My husband used to work here for a couple years when he was in college, and nostalgia hit him. On our way home from Cleveland, we made a pit stop at Tasty Pizza where Phil filled me in on all the memories, and what to order. They had gluten free pizza, so I ended up ordering a gluten free pie with sausage and cheese. My husband got a regular pie with olives, sausage and onions. He said that I had to get the sausage because that was one product he remembered was from a local farm and was always delicious and quality. I'm not normally a sausage girl, but this pizza was excellent. I mostly look down on pizza that isn't from Buffalo, but this pizza is incredible. I couldn't even taste the cauliflower in my crust. It is outstanding. We took our pizza on the road and ate it 3 hours later when we got home and it heated up wonderfully. My husband enjoyed his slices and said they still taste just as good as he remembered. I would recommend grabbing a pizza or two as you head home, or out of Cleveland back to wherever you are going back to, or even if you live down the street. Quality and delicious pizza. read more

Tasty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lyndhurst, Ohio

See all

I have been a life long customer. Pizzas are consistently yummy! I totally recommend tasty pizza!!

Great pizza and friendly atmosphere! A good local business and a change from the "chain" pizzerias.

No more tasty pizza for me. Horrible service. Poor quantity of pasta, tells me they are pre bagged and boiled. And forgot the meatballs!! Says I could put them on the counter for you to come pickup. Been going there for 50 years. Nomore, plenty of good pizza joints in the area. read more

This is the best pizza on the east side, hands down. It's hefty, the sauce has a perfect sweetness to it, the dough is just the right balance of soft and firm. And the bake? Just a little brown on the top layer of cheese, which by the way is good quality and holds all the topping beautifully inside. The very ideal of a pizzeria-style pizza. The family are good people too. read more

Friendly staff and some of the best pizza I've ever had. I definitely recommend Tasty Pizza to all my loved ones

I'd rate Tasty Pizza between 3 and 4 starts for the pizza itself. I think it's a matter of personal taste but the pizza sauce itself has a bit too much onion for my palate. Great appetizers and nice service, so overall a solid option, if you're in the area. read more

Everything about this place is just amazing. Best house salad dressing I've ever had and the pizza is fantastic as well. The atmosphere is really cool and it's all self serve which is unique. The owner Joe is a great guy to talk to as well and loves sports. Great place to watch a game and eat pizza read more

The greatest pizza I have ever eaten, Super nice staff, Would buy if old enough. I am really happy this is near me I hope it stays for the rest of my life. read more

"Dining In". Is a joke. It's all self service but you won't be told that. You'll have to figure it out on your own. E.g. You ordered a salad? For here? You want your salad? Did you tell the dishwasher in back to make you a salad? No? Well if you want your salad tell the dishwasher. This is all True. I do finally get a salad. It was OK. Pizza was dry. Unimpressive. In the day this place rocked. Now? I smell death on it. read more

Tastys is my picky sons favorite pizza...and Dads too! Love this place and the staff is great too! We'll be back and we'll keep going as long as we live here!! read more

Very cool pizza place. Family setting. It's a little unique because you order at the counter and get your own drinks, silverware, etc. Not for everyone but if you are patient it is worth it. The soda and beer selection is very extensive. Deep fried wings are very tasty and hot wing sauce is good. Pizza is made from scratch with fresh ingredients and it is really good. Gluten free pizzas available. Good price for a good meal in a casual family setting. Would recommend for anyone in the area. Also a few TVs to follow the game. read more

Tasty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lyndhurst, Ohio

See all

The last time I had Tasty Pizza was over 10 years ago while I was in high school and I remember loving their pizza. Last night we wanted to get pizza so we decided to try Tasty's and got a pepperoni pizza and "homemade" lasagna. The pizza was ok, nothing special especially for $18.50! I usually don't order pasta from restaurants since my grandmother makes homemade pasta and many places over-cook their pastas. But, it said "homemade" lasagna so I wanted to give them a try. It seemed they bought all the ingredients and put it together in house.. maybe that's why they said it was "homemade." The sauce was greasy and full of oil and all I tasted was ricotta. After a few bites I had to throw it away. Also, the salad that came with the meal was the cheap iceberg bag stuff you can buy from the grocery store for $1. I really wanted to love this place again but it's lacking flavor and quality for the amount we paid. read more

Tasty Pizza - "Homemade" lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Lyndhurst, Ohio

This is our go to local pizza hangout. Always great service and good pizza w/ fresh toppings (recommend the mushrooms). Been going to Tasty's since we moved to Lyndhurst in 2004. read more

Tasty Pizza - Bacon/Pepperoni fold-over. Mike makes them the best. Throw-back from Tiffin. Cav & marinara in the background - Pizza Near Me - Lyndhurst, Ohio

See all

I would like to give this quaint family establishment a better review, everyone was very friendly and polite. Unfortunately the things I enjoyed about my experience end there. Ordered a large pizza and cheesy garlic bread to eat-in. Pizza was quite expensive considering the sparse toppings it had, definitely needed more cheese. The homemade crust and sauce were quite good though. The cheesy garlic bread wasn't quite cooked enough, again barely any cheese and what was there wasn't quite cooked. Seemed like a great place for large groups. read more

See all

Tonight we got a thin with double pepperoni with an extra turn. The amount of double pepperoni was (in my opinion) not a double amount. However, the thin with an extra turn was on point!! Slowwwwllyyy.... become our favorite on the Mayfield Strip between Som Center and Richmond....not including the chains. So much pizza, so little time! read more

A lovely little family place with great food and service. It's not fine dining. Just good

I've been eating pizza all over the country for 50 years. We even have indoor and outdoor pizza ovens at our house. Yeah, we like pizza. Recently I was home in Lyndhurst visiting my 94 year old Mom. My husband went out to grab a pizza from Tasty and WOW! We all enjoyed it SO much! (Mom too). Only after tasting that incomparable mix of sauce, sausage & pep did I recall that THIS is the pizza my bunches of friends from Brush High School always got. The crust, the sauce, the amount of cheese, just the real deal! and this is coming from someone who has tried every possible interesting combination on flatbreads, and even invented some. This is Tony Soprano pizza. We'll have to get back up there soon, for Mom, and Tasty pizza. read more

Compola's Tasty Pizza is a Lyndhurst institution. A 50+ year staple of family, tradition and honor. If you eat in, you tell Joe at the counter what type of pie you'll be having. When it's ready, he'll bring it to your table. If you want a drink, help yourself to a cold one from the cooler. If you want a salad or soup, go through the saloon-style swinging doors and back to the kitchen to tell Edith. She'll serve you up right there. At the end of the night, tell Joe what you had throughout the night and he'll ring you out. No checks or invoices are kept. It's all done on an honor system. At Tasty, you're a part of the family and this is one of the main reasons why it's so comfortable to dine here. Tasty Pizza is a rare kind of place. A throwback to a more trustworthy era; a simpler time when family gatherings around the dinner table and sharing good food was commonplace. Places like this make me proud to support the Mom & Pops over the competing chains. Long live Tasty! read more

Tasty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lyndhurst, Ohio

We have ordered from this place on occasion over the years. Recently we ordered a pizza (Green Pepper, Sausage, Pepperoni, Mushroom). Rather than Green Pepper we got Onion. A member of the family is allergic to Onion. We had to throw the pizza away as we could not risk onion in the house. Spoke with manager and he got the owner on the phone. I was ok as mistakes happen but by the time I was done speaking with this A$S-hat I was pretty angry. He was telling me onions are in the sauce. Well the person in question has had their pizza before with no reaction so it must not be much onion; I don't know what the sensitivity level is. Anyway he is kind of giving me a hard time. When I said it is fine, not worth spending a lot of time on I said It is ok I just wont be back; I did not think it was such a problem. He then said look stop in and I will give your money back. That is all I wanted to begin with. We could not eat the food and it was not our fault it was made wrong; just make it right. I go there, on our way out to dinner (Opposite direction); to thank him and get my refund... We would have ordered again. So I get there and he has this cocky attitude and says I will just give you a gift certificate. Are you kidding me? Now I am on the hook with an obligation to go back? NOPE.. I refused the certificate and now I am out 20 bucks. He gives a crap about 20 bucks, it is principal. I will never be back and anyone I can tell about this I will. Basically 20 bucks was stolen and the only way I can get any compensation is by being forced to order again. We did not go there and order a gift certificate we ordered food that we could not eat. The next web site I am visiting is the BBB and filing a formal complaint. read more

1. Employees not wearing masks or gloves. 2. Pizza is small, odd tasting and an overall ode to pathetic Cleveland attempts at pizza. 3. The owner drives a Hummer (should tell you everything) but nearly broadsided my car flying out of the parking lot onto Mayfield. Don't bother with this place. read more

Very Good, good value, good service, great pasta. Very glad they are still around. a great local restaurant and good carryout.

I admit, it's been a while but I wanted to write a review on the pizza we got a while back, maybe three months ago. I was recommended to try this place by someone who has been living in the area (I'm fairly new to Lyndhurst) and he said it was awesome pizza. Well, he didn't lie. The pizza was definitely very good, but for the price of it (I have NO problem paying a decent price for a decent sized pizza - at all) I was surprised at the size. Fourteen inch, two toppings for twenty three dollars? Really? Anyhow, maybe it's me and things have gone up a bit but I'm also cognizant of how much ingredients that go into pizza cost and trust me, making pizza is not a really expensive venture, but if it's good it's worth the money. This was VERY, VERY good pizza, but I can't bring myself to spend that much on such a small pizza. Call me cheap, but I'll spend ten more dollars and get something that four people can be satisfied with. I DO recommend it though, just on the delicious taste of it. Just be ready to be a little surprised at the cost of dough and sauce and cheese and pepperoni. read more

This pizza is excellent. It's a conveniently located pizza joint with great food. Pizza is a luxury item for me, so I'm picky about where I get my pizza. I'm always happy to have my pizza from Tasty. There are many choices within walking distance of this restaurant, but I'd choose Tasty over any other one in the area. read more

Had the best time, use to take my kids when they were younger and we all met up there with now the grandchildren, it was so much fun!! Food was great!!! Kids loved it!!! read more

I Passed by here on my way to visit friends in the area. Really good pizza with everything made on the spot. I'd recommend to anybody. Intimate atmosphere in a small strip mall. read more

Grabbed a large cheese and an artichoke special from Tasty on a whim and was really impressed. I was enchanted by their red sauce - really velvety and light, almost like a marinara, but big time flavor! Plenty of cheese, too, and a buttery crust. It reminded me of Geppetto's, which I say as a compliment. The special was nice also, but I'll be sticking with that killer red sauce. read more

Best pizza. Best service and you truly feel like a family. I have been coming here for 15+ years. Thank you, Joe

Extreme bias here. Tasty Pizza was the hangout in high school. We'd go on Friday nights after football games and order the biggest, greasiest pizza we could imagine. We'd just sit, and eat pizza and just do the stuff that high school kids do. I love that I can return and the food tastes exactly the same. The dining room hasn't changed much, even though the front counter / kitchen area has changed quite a bit. But, the pizza is still Tasty Pizza. It's great comfort food served with a side of nostalgia. (For me.) Would I put this in a category as the best pizza? Well, without all of the history, no. But, pizza is supposed to be good for the soul. For me, this heals a lot of ails and brings me back home. You can't beat the meats here. I usually go full pepperoni, and sometimes mix in the sausage and banana peppers. Note: their peppers are the mild variety, and fresh. Don't expect heat or the acidity sting of jarred peppers. But, it's pizza. Do your own thing! read more

Great little pizza spot with an old school vibe. You order your pizza from the counter and then can either sit in their large dining room and eat there or take it out. The dining area is mainly self serve where you get your own plates, napkins and silver wear. You can also serve yourself beverages (including a decent selection of beer and wine) from their coolers. When you are done eating, you let them know what and how many you had and they add it to your bill. The pizza is decent. Good sauce and a great selection of toppings. I usually ask them to cook my pie a little well done as I feel like it can be a bit soggy/limp if you get a few toppings and don't have it cooked a little extra. Definitely a neighborhood place with a lot of regulars who know each other by name. read more

Not the best pizza, but very good. Service is great. They have Stroh's Beer which is now hand crafted micro brew and only sold in Michigan, so they must special order it. I went to Brush in the 60's and our class meets here once a month. I have driven in from Denver twice! read more

I joined yelp so no one else would make a mistake and buy pizza from here. This pizza stunk. No flavor, almost no toppings, 15 bucks for a tiny pizza, and I actually wish I would have bought a pizza from Aldi...that tastes better. If you want real pizza, drive 40miles south to Luigi's in Akron...bring cash, best pizza in NE Ohio read more

All I have to say is this: two of my sisters were in a very heated disagreement for several hours because one of them threw away the leftovers from Tasty Pizza without considering that the other may have wanted to eat it. Said pizza had been sitting out in a hotel room unrefrigerated for 14 hours. This did not deter the scorned sister one bit from desiring to devour it. Also, they have a very impressive, serve-yourself beer fridge. Well, the fridge itself isn't that impressive, but the quality and variety of beers within it are. read more

Decent pizza. I called in and was placed on hold immediately. And I waited. And waited. I hung up. I called back and explained to the young man who answered what happened his response? Do you want to order or not? I said, will you forget to place the order since you forgot to get the call on hold? And he hung up. I called back and spoke to the manager. I eventually ordered. Delivery wasn't available. Great. I picked it up and got a stare down from the young man. Lovely. Attitude was unreal. I won't be going back because I felt uncomfortable. The chip on his shoulders while he drank his smoothie from Pulp was typical. Thank you Tasty for making my first and last experience here memorable. I won't return and won't let anyone I know go there. read more

Simple, cozy and delicious. Their sausage, either on pizza or the baked subs, is something special. Pair that with their sauce that's well balanced and seasoned and consistently baked crust - perfect. Great informal dining experience if that's what you like. Best pizza for the money. Everything on the menu is great. read more

I must admit I love Tasty's. A nice family run Pizza and then some restaurant. When I saw they have artichokes I knew I would love it here and come back again and again. Now they have whole wheat and even glutten free crust that is delicious and really nutritious. May I please suggest Kalmata Olives they pair nicely with artichokes and garlic white sauce and I'd be honored to order vegetarian and vegan cheese options. All I can say is Yum Good work Tasty All The Best, Sandy read more

I ducked in here to grab a pizza when visiting a friend who lives in Lyndhurst. I loved it! It's like going back in time at Tasty Pizza, and that's what I liked about it. This is a classic, "old-school", neighborhood pizza place - good people, simple menu, quality ingredients, etc. Their selection of toppings is ample and thus has something for everyone. The price was a little on the high side, but that's to be expected from a non-chain like Tasty's. Totally worth it! The location is pretty low-key, on the end in a nondescript strip mall, with limited parking. They have a surprising amount of space, though. I went in on a Wednesday and they had my pizza done in about 20 minutes. I'd go back. read more

The counter guy is overworked and has no help. He has no customer service skills. The pizza is like cardboard, frozen grocery store pizza would be better. I watch as the guy goes from food to money to food barehanded without washing. He really needs help. This place is a one and done. read more

This pizza place is one of my favorite pizza spots!!! Every time I go hear the pizza is fantastic and the place is semi-clean! I do like the self-serve pop and sodas! read more

This place is the home for laid back atmosphere, good food, and coolers full of beer. Tasty's is the place friends go to have a good meal and good fun. Great atmosphere for kids. read more

Tasty Pizza - Eggplant Parm! - Pizza Near Me - Lyndhurst, Ohio

See all