I'd say have a wonderful time.

First time eating here, the decor is amazing, the food, someone the nest I've ever had. And I live how they give you your check in an old book. Will eat there again very soon :) read more

Food is really tasty! They have unique style of the menu and well delivered. We're very satisfied, and the service is good as well.

Absolutely the best place to eat in downtown Eureka....great food, ambiance & very personable servers....ate here 4 times during our stay at the Inn ~ can't wait to schedule another trip here .... Great vacation! read more

Amazing ambiance with food quality and service to match! A little hard to find, we almost drove past it.

Stumbled upon the place when in the area. It was amazing. The cocktails were what you'd expect from a world class cocktail bar. We had mushroom cakes and a pasta dish which were both beautifully plated and delicious. I highly recommend and know I'll be back. read more

On the road home from San Francisco on Thanksgiving weekend and needed dinner. From the reviews and menu we decided we'd give Tavern 1888 a try - we weren't disappointed. Food was most excellent t with great service in a warm atmosphere. Hope to dine there again when we're on the road home. read more

A wonderful setting in old town, with great team both front of house and in the kitchen. Rack of lamb was to die for, cooked to perfection. Excellent service from bar staff and our waitresses Lilly read more